hero

Sanfratello's Pizza

9400 Indianapolis Blvd, Highland, IN 46322

Currently ClosedFull HoursAre you the owner?

We're all about supporting local pizzerias - even those who are not Slice partners.
Give Sanfratello's Pizza a call to order. We hear their food's delish.

Menu
classic-thin-crust-pizza
House-made dough topped with scamorza cheese and sauce made from our Sicilian great-grandma Mary's recipe.Our pizza is baked to perfection in old-school deck ovens and cut into southside squares.
  • Classic Cheese Pizza$10.50 +
    Classic cheese or create your own pizza.
  • Gluten-Free Thin Crust Pizza$12.50
    With cheese.
pan-pizza
Our pan pizza is not too thick and contains the perfect ratio of gooey cheese and perfectly seasoned crushed tomatoes. We cut it into squares in the Chicago tradition.
  • Cheese Pan Pizza$14.50 +
specialty-pizza
  • Pizza Ala Sanfratello’s$15.25 +
    We added mushrooms and sliced tomatoes.
  • Meat Lovers Pizza$18.25 +
    Loaded with chi town meats: sausage, pepperoni, salami, ham and bacon.
  • Meat Lovers Pan Pizza$22.45 +
    Loaded with chi town meats: sausage, pepperoni, salami, ham and bacon.
  • Buffalo Chicken Pizza$13.40 +
    Our thin crust pizza topped with spicy buffalo sauce, fried chicken and chopped pineapple.
  • Hawaiian Pizza$13.45 +
    A sweet and salty classic topped with ham and chopped pineapple.
  • Hawaiian Pan Pizza$17.75 +
    A sweet and salty classic topped with ham and chopped pineapple.
  • Vegietello Pizza$16.45 +
    Artichoke, sliced tomato, garlic, mushroom, green pepper.
  • Papa Joe’s Favorite Pizza$15.25 +
    Our founder’s favorite pizza with spinach, sausage and fresh garlic.
  • Vegietello Pan Pizza$21.45 +
    Artichoke, sliced tomato, garlic, mushroom, green pepper.
  • Papa Joe’s Favorite Pan Pizza$19.25 +
    Our founder’s favorite pizza with spinach, sausage and fresh garlic.
appetizers
  • Zucchini Slices$6.95 +
    Fresh lightly breaded zucchini. Served with a side of grandma Sharon's Sicilian marinara sauce.
  • Cheese Sticks$6.95 +
    Lightly coated mozzarella served with a side of grandma Sharon's Sicilian marinara sauce.
  • Mushrooms$7.95 +
    Buttered and breaded mushrooms cooked to golden.
  • Combo Platter$13.95
    A generous portion of our favorite appetizers – cheese sticks, zucchini slices and mushrooms.
  • Fried Ravioli$7.25
    Breaded and stuffed with a light and creamy ricotta cheese. Served with grandma Sharon's Sicilian marinara sauce.
  • Jalapeno Stuffers$7.25
    Large breaded mild jalapeno peppers stuffed with cheddar cheese.
  • Bruschetta$6.95
  • Tomato Bread$5.95
    Our signature garlic bread topped with fresh tomatoes and baked mozzarella.
  • Garlic Bread$3.95
    An Italian roll halved and topped with our garlic butter herb spread, toasted to a golden brown.
  • Buffalo Wings$8.45
    Large lightly breaded served naked or with your choice of buffalo, sweet BBQ or parmesan garlic sauce.
  • Calamari$10.25
    Lightly breaded in house and fried to a golden brown. Served with your choice of cocktail or grandma Sharon's Sicilian marinara sauce.
  • Bread Sticks$4.95
    Five freshly baked slender loaves, lightly buttered with fresh garlic and Italian seasonings.
  • Pretzel Sticks$7.25
    Four house-made pretzels lightly fried to a golden brown served with a cheddary cheese sauce.
  • Chicken Strips$6.95
    Six breaded chicken strips served with your choice of grandma Sharon's Sicilian marinara or ranch sauce.
  • Sicilian Fries$4.95
    Strips of our homemade pizza dough fried and tossed in Italian seasonings.
  • Fries$3.95
    Hearty basket of cut potatoes, fried to perfection.
  • House Chips$3.95
    A basket of thick-cut house-made potato chips.
  • House Onion Rings$5.95
    House cut and battered onion rings served with spicy ranch.
salads
  • Antipasto Salad$7.45 +
    A Sanfratello’s favorite. Mixed lettuce with ham, salami, pepperoni, black olives, tomatoes, pepperoncini and cheese tossed in our creamy Italian dressing.
  • House Salad$4.25 +
    Mixed lettuce, tomato, croutons and cheese.
  • Caesar Salad$8.95 +
    Crisp Romaine lettuce tossed with Caesar dressing and topped with croutons and Asiago cheese.
  • Chicken Caesar Salad$11.95
    Caesar salad with grilled chicken.
  • Mixed Spring Greens Salad$11.95
    Baby spring mix with dried cranberry, walnuts, apple, mandarin oranges, feta cheese served with a raspberry vinaigrette dressing.
  • Southwest Chicken Salad$11.95
    Grilled chicken breast over a bed of mixed lettuce, corn, black beans, tomatoes, feta cheese, tortilla strips served with ranch dressing.
sandwiches
  • Italian Beef Sandwich$8.95
    Served on an Italian roll.
  • Joe’s Special Sandwich$9.95
    Our grandpa guido’s Italian beef topped with baked mozzarella.
  • Italian Sausage Sandwich$8.95
    Smothered in grandma Sharon's Sicilian marinara sauce and served on an Italian roll.
  • Sanfratello’s Stromboli$9.75
    Italian sausage topped with onions, peppers, grandma Sharon's Sicilian marinara sauce and baked mozzarella served on one of our famous Italian rolls.
  • Southside Poorboy Sandwich$10.50
    An Italian beef-sausage beef combo covered with peppers, grandma Sharon's Sicilian marinara sauce and baked mozzarella.
  • Stromboli$10.75
    Delicious Italian beef and sausage combo covered with mushrooms, peppers, onions, pepperoni, grandma Sharon's Sicilian marinara sauce and baked mozzarella. Served on an Italian roll.
  • Meatball Sandwich$9.95
    Three huge house-made meatballs smothered in our grandma Sharon's Sicilian marinara sauce.
  • Grilled Chicken Sandwich$9.95
    Grilled marinated chicken breast topped with lettuce, tomatoes and mayo.
  • Chicken Parmesan Sandwich$9.95
    Breaded chicken breast smothered in grandma Sharon's Sicilian marinara sauce and topped with baked mozzarella.
  • Buffalo Chicken Sandwich$9.95
    Breaded chicken breast tossed in buffalo sauce and topped with chopped lettuce, tomatoes and baked mozzarella.
pasta
Grandma Sharon's Sicilian marinara sauce over perfectly cooked pasta. Choice of garlic bread or bread sticks.
  • Spaghetti$9.95
    Your choice of sauce.
  • Rigatoni$9.95
    Your choice of sauce.
  • Fettuccine$9.95
    Your choice of sauce.
  • Angel Hair Pasta$9.95
    Your choice of sauce.
  • Ravioli$11.95
    Tender pasta filled with meat or creamy ricotta cheese.
  • Tortellini with Meat$11.95
  • Tortellini with Ricotta Cheese$11.95
  • Homemade Lasagna$11.95
    Layers of meat, ricotta cheese, mozzarella with grandma Sharon's Sicilian marinara sauce.
  • Baked Rigatoni$11.95
    Rigatoni with your choice of meat or grandma Sharon's Sicilian marinara sauce topped with mozzarella and baked to perfection.
  • Chicken Parmesan Pasta$13.95
    A lightly breaded chicken breast served over spaghetti and topped with baked mozzarella and the sauce of your choice.
  • Fettuccine Alfredo$10.50
    Thick, tender pasta noodles tossed in our creamy Alfredo sauce.
desserts
  • Pizza Fritz$4.95
  • Cannoli$4.50
    Filled with sopraffina cheese and capped with chopped nuts.
  • Tiramisu$4.95
    Sponge cake soaked in coffee and brandy layered with sweet, creamy mascarpone cheese.

FAQ

SliceRestaurants in Highland Sanfratello's Pizza
Price: $$