hero

Jay's Deli

534 NY-32, Highland Mills, NY 10930

Open NowFull HoursAre you the owner?

We're all about supporting local pizzerias - even those who are not Slice partners.
Give Jay's Deli a call to order. We hear their food's delish.

Menu
pizza
  • Cheese Pizza $14.00
    Classic cheese or create your own pizza.
  • Sicilian Pizza $16.00
  • Cheese Calzone $6.99
    A generous portion of ricotta and mozzarella cheese with Jay's tomato sauce on the side.
  • Family Size Calzone $12.99
    This thing feeds a small army.
specialty-pizzas
Our signature pizzas! Mouse over a menu item for a description of our delicious ingredients.
  • Breakfast Pizza Cheeses $19.99
    Eggs, mozzarella & cheddar combined to perfection.
  • White Pizza $16.99
    Parmesan, ricotta, and mozzarella.
  • White Tomato Basil Pizza $17.99
    White pizza with tomato, mozzarella, and basil.
  • Penne a la Vodka Pizza $18.99
    Penne pasta with Jay's own vodka sauce and mozzarella.
  • Chicken Parm Pizza $21.99
    Breaded chicken cutlet with Jay's marinara sauce and mozzarella cheese.
  • Lemon Chicken Pizza $21.99
    Chicken cutlet with sautéed mushrooms and light lemon sauce. Topped with mozzarella.
  • Vegetable Mediterranean Pizza $17.00
    Spinach, grape tomatoes, kalamata olives, oil and garlic and feta cheese.
  • Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza $21.99
    Breaded chicken, diced tomatoes, bacon, ranch dressing and mozzarella cheese.
  • Taco Pizza $17.99
    Beef, onions, peppers, jalapeños and cheddar.
  • Spinach Gorgonzola Pizza $18.99
    Sautéed spinach, fresh diced tomatoes, fresh garlic, gorgonzola and mozzarella cheese.
  • Cheese Steak Pizza $21.99
    Steak, peppers, onions, mozzarella and American cheese.
  • Salad Pizza $17.99
    House salad tossed with Italian dressing and fresh mozzarella placed on a whole wheat pizza crust.
  • Veggie Breakfast Pizza $23.99
    Eggs with fresh veggies, mozzarella and cheddar.
  • White Broccoli Pizza $17.99
    Three cheeses and chopped broccoli.
  • Margherita Pizza $17.99
    Mozzarella, tomato, basil, and garlic.
  • Baked Ziti Pizza $18.99
    Zita, ricotta, tomato sauce and mozzarella.
  • Chicken Marsala Pizza $21.99
    Breaded chicken cutlet with sautéed mushrooms, marsala sauce, and mozzarella.
  • Buffalo Chicken Pizza $21.99
    Tender fried chicken cutlet tossed with Buffalo sauce. Bleu cheese is available.
  • Honey BBQ Chicken Pizza $21.99
    Breaded crispy chicken tossed with honey barbecue sauce, topped with mozzarella cheese.
  • Meat Lovers Pizza $21.99
    Pepperoni, meatballs, sausage, and bacon.
  • Ranchero Pizza $17.99
    Bacon, ranch, mozzarella, cheddar, pepperoni and tomato sauce.
  • Eggplant Parm Pizza $17.99
    Fried eggplant, ricotta, tomato sauce and mozzarella.
  • Leave It To Us Everything Pizza $21.99
    It's everything but the kitchen sink.
pizza-by-the-slice
  • Chicken Pizza Slice $3.50
  • Pizza Slice $2.25
  • Sicilian Pizza Slice $3.00
  • Specialty Pizza Slice $3.50
breakfast
Enjoy our delicious entrees for the AM!
  • Egg Sandwich $2.49
    Choice of kaiser roll, bagel or toast.
  • Egg Sandwich with Meat $3.49
  • Hobo $4.59
    Egg sandwich with choice of meat and cheese, topped with home fries
  • Sausage on a Roll $1.99
    Golden sausage patty on a bakery fresh roll.
  • Chocolate Chip $4.99
  • Blueberry Pancakes $4.99
  • French Toast $4.99
    Challah bread with vanilla and cinnamon batter.
  • Eggasaurus Platter with Two Pancakes $6.99
    Two eggs, any style, with choice of meat, home fries and toast or roll.
  • Veggie Breakfast Pizza $23.99
    Eggs with fresh veggies, mozzarella and cheddar.
  • Egg Sandwich With Cheese $2.99
  • Egg Sandwich Cheese & Meat $3.99
  • Bacon on a Roll $2.59
    Fresh bacon on a bakery fresh roll.
  • Three Buttermilk Pancakes with Syrup $4.99
  • Fresh Fruit Pancakes $5.99
    Topped with seasonal fruit and whipped cream.
  • Eggasaurus Platter $5.99
    Two eggs, any style, with choice of meat, home fries and toast or roll.
  • Breakfast Pizza with Meat $23.99
  • Breakfast Plain Pizza $19.99
    Eggs with mozzarella and cheddar cooked to perfection.
breakfast-sides
  • Homemade Home Fries $2.25 +
  • Extra Meat $1.00
  • Homemade Muffins $2.29
  • Bagel with Butter $1.75
  • Kaiser Roll $0.65
  • Order of Toast $1.25
  • Extra Cheese $0.50
  • Bagel $0.75
  • Bagel with Cream Cheese $1.75
  • Kaiser Roll with Butter $1.15
  • English Muffin with Butter $1.50
  • Garlic Knots $0.50
    With Jay's marinara.
appetizers
For when you just want something to nibble.
  • Jalapeno Poppers $6.99
    With a choice of sauce.
  • Onion Rings $3.99
  • Mozzarella Sticks $4.99
    With Jay's marinara.
  • Sample Platter $6.99
    3 ravioli, 2 poppers, 3 sticks, and 2 fingers. Served with choice of sauce.
  • Chicken Fingers $4.99 +
    Regular or hot.
  • Chicken Fingers with Fries $6.99
    Regular or hot.
  • Popcorn Chicken $4.95
    With a choice of sauce.
  • French Fries $2.99
  • Fried Ravioli $3.99
    With Jay's marinara.
  • Chicken Wings $8.99
    Mild, medium, hot, honey bbq, sesame ginger, bbq, garlic parm.
soups
Gumbos & chowders prepared fresh daily.
  • Chili Soup $4.95 +
    Our secret recipe.
garden-salads
  • Tossed Salad $3.59 +
    Fresh garden greens with choice of dressing.
  • Caesar Salad $5.99
    Hearts of Romaine with a creamy Caesar dressing.
  • Grilled Chicken Caesar Salad $7.99
    Chicken, hearts of romaine and creamy Caesar dressing.
  • Chef Salad $5.99 +
    Our green salad with sliced cold cuts and cheese. Served with choice of dressing.
deli-sandwiches
Served on bread or a roll.
  • Tuna Salad Sandwich $5.95
  • Egg Salad Sandwich $4.95
  • Shrimp Salad Sandwich $6.95
  • Ham & Cheese Sandwich $5.75
  • Olive Loaf Sandwich $4.50
  • Cheese Sandwich $4.50
  • PB & J Sandwich $3.00
  • Salami Sandwich $4.95
  • Turkey Sandwich $5.95
  • Virginia Ham Sandwich $5.95
  • Tuna Salad Hero $6.95
  • Egg Salad Hero $5.95
  • Shrimp Salad Hero $7.95
  • Ham & Cheese Hero $6.75
  • Olive Loaf Hero $5.50
  • Cheese Hero $5.50
  • PB & J Hero $4.00
  • Salami Hero $5.95
  • Turkey Hero $6.95
  • Virginia Ham Hero $6.95
  • Chicken Salad Sandwich $5.95
  • Seafood Salad Sandwich $5.95
  • Ham Sandwich $4.95
  • Liverwurst Sandwich $4.50
  • Prosciutto Sandwich $5.95
  • Cappicola Sandwich $4.95
  • Bologna Sandwich $4.50
  • Spiced Ham Sandwich $4.50
  • Roast Beef Sandwich $6.95
  • Fresh Mozzarella Sandwich $4.95
  • Chicken Salad Hero $6.95
  • Seafood Salad Hero $6.95
  • Ham Hero $5.95
  • Liverwurst Hero $5.50
  • Prosciutto Hero $6.95
  • Cappicola Hero $5.95
  • Bologna Hero $5.50
  • Spiced Ham Hero $5.50
  • Roast Beef Hero $7.95
  • Fresh Mozzarella Hero $5.95
hot-sandwiches
  • Meatball Sandwich $5.95
    Homemade meatballs with sauce.
  • Eggplant Sandwich $5.50
    Hand breaded eggplant with sauce
  • Pastrami Sandwich $6.95
    Thin sliced pastrami with brown spicy mustard.
  • Cheesesteak Sandwich $8.95
    Sliced roasted beef with peppers, onions, and mushrooms with melted American cheese.
  • Susage & Pepper Hero $6.50
    Sweet Italian sausage with pepper and onions.
  • Chicken Cutlet Hero $7.95
    Hand breaded cutlet plain or with sauce
  • Reuben Hero $7.95
    Corned beef or pastrami with sauerkraut and Russian dressing. Topped with Swiss cheese.
  • Sausage & Peppers Sandwich $5.50
    Sweet Italian sausage with peppers and onions.
  • Chicken Cutlet Sandwich $6.95
    Hand breaded chicken plain or with sauce.
  • Reuben Sandwich $6.95
    Corned beef or pastrami with sauerkraut and Russian dressing. Topped with Swiss cheese.
  • Meatball Hero $6.95
    Homemade meatballs with sauce.
  • Eggplant Hero $6.50
    Hand breaded eggplant with sauce.
  • Pastrami Hero $7.95
    Thin sliced pastrami with brown spicy mustard.
  • Grilled Cheese Sandwich $4.95
    With melted American cheese. Choice of bread.
specialty-sandwiches
  • Texas Ranger Sandwich $7.95
    Chicken cutlet, bacon, BBQ sauce & melted cheese.
  • Jay's American Combo Sandwich $6.95
    Turkey, ham, American and swiss.
  • Chicken Cordon Bleu Sandwich $6.95
    Fried chicken cutlet with ham, melted swiss cheese, and honey mustard dressing.
  • Turkey Sombrero Sandwich $6.95
    Turkey breast smothered with melted cheddar and topped with chili.
  • Honey of a Sandwich $6.95
    Honey turkey, honey ham, Muenster cheese, lettuce and honey mustard dressing.
  • Texas Ranger Hero $8.95
    Chicken cutlet, bacon, BBQ sauce & melted cheese.
  • Jay's American Combo Hero $7.95
    Turkey, ham, American and Swiss.
  • Leo's Eggplant Tower Hero $7.95
    Fresh fried eggplant, topped with Jay's zesty marinara sauce, roasted peppers and smothered with melted mozzarella cheese.
  • Jay's Italian Combo Hero $7.95
    Ham, salami, pepperoni, provolone.
  • Sir Wrap A Lot $8.95
    Grilled chicken, sauteed mushrooms and spinach topped with melted cheddar cheese. All wrapped or toasted on the panini grill.
  • Sundried Tomato Overdose Hero $8.95
    Grilled chicken, feta cheese, spinach and sundried tomatoes with jay's special dressing in a sundried tomato wrap. Served cold or warm.
  • Bleu Bayou Sandwich $7.95
    Turkey topped with bacon & melted cheese & then smothered in bleu cheese.
  • Mexican Cheese Steak Sandwich $7.95
    Roast beef with melted jalapeno cheese and salsa.
  • Leo's Eggplant Tower Sandwich $6.95
    Fresh fried eggplant, topped with Jay's zesty marinara sauce, roasted peppers and smothered with melted mozzarella cheese.
  • Jay's Italian Combo Sandwich $6.95
    Ham, salami, pepperoni, provolone.
  • Bleu Bayou Hero $8.95
    Turkey topped with bacon & melted cheese & then smothered in bleu cheese.
  • Mexican Cheese Steak Hero $8.95
    Roast beef with melted jalapeno cheese and salsa.
  • Turkey Sombrero Hero $7.95
    Turkey breast smothered with melted cheddar and topped with chili.
  • Honey of a Hero $7.95
    Honey turkey, honey ham, Muenster cheese, lettuce and honey mustard dressing
  • Italian Stallion Hero $8.95
    Meatballs, eggplant, roasted peppers, tomato sauce. With melted cheese.
  • Cuban Sandwich $8.95
    Ham, pork, Swiss, pickles, mustard & mayo on buttered bread pressed on the Panini grill. Mmmm...Good!
hamburgers
Hand-crafted burgers are sure to please.
  • Hamburger $4.99
    Moist & juicy.
  • BBQ Bacon Burger $6.99
    With cheese.
  • Pepperoni Pizza Burger $6.99
    With sauce, cheese and pepperoni.
  • Italian Dog $5.95
    With peppers, onions, and potatoes in a hoagie roll.
  • Cheeseburger $5.99
    With melted American cheese.
  • Deluxe Burger $7.99
    Lettuce, tomato, onion and of course, French fries.
  • Hot Dog $2.25
    Boars Head brand hot dog. Chili, onions, and kraut available.

FAQ