Skip to main content
Brothers Pizza & Italian Restaurant

Brothers Pizza & Italian Restaurant

455 Route 23, Wantage, NJ 07461
973-702-1436

We're all about supporting local pizzerias - even those who are not Slice partners.
Give Brothers Pizza & Italian Restaurant a call to order. We hear their food's delish.

Nearby Pizzerias on Slice
logo
Franico's Cafe
696 County Rd 1, Pine Island, NY
Open NowPickup Only
logo
Goodfella's Pizza & Italian Restaurant
111 Hulst Dr, Matamoras, PA
Open NowPickup Only
logo
Casa Mia
20 White Deer Plaza, Sparta Township, NJ
Open NowPickup Only
logo
Uncle Sal's Pizza II
147 Woodport Rd, Sparta Township, NJ
Open NowPickup Only
logo
Mamma Mia's Too - Oak Ridge
3043 Route 23, Oak Ridge, NJ
Open NowPickup Only
logo
Franico's Pizzeria & Trattoria
302 Pennsylvania Ave, Matamoras, PA
Open NowPickup Only
logo
A Taste of Sicily
50-52 Front St, Port Jervis, NY
Open NowPickup Only
logo
A G Pizza & Restaurant Newton
220 Spring St, Newton, NJ
Open NowPickup Only
logo
Franico's Pizzeria
25 Elm St, Warwick, NY
Open NowPickup Only
logo
Frank's Pizza & Restaurant
64 Main St, Warwick, NY
Open NowPickup Only
logo
Joey's Pizza
201 W Harford St, Milford, PA
Open NowPickup Only
logo
Three Brothers Pizza & Italian Restaurant
5531 Berkshire Valley Rd, Oak Ridge, NJ
Open NowPickup Only
logo
Antonio's Brick Oven Pizzeria
179 Cahill Cross Rd, West Milford, NJ
Open NowPickup Only
logo
Blini Restaurant Pizza & Bar
216 Cahill Cross Rd, West Milford, NJ
Open NowPickup Only
logo
Bella Notte Pizza
230 US-209, Port Jervis, NY
Open NowPickup Only
logo
Carlos Pizza & Catering
397 NJ-94, Newton, NJ
Open NowPickup Only
logo
Bella Italia Ristorante & Pizzeria
448 US-206, Newton, NJ
Open NowPickup Only
logo
Franico's Pizzeria Florida
8 S Main St, Florida, NY
Open NowPickup Only
logo
Pizza Express
1 Meadow Rd, Florida, NY
Open NowPickup Only
logo
4 Brothers Pizzeria & Restaurant
92 Windermere Ave, Greenwood Lake, NY
Open NowPickup Only
logo
Planet Pizza
126 Windermere Ave, Greenwood Lake, NY
Open NowPickup Only
logo
Firehouse Pizza
152 Main St, Andover, NJ
Open NowPickup Only
logo
Saporito Pizza
382 Kings Hwy, Warwick, NY
Open NowPickup Only
logo
Carlo's Pizzeria & Bar
295 Wawayanda Ave, Middletown, NY
Open NowPickup Only
View More Pizzerias on Slice
Menu
appetizers
Appetizers

Poppers

$6.95


French Fries

$2.95


Garlic Knots

$3.95


Fried Mushrooms

$6.95


Garlic Bread

$2.95


Garlic Bread with Cheese

$3.95


Onion Rings

$6.95


Bruschetta

Tomatoes, basil and onions.

$5.95


Zucchini Sticks

$7.50


Chicken Fingers & Fries

$7.50


Mussels

Your choice of marinara or white sauce.

$8.95


Fried Calamari

$8.95


Wings

Your choice of Buffalo or BBQ.

$9.95


Mozzarella Sticks

$6.95


Perogies

Potato and cheddar.

$6.95


Pizza Fries

$3.95


Potato Wedges

$3.00


Appetizers for Two

Mozzarella Sticks, Chicken Fingers, Fried Calamari, Fried Mushrooms, Zucchini Sticks

$9.95

soups
Soups

Pasta Faggiola Soup

$3.95


Minestone Soup

$3.95


Chicken Noodle Soup

$3.95


Chicken Tortellini Soup

$3.95


Italian Wedding Soup

$3.95


Stracciatella Romano Soup

$3.95


Manhattan Clam Chowder Soup

$4.95


Broccoli & Cheddar Soup

$4.95

salads
Salads

Country Chicken Salad

$7.95


Tuna Salad

$7.95


Caesar Salad

$6.95


Caesar Salad with Chicken

$7.95


Grilled Chicken Salad

$7.95


Antipasto

$6.95


Antipasto For Two

$8.95


Fresh Mozzarella & Tomato

$7.50


Calamari Salad

$7.95


Seafood Salad

Made with calamari, clams, shrimp, mussels, celery, onions and tomatoes.

$10.95


Chef Salad

$7.95


Turkey Salad

$7.95


Grilled Shrimp Salad

$8.95


Grilled Chicken & Shrimp Salad

$8.95


Italiano Salad

Made with salami, prosciutto and fresh mozzarella.

$8.95


Tossed Salad

$4.50

parmigiana-dinners
Parmigiana Dinners
Served over your choice of pasta, salad & bread

Eggplant Rollatini Dinner

$10.95


Eggplant Parmigiana Dinner

$10.95


Sausage Parmigiana Dinner

$10.95


Meatball Parmigiana Dinner

$10.95


Sausage & Peppers Dinner

$10.95


Meatballs & Peppers Dinner

$10.95

pasta-dinners
Pasta Dinners
Served with your choice of salad & bread. When given a choice of pasta we have penne, rigatoni, spaghetti, linguini, gnocchi, cavatelli, angel hair, tortellini, or fettuccini.

Brothers Special Baked Rigatoni

Made with sausage, eggplant, onions and mushrooms in marinara sauce.

$10.95


Baked Manicotti

$10.95


Baked Penne Sicilian Style

$10.95


Baked Stuffed Shells

$10.95


Baked Lasagna

$10.95


Baked Penne Bolognese

$10.95


Baked Stuffed Macaroni

Served with Pink Sauce.

$10.95


Baked Ravioli

Your choice of cheese, meat OR spinach ravioli.

$10.95


Baked Tortellini Alfredo

$10.95


Anchovies, Garlic & Oil

$10.95


Fettuccine Alfredo

$10.95


Fettuccine Primavera

Your choice of red sauce or cream sauce.

$10.95


Your Choice!

Your choice of pasta and sauce. Choose one sauce: red, mushroom, tomato, marinara, meat, carbonara, vodka or pink.

$10.95


Broccoli

Served in your choice of red or white sauce with your choice of pasta.

$10.95


Meatball or Sausage

Served in a red sauce with your choice of pasta.

$10.95


Cavatelli & Broccoli

Served in your choice of red or white sauce.

$10.95


Tortellini & Broccoli

Served in your choice of red or white sauce.

$10.95

veal
Veal
Served with your choice of pasta, soup OR salad AND bread or garlic bread

Veal Cutlet Parmigiana

With melted mozzarella.

$14.95


Veal Reale

Sautéed in white wine. Topped with eggplant and mozzarella.

$14.95


Veal Scaloppine Sorrentina

With spinach, prosciutto, eggplant and mozzarella.

$14.95


Veal Saltimbocca

With prosciutto and spinach sautéed in wine sauce. Topped with mozzarella.

$14.95


Veal Marsala

Sautéed with mushrooms in Marsala wine.

$14.95


Veal Piccata

Sautéed with Sautéed in white wine and lemon with capers. in Marsala wine.

$14.95


Veal Florentine

Topped with spinach, tomatoes and mozzarella in a light red sauce.

$14.95


Veal Contadina

Artichokes and mushrooms in a light red sauce.

$14.95

seafood
Seafood
Served with your choice of pasta, soup or salad AND bread or garlic bread.

Zuppa di Pesce

Shrimp, calamari, mussels, and clams in a light red sauce.

$17.95


Shrimp Parmigiana

With melted mozzarella.

$14.95


Shrimp Marinara

With garlic in marinara sauce.

$14.95


Shrimp Fra Diavolo

With spicy marinara sauce.

$14.95


Shrimp Francese

In a lemon sauce.

$14.95


Shrimp Scampi

In a white wine, garlic and lemon sauce.

$14.95


Shrimp & Broccoli

In a white wine and garlic sauce.

$14.95


Shrimp Alfredo

With peas in Alfredo sauce.

$14.95


Clams sauce

In your choice of a white or red sauce.

$12.95


Mussels & Clams

In a red sauce.

$14.95


Clams & Calamari

In a red sauce.

$14.95


Calamari & Scungilli

In a red sauce.

$15.95


Scallops Florentine

With spinach, tomatoes, and mozzarella in a light red sauce.

$14.95


Lobster Ravioli

With pink sauce.

$12.95


Tilapia francese or piccata

$14.95

poultry
Poultry
Served with your choice of pasta, soup or salad AND bread or garlic bread

Chicken Parmigiana

With melted mozzarella.

$13.95


Chicken Sorrentino

Served with melted mozzarella.

$13.95


Chicken Piccata

Sautéed in white wine & lemon with capers.

$13.95


Chicken Carbonara

Served with onions, prosciutto and mushrooms in a light garlic cream sauce.

$13.95


Chicken Scampi

Served in a white sauce with garlic and lemon.

$13.95


Chicken Vodka

Strips of chicken served in a creamy vodka sauce.

$13.95


Chicken Marsala

Strips of chicken served in a creamy vodka sauce.

$16.95


Chicken Reale

Topped with eggplant and mozzarella.

$13.95


Chicken Cacciatore

Topped with eggplant and mozzarella.

$13.95


Chicken Francese

Sautéed in butter and lemon.

$13.95


Chicken Pizzaiola

Sautéed in marinara sauce with onions and peppers.

$13.95


Chicken & Broccoli

Served in your choice of a light red or white sauce.

$13.95


Chicken Alfredo

$13.95


Chicken Rollatini

Served with prosciutto, eggplant and mozzarella.

$13.95


Chicken Primavera

Served in a cream sauce.

$13.95


Chicken Florentine

Topped with spinach, tomatoes and mozzarella in a light red sauce.

$13.95


Chicken Contadina

Served with artichokes and mushrooms in a light red sauce.

$13.95


Chicken Saltimbocca

Served with prosciutto and spinach. Sautéed in a wine sauce and topped with mozzarella.

$13.95


Chicken Murphy

Served with mushrooms, onions, peppers, and potatoes.

$13.95


Chicken Balsamic

Served with roasted peppers & broccoli in a white sauce.

$13.95


Chicken Anthony

Served with shrimp and broccoli.

$13.95


Chicken Scarpiello

Served with sausage, mushroom, and onions in a garlic wine sauce.

$13.95

from-the-grill
From The Grill

Cheesesteak

add toppings 50c

$5.95


Chicken Cheesesteak

$7.50


House Special Cheesesteak

Served with peppers, onions and mushrooms.

$7.95


Cheesesteak California

Served with lettuce, onions, tomatoes, and mayonnaise.

$7.95


Grilled Chicken California

Served with lettuce, onions and tomatoes and mayonnaise.

$7.95


Cheeseburger Deluxe

$6.95


New York Sub

Served with grilled chicken, fresh mozzarella, roasted red pepper, and balsamic dressing.

$7.50


Pizza Burger

$6.95


Gyro sandwich with french fries

Beef or chicken

$6.95


Chicken Quesadilla with French Fries

pepper, onion, and mushrooms

$6.95

cold-subs
Cold Subs
Served with lettuce, tomato, and onions.

Italian Sub

Served with ham, cheese, and salami.

$6.95


Ham & Cheese Sub

$5.95


Salami & Cheese Sub

$5.95


Turkey & Cheese Sub

$7.50


Prosciutto & Provolone Sub

$7.50


Prosciutto, Roasted Peppers and Fresh Mozzarella Sub

$7.50


Tuna Sub

$6.95


Roast Beef with Provolone Sub

$7.50


Roast Beef & Turkey with Mozzarella Sub

$7.95


Salami, Prosciutto and Mozzarella Sub

$7.50

hot-subs
Hot Subs

Chicken Cutlet Parmigiana

$7.50


Eggplant Parmigiana

$6.95


Peppers & Egg Sub

$5.95


Meatball Parmigiana Sub

$6.95


Sausage, Peppers, and Onions Sub

$6.95


Crispy Chicken with Vodka Sauce Sub

$7.95


Veal Cutlet Parmigiana Sub

$7.95


Sausage & Egg Sub

$5.95


Italian Hot Dog

Served with peppers, onions, and potatoes.

$6.95


Sausage Parmigiana Sub

$6.95


Meatball, Peppers, and Onions Sub

$6.95


Shrimp Parmigiana Sub

$8.50

grilled-panini
Grilled Panini
Served with fries. Can be served with salad, just add $1.

Antipasto Panini

Grilled chicken, artichoke hearts, sun dried tomatoes, roasted red peppers, provolone, prosciutto, and Italian dressing.

$7.50


The Godfather Panini

Grilled chicken, portobello mushrooms, roasted red peppers, fresh mozzarella, basil, and balsamic dressing.

$7.50


Brothers Special Panini

Breaded chicken cutlet, grilled eggplant, fresh mozzarella, red peppers and balsamic dressing.

$7.50


Caprese Panini

Fresh mozzarella, tomatoes, roasted red peppers, basil and balsamic dressing.

$7.50


Americano Panini

Ham, salami, American cheese, tomatoes, oil, and vinegar.

$7.95


Vegetable Panini

Eggplant, spinach, roasted red peppers, portobello mushrooms, fresh mozzarella, and balsamic dressing.

$7.50


Turkey Club Panini

Turkey, American cheese, tomatoes, and bacon. Served with your choice of mustard or mayonnaise.

$7.50


Italiano Panini

Ham, salami, provolone, lettuce, onions, tomatoes, oil and vinegar.

$7.50


The New York Panini

Grilled chicken, roasted red peppers, fresh mozzarella, basil, and balsamic dressing.

$7.50

wraps
Wraps
Served with potato wedges or salad with salad $1 extra

California Chicken Wrap

$7.50


Cheesesteak Wrap

Served with peppers, onions, and mushrooms.

$7.50


Honey Mustard Chicken Wrap

$7.50


Buffalo Chicken Wrap

$7.50


Blackened Chicken Wrap

$7.50


Chicken Caesar Wrap

$7.50


Breaded Chicken Wrap

Served with mozzarella, lettuce, onion and tomato.

$7.50


Italian Wrap

Served with ham, salami, and cheese.

$7.50


Chicken, Bacon, and Ranch Wrap

Served with lettuce and tomato.

$7.50


Prosciutto, Fresh Mozzarella, and Balsamic Wrap

$7.50


New York Grilled Chicken Wrap

Served with roasted red peppers, fresh mozzarella, basil, and balsamic dressing.

$7.50

cluk-u-chicken
Cluk U Chicken

Wings

$5.95


Tenders

$5.95

baked-specialties
Baked Specialties
All calzones served with mozzarella and ricotta cheese. All other rolls with mozzarella. Additional toppings for 50¢ each. Additional toppings for large are $2 each.

Cheese Calzone

$6.95


Deep Fried Calzone

$7.95


One Filling Calzone

$7.50


Vegetable Special Calzone

$7.95


Chicken Calzone

$8.50


Veal Calzone

$7.95


Meat Stromboli

$7.95


Sausage Roll

Sausage served with peppers, onions and mozzarella.

$6.95


Pepperoni Roll

$7.50


Chicken Roll

$7.50


Steak Roll

Served with peppers, onions and mushrooms.

$7.95

pizza
Pizza

Plain Cheese Pizza

$10.00


Plain White with Ricotta Pizza

$12.00


White with Broccoli Pizza

$15.95


White Tomato and Garlic Pizza

$15.95


Four Cheese Pizza

$15.95


Vegetable Special Pizza

$15.95


Brothers Special

Made with peppers, onions, mushrooms, pepperoni and sausage

$15.95


Ziti with Vodka Sauce Pizza

$15.95


Tortellini Alfredo Pizza

$15.95


Eggplant with Ricotta Pizza

$15.95


Tomato, Garlic and Basil with Red Sauce Pizza

$15.95


Chicken, Bacon and Ranch Pizza

$14.95


BLT Pizza

Bacon, Lettuce, Tomato

$14.95


Hawaiian Pizza

$15.95


Chicken Marsala Pizza

$15.95


Chicken Parm Pizza

$15.95


Buffalo Chicken Pizza

$15.95


Chicken with POM Pizza

Peppers, Onions, and Mushrooms.

$15.95


Gluten Free Pizza

$10.95


Margarita Pizza

$15.95


Cheesesteak with POM

Peppers, Onions, and Mushrooms.

$15.95


Chicken, Broccoli and Tomatoes

$15.95


Chicken and Honey Mustard

$15.95


Stuffed Pizza

Your choice, meat or veggie.

$19.00


Barbecue Chicken Pizza

$15.95


Chicken Fajitas Pizza

$15.95


Taco Pizza

$15.95

personal-pizza
Personal Pizza
These are 12'' personal pizzas! Get one for every member of the family! Additional toppings are 75¢ for half or $1.50 on the whole pizza.

Plain Cheese Pizza

$7.50


Brothers Special Pizza

Made with peppers, onions, mushrooms, pepperoni, and sausage.

$9.95


Plain White with Ricotta and Mozzarella

$7.95

thick-crust-pan-pizza
Thick Crust Pan Pizza
Additional toppings are $1.25 for half or $2.50 on the whole pizza.

Plain Cheese Pan Pizza

$14.95


Chicken, Broccoli and Tomato Pan Pizza

$18.95


Honey Mustard Chicken Pan Pizza

$18.95


Bruschetta Pan Pizza

$18.95


Vegetable Pan Pizza

$18.95


Chicken Marsala Pan Pizza

$18.95


Chicken Parmigiana Pan Pizza

$18.95

square-sicilian-pizza
Square Sicilian Pizza
Additional toppings are $1.25 for half or $2.50 on the whole pizza.

Plain Sicilian Pizza

$14.95


Brothers Special Sicilian Pizza

Made with peppers, onions, mushrooms, pepperoni, and sausage.

$18.95


Vegetable Special Sicilian Pizza

$18.95

desserts
Desserts

Zeppolis

$3.95


Tiramisu

$5.50


Oreo Cookie Bash

$5.50


New York Cheesecake

$5.50


Cannoli

$3.50


Chocolate Peanut Butter Pie

$5.50


The Big Blitz with Snickers

$5.50

childrens-menu
Children's Menu

Spaghetti with Tomato Sauce

$5.95


Ravioli

$5.95


Baked Penne

$5.95


Hot Dog & Fries

$5.95


Cheeseburger & Fries

$5.95


Grilled Cheese & Fries

$5.95


Spaghetti with Meatball

$5.95


Stuffed Shells

$5.95


Penne with Broccoli

Served in a white sauce.

$5.95


Chicken Fingers & Fries

$5.95


Pizza Burger & Fries

$5.95


Macaroni & Cheese

$5.95

sides
Sides

Side of Sausage

Served in red sauce.

$4.95


Side og Meatball

Served in red sauce.

$4.95


Steamed Broccoli

In garlic and oil.

$4.95


Broccoli Rabe

Served with portobello, garlic, and oil.

$4.95


Steamed Spinach

In garlic and oil.

$4.95

SlicePizza Places in Wantage, NJ Brothers Pizza & Italian Restaurant
Price: $$