Skip to main content
Goodfellas Pizzeria

Goodfellas Pizzeria

110 N Mill St, Lexington, KY 40507

We're all about supporting local pizzerias - even those who are not Slice partners.
Give Goodfellas Pizzeria a call to order. We hear their food's delish.

Craft Your Own Pizza
Hand tossed, freshly made dough, thin crust, and baked off on the stone. This is New York Pizza!

Craft Your Own Pizza


Specialty Pies

Goodfella Pizza

A meaty pie is suitable for any gangster with pepperoni, spicy sliced Italian sausage, ground beef, bacon.


Wiseguy Pizza

Straight from the garden with green peppers, red onions, mushrooms, black olives, tomatoes.


The Don Pizza

The choice for any head of the family with pepperoni, spicy sliced Italian sausage, ground beef, bacon, green peppers, onions, mushrooms, black olives.


Tommy "Two Times" Pizza

Two times the amount of pepperoni... pepperoni.


The Vinny Pizza

A friend of the family's traditional white pie made with olive oil, ricotta, fresh roasted garlic, mozzarella.


The Boss Pizza

Calling the shots with chicken, tomatoes, red onions, bacon, drizzled ranch.


Taste of Naples Pizza

Travel back to the "Old Country" with this Margherita pie made up of tomatoes, basil, fresh ciliegine mozzarella.


Jimmy the Gent Pizza

Greek pizza made with olive oil, bacon, kalamata olives, roasted garlic, spinach, onion, feta cheese.


Paulie's Favorite Pizza

Paulie's passion for cooking sausage inspired this pie with spicy sliced Italian sausage, garlic sausage crumble, green peppers, red onions, and roasted garlic.


The Bootlegger Pizza

Nucky Thompson approved with spinach, mushrooms, sun dried tomatoes, dolloped pesto.


Fuhgeddaboutit Pizza

Every available topping... FUHGETABOUTIT!



Caprese Salad

A simple salad made of fresh ciliegine mozzarella, tomatoes, basil, and seasoned with salt & olive oil.


Pasta Salad

A tri-colored rotini pasta salad tossed with diced Roma tomatoes, black olives, red onions, and broccoli. Finished with a creamy Italian dressing a pinch of parmesan cheese.


Spring Mix Salad

A side salad with fresh spring mix lettuce, red onions, tomatoes, and slice buttons mushrooms.




A single breadstick that is literally the size of your arm. Covered in garlic butter, parmesan, and dusted with oregano. Served with your choice of sauce.


Cheese Bread

Our original hand-tossed dough brushed with garlic butter and covered with a pile of mozzarella. Finished with oregano and perfect for sharing.


Buffalo Chicken Cheese Bread

Need we say more? This snack is a tastebud pleaser! Served with our housemade ranch.


Pesto Bread

Our light but crisp sub bun, spread with a generous amount of housemade pesto, topped with mozzarella and baked till golden.


The Boss' Sauces

Marinara, Alfredo, Ranch, Garlic Butter, Nacho Cheese




This half moon turnover is stuffed with ricotta, mozzarella, and your choice of toppings. Prepare to share!


Oven Baked Subs

Robert DeNiro Sub

oven baked, hand sliced spicy Italian rope sausage with fresh green peppers and red onions.


Al Pacino Sub

A classic New York meatball sub sandwich with our signature marinara sauce and the best meatballs you'll ever taste.


Dean Martin Sub

A combination of peppery seasoned chicken, artichokes, and fresh mushrooms finished in a creamy alfredo sauce.


Frank Sinatra Sub

Sliced grilled chicken smothered in marinara and topped with a generous portion of parmesan.


The Italian Stallion Sub

Marinated ribeye steak, onion, and fresh mushrooms.




A classic Italian pastry filled with house-made sweet ricotta cream and chocolate chips


Black & White Cookie

Seinfeld's favorite...a New York staple.


Chocolate Chip Cookie

Everyone's favorite!


Carnegie Deli's Famous NY Cheesecake

Straight from New York, this cheesecake is hands down the best you'll ever have.


SliceKYLexington40507 Goodfellas Pizzeria
Price: $$