Mustachio's Pizzeria is not currently open. Place a future order or find other great pizzerias around you!
Mustachio's Pizzeria
2701 Elmwood Ave, Buffalo, NY 14217
4.9(515)
Currently ClosedFull HoursNo MinimumPickup (30 - 45 min)Menu
fresh-baked-pizza
Fresh Baked Pizza
Cheese Pizza$12.99 +
Classic cheese or create your own pizza.
Gluten Free Pizza$13.99
Cheese & 1 item.
specialty-pizza
Specialty Pizza
Sicilian Pizza$16.99 +
Oil, garlic, romano, tomatoes dipped in special sauce, onions & your choice of hot or sweet peppers & sausage or pepperoni.
Spinach Ricotta Pizza$16.99 +
Spinach, mushrooms, garlic, ricotta, mozzarella & romano.
Broccoli Cheddar Pizza$16.99 +
Melted cheddar, grated romano, onions, 100% pure olive oil, garlic, pepper & oregano.
White Pizza$16.99 +
Romano & mozzarella, onions, fresh cut tomatoes, 100% pure olive oil, garlic, pepper & oregano. Anchovies upon request.
Taco Pizza$16.99 +
Hot, medium, or mild sauce with mozzarella, cheddar, ground beef, lettuce & tomatoes.
Buffalo Style Pizza$16.99 +
Hot, medium, or mild diced chicken fingers, pizza sauce or blue cheese base & mozzarella.
Veggie Deluxe Pizza$16.99 +
Mushrooms, sweet & hot peppers, green & black olives, onions & mozzarella.
Spaghetti & Meatballs Parm Pizza$16.99 +
Pizza sauce, cooked spaghetti, chopped meatballs, mozzarella & romano.
Hawaiian Pizza$16.99 +
Pizza sauce, ham, pineapple & mozzarella .
billys-zas-pizza
Billy's 'ZAs Pizza
CBR Pizza$17.99 +
Chicken fingers, bacon, ranch, lite onion, mozzarella & cheddar.
BBQ Chicken Pizza$17.99 +
BBQ sauce, chicken, bacon, cheddar, mozzarella & lite onions.
Meat Lover's Deluxe Pizza$17.99 +
Pepperoni, sausage, meatball, ham & bacon.
Steak Hoagie Pizza$17.99 +
Oil base hoagie cheese with a mixture of sweet peppers, mushrooms, onions & ribeye steak topped with romano & your choice of mozzarella or cheddar cheese.
Supreme Deluxe Pizza$17.99 +
Our veggie deluxe topped with pepperoni & sausage.
Grilled Chicken & Mushroom Pizza$17.99 +
Available with pizza sauce or white style topped with mozzarella cheese. Also great with broccoli!
Stuffed Hot Pepper Pizza$17.99 +
Oil base, homemade cheese-filled hot banana peppers, topped with mozzarella & sausage.
Chef Andrew's Alfredo Pizza$17.99 +
Alfredo sauce, broccoli, chicken, mozzarella & cheddar.
Stinger Pizza$17.99 +
Hot, medium, or mild chicken fingers, oil base, ribeye steak, hoagie cheese & mozzarella.
Greek Pizza$17.99 +
Oil base, tomatoes, black olives, hot peppers, chicken & feta topped with mozzarella or cheddar.
Hitman Pizza$17.99 +
Oil base, sausage, capicola, salami, ham, sweet peppers, onions, hot peppers, hot sauce & mozzarella.
pizza-by-the-slice
Pizza by the Slice
Cheese Pizza Slice$2.76
Pepperoni Pizza Slice$2.76
Classic cheese topped with pepperoni.
everyday-combo-specials
Everyday Combo Specials
Small One Item Pizza & 10 Wings Combo Special$24.99
Mini pak.
Small One Item Pizza & 10 Boneless Wings Combo Special$24.99
Mini pak.
Large One Item Pizza & 10 Wings Combo Special$28.99
Fab pak.
Large One Item Pizza & 10 Boneless Wings Combo Special$28.99
Fab pak.
Large One Item Pizza & 20 Wings Combo Special$34.99
Family pak.
Large One Item Pizza & 20 Boneless Wings Combo Special$34.99
Family pak.
Large One Item Pizza & 30 Wings Combo Special$42.99
Super pak.
Large One Item Pizza & 30 Boneless Wings Combo Special$42.99
Super pak.
Large One Item Pizza & 50 Wings Combo Special$53.99
Royal pak.
Large One Item Pizza & 50 Boneless Wings Combo Special$53.99
Royal pak.
Sheet One Item Pizza & 50 Wings Combo Special$63.99
Party pak.
Sheet One Item Pizza & 50 Boneless Wings Combo Special$63.99
Party pak.
tuesday-specials
Tuesday Specials
Cheese Pizza Tuesday Special$13.99
Classic cheese or create your own pizza. Available Tuesdays!
Sicilian Pizza Tuesday Special$19.99
Oil, garlic, romano, tomatoes dipped in special sauce, onions & your choice of hot or sweet peppers & sausage or pepperoni. Available Tuesdays!
CBR Pizza Tuesday Special$21.99
Chicken fingers, bacon, ranch, lite onion, mozzarella & cheddar. Available Tuesdays!
Spinach Ricotta Pizza Tuesday Special$19.99
Spinach, mushrooms, garlic, ricotta, mozzarella & romano. Available Tuesdays!
BBQ Chicken Pizza Tuesday Special$21.99
BBQ sauce, chicken, bacon, cheddar, mozzarella & lite onions. Available Tuesdays!
Broccoli Cheddar Pizza Tuesday Special$19.99
Melted cheddar, grated romano, onions, 100% pure olive oil, garlic, pepper & oregano. Available Tuesdays!
Meat Lover's Deluxe Pizza Tuesday Special$21.99
Pepperoni, sausage, meatball, ham & bacon. Available Tuesdays!
White Pizza Tuesday Special$19.99
Romano & mozzarella, onions, fresh cut tomatoes, 100% pure olive oil, garlic, pepper & oregano. Anchovies upon request. Available Tuesdays!
Steak Hoagie Pizza Tuesday Special$21.99
Oil base hoagie cheese with a mixture of sweet peppers, mushrooms, onions & ribeye steak topped with romano & your choice of mozzarella or cheddar cheese. Available Tuesdays!
Taco Pizza Tuesday Special$19.99
Hot, medium, or mild sauce with mozzarella, cheddar, ground beef, lettuce & tomatoes. Available Tuesdays!
Supreme Deluxe Pizza Tuesday Special$21.99
Our veggie deluxe topped with pepperoni & sausage. Available Tuesdays!
Buffalo Style Pizza Tuesday Special$19.99
Hot, medium, or mild diced chicken fingers, pizza sauce or blue cheese base & mozzarella. Available Tuesdays!
Grilled Chicken & Mushroom Pizza Tuesday Special$21.99
Available with pizza sauce or white style topped with mozzarella cheese. Also great with broccoli! Available Tuesdays!
Veggie Deluxe Pizza Tuesday Special$19.99
Mushrooms, sweet & hot peppers, green & black olives, onions & mozzarella. Available Tuesdays!
Stuffed Hot Pepper Pizza Tuesday Special$21.99
Oil base, homemade cheese-filled hot banana peppers, topped with mozzarella & sausage. Available Tuesdays!
Spaghetti & Meatballs Parm Pizza Tuesday Special$19.99
Pizza sauce, cooked spaghetti, chopped meatballs, mozzarella & romano. Available Tuesdays!
Chef Andrew's Alfredo Pizza Tuesday Special$21.99
Alfredo sauce, broccoli, chicken, mozzarella & cheddar. Available Tuesdays!
Hawaiian Pizza Tuesday Special$19.99
Pizza sauce, ham, pineapple & mozzarella. Available Tuesdays!
Stinger Pizza Tuesday Special$21.99
Hot, medium, or mild chicken fingers, oil base, ribeye steak, hoagie cheese & mozzarella. Available Tuesdays!
Greek Pizza Tuesday Special$21.99
Oil base, tomatoes, black olives, hot peppers, chicken & feta topped with mozzarella or cheddar. Available Tuesdays!
Hitman Pizza Tuesday Special$21.99
Oil base, sausage, capicola, salami, ham, sweet peppers, onions, hot peppers, hot sauce & mozzarella. Available Tuesdays!
friday-specials
Friday Specials
Fabulous Fish Fry Friday Special$12.99
Beer battered haddock with fries, potato, macaroni salad & coleslaw. Available Fridays!
soups
Soups
Homemade Chili Soup$5.99
Homemade Chicken Noodle Soup$5.99
Clear chicken broth with pieces of chicken and noodles.
salads
Salads
Kevin's Catering Famous Strawberry Caesar Salad$13.99
Romaine, strawberries, blueberries, red onion & the famous dressing!
Chef Salad$6.99 +
Lettuce, tomato, onion, celery, mozzarella cheese.
Julienne Salad$9.99 +
Turkey, ham, lettuce, tomato, onion, hot & sweet peppers, mushrooms, black & green olives, mozzarella cheese.
Antipasto Salad$9.99 +
Salami, ham, pepperoni, lettuce, tomato, onion, hot & sweet peppers, mushrooms, black & green olives, provolone & mozzarella cheese.
Tuna Salad$9.99
Tuna, lettuce, tomato, onion, celery & mozzarella cheese.
Taco Salad$9.99
Lettuce, tomato, hot pepper, black olives, taco meat, cheddar, mozzarella & salsa.
Greek Chicken Salad$9.99
Lettuce, tomato, onion, hot pepper, black olives, feta & Greek dressing.
Grilled Chicken Salad$9.99
Lettuce, tomato, onion, hot & sweet peppers, mushrooms, black & green olives, mozzarella cheese.
Chicken Finger Salad$9.99
Hot, medium or mild chicken, lettuce, tomato, celery, onions, cheddar & mozzarella.
Turkey Club Salad$9.99
Lettuce, tomato, mozzarella, cheddar, turkey and bacon.
side-orders
Side Orders
Bread Staches$5.99
Breadsticks flavored with garlic, butter & spices with spaghetti sauce.
Apple Pie Logs$6.99
4 logs with caramel sauce dip.
Seasoned Curly Q Fries$4.49
Spiralized potatoes, deep fried and seasoned.
French Fries$4.49
Steak cut.
Cheesy Fries$6.49
Nacho cheese.
Poutine$7.49
Steak fries, gravy, topped with melted mozzarella.
Onion Rings$4.99
Crispy onion slices deep-fried until golden-brown.
Battered Cauliflower$6.49
Served with dipping sauce.
Battered Mushrooms$6.49
Served with dipping sauce.
Battered Pickle Chips$6.49
Served with dipping sauce.
Battered Broccoli Cheddar Bites$6.99
Served with dipping sauce.
Deluxe Potato Skins$8.99
Skins with cheddar cheese, bacon, sour cream.
Mozzarella Stix$6.49
Stixs with spaghetti sauce.
Pizza Logs$6.79
Logs with pizza sauce.
Jalapeno Poppers$6.49
Peppers with dipping sauce.
Garlic Bread$2.59 +
Bread, topped with garlic, herb seasoning, baked to perfection.
Garlic Bread with Mozzarella Cheese$4.99 +
French garlic bread with mozzarella cheese served with marinara sauce.
Garlic Bread with Tomatoes & Mozzarella Cheese$5.49 +
French garlic bread with mozzarella cheese served with marinara sauce & tomatoes.
Garlic Bread with Spinach & Mozzarella Cheese$5.49 +
French garlic bread with mozzarella cheese served with marinara sauce & spinach.
Chips$0.99
Hot Dipping Sauce$0.99
Bleu Cheese Dipping Sauce$0.99
Ranch Dipping Sauce$0.99
Homemade Coleslaw$2.49
Finely-shredded raw cabbage & dressing. A hit at both the picnic table and the dining room table.
Homemade Macaroni Salad$2.49
Homemade Potato Salad$2.49
Gravy$1.99
Nachos with Cheese$2.99
Jalapenos on request.
Nacho Cheese$0.99
Jalapenos$0.99
Salsa Sauce$0.99
chicken-wings
Chicken Wings
Chicken Wings$11.99 +
Served with bleu cheese and celery.
Boneless Wings$11.99 +
Served with bleu cheese and celery.
specialty-wings
Specialty Wings
Specialty Wings$12.99 +
chicken-fingers
Chicken Fingers
Chicken Fingers$11.99 +
Served with bleu cheese & celery.
Chicken Fingers with Fries$12.99 +
Served with bleu cheese & celery.
calzones-stromboli-rolls
Calzones, Stromboli & Rolls
Pizza Roll$18.99
Large dough stuffed with pepperoni, sausage, sweet peppers, mozzarella & a side of pizza sauce.
Calzone$14.99
Up to 3 items. Dough filled with mozzarella and ricotta cheese served with a side of spaghetti or pizza sauce.
Stromboli$13.99
Mozzarella, pepperoni, sweet peppers & ham wrapped in dough with a side of sauce.
deli-sandwiches
Deli Sandwiches
Piled high deli-style meats with lettuce, tomatoes. White American cheese and onions on request. Served on a Costanzo's hard roll with a pickle spear.
Roast Beef Sandwich$8.49
Juicy roast beef.
Ham Sandwich$7.49
Topped with deli-sliced ham.
Corned Beef Sandwich$7.49
Sandwich filled with corned beef traditionally.
Turkey Sandwich$7.49
Oven-roasted.
Capicola Sandwich$7.49
Lettuce, tomatoes, and cheese.
Hard Salami Sandwich$7.49
Lettuce, tomatoes, and cheese.
Cheese Sandwich$7.49
Lettuce, tomatoes, and cheese.
Tuna Sandwich$7.49
Veggies in a satisfying sub.
hot-sandwiches
Hot Sandwiches
Steak & Cheese Sandwich$7.99
With lettuce & tomatoes.
Chicken Finger Sandwich$7.99
With lettuce & tomatoes.
BLT Sandwich$7.99
A lot of bacon!
Turkey Club$7.99
With lettuce & tomatoes.
Chicken Breast Fillet Sandwich$7.99
With lettuce & tomatoes.
Fried Bologna Sandwich$7.99
American cheese & fried onions.
Fish Sandwich$7.99
With lettuce & tomatoes.
Italian Sausage Sandwich$6.99
With lettuce & tomatoes.
Cheeseburger Sandwich$7.99
With lettuce & tomatoes.
Roast Beef Sandwich$8.99
With gravy.
Turkey Sandwich$8.99
With gravy.
Hot Capicola & Cheese Sandwich$7.99
Lettuce, tomatoes, and cheese.
Beef Sandwich$8.99
On weck.
submarines
Submarines
On a white or wheat oven-toasted roll. All subs include white American cheese, lettuce, tomatoes. Onions on request.
Roast Beef Sub$8.49 +
Our own slow oven-roasted.
Tuna Sub$7.49 +
Delicious tuna fish salad & veggies in a satisfying sub.
Corned Beef Sub$7.49 +
Sandwich filled with corned beef traditionally served with mustard and pickles.
Ham Sub$7.49 +
Topped with deli-sliced ham.
Turkey Sub$7.49 +
Oven-roasted.
Ham & Turkey Sub$7.49 +
Lettuce, tomatoes, and cheese.
Italian Assorted Sub$7.49 +
Hard salami, capicola & ham.
Ham, Turkey & Roast Beef Sub$7.49 +
Capicola Sub$7.49 +
Lettuce, tomatoes, and cheese.
Hard Salami Sub$7.49 +
Lettuce, tomatoes, and cheese.
Cheese Sub$7.49 +
Lettuce, tomatoes, and cheese.
Bologna Sub$7.49 +
Lettuce, tomatoes, and cheese.
hot-submarines
Hot Submarines
Stinger Sub$10.99 +
Steak & chicken finger.
Bully Sub$10.99 +
Steak & sausage.
Steak & Cheese Sub$7.99 +
Fried peppers & onions.
Steak & Cheese Sub with Fried Mushrooms$7.99 +
With onions.
Steak & Cheese Sub with Lettuce & Tomatoes$7.49 +
Steak & Spinach Sub with Lettuce & Tomatoes$7.99 +
Steak & Spinach Sub with Fried Peppers & Onions$7.99 +
Chicken & Spinach Sub with Lettuce & Tomatoes$7.99 +
Chicken & Spinach Sub with Fried Peppers & Onions$7.99 +
Hitman's Delight Sub$7.99 +
Fried hot & sweet peppers, onions, Italian sausage, ham, salami, capicola, cheese & hot sauce.
Baked Reuben Sub$7.99 +
Corned beef, kraut, swiss cheese, thousand island dressing.
Rib Sub$7.99 +
Rib, BBQ sauce, mozzarella cheese.
Royale Sub$7.99 +
Italian sausage & capicola, lettuce & tomatoes.
Italian Sausage Sub$7.99 +
Lettuce & tomato.
Fish Sub$7.99 +
Battered haddock, lettuce & tomato.
Cheeseburger Sub$7.99 +
3/4 lb. of black Angus, lettuce & tomato.
Cheeseburger Royale Sub$7.99 +
3/4 lb. of black Angus, ham, cheese, lettuce & tomato.
Bacon Cheeseburger Sub$8.99 +
Lettuce & tomato.
Baked Roast Beef Sub$8.99 +
Lettuce, tomatoes & mozzarella or cheddar.
Roast Beef Classic Sub$8.49 +
On garlic bread with mushrooms & mozzarella.
Pizza Sub$7.49 +
Pepperoni, mozzarella & pizza sauce.
White Pizza Sub$7.49 +
Just like our white pizza. Romano & mozzarella, onions, fresh cut tomatoes, 100% pure olive oil, garlic, pepper & oregano. Anchovies upon request.
Veal Parmesan Sub$7.99 +
Veal, spaghetti sauce, mozzarella cheese.
Sausage Parmesan Sub$7.99 +
Italian sausage, spaghetti sauce, mozzarella.
Meatball Parmesan Sub$7.99 +
Meatballs, spaghetti sauce, mozzarella.
Chicken Parmesan Sub$7.99 +
Chicken, spaghetti sauce, mozzarella.
Eggplant Parmesan Sub$7.99 +
5-6 pieces of eggplant, spaghetti sauce & mozzarella.
Chicken Finger Sub$7.99 +
Provolone & bleu cheese, lettuce & tomatoes.
BLT Sub$7.99 +
A lot of bacon! Lettuce & tomatoes.
Chicken Cordon Bleu Sub$7.99 +
Chicken, ham, swiss cheese, lettuce & tomatoes.
Turkey Club$7.99 +
Turkey, bacon, cheese, lettuce & tomatoes.
Chicken Breast Fillet Sub$7.99 +
Lettuce & tomatoes. Try with BBQ or dijon.
California Dream Sub$8.49 +
Chicken breast, bacon, swiss, ranch, lettuce & tomatoes.
Tuna Cheddar Melt Sub$7.99 +
Tuna, lettuce, cheddar & tomatoes.
Piglet Sub$8.49 +
Sausage, ham, bacon, lettuce & tomatoes.
super-hoagies
Super Hoagies
All hoagies include fried sweet peppers, onions, mushrooms, hoagie cheese & special sauce.
Super Steak Hoagie$8.99 +
A killer sub packed with steak.
Super Sausage Hoagie$8.99 +
Super Steak & Sausage Hoagie$10.99
Super Turkey Hoagie$8.99 +
Topped with sliced turkey meat.
Super Chicken Hoagie$8.99 +
Breaded white meat chicken covered with tomato sauce, topped with mozzarella cheese.
Super Cheeseburger Hoagie$8.99 +
Try adding lettuce & tomatoes.
wraps
Wraps
White or wheat. All wraps include lettuce, tomatoes, white American cheese & pickles. Onions upon request.
Ham Wrap$6.99
Topped with deli-sliced ham.
Assorted Wrap$6.99
Turkey Wrap$6.99
Turkey, lettuce, tomatoes and onions.
Capicola Wrap$6.99
Hard Salami Wrap$6.99
Tuna Wrap$6.99
Lettuce, tomatoes, onions, and melted cheese.
Vegetable Wrap$6.99
Lettuce, tomatoes, onions, and melted cheese.
Turkey Club Wrap$7.49
Freshly made with cheese, bacon, lettuce, tomato, and mayonnaise, layered between toasted bread.
Steak Wrap$7.49
A killer wrap packed with steak.
Chicken Breast Wrap$7.49
Chicken Finger Wrap$7.49
Chicken fingers and classic cheese.
Greek Wrap$7.99
Chicken breast, feta, black olives, hot banana peppers & Greek dressing.
Beef on Weck Wrap$8.49
Roast beef, horsey sauce, pepper jack, pretzel salt & caraway seeds.
tacos-burritos
Tacos & Burritos
All tacos include soft shell, lettuce, tomatoes & cheese.
Ground Beef Taco$5.59
Sliced steak, cheese, lettuce, and tomato.
Chicken Taco$6.99
Steak Taco$6.99
Sliced steak, cheese, lettuce, and tomato.
Chicken Finger Taco$6.99
Roast Beef Taco$6.99
Juicy roast beef.
Steak Burrito$6.99
Fried sweet peppers & onions, cheddar & sub cheese.
Chicken Fajita Burrito$6.99
Fried sweet peppers & onions, cheddar & sub cheese.
Stinger Taco$8.99
Steak & chicken finger.
dinners
Dinners
Stuffed Hot Banana Peppers$15.99
Peppers on garlic points.
Bar-B-Que Ribs$15.99 +
Includes coleslaw, fries & roll.
Honey Dipped Fried Chicken Dinner$12.99
Includes salad & fries.
Grilled Chicken Dinner$12.99
Boneless chicken breast, salad & fries.
Cheese Ravioli$12.99
Jumbo ravioli, two meatballs & garlic bread.
Shells$12.99
Jumbo shells, two meatballs & garlic bread.
Spaghetti$12.99
With two meatballs & garlic bread.
Spaghetti Parmesan$12.99
With two meatballs, mozzarella & garlic bread.
Eggplant Parmesan$12.99
Breaded eggplant, spaghetti, mozzarella & garlic bread.
Veal Parmesan$12.99
Breaded veal, spaghetti, mozzarella & garlic bread.
Chicken Parmesan$12.99
Breaded chicken, spaghetti, mozzarella & garlic bread.
Baked Penne$12.99
Penne pasta, mozzarella & garlic bread.
Fish Dinner$12.99
Two pieces of haddock fish, salad & fries.
Shrimp Dinner$12.99
Breaded butterfly shrimp with fries & cocktail sauce.
Roast Beef Dinner$12.99
Served on Costanzo's roll with gravy, salad & fries.
Turkey Dinner$12.99
Served on Costanzo's roll with gravy, salad & fries.
desserts
Desserts
Cookies$1.49
Huge! Chocolate chips, peanut butter, oatmeal raisin, macadamia nut & white chocolate.
Iced Lemon$3.49
Chocolate Banana Swirled Loaf Cake$3.49
beverages
Beverages
Soda$2.25 +
Nothing like a cold soda to go with your pizza.
Water$1.59
Slush Puppie$1.00 +
lunch-specials
Lunch Specials
Half Cold Sub & Pop Soda Lunch$7.99
Half Cold Sub & French Fries Lunch$7.99
Half Hot Sub & Pop Soda Lunch$8.49
Half Hot Sub & French Fries Lunch$8.49
Large Beef Taco & Pop Soda Lunch$6.49
Large Beef Taco & French Fries Lunch$6.49
Two Pizza Slices & Pop Soda Lunch$6.49
Two Pizza Slices & French Fries Lunch$6.49
5 Wings & Pop Soda Lunch$7.99
5 Wings & French Fries Lunch$7.99
subs-wraps-catering
Subs & Wraps Catering
Sub Platter Catering$32.99 +
Cold cuts & tuna.
Wrap Platter Catering$35.99 +
Cold cuts & tuna.
FAQ
🍕Does Mustachio's Pizzeria have any deals?
🍕Does Mustachio's Pizzeria offer delivery?
🍕Where is Mustachio's Pizzeria located?
🍕What food is served at Mustachio's Pizzeria?
Price: $$
Browse Pizza Delivery or Pickup by City
Browse Pizza Types
More Restaurants