Carlo's Pizzeria/Big Butt BBQ

13231 Wicker Ave, Cedar Lake, IN 46303

Open NowFull HoursAre you the owner?

We're all about supporting local pizzerias - even those who are not Slice partners.
Give Carlo's Pizzeria/Big Butt BBQ a call to order. We hear their food's delish.

Only pan pizza.
Cheese Pan$14.25 +
Sausage Pan$15.75 +
Spinach Special Pan$17.75 +
Carlo's Special Pan$17.75 +
BBQ Chicken Pan$17.75 +
BBQ Pork Pan$17.75 +
BBQ Brisket Pan$19.25 +
French Fries$3.85
Broasted Potatoes$3.85
Breaded Mushrooms$6.25
Breaded Cauliflower$6.25
Combo Platter$8.45
Breaded Mozzarella$4.75
Tomato Bread$3.75
With provolone.
Bosco Sticks$5.00
With red sauce.
Pint Of Garlic Dressing$4.25
Chili Cheese Fries$5.85
Onion Rings$5.25
Breaded Zucchini$6.25
Onion Straws$4.00
Jalapeno Poppers$4.75
Garlic Bread$3.50
With cheese.
Pizza Bread$4.00
Garlic Knots$4.00
Cup Of Cheese$1.00
Anti Pasta Salad$8.95
Fresh Garden Salad$4.95
Fresh Garden with Mozzarella$5.95
Fresh Garden with Brisket$7.50
Fresh Garden with Smoked Chicken Breast$7.50
Fresh Garden with Smoked Turkey Breast$7.50
Box Chicken$5.75
Box Chicken All Dark$5.75
Box Chicken All White$7.45
Dinner Chicken$7.45
Dinner Chicken All Dark$7.45
Dinner Chicken All White$9.05
Big Butt Mac Bowl Plain$3.95
The Wiper$7.95
Pork, chili, chopped brisket drizzled with chipotle sauce.
Big Butt Mac Bowl with Pulled Pork$4.95
Big Butt Mac Bowl with Chili$4.95
Big Butt Mac Bowl with Chopped Brisket$6.95
All served with 2 slices of bread.
Rib Dinners$9.95 +
Rib Tip Special$6.50
Smoked Pulled Pork$5.45
Sold by the 1/2 lb. and 1 lb.
Rib Tip Dinner$7.95
Smoked Turkey$5.45
Smoked Chicken Breast$5.45
Sold by the 1/2 lb. and 1 lb.
Smoked Brisket$7.45
Sold by the 1/2 lb. and 1 lb.
Smoked Corned Beef$7.45
Sold by the 1/2 lb. and 1 lb.
Up-Size Sides to Pint for $1.50 per 16 oz. side
Butt Family Pack$18.95
Big Butt Family Pack$32.95
Bigger Butt Family Pack$53.95
Biggest Butt Family Pack$75.95
Create Your Own Pizza$9.50 +
Sausage Pizza$11.00 +
Spinach Special Pizza$13.65 +
Carlo's Special Pizza$13.65 +
BBQ Chicken Pizza$13.65 +
BBQ Pork Pizza$13.65 +
BBQ Brisket Pizza$15.15 +
Hot, mild, bbq, honey mustard, garlic parmesan.
Chicken Wings$9.95
Chicken Wings Dinner$10.95
Dinner includes.
Served on island bun with fries.
Smoked Turkey Sandwich$7.45
Smoked Pulled Pork Sandwich$7.45
Smoked Corned Beef Sandwich$9.20
Reuben Sandwich$9.95
Smoked Chicken Sandwich$7.45
Smoked Brisket Sandwich$9.20
Big Butt BBQ Slider Sampler Sandwich$9.95
Italian Beef Sandwich$7.45
With red sauce on request.
Meat Ball Sandwich$7.45
With red sauce.
Meat Ball Sandwiches$7.45 +
With red sauce.
Cinnamon Knots$4.00
Homemade Peach Cobbler$4.00
Homemade Cake$4.00


SliceRestaurants in Cedar Lake Carlo's Pizzeria/Big Butt BBQ
Price: $$