Brothers Pizza & Italian Restaurant

455 Route 23, Wantage, NJ 07461

Open NowFull HoursAre you the owner?

We're all about supporting local pizzerias - even those who are not Slice partners.
Give Brothers Pizza & Italian Restaurant a call to order. We hear their food's delish.

  • Poppers$6.95
  • French Fries$2.95
  • Garlic Knots$3.95
  • Fried Mushrooms$6.95
  • Garlic Bread$2.95
  • Garlic Bread with Cheese$3.95
  • Onion Rings$6.95
  • Bruschetta$5.95
    Tomatoes, basil and onions.
  • Zucchini Sticks$7.50
  • Chicken Fingers & Fries$7.50
  • Mussels$8.95
    Your choice of marinara or white sauce.
  • Fried Calamari$8.95
  • Wings$9.95
    Your choice of Buffalo or BBQ.
  • Mozzarella Sticks$6.95
  • Perogies$6.95
    Potato and cheddar.
  • Pizza Fries$3.95
  • Potato Wedges$3.00 +
  • Appetizers for Two$9.95
    Mozzarella Sticks, Chicken Fingers, Fried Calamari, Fried Mushrooms, Zucchini Sticks
  • Pasta Faggiola Soup$3.95
  • Minestone Soup$3.95
  • Chicken Noodle Soup$3.95
  • Chicken Tortellini Soup$3.95
  • Italian Wedding Soup$3.95
  • Stracciatella Romano Soup$3.95
  • Manhattan Clam Chowder Soup$4.95
  • Broccoli & Cheddar Soup$4.95
  • Country Chicken Salad$7.95
  • Tuna Salad$7.95
  • Caesar Salad$6.95
  • Caesar Salad with Chicken$7.95
  • Grilled Chicken Salad$7.95
  • Antipasto$6.95
  • Antipasto For Two$8.95
  • Fresh Mozzarella & Tomato$7.50
  • Calamari Salad$7.95
  • Seafood Salad$10.95
    Made with calamari, clams, shrimp, mussels, celery, onions and tomatoes.
  • Chef Salad$7.95
  • Turkey Salad$7.95
  • Grilled Shrimp Salad$8.95
  • Grilled Chicken & Shrimp Salad$8.95
  • Italiano Salad$8.95
    Made with salami, prosciutto and fresh mozzarella.
  • Tossed Salad$4.50 +
Served over your choice of pasta, salad & bread
  • Eggplant Rollatini Dinner$10.95
  • Eggplant Parmigiana Dinner$10.95
  • Sausage Parmigiana Dinner$10.95
  • Meatball Parmigiana Dinner$10.95
  • Sausage & Peppers Dinner$10.95
  • Meatballs & Peppers Dinner$10.95
Served with your choice of salad & bread. When given a choice of pasta we have penne, rigatoni, spaghetti, linguini, gnocchi, cavatelli, angel hair, tortellini, or fettuccini.
  • Brothers Special Baked Rigatoni$10.95
    Made with sausage, eggplant, onions and mushrooms in marinara sauce.
  • Baked Manicotti$10.95
  • Baked Penne Sicilian Style$10.95
  • Baked Stuffed Shells$10.95
  • Baked Lasagna$10.95
  • Baked Penne Bolognese$10.95
  • Baked Stuffed Macaroni$10.95
    Served with Pink Sauce.
  • Baked Ravioli$10.95
    Your choice of cheese, meat OR spinach ravioli.
  • Baked Tortellini Alfredo$10.95
  • Anchovies, Garlic & Oil$10.95
  • Fettuccine Alfredo$10.95
  • Fettuccine Primavera$10.95
    Your choice of red sauce or cream sauce.
  • Your Choice!$10.95
    Your choice of pasta and sauce. Choose one sauce: red, mushroom, tomato, marinara, meat, carbonara, vodka or pink.
  • Broccoli$10.95
    Served in your choice of red or white sauce with your choice of pasta.
  • Meatball or Sausage$10.95
    Served in a red sauce with your choice of pasta.
  • Cavatelli & Broccoli$10.95
    Served in your choice of red or white sauce.
  • Tortellini & Broccoli$10.95
    Served in your choice of red or white sauce.
Served with your choice of pasta, soup OR salad AND bread or garlic bread
  • Veal Cutlet Parmigiana$14.95
    With melted mozzarella.
  • Veal Reale$14.95
    Sautéed in white wine. Topped with eggplant and mozzarella.
  • Veal Scaloppine Sorrentina$14.95
    With spinach, prosciutto, eggplant and mozzarella.
  • Veal Saltimbocca$14.95
    With prosciutto and spinach sautéed in wine sauce. Topped with mozzarella.
  • Veal Marsala$14.95
    Sautéed with mushrooms in Marsala wine.
  • Veal Piccata$14.95
    Sautéed with Sautéed in white wine and lemon with capers. in Marsala wine.
  • Veal Florentine$14.95
    Topped with spinach, tomatoes and mozzarella in a light red sauce.
  • Veal Contadina$14.95
    Artichokes and mushrooms in a light red sauce.
Served with your choice of pasta, soup or salad AND bread or garlic bread.
  • Zuppa di Pesce$17.95
    Shrimp, calamari, mussels, and clams in a light red sauce.
  • Shrimp Parmigiana$14.95
    With melted mozzarella.
  • Shrimp Marinara$14.95
    With garlic in marinara sauce.
  • Shrimp Fra Diavolo$14.95
    With spicy marinara sauce.
  • Shrimp Francese$14.95
    In a lemon sauce.
  • Shrimp Scampi$14.95
    In a white wine, garlic and lemon sauce.
  • Shrimp & Broccoli$14.95
    In a white wine and garlic sauce.
  • Shrimp Alfredo$14.95
    With peas in Alfredo sauce.
  • Clams sauce$12.95
    In your choice of a white or red sauce.
  • Mussels & Clams$14.95
    In a red sauce.
  • Clams & Calamari$14.95 +
    In a red sauce.
  • Calamari & Scungilli$15.95
    In a red sauce.
  • Scallops Florentine$14.95
    With spinach, tomatoes, and mozzarella in a light red sauce.
  • Lobster Ravioli$12.95
    With pink sauce.
  • Tilapia francese or piccata$14.95
Served with your choice of pasta, soup or salad AND bread or garlic bread
  • Chicken Parmigiana$13.95
    With melted mozzarella.
  • Chicken Sorrentino$13.95
    Served with melted mozzarella.
  • Chicken Piccata$13.95
    Sautéed in white wine & lemon with capers.
  • Chicken Carbonara$13.95
    Served with onions, prosciutto and mushrooms in a light garlic cream sauce.
  • Chicken Scampi$13.95
    Served in a white sauce with garlic and lemon.
  • Chicken Vodka$13.95
    Strips of chicken served in a creamy vodka sauce.
  • Chicken Marsala$16.95
    Strips of chicken served in a creamy vodka sauce.
  • Chicken Reale$13.95
    Topped with eggplant and mozzarella.
  • Chicken Cacciatore$13.95
    Topped with eggplant and mozzarella.
  • Chicken Francese$13.95
    Sautéed in butter and lemon.
  • Chicken Pizzaiola$13.95
    Sautéed in marinara sauce with onions and peppers.
  • Chicken & Broccoli$13.95
    Served in your choice of a light red or white sauce.
  • Chicken Alfredo$13.95
  • Chicken Rollatini$13.95
    Served with prosciutto, eggplant and mozzarella.
  • Chicken Primavera$13.95
    Served in a cream sauce.
  • Chicken Florentine$13.95
    Topped with spinach, tomatoes and mozzarella in a light red sauce.
  • Chicken Contadina$13.95
    Served with artichokes and mushrooms in a light red sauce.
  • Chicken Saltimbocca$13.95
    Served with prosciutto and spinach. Sautéed in a wine sauce and topped with mozzarella.
  • Chicken Murphy$13.95
    Served with mushrooms, onions, peppers, and potatoes.
  • Chicken Balsamic$13.95
    Served with roasted peppers & broccoli in a white sauce.
  • Chicken Anthony$13.95
    Served with shrimp and broccoli.
  • Chicken Scarpiello$13.95
    Served with sausage, mushroom, and onions in a garlic wine sauce.
  • Cheesesteak$5.95
    add toppings 50c
  • Chicken Cheesesteak$7.50
  • House Special Cheesesteak$7.95
    Served with peppers, onions and mushrooms.
  • Cheesesteak California$7.95
    Served with lettuce, onions, tomatoes, and mayonnaise.
  • Grilled Chicken California$7.95
    Served with lettuce, onions and tomatoes and mayonnaise.
  • Cheeseburger Deluxe$6.95
  • New York Sub$7.50
    Served with grilled chicken, fresh mozzarella, roasted red pepper, and balsamic dressing.
  • Pizza Burger$6.95
  • Gyro sandwich with french fries$6.95
    Beef or chicken
  • Chicken Quesadilla with French Fries$6.95
    pepper, onion, and mushrooms
Served with lettuce, tomato, and onions.
  • Italian Sub$6.95
    Served with ham, cheese, and salami.
  • Ham & Cheese Sub$5.95
  • Salami & Cheese Sub$5.95
  • Turkey & Cheese Sub$7.50
  • Prosciutto & Provolone Sub$7.50
  • Prosciutto, Roasted Peppers and Fresh Mozzarella Sub$7.50
  • Tuna Sub$6.95
  • Roast Beef with Provolone Sub$7.50
  • Roast Beef & Turkey with Mozzarella Sub$7.95
  • Salami, Prosciutto and Mozzarella Sub$7.50
  • Chicken Cutlet Parmigiana$7.50
  • Eggplant Parmigiana$6.95
  • Peppers & Egg Sub$5.95
  • Meatball Parmigiana Sub$6.95
  • Sausage, Peppers, and Onions Sub$6.95
  • Crispy Chicken with Vodka Sauce Sub$7.95
  • Veal Cutlet Parmigiana Sub$7.95
  • Sausage & Egg Sub$5.95
  • Italian Hot Dog$6.95
    Served with peppers, onions, and potatoes.
  • Sausage Parmigiana Sub$6.95
  • Meatball, Peppers, and Onions Sub$6.95
  • Shrimp Parmigiana Sub$8.50
Served with fries. Can be served with salad, just add $1.
  • Antipasto Panini$7.50
    Grilled chicken, artichoke hearts, sun dried tomatoes, roasted red peppers, provolone, prosciutto, and Italian dressing.
  • The Godfather Panini$7.50
    Grilled chicken, portobello mushrooms, roasted red peppers, fresh mozzarella, basil, and balsamic dressing.
  • Brothers Special Panini$7.50
    Breaded chicken cutlet, grilled eggplant, fresh mozzarella, red peppers and balsamic dressing.
  • Caprese Panini$7.50
    Fresh mozzarella, tomatoes, roasted red peppers, basil and balsamic dressing.
  • Americano Panini$7.95
    Ham, salami, American cheese, tomatoes, oil, and vinegar.
  • Vegetable Panini$7.50
    Eggplant, spinach, roasted red peppers, portobello mushrooms, fresh mozzarella, and balsamic dressing.
  • Turkey Club Panini$7.50
    Turkey, American cheese, tomatoes, and bacon. Served with your choice of mustard or mayonnaise.
  • Italiano Panini$7.50
    Ham, salami, provolone, lettuce, onions, tomatoes, oil and vinegar.
  • The New York Panini$7.50
    Grilled chicken, roasted red peppers, fresh mozzarella, basil, and balsamic dressing.
Served with potato wedges or salad with salad $1 extra
  • California Chicken Wrap$7.50
  • Cheesesteak Wrap$7.50
    Served with peppers, onions, and mushrooms.
  • Honey Mustard Chicken Wrap$7.50
  • Buffalo Chicken Wrap$7.50
  • Blackened Chicken Wrap$7.50
  • Chicken Caesar Wrap$7.50
  • Breaded Chicken Wrap$7.50
    Served with mozzarella, lettuce, onion and tomato.
  • Italian Wrap$7.50
    Served with ham, salami, and cheese.
  • Chicken, Bacon, and Ranch Wrap$7.50
    Served with lettuce and tomato.
  • Prosciutto, Fresh Mozzarella, and Balsamic Wrap$7.50
  • New York Grilled Chicken Wrap$7.50
    Served with roasted red peppers, fresh mozzarella, basil, and balsamic dressing.
  • Wings$5.95 +
  • Tenders$5.95 +
All calzones served with mozzarella and ricotta cheese. All other rolls with mozzarella. Additional toppings for 50¢ each. Additional toppings for large are $2 each.
  • Cheese Calzone$6.95 +
  • Deep Fried Calzone$7.95 +
  • One Filling Calzone$7.50 +
  • Vegetable Special Calzone$7.95 +
  • Chicken Calzone$8.50 +
  • Veal Calzone$7.95 +
  • Meat Stromboli$7.95 +
  • Sausage Roll$6.95 +
    Sausage served with peppers, onions and mozzarella.
  • Pepperoni Roll$7.50 +
  • Chicken Roll$7.50 +
  • Steak Roll$7.95 +
    Served with peppers, onions and mushrooms.
  • Plain Cheese Pizza$10.00 +
  • Plain White with Ricotta Pizza$12.00 +
  • White with Broccoli Pizza$15.95 +
  • White Tomato and Garlic Pizza$15.95 +
  • Four Cheese Pizza$15.95 +
  • Vegetable Special Pizza$15.95 +
  • Brothers Special$15.95 +
    Made with peppers, onions, mushrooms, pepperoni and sausage
  • Ziti with Vodka Sauce Pizza$15.95 +
  • Tortellini Alfredo Pizza$15.95 +
  • Eggplant with Ricotta Pizza$15.95 +
  • Tomato, Garlic and Basil with Red Sauce Pizza$15.95 +
  • Chicken, Bacon and Ranch Pizza$14.95 +
  • BLT Pizza$14.95 +
    Bacon, Lettuce, Tomato
  • Hawaiian Pizza$15.95 +
  • Chicken Marsala Pizza$15.95 +
  • Chicken Parm Pizza$15.95 +
  • Buffalo Chicken Pizza$15.95 +
  • Chicken with POM Pizza$15.95 +
    Peppers, Onions, and Mushrooms.
  • Gluten Free Pizza$10.95
  • Margarita Pizza$15.95 +
  • Cheesesteak with POM$15.95 +
    Peppers, Onions, and Mushrooms.
  • Chicken, Broccoli and Tomatoes$15.95 +
  • Chicken and Honey Mustard$15.95 +
  • Stuffed Pizza$19.00
    Your choice, meat or veggie.
  • Barbecue Chicken Pizza$15.95 +
  • Chicken Fajitas Pizza$15.95 +
  • Taco Pizza$15.95 +
These are 12'' personal pizzas! Get one for every member of the family! Additional toppings are 75¢ for half or $1.50 on the whole pizza.
  • Plain Cheese Pizza$7.50
  • Brothers Special Pizza$9.95
    Made with peppers, onions, mushrooms, pepperoni, and sausage.
  • Plain White with Ricotta and Mozzarella$7.95
Additional toppings are $1.25 for half or $2.50 on the whole pizza.
  • Plain Cheese Pan Pizza$14.95
  • Chicken, Broccoli and Tomato Pan Pizza$18.95
  • Honey Mustard Chicken Pan Pizza$18.95
  • Bruschetta Pan Pizza$18.95
  • Vegetable Pan Pizza$18.95
  • Chicken Marsala Pan Pizza$18.95
  • Chicken Parmigiana Pan Pizza$18.95
Additional toppings are $1.25 for half or $2.50 on the whole pizza.
  • Plain Sicilian Pizza$14.95
  • Brothers Special Sicilian Pizza$18.95
    Made with peppers, onions, mushrooms, pepperoni, and sausage.
  • Vegetable Special Sicilian Pizza$18.95
  • Zeppolis$3.95
  • Tiramisu$5.50
  • Oreo Cookie Bash$5.50
  • New York Cheesecake$5.50
  • Cannoli$3.50
  • Chocolate Peanut Butter Pie$5.50
  • The Big Blitz with Snickers$5.50
  • Spaghetti with Tomato Sauce$5.95
  • Ravioli$5.95
  • Baked Penne$5.95
  • Hot Dog & Fries$5.95
  • Cheeseburger & Fries$5.95
  • Grilled Cheese & Fries$5.95
  • Spaghetti with Meatball$5.95
  • Stuffed Shells$5.95
  • Penne with Broccoli$5.95
    Served in a white sauce.
  • Chicken Fingers & Fries$5.95
  • Pizza Burger & Fries$5.95
  • Macaroni & Cheese$5.95
  • Side of Sausage$4.95
    Served in red sauce.
  • Side og Meatball$4.95
    Served in red sauce.
  • Steamed Broccoli$4.95
    In garlic and oil.
  • Broccoli Rabe$4.95 +
    Served with portobello, garlic, and oil.
  • Steamed Spinach$4.95
    In garlic and oil.


SliceRestaurants in Wantage Brothers Pizza & Italian Restaurant
Price: $$