Skip to main content
Benny's Pizza Ave J

Benny's Pizza Ave J

1418 Ave J, Brooklyn, NY 11230
717-356-3288

Open until 8:00 PM

Full Hours
    Skip to first category
    pizza

    Pizza

    Regular Pizza

    Classic cheese or create your own pizza.

    $29.95

    Regular Pizza

    Grandma Pizza

    Mixed mozzarella, tomato sauce topped with parmesan.

    $34.00

    Original Pizza

    $31.99

    Sicilian Pizza

    $34.00

    Ala Vodka Pizza

    Mozzarella in vodka sauce.

    $34.00

    Deep Dish Pizza

    Thick dough with tomato sauce topped with mozzarella.

    $34.00

    Bianca Pizza

    Mozzarella, parmesan, ricotta, and a touch of garlic (no sauce).

    $34.00

    Bianca Pizza

    Tomato Basil Deep Dish

    Roasted tomatoes, mozzarella, and fresh basil.

    $34.00

    Fresh Mozzarella Pizza

    $34.00

    Stuffed Crust Pizza

    Crust stuffed with cheese and spread with butter and garlic.

    $35.00

    Spinach Tomato Pizza

    Roasted tomatoes and fresh spinach with a touch of garlic.

    $34.00

    Whole Wheat Pie

    $30.00

    Margarita Pizza

    Mozzarella, fresh tomato sauce, and basil.

    $34.00

    Green Olives Pie

    $32.00

    Mushroom Pizza

    Wild mushrooms topped with roasted garlic and three cheeses.

    $34.00

    Mushroom Pizza

    Black Olives Pie

    $32.00

    Pepper Pizza

    Mixed peppers and onions and tomato sauce.

    $34.00

    Eggplant Pie

    $34.00

    Pasta Pizza

    Vodka sauce and cheese on pasta.

    $39.00

    Broccoli Pie

    $34.00

    Broccoli Pie

    Cheeseless Vegetable Pizza

    Mixed peppers, roasted tomatoes, and fresh tomato sauce.

    $33.00

    Vegan Pepperoni Pie

    Vegan Pepperoni

    $36.00

    Vegan Pepperoni Pie
    low-carb-pizza

    Low Carb Pizza

    Made on a wrap.

    Regular Low Carb Pizza

    $14.00

    Fresh Spinach & Cheese Low Carb Pizza

    $15.00

    Olive & Cheese Low Carb Pizza

    $15.00

    Mushroom Roasted Garlic with Cheese Low Carb Pizza

    $15.00

    Grandma Sauce Low Carb Pizza

    $15.00

    Gluten Free Pizza

    $18.00

    personal-pies

    Personal Pies

    Vodka Pie

    $17.00

    Mushroom Pie

    $17.00

    Pepper Pie

    $17.00

    Original Pie

    $17.00

    Olive Pie

    $17.00

    Regular Pie

    $16.00

    Broccoli Pie

    $17.00

    Vegan Pepperoni Pie

    Vegan Pepperoni

    $17.00

    Vegan Pepperoni Pie
    slices

    Slices

    Regular Slice

    Classic cheese or create your own pizza.

    $4.99

    Vegan Pepperoni Slice

    Vegan Pepperoni

    $5.50

    Vegan Pepperoni Slice

    Original Pizza Slice

    $5.50

    specialty-slices

    Specialty Slices

    Ala Vodka Pizza Slice

    Mozzarella in vodka sauce.

    $5.50

    Pasta Pizza Slice

    Vodka sauce and cheese on pasta.

    $6.50

    Bianca Pizza Slice

    Mozzarella, parmesan, ricotta, and a touch of garlic (no sauce).

    $5.50

    Grandma Pizza Slice

    Mixed mozzarella, tomato sauce topped with parmesan.

    $5.50

    Fresh Mozzarella Pizza Slice

    $5.50

    Sicilian Pizza Slice

    $5.00

    Cheese Crust Pizza Slice

    $5.50

    Deep Dish Pizza Slice

    Thick dough with tomato sauce topped with mozzarella.

    $5.00

    Spinach Tomato Pizza Slice

    Roasted tomatoes and fresh spinach with a touch of garlic.

    $5.50

    Tomato Basil Deep Dish Slice

    Roasted tomatoes, mozzarella, and fresh basil.

    $5.00

    Margarita Pizza Slice

    Mozzarella, fresh tomato sauce, and basil.

    $5.50

    Stuffed Crust Pizza Slice

    Crust stuffed with cheese and spread with butter and garlic.

    $5.50

    Mushroom Pizza Slice

    Wild mushrooms topped with roasted garlic and three cheeses.

    $5.50

    Pesto Pizza Slice

    $5.50

    Pepper Pizza Slice

    Mixed peppers and onions and tomato sauce.

    $5.50

    omelets

    Omelets

    With garden veggies or French fries.

    Sunny Side Up Omelette

    Egg fried on one side.

    $15.00

    Marinara Omelette

    Sauteed spinach and mozzarella.

    $15.00

    Cheese Omelette

    Filled with melted mozzarella.

    $15.00

    Greek Omelette

    Feta cheese, olives, and onion.

    $15.00

    Italian Omelette

    Fresh basil, roasted tomatoes, and mozzarella.

    $15.00

    Sam’s Omelette

    Sauteed spinach and feta cheese.

    $15.00

    appetizers

    Appetizers

    Mozzarella Sticks

    Cheese sticks with a side of marinara sauce.

    $11.00

    Mozzarella Sticks

    Eggplant Rollatini

    Ricotta, mozzarella, and parmesan with tomato sauce.

    $16.00

    Homemade Onion Rings

    $11.00

    Homemade Onion Rings

    Stacked Eggplant Florentine

    Fresh spinach, eggplant, ricotta, parmesan, and mozzarella cheese topped with tomato sauce.

    $16.00

    Regular Fries

    $9.00

    Sauteed Vegetables

    $16.00

    Cajun Fries

    $9.00

    Garlic Knots

    $4.00

    Garlic Knots

    Sweet Chili Fries

    $9.50

    Cheese Pretzels

    $10.00

    Cheese Fries

    $13.00

    Pizza Roll

    Deep-Fried crust with sauce and cheese

    $8.50

    Gravy Fries

    Melted cheese and hot gravy.

    $13.00

    soup

    Soup

    Fagioli Soup

    White bean, spinach, and vegetables.

    $10.00

    Lentil Soup

    $10.00

    French Onion Soup

    Served with bread and melted cheese.

    $11.00

    salad

    Salad

    Greek Salad

    $16.00

    Greek Salad

    Create Own Salad

    $15.00

    Caesar Salad

    $16.00

    Caesar Salad
    stromboli

    Stromboli

    Mushroom & Cheese Stromboli

    $10.00

    Spinach & Cheese Stromboli

    $10.00

    wraps

    Wraps

    Tuna Wrap

    $13.00

    Eggplant Parmigiana Wrap

    $13.00

    Primavera Wrap

    Spinach, zucchini, mushroom, tomato, and mozzarella cheese.

    $13.00

    Veggie Burger Wrap

    Lettuce and tomato.

    $13.00

    Avocado Wrap

    Peppers, red onion, and avocado.

    $13.00

    Caprese Wrap

    Roasted peppers, tomato, and mozzarella with pesto.

    $13.00

    Vegetable Wrap

    Zucchini, onions, peppers, mushrooms, and cheese.

    $13.00

    Grilled Salmon Wrap

    Salmon filet with sauteed spinach and honey dijon.

    $18.00

    paninis

    Paninis

    Tuna Panini

    $14.00

    Eggplant Parmigiana Panini

    $14.00

    Vegetable Panini

    Peppers, zucchini, red onions, mushrooms, and mozzarella.

    $14.00

    Greek Panini

    Feta cheese, tomatoes, olives, and pesto.

    $14.00

    Caprese Panini

    Roasted peppers, tomato, mozzarella with pesto.

    $14.00

    Sam's Panini

    Omelette, feta cheese, and sauteed spinach.

    $14.00

    pasta

    Pasta

    Chef’s Pasta

    Fresh spinach, capers, tomatoes, and basil in white wine.

    $17.00

    Benny’s Pasta

    Sauteed artichokes, broccoli, cherry tomatoes, capers, and fresh garlic in the red sauce.

    $17.00

    Pasta Primavera

    Broccoli, zucchini, black olives, and roasted red peppers.

    $17.00

    Pasta Primavera

    Pasta Con Broccoli

    Sauteed garlic, broccoli, and parmesan in a white wine sauce.

    $17.00

    Penne Di Pomodoro Pasta

    Tomatoes, fresh basil, and parmesan cheese.

    $17.00

    Pasta Luigino

    Sauteed garlic, basil, mushrooms, and roasted tomatoes.

    $17.00

    Penne Ala Funghi Pasta

    Wild mushrooms in cream sauce.

    $17.00

    Alfredo Sauce Pasta

    Fettuccine in cream and parmesan.

    $17.00

    Pasta Puttanesca

    Capers, black olives, and fresh basil in tomato sauce.

    $17.00

    Marinara Sauce Pasta

    Fresh garlic and basil in tomato sauce.

    $17.00

    Penne Ala Vodka Pasta

    Cream sauce and fresh marinara.

    $17.00

    Pesto Pasta

    Olive oil, fresh garlic, heavy cream, and pesto, and parmesan.

    $17.00

    Eggplant Parmesan Pasta

    Breaded eggplant, mozzarella cheese in tomato sauce.

    $17.00

    Gnocchi Pasta

    $19.00

    Baked Penne Pasta

    Parmesan, mozzarella in tomato sauce.

    $17.00

    Ravioli Pasta

    $19.00

    fish

    Fish

    Grilled Salmon

    $18.00

    drinks

    Drinks

    Soda

    $2.50

    Water

    $2.00

    Snapple

    $3.00

    Seltzer Water

    $2.50

    Benny's Pizza Ave J - View Menu & Order Online - 1418 Ave J, Brooklyn, NY 11230 - Slice

    SliceNYBrooklyn11230 Benny's Pizza Ave J
    Price: $$