hero

Tony's Pizzeria

443 Knickerbocker Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11237

Open NowFull HoursAre you the owner?

We're all about supporting local pizzerias - even those who are not Slice partners.
Give Tony's Pizzeria a call to order. We hear their food's delish.

Menu
traditional-slices-pies
  • Traditional Pie Slice $2.30
  • Traditional Pie $9.50 +
tonys-specialty-pizza-pies
  • Bacon Double Cheeseburger Pizza (Stuffed) $16.75 +
    Order comes w/ Sm. Tray of Fries or Onion Rings. Mouthwatering blend of American & mozzarella cheeses on our perfectly seasoned ground beef with crisp beef bacon bits, luscious romaine lettuce & diced tomatoes. No Bacon or Turkey Bacon options available.
  • Bacon Cheese Fries Pizza $13.50 +
    Seasoned curly fries with Beef or Turkey Bacon & smothered w/ Am, Cheddar & Mozz.
  • Buffalo Chicken Pizza $16.50 +
    Tender breaded chicken marinated in BBQ or Buffalo sauce & topped w/ Sizzling mozzarella cheese.
  • Baked Ziti $11.00 +
    Al dente ziti smothered in Tony's prized garlic & basil based San-Marzano marinara sauce. Baked to perfection w/ ricotta & mozzarella cheeses & garnished w/ freshly chopped basil.
  • Chicken Caesar Pizza $13.50 +
    Crisp romaine lettuce, grilled chicken & caesar dressing.
  • Brooklyn's Own Pizza $15.00 +
    Tender breaded chicken, crisp pepperoni & glazed Italian sausages. Topped w/ cheddar & mozzarella cheeses & garnished w/ fresh oregano.
  • Cinco de Mayo Pizza $13.00 +
    Mexico's Special. Sauteed onions & jalapeno peppers w/ spicy chorizo sausage smothered in sizzling mozzarella & cheddar cheeses.
  • Chicken Parmigiana Pizza $14.50 +
    Diced chicken cutlet topped with Tony's prized zesty garlic & basil based San-Marzano marinara sauce & fresh mozzarella cheese.
  • Cinque Formaggi Pizza (No Sauce) $14.00 +
    Blend of mozzarella, cheddar, Mont. Jack, Pecorino Romano & ricotta.
  • Cream Cheesed Pizza $10.50 +
    Freshly baked pizza base w/ a creamy blend of cream cheese. Spiced and garnished to perfection.
  • Egg & Cheese Hashed Browns Pizza (Stuffed) $13.50 +
    Shredded hashed browns w/ eggs, American cheese, bacon or ham.
  • Grandma Sicilian Pizza (Thin Crust) $15.50 +
    Home-made fresh mozzarella cheese & blend of Tony's garlic & basil based San-Marzano tomato sauce w/ roasted garlic, basil & olive oil base.
  • Gyro Pizza $16.75 +
    Beef/lamb or chicken gyro strips with tomato, lettuce & tzatziki sauce.
  • Ham & Cheese Triple Decker Pizza $13.50 +
    Smoked, BLK Forest, & Virg. ham with/sizzling Am. cheese & Mozz.
  • Hawaiian Pizza $13.50 +
    Ham & crushed pineapple topped w/ mozz. cheese.
  • Lasagna Pizza $16.75 +
    Layers of lasagna noodles, meat sauce & sizzling mozzarella, ricotta, & parmesan cheeses topped w/ Tony's specially made garlic & basil based San-Marzano marinara sauce. Classically seasoned & baked to perfection.
  • Macaroni & Cheese Pizza $11.00 +
    Classic macaroni smothered in cheddar & Mozzarella Cheese.
  • Margherita Pizza $11.50 +
    Tony's specially made garlic & basil San-Marzano marinara sauce & fresh mozzarella cheese. Baked to perfection & garnished w/ fresh basil and Pecorino Romano cheese (crust glazed with extra-origin olive oil).
  • Mediterranean Pizza $16.75 +
    Falafel & tabouli with freshly made hummus.
  • New Yorker Pizza $12.50 +
    Freshly diced portobello mushrooms, glazed Italian sausages, crisp pepperoni & Tony's house sauce. Topped w/ sizzling mozzarella cheese.
  • Pastrami & Swiss Pizza $16.75 +
    Mildly smoked pastrami sliced & cooked to perfection. Topped w/ crisp bacon, sauteed red onions, Swiss, Mont. Jack & mozzarella cheeses.
  • Pico de Gallo Pizza $14.50 +
    A chopped blend of chili peppers, cilantro & Roma tomatoes topped w/ avocado & mozz. cheese.
  • Philly Cheesesteak Pizza (Stuffed) $15.00 +
    Our prized hand-made pizza shell stuffed w/ sauteed onions, thinly sliced steak & sizzling Mozzarella & American cheeses.
  • Potato Lover's Pizza $13.50 +
    Seasonal mashed potatoes, crisp bacon & mozzarella & cheddar cheeses.
  • Popcorn Shrimp Pizza $16.75 +
    Or buffalo shrimp. Seasonal Shrimps with sizzling mozzarella & cheddar cheeses.
  • Roast Beef & Cheddar Pizza $16.75 +
    Seasonal roast beef, sauteed red onion & crisp bacon topped with mozzarella & cheddar cheeses.
  • Taco Pizza $12.50 +
    Seasoned ground beef, crisp romaine lettuce & freshly chopped tomatoes smothered in sizzling cheddar & mozzarella cheeses.
  • Ti Amo Dessert Pizza $16.75 +
    Nutella chocolate smothered with strawberries & marshmallows.
  • Tuna Melt Pizza $13.50 +
    Seasoned tuna with tomatoes, romaine lettuce, carrots & mayo.
  • Traditional New York-Style Neapolitan Pizza $9.50 +
    San-Marzano Tomato Sauce topped w/ sizzling Mozzarella Cheese.
  • Vegan Veggie Pizza $16.75 +
    Chopped blend of vegan vegetables topped with hummus.
  • White (Cheese Only) Pizza $11.00 +
    A seasonal blend of mozzarella & ricotta cheeses. Cherry tomatoes optional.
  • Veggie Burger Pizza (J Special) $15.50 +
    Chopped blend of vegetables topped w/ hummus & Am. Mozz. cheeses.
  • Upside Down Sicilian Pizza $14.50 +
    San-Marzano marinara sauce over sizzling fresh mozzarella cheese.
  • Sicilian Pizza $13.50 +
    Tony's prized San-Marzano sauce topped w/sizzling mozzarella cheese.
  • Pasta Arrabiata $7.75
    Spicy San-Marzano based marinara sauce w/ chopped blend of spices.
  • Pasta Alfredo $10.75
    Classic parmigiano-reggiano cream sauce (pink sauce upon request).
  • Pasta All' Aglio e Olio $8.75
    Freshly chopped garlic sauteed in seasoned Extra - Virgin Olive Oil.
  • Pasta Alla Bolognese $12.75
    Southern Italian-style meat sauce w/ a touch of parmigiano-reggiano cream & herb.
  • Pasta Alla Carbonara $13.50
    Minced onions, pancetta (bacon) & egg yolk in parmesan based cream sauce.
  • Pasta Alla Marinara $7.00
    Classic garlic & basil based San-Morzano sauce.
  • Pasta Alla Pesto $11.25
    Classic and savory pesto sauce w/ chopped blend of basil, garlic, parmesan cheese, pine nuts & extra-virgin olive oil.
  • Pasta Alla Romano $12.50
    Tony's classic parmesan based cream sauce, peas & prosciutto.
  • Pasta Alla Vodka $11.50
    Smooth Parmesan-based cream sauce w/ a sultry blend of vodka. San-Marzano based tomato sauce, mushrooms, Italian bacon & herbs.
tonys-hearty-appetizers
  • Antipasto Salad $8.50 +
    Tossed choice of salad topped with choice of Italian cold cuts & cheeses.
  • Artichoke Flowers $9.50
    (in season) Seasoned breaded (w/artichoke / spinach cream sauce) or grilled artichokes (white wine butter sauce).
  • Baked Clams Oreganata $9.75
    Little neck clams baked to perfection with seasoned bread crumbs in a sultry butter-based lemon sauce.
  • Bacon Cheese Fries $6.50 +
    French, waffle, sweet potato or curly fries topped w/ crisp bacon bits & smothered in sizzling choice of cheeses.
  • Beef Pattie $2.30
    Mild Jamaican meat (beef) pattie.
  • Broccoli Rabe $7.75
    Sauteed broccoli rabe in a garlic and extra-virgin olive oil sauce.
  • Bruschetta Pomodoro $5.50
    Toasted Italian bread served with traditional Italian topping of chopped fresh garlic, Roma tomatoes, fresh basil & extra-virgin olive oil.
  • Calamari Fritti $9.50
    Golden fried calamari served w/ Tony's prized garlic & basil based San-Marzano marinara sauce.
  • Chicken Thumbs $8.50
    Tender chicken thumbs served w/ Tony's prized garlic & basil based San-Marzano marinara sauce.
  • Chicken Tenders $8.50
    Boneless chicken tenders (6) served w/ Tony's prized garlic & basil based San-Marzano marinara sauce.
  • Chicken Roll $5.50
    Diced tender breaded chicken smothered in mozzarella cheese & Tony's prized garlic & basil based San-Marzano marinara sauce.
  • Eggplant Rollatini $9.50
    Breaded eggplant (3) rolled to perfection with seasoned ricotta, mozzarella and parmesan cheeses. Topped with marinara sauce & sizzling mozzarella cheese.
  • French Fries $3.50 +
  • Fried Ravioli $6.50
    Freshly prepared breaded ravioli (10) fried to perfection & served w/ San-Marzano based marinara sauce.
  • Garlic Bread $1.75 +
    Freshly baked Italian hero or roll topped w/ roasted garlic & extra-virgin olive oil. Seasoned & toasted to perfection.
  • Garlic Knots $2.00
    Freshly baked knots (6) in fresh garlic & extra-virgin olive oil sauce. Seasoned to perfection.
  • Hot Dog (Combo Special) $5.50
    Grilled Hot Dog (2) served w/ fries or chips.
  • Hot Dog Mini Rolls $2.50
    Pizza dough rolled w/ mini hot dog & blend of mozzarella & American cheeses. Baked to perfection.
  • Mini Phillies (Combo Special) $5.50
    Two Mini Philly Cheese Steak sandwiches served w/ fries or chips.
  • Knish $2.30
    Seasoned potato pattie baked to perfection.
  • Onion Rings $3.75
    Golden fried onion rings served with choice of sauces.
  • Mozzarella Sticks $6.50
    Seasoned mozzarella cheese sticks (6) served w/ Tony's prized garlic & basil based San-Marzano marinara sauce.
  • Pepperoni Wheel $2.00
    Pizza dough rolled with crisp pepperoni or spinach & sizzling mozzarella cheese. Baked to perfection.
  • Pizza Fries $5.50 +
    Tony's prized garlic & basil based San-Marzano marinara sauce & sizzling mozzarella cheese.
  • Pizza Sub $4.00
    Freshly baked-Italian hero topped with Tony's prized garlic & basil based sauce & sizzling mozzarella cheese.
  • Rice Ball $3.75
    Ball of rice filled with meat sauce and peas. Seasoned to perfection.
  • Quesadilla $6.50
    Tortilla / Flat Bread toasted w/ grilled chicken, bell peppers & onions, mozzarella & Am. cheese. Baked to perfection.
  • Sausage & Peppers Roll $5.50
    Glazed Italian sausages w/ sauteed onions & bell peppers smothered in sizzling mozzarella cheese.
  • Sesame Seed & Roasted Garlic & Onion Cheese Twists $1.50
    Seasoned cheese twists.
  • Shrimp Cocktail $12.50
    Freshly breaded tiger shrimp (6) fried to perfection & served w/ San-Marzano based marinara sauce.
  • Shrimp $10.50
    Spicy Buffalo / BBQ - popcorn style shrimp served with blue cheese dipping sauce and celery stix.
  • Sliders (Combo Special) $6.50
    Mini Cheese Burger / Meatballs sliders (2) served w/ fries or chips.
  • Stuffed Mushrooms $9.75
    Shapely mushrooms filled with sultry blend of seasoned breadcrumbs, Pecorino Romano, garlic, parsley and extra-virgin olive oil. Topped w/ a Southern Italian vegetable mix.
  • Wings $0.75
    (Spicy or mild) Buffalo / BBQ wings (10) served with bleu cheese dipping sauce and celery stix.
  • Zeppoles $2.25
    Classic Italian battered dough balls (6) served with powdered sugar.
tonys-hearty-calzones
Calzone order comes with a complimentary side of Tony's San-Marzano based garlic and basil based marinara sauce.
  • Calzone $6.50
    Blend of sizzling mozzarella and seasoned ricotta cheese.
  • Calzone with Any One Meat Topping $7.50
  • Calzone with Any One Veggies & Herb Topping $7.00
  • Lasagna Calzone $8.25
    Lasagna noodles, blend of sizzling mozzarella and ricotta cheese & seasoned meat sauce.
tonys-freshly-grilled-burgers
  • Burger $6.50
    Tony's freshly made and seasoned 1/2 pound beef or turkey burger on kaiser roll.
  • Bacon Burger $8.00
    Tony's freshly made & seasoned 1/2 pound beef or turkey burger w/ crisp bacon on kaiser roll.
  • Tony's Italian-Style Pizza Burger $7.75
    1/2 lb. beef or turkey burger or kaiser roll smothered in San-Marzano Marinara sauce & mozzarella cheese.
  • Brooklyn's 'Best' Burger $9.50
    1/2 lb. seasoned burger w/ sizzling ham, egg & hash brown.
  • Vegan Veggie Burger $7.50
    Freshly-made vegan vegetable patties w/ choice of hummus (classic, garlic herb or roasted peppers).
  • Bacon Double Cheeseburger Slice $4.50
    Special: order comes w/ small fries.
  • Veggie Burger $6.50
    Freshly chopped blend of Vegetables Burger.
combo-wraps-flat-breads-gyros
ll orders served with choice of sm. drink and fries or chips. Choice of wraps: black bean, honey wheat, garlic & herb, habanero salsa, multigrain, tomato & basil, spinach & herb, white flour or whole wheat.
  • Beef Gyro $7.25
    Beef gyro strips, romaine lettuce, diced tomatoes and gyro sauce in a plain pita bread.
  • Chicken Gyro $7.25
    Beef gyro strips, romaine lettuce, diced tomatoes and gyro sauce in a plain pita bread.
  • Chicken Caesar Wrap $6.25
    Grilled or breaded chicken & romaine lettuce w/ our classic Caesar dressing.
  • BBQ Chicken Wrap $7.00
    Grilled or breaded chicken smothered in a BBQ / Buffalo sauce & mozz. & cheddar.
  • Buffalo Chicken Wrap $7.00
    Grilled or breaded chicken smothered in a BBQ / Buffalo sauce & mozz. & cheddar.
  • Chicken Club Wrap $7.00
    Grilled or breaded chicken, American cheese, romaine lettuce & diced tomatoes.
  • Turkey BLT Wrap $7.00
    Diced smoked turkey, crisp bacon, lettuce and tomatoes.
  • BLT Wrap $7.00
    Crisp bacon, lettuce & tomatoes.
  • Tuna Wrap $6.25
    Seasoned tuna smothered in mayonnaise, carrots, lettuce and tomatoes.
  • Monterey-Jack Chicken Wrap $7.00
    Grilled chicken, sauteed mushrooms & onions, Monterey Jack cheese & ranch dressing.
baked-entrees
  • Gnocchi $10.75
    Italian-style potato dumplings w/ our San-Marzano marinara sauce & mozzarella.
  • Lasagna $10.75
    Layers of lasagna noodles, meat sauce & mozzarella, ricotta & parmesan cheeses classically seasoned & topped w/ Tony's garlic & basil based San-Marzano marinara sauce. Baked to perfection w/ sizzling mozzarella cheese & garnished w/ fresh parsley.
  • Manicotti $10.75
    Manicotti can be stuffed w/ any type of meat, seafood or vegetable for additional cost. Ricotta and parmesan cheeses & herbs baked in freshly made pasta rolls & topped w/ Tony's garlic & basil based San-Marzano marinara sauce. Baked to perfection w/ sizzling mozzarella cheese & garnished w/ fresh parsley.
  • Ravioli $10.75
    Freshly made beef, cheese, portobello mushroom, roasted vegetable or spinach ravioli served in your choice of sauce & baked to perfection w/ sizzling mozzarella cheese.
  • Stuffed Shells $10.75
    Shells can be stuffed w/ any type of meat, seafood or vegetable for additional cost. Freshly made pasta shells stuffed w/ seasoned ricotta cheese & topped w/ Tony's garlic & basil based San-Marzano marinara. Baked to perfection w/ sizzling mozzarella cheese & garnished w/ fresh parsley.
  • Pasta $7.50
    Freshly made pasta w/ Tony's garlic & basil based San-Marzano marinara sauce. Baked to perfection w/ sizzling mozzarella cheese. Garnished w/ fresh parsley.
  • Tortellini $10.75
    Freshly made beef or cheese tortellini served in your choice of sauce of sauce & baked to perfection w/ sizzling mozzarella cheese.
vegetable-entrees
  • Broccoli All' Aglio e Olio $5.25 +
    in Extra Virgin Olive Oil & freshly chopped garlic.
  • Broccoli Rabe All' Aglio e Olio $5.25 +
    in Extra Virgin Olive Oil & freshly chopped garlic.
  • Spinach All' Aglio e Olio $5.25 +
    in Extra Virgin Olive Oil & freshly chopped garlic.
  • Eggplant $5.75 +
    Lightly breaded eggplant topped w/ Tony's garlic & basil based San-Marzano marinara sauce.
  • Primavera $4.75 +
    Sauteed garden vegetables in a cherry tomato cream sauce or garlic sauce w/ fresh mozzarella.
  • Potatoes, Peppers, Onions & Eggs $3.75 +
    Potato medley, bell peppers, onions & eggs (2) cooked & seasoned to perfection.
  • Vegetarian Sausage $7.00 +
    Sweet & savory veggie sausages sauteed in truffle oil, garlic, sauce & topped with San Marzano Marinara.
  • Vegetarian Lasagna $10.75
    Baked with mozzarella cheese.
chicken-veal
  • Chicken Alla Palermo $5.75 +
    Sauteed cutlets & broccoli (or spinach) in Tony's garlic based cream sauce. Tossed w/ parmesan cheese fresh mozzarella & topped w/ a touch of lemon sauce.
  • Chicken Cutlet $7.00 +
    Served without pasta. Tender breaded cutlets served with or without lettuce & Romano tomatoes (grilled chicken upon request).
  • Chicken Francese $7.00 +
    Battered cutlets in a buttery white-wine lemon sauce.
  • Chicken Florentina $5.25 +
    Sauteed tender cutlets, sauteed spinach & fresh mozzarella cheese tossed in a creamy pink sauce.
  • Chicken Marinara $5.00 +
    Perfectly breaded cutlets topped w / Tony's garlic & basil based San-Marzano marinara sauce.
  • Chicken Marsala $7.00 +
    Tender cutlets sauteed w / mushrooms in a marsala wine sauce.
  • Chicken Primavera $7.25 +
    Sauteed tender cutlets, fresh mozzarella, bell peppers, onions, spinach, broccoli, cherry tomatoes & mushrooms in a boldly arrabiata (spicy) basil based San-Marzano marinara sauce.
  • Chicken Pizzaiola $5.75 +
    Sauteed tender cutlets, sauteed onions & bell peppers tossed w / fresh mozzarella & Tony's prized garlic & basil based San-Marzano marinara sauce.
meat
  • Alla Palermo $5.75 +
    Glazed sweet Italian sausage & sauteed broccoli in Tony's garlic based cream sauce. Tossed w/ Parmesan cheese, fresh mozzarella & topped w/ a touch of lemon sauce.
  • Bolognese (Meat Sauce) $8.75 +
    Seasoned ground beef in a Southern Italian style cream sauce (spicy upon request).
  • Sausages $6.50 +
    Glazed sweet Italian sausages w/ Tony's prized garlic & basil based San-Marzano marinara sauce (spicy upon request).
  • Meatballs $6.50 +
    Perfectly baked home-made meatballs topped w/ garlic & basil based San-Marzano Marinara Sauce (spicy upon request).
  • Philly Cheesesteak $6.75 +
    All Platter served with garlic stix. Thinly sliced steak, sauteed onions & sizzling mozzarella & Am. cheeses. Served w/ out pasta.
seafood
  • Seafood Sauteed in White Wine & Lemon Sauce. $10.50 +
    Calamari, clams, mussels, scallops, shrimp or tilapia scampi. Sauteed in a white wine-based buttery lemon sauce. Dish garnished w/ freshly chopped parsley
  • Seafood in San Marzano Marinara Sauce $9.50 +
    Calamari, clams, mussels, scallops, shrimp or tilapia marinara. Served in Tony's garlic & basil based San-Marzano marinara sauce (spicy upon request). Dish garnished w/ freshly chopped parsley.
  • Seafood in Buttery Garlic & Oil Sauce $11.50 +
    Calamari, clams, mussels, scallops, shrimp or tilapia.
  • Seafood in Creamy Cheese Sauce $11.50 +
    Calamari, clams, mussels, scallops, shrimp or tilapia.
  • Seafood Sauteed in Sauteed Bell Peppers, Onions $11.50 +
    Served w/ sauteed bell peppers, onions, cherry tomatoes, broccoli, spinach & mushrooms. Dish garnished w/ freshly chopped parsley.
desserts-milkshakes-smoothies
  • Cakes $4.00
    Assorted and freshly baked.
  • Cannoli $2.50
    Freshly baked & filled.
  • Chocolate Cannoli $3.00
    Freshly baked & filled.
  • Fresh Fruit Salad $3.50 +
  • Freshly Baked Chocolate Chip Cookies $1.00
  • Cinnamon Bacon Cookies $1.00
  • Brownie $1.00
  • Ices $0.75
  • Ice Cream $1.50
  • Muffins $1.75
  • Danishes $1.75
  • Elephant Ears $1.75
  • Smoothies $3.50 +
  • Caramel Iced Lattes $3.50 +
  • Milkshakes $4.50 +
    Vanilla/Strawberry/Chocolate.
beverages
  • Naked Food Drinks $2.50
  • Tropicana $1.75
  • Sea Pellegrino $3.50 +
  • Snapple $1.50 +
  • Gatorade $1.50 +
  • Sodas $1.00 +
  • Water $1.00

FAQ