hero

John's Pizzeria

1209 Sheffield Ave, Dyer, IN 46311

Open NowFull HoursAre you the owner?

We're all about supporting local pizzerias - even those who are not Slice partners.
Give John's Pizzeria a call to order. We hear their food's delish.

Menu
pizza
  • Cheese Pizza $0.75 +
    Classic cheese pizza or create your own pizza.
appetizers
  • Fried Zucchini $5.95
    Lightly floured & made fresh to order. Served with red sauce.
  • Fried Mushrooms $5.75
    Served with red sauce.
  • Stuffed Mushrooms $6.50
    Fresh mushrooms stuffed with seasoured bread crumbs, parmesan & topped with red sauce.
  • Choose Sticks $5.95
    Real mozzarella, hand cut & breaded. Served with red sauce.
  • Fried Calamari $8.50
    Lightly floured & made to order. Served with red sauce.
  • Loaded Potato Skins $6.95
    Made fresh and baked with mozzarella, cheddar and bacon.
  • Fried Onion Strings $4.95
    Lightly floured & made fresh to order.
  • Chicken Strips $4.95
    Served with your choice of dressing.
  • Fried Cheese Ravioli $6.95
    Crispy ricotta filled ravioli served with red sauce.
  • Baked Clams $7.95
    Clams baked with seasoned bread crumbs, cheese, capicola & red sauce.
  • Wings $5.95
    Served plain, hot sauce, BBQ or ranch.
salads
  • Dinner Salad $3.95
    Dressing-house Italian, creamy garlic, Russian, thousand islands, ranch & blue cheese.
  • Antipasto Salad $6.95
    Lettuce, zucchini, tomato, onion, black olives, pepperoncini, capicola, ham, salami cheese & house Italian dressing.
  • Caesare Salad $6.95
    Chopped romaine & homemade croutons mixed with classic caesar dressing.
  • Zucchini Salad $6.95
    Fresh zucchini, tomatoes, red onions & parmesan cheese tossed in our house Italian dressing.
side-orders
  • French Fries $2.00
  • Side of Spaghetti $3.00
  • Vesucio Potatoes $4.95
    Browned potatoes cooked in olive oil, garlic & wine.
  • Phillipo Potatoes $5.95
    Potatoes, green peppers & onions cooked in olive oil.
  • Sauteed fresh Mushrooms $3.95
  • Cream Spinach $3.95
  • Homemade Meatballs (2) $3.50
    Served with red sauce.
  • Italian Sausage Link $3.50
    Served with red sauce.
  • Bowl of Homemade Soup $3.00
  • Basket of Fries $3.00
homemade-breads
  • Ponzanells $6.50
    Homemade bread topped with tomatoes cooked in seasoned olive oil & fresh garlic.
  • Foccacio $7.00
    Pizza crust baked with olive oil, fresh garlic, onions & parmesan cheese.
  • Pesto Bread $6.50
    Homemade bread baked with our house pesto sauce & mozzarella cheese.
  • Pizza Bread $5.95
    Crusty bread baked with garlic butter, homemade marinara sauce & mozzarella.
  • Tomato Bread $6.50
    Homemade bread baked with garlic butter, fresh tomatoes & mozzarella cheese.
  • Bread Sticks $4.95
    Made fresh or order & served with red sauce.
  • Homemade Garlic Bread $3.00
    Made fresh & baked in house.
sandwiches
Deluxe sandwiches served with fresh fries or spaghetti.
  • Italian Roast Beef Sandwich $5.95
    Slow cooked & sliced in house.
  • Combo Sandwich $7.95
    Roast beef & Italian sausage baked with red sauce and mozzarella cheese.
  • Submarino $6.95
    Ham, salami capicola & mozzarella served with lettuce, onions and Italian dressing, hot or cold.
  • Baked Beef Sandwich $6.95
    Roast beef, red sauce & mozzarella baked in a toasted garlic bun.
  • MMM Megan $6.95
    Homemade meatballs, mushrooms, red sauce & mozzarella.
  • Deli Sandwich $5.95
    Homemade meatballs & red sauce served on a toasted bun.
  • Beef Sandwich $7.95
    Served cold with lettuce, red onions & creamy Italian dressing.
  • Ham Mojo Sandwich $7.95
    Served cold with lettuce, red onions & creamy Italian dressing.
  • Italian Sausage Sandwich $5.95
    Served with red sauce on a toasted bun.
  • Chicken Parmigiana Sandwich $7.95
    Crispy chicken baked with red sauce & mozzarella cheese.
  • Shotgun Jeff Sandwich $7.95
    Double sausage links baked with red sauce mozzarella cheese.
pasta-dishes
Choose from - Spaghetti, extra fine, linguini, fettuccini, mostacolli & rotini.
  • Homemade Red Sauce $9.95
    Slow cooked in house.
  • Homemade Red with Lighter Side $6.95
  • Phil's Special $11.95
    Our homemade red sauce combined with beef, fresh mushrooms & fresh green peppers.
  • Phil's Special with Lighter Side $6.95
    Our homemade red sauce combined with beef, fresh mushrooms & fresh green peppers.
  • Meat Sauce $10.95
    Red sauce combined with beef & pork.
  • Meat Sauce with Lighter Side $7.95
    Red sauce combined with beef & pork.
  • Homemade Meatballs $12.95
    Served with homemade red sauce.
  • Italian Sausage $12.95
    Served with homemade red sauce.
  • Homemade Meatballs with Lighnter Side $7.95
    Served with homemade red sauce.
  • Italian Sausage with Lighnter Side $7.95
    Served with homemade red sauce.
  • Marinara Sauce $11.95
    Homemade meatless sauce.
  • Marinara Sauce Lighter Side $8.95
    Homemade meatless sauce.
  • Clam Sauce with Lighter Side $8.95
    Chopped clams combined with homemade marinara or classic garlic & oil.
  • Alfredo Sauce $12.95
    Prepared to order with imported parmesan cheese & real heavy whipping cream.
  • Alfredo Sauce with Lighter Side $8.95
    Prepared to order with imported parmesan cheese & real heavy whipping cream.
  • Clam Sauce $12.95
    Chopped clams combined with homemade marinara or classic garlic & oil.
  • Bolognese Sauce $12.95
    Meat lovers combination of beef & pork.
  • Bolognese Sauce with Lighter Side $8.95
  • Garlic & Oil $10.95
    Fresh chopped garlic cooked in olive oil.
  • Garlic & Oil with Lighter Side $7.50
  • Sausage & Peppers with Lighter Side $10.95
    Thick cut Italian sausage links, green peppers & onions cooked in red sauce and wine.
  • Sausage & Peppers $14.95
    Thick cut Italian sausage links, green peppers & onions cooked in red sauce and wine.
specialty-pasta
  • Manicotti $10.95
    Delicate pasta shells stuffed with seasoned ricotta of beef. Try one of each.
  • Homemade Lasagna $12.95
    Layers of pasta, mozzarella & ricotta cheese.
  • Ravioli $11.95
    Tender ravioli stuffed with seasoned ricotta or beef & served with homemade red sauce.
  • Gnocci $11.95
    Pasta & potato dumpling served with homemade red sauce.
seafood-dishes
  • Shrimp Saute $18.50
    Butterfly shrimp lightly breaded & sauteed lemon, wine and butter.
  • Fried Jumbo Shrimp $17.50
    Fried golden brown & served with cocktail sauce.
  • Stuffed Shrimp $19.50
    Jumbo shrimp stuffed with seasoned breading, crab meat & ricotta cheese.
  • Fried Lake Perch $17.50
    Lightly breaded & pan fried.
  • Sauteed Lake Perch $18.50
    Lightly breaded & sauteed in lemon, wine and butter.
veal-dishes
  • Veal Saute $19.50
    Tender breaded veal sauteed in lemon & butter.
  • Veal Parmigiana $17.50
    Fried breaded cutlet baked in real sauce with melted mozzarella & served with spaghetti side.
  • Veal Scallopini $19.50
    Veal medallions & fresh mushrooms cooked in sweet marsala wine.
  • Veal Cutlet $18.50
    Fried breaded cutlet served with seasoned pepper & topped with crispy fried onions.
chicken-dishes
  • Chicken Vesuvio $16.95
    Half a chicken & browned potatoes cooked in olive oil, fresh garlic & wine.
  • Drunken Chicken $16.50
    Half a chicken & fresh mushrooms cooked in sweet marsala wine.
  • Chicken Livers $15.95
    Tender livers & onions cooked in butter sauce.
  • Italian Fried Chicken $12.95
    Half a chicken fried with a hint of garlic butter.
  • Chicken Michael Luke $17.50
    Breaded Chicken breast sauteed in lemon wine & butter.
  • Chicken Cacciatore $16.95
    Half a chicken, pepperoncini's black olives & mushrooms cooked in a spicy red sauce and wine.
steaks
  • Filet Mignon $29.95
    Steak are served with sauteed fresh mushrooms.
  • New York Strip Steak $23.95
    Steak are served with sauteed fresh mushrooms.
vegetarian-special
  • Eggplant Parmigiana $12.95
    Lightly breaded eggplant slices baked in red sauce & melted mozzarella cheese. Served with soup or salad & side or spaghetti.
kids-menu
  • Kids Jr. Cheese Pizza $4.00
  • Kids Chicken Strips & Frie $4.00
  • Kids Bowl of Spaghetti & Bread Sticks $4.00
  • Kids Homemade Mac & Cheese $4.00
desserts
  • New York Style Cheesecake $4.50
  • 7 Layer Chocolate Cake $5.00
  • Spamoni Gellato $3.50
beverages
  • Soft Drinks $2.50
    Pepsi, diet, sierra mist, dr pepper, mountain dew, raspberry tea, brewed ice tea & lemonade.
  • San Pellagrino Limonata $3.00
    Imported flavored sparkling water.
  • Orangata $3.00
    Imported flavored sparkling water.
  • Regular Coffee $2.00
  • Decaf Coffee $2.00
  • Cappuccino $4.00
  • Espresso $3.00
  • Iced Cappuccino $5.00

FAQ

SliceRestaurants in Dyer John's Pizzeria
Price: $$