Skip to main content
Jay's Deli

Jay's Deli

534 NY-32, Highland Mills, NY 10930
845-928-2803

We're all about supporting local pizzerias - even those who are not Slice partners.
Give Jay's Deli a call to order. We hear their food's delish.

Nearby Pizzerias on Slice
logo
Prima Pizza Cafe & Shipping
252 Main St, Cornwall, NY
Open NowPickup Only
logo
Marcelino's Pizzeria
1020 State Route 94, New Windsor, NY
Open NowPickup Only
logo
Brother Bruno's Pizza
78 Brookside Ave, Chester, NY
Open NowPickup Only
logo
Frank's Pizza & Restaurant
179 Temple Hill Rd, New Windsor, NY
Open NowFree Delivery
logo
Amore Pizzeria
265 Main St, Highland Falls, NY
Open Now$5 Delivery
logo
Capri Restaurant & Pizzeria
359 Windsor Hwy, New Windsor, NY
Open NowPickup Only
logo
Tosco's Pizzeria New Windsor
434 Blooming Grove Tpke, New Windsor, NY
Open Now$6.90 Delivery
logo
Saporito Pizza
382 Kings Hwy, Warwick, NY
Open Now$4 Delivery
logo
Primo's Pizza
573 Union Ave, New Windsor, NY
Open NowFree Delivery
logo
K&J Deli Pizzeria
904 Little Britain Rd, New Windsor, NY
Open NowFree Delivery
logo
El Rinconcito Latin Food
266 Quassaick Ave, New Windsor, NY
Open Now$6.90 Delivery
logo
Midway's Villa Roma
264 Quassaick Ave, New Windsor, NY
Open Now$1 Delivery
logo
Garrison Pizza Cafe
1135 Rd 9D, Garrison, NY
Open NowPickup Only
logo
Cinema Pizza
215 Quassaick Ave, New Windsor, NY
Open NowFree Delivery
logo
Little Pops Pizza
87 Homestead Ave, Maybrook, NY
Open Now$1 Delivery
logo
Paradise Restaurant
135 Broadway, Verplanck, NY
Open NowPickup Only
logo
Sorrento's Pizzeria
15 Main St, Goshen, NY
Open NowFree Delivery
logo
Marcello's Pizza & Deli
104 6th St, Verplanck, NY
Open NowFree Delivery
View More Pizzerias on Slice
Menu
pizza
Pizza

Cheese Pizza

Classic cheese or create your own pizza.

$14.00


Sicilian Pizza

$16.00


Cheese Calzone

A generous portion of ricotta and mozzarella cheese with Jay's tomato sauce on the side.

$6.99


Family Size Calzone

This thing feeds a small army.

$12.99

specialty-pizzas
Specialty Pizzas
Our signature pizzas! Mouse over a menu item for a description of our delicious ingredients.

Breakfast Pizza Cheeses

Eggs, mozzarella & cheddar combined to perfection.

$19.99


White Pizza

Parmesan, ricotta, and mozzarella.

$16.99


White Tomato Basil Pizza

White pizza with tomato, mozzarella, and basil.

$17.99


Penne a la Vodka Pizza

Penne pasta with Jay's own vodka sauce and mozzarella.

$18.99


Chicken Parm Pizza

Breaded chicken cutlet with Jay's marinara sauce and mozzarella cheese.

$21.99


Lemon Chicken Pizza

Chicken cutlet with sautéed mushrooms and light lemon sauce. Topped with mozzarella.

$21.99


Vegetable Mediterranean Pizza

Spinach, grape tomatoes, kalamata olives, oil and garlic and feta cheese.

$17.00


Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza

Breaded chicken, diced tomatoes, bacon, ranch dressing and mozzarella cheese.

$21.99


Taco Pizza

Beef, onions, peppers, jalapeños and cheddar.

$17.99


Spinach Gorgonzola Pizza

Sautéed spinach, fresh diced tomatoes, fresh garlic, gorgonzola and mozzarella cheese.

$18.99


Cheese Steak Pizza

Steak, peppers, onions, mozzarella and American cheese.

$21.99


Salad Pizza

House salad tossed with Italian dressing and fresh mozzarella placed on a whole wheat pizza crust.

$17.99


Veggie Breakfast Pizza

Eggs with fresh veggies, mozzarella and cheddar.

$23.99


White Broccoli Pizza

Three cheeses and chopped broccoli.

$17.99


Margherita Pizza

Mozzarella, tomato, basil, and garlic.

$17.99


Baked Ziti Pizza

Zita, ricotta, tomato sauce and mozzarella.

$18.99


Chicken Marsala Pizza

Breaded chicken cutlet with sautéed mushrooms, marsala sauce, and mozzarella.

$21.99


Buffalo Chicken Pizza

Tender fried chicken cutlet tossed with Buffalo sauce. Bleu cheese is available.

$21.99


Honey BBQ Chicken Pizza

Breaded crispy chicken tossed with honey barbecue sauce, topped with mozzarella cheese.

$21.99


Meat Lovers Pizza

Pepperoni, meatballs, sausage, and bacon.

$21.99


Ranchero Pizza

Bacon, ranch, mozzarella, cheddar, pepperoni and tomato sauce.

$17.99


Eggplant Parm Pizza

Fried eggplant, ricotta, tomato sauce and mozzarella.

$17.99


Leave It To Us Everything Pizza

It's everything but the kitchen sink.

$21.99

pizza-by-the-slice
Pizza by the Slice

Chicken Pizza Slice

$3.50


Pizza Slice

$2.25


Sicilian Pizza Slice

$3.00


Specialty Pizza Slice

$3.50

breakfast
Breakfast
Enjoy our delicious entrees for the AM!

Egg Sandwich

Choice of kaiser roll, bagel or toast.

$2.49


Egg Sandwich with Meat

$3.49


Hobo

Egg sandwich with choice of meat and cheese, topped with home fries

$4.59


Sausage on a Roll

Golden sausage patty on a bakery fresh roll.

$1.99


Chocolate Chip

$4.99


Blueberry Pancakes

$4.99


French Toast

Challah bread with vanilla and cinnamon batter.

$4.99


Eggasaurus Platter with Two Pancakes

Two eggs, any style, with choice of meat, home fries and toast or roll.

$6.99


Veggie Breakfast Pizza

Eggs with fresh veggies, mozzarella and cheddar.

$23.99


Egg Sandwich With Cheese

$2.99


Egg Sandwich Cheese & Meat

$3.99


Bacon on a Roll

Fresh bacon on a bakery fresh roll.

$2.59


Three Buttermilk Pancakes with Syrup

$4.99


Fresh Fruit Pancakes

Topped with seasonal fruit and whipped cream.

$5.99


Eggasaurus Platter

Two eggs, any style, with choice of meat, home fries and toast or roll.

$5.99


Breakfast Pizza with Meat

$23.99


Breakfast Plain Pizza

Eggs with mozzarella and cheddar cooked to perfection.

$19.99

breakfast-sides
Breakfast Sides

Homemade Home Fries

$2.25


Extra Meat

$1.00


Homemade Muffins

$2.29


Bagel with Butter

$1.75


Kaiser Roll

$0.65


Order of Toast

$1.25


Extra Cheese

$0.50


Bagel

$0.75


Bagel with Cream Cheese

$1.75


Kaiser Roll with Butter

$1.15


English Muffin with Butter

$1.50


Garlic Knots

With Jay's marinara.

$0.50

appetizers
Appetizers
For when you just want something to nibble.

Jalapeno Poppers

With a choice of sauce.

$6.99


Onion Rings

$3.99


Mozzarella Sticks

With Jay's marinara.

$4.99


Sample Platter

3 ravioli, 2 poppers, 3 sticks, and 2 fingers. Served with choice of sauce.

$6.99


Chicken Fingers

Regular or hot.

$4.99


Chicken Fingers with Fries

Regular or hot.

$6.99


Popcorn Chicken

With a choice of sauce.

$4.95


French Fries

$2.99


Fried Ravioli

With Jay's marinara.

$3.99


Chicken Wings

Mild, medium, hot, honey bbq, sesame ginger, bbq, garlic parm.

$8.99

soups
Soups
Gumbos & chowders prepared fresh daily.

Chili Soup

Our secret recipe.

$4.95

garden-salads
Garden Salads

Tossed Salad

Fresh garden greens with choice of dressing.

$3.59


Caesar Salad

Hearts of Romaine with a creamy Caesar dressing.

$5.99


Grilled Chicken Caesar Salad

Chicken, hearts of romaine and creamy Caesar dressing.

$7.99


Chef Salad

Our green salad with sliced cold cuts and cheese. Served with choice of dressing.

$5.99

deli-sandwiches
Deli Sandwiches
Served on bread or a roll.

Tuna Salad Sandwich

$5.95


Egg Salad Sandwich

$4.95


Shrimp Salad Sandwich

$6.95


Ham & Cheese Sandwich

$5.75


Olive Loaf Sandwich

$4.50


Cheese Sandwich

$4.50


PB & J Sandwich

$3.00


Salami Sandwich

$4.95


Turkey Sandwich

$5.95


Virginia Ham Sandwich

$5.95


Tuna Salad Hero

$6.95


Egg Salad Hero

$5.95


Shrimp Salad Hero

$7.95


Ham & Cheese Hero

$6.75


Olive Loaf Hero

$5.50


Cheese Hero

$5.50


PB & J Hero

$4.00


Salami Hero

$5.95


Turkey Hero

$6.95


Virginia Ham Hero

$6.95


Chicken Salad Sandwich

$5.95


Seafood Salad Sandwich

$5.95


Ham Sandwich

$4.95


Liverwurst Sandwich

$4.50


Prosciutto Sandwich

$5.95


Cappicola Sandwich

$4.95


Bologna Sandwich

$4.50


Spiced Ham Sandwich

$4.50


Roast Beef Sandwich

$6.95


Fresh Mozzarella Sandwich

$4.95


Chicken Salad Hero

$6.95


Seafood Salad Hero

$6.95


Ham Hero

$5.95


Liverwurst Hero

$5.50


Prosciutto Hero

$6.95


Cappicola Hero

$5.95


Bologna Hero

$5.50


Spiced Ham Hero

$5.50


Roast Beef Hero

$7.95


Fresh Mozzarella Hero

$5.95

hot-sandwiches
Hot Sandwiches

Meatball Sandwich

Homemade meatballs with sauce.

$5.95


Eggplant Sandwich

Hand breaded eggplant with sauce

$5.50


Pastrami Sandwich

Thin sliced pastrami with brown spicy mustard.

$6.95


Cheesesteak Sandwich

Sliced roasted beef with peppers, onions, and mushrooms with melted American cheese.

$8.95


Susage & Pepper Hero

Sweet Italian sausage with pepper and onions.

$6.50


Chicken Cutlet Hero

Hand breaded cutlet plain or with sauce

$7.95


Reuben Hero

Corned beef or pastrami with sauerkraut and Russian dressing. Topped with Swiss cheese.

$7.95


Sausage & Peppers Sandwich

Sweet Italian sausage with peppers and onions.

$5.50


Chicken Cutlet Sandwich

Hand breaded chicken plain or with sauce.

$6.95


Reuben Sandwich

Corned beef or pastrami with sauerkraut and Russian dressing. Topped with Swiss cheese.

$6.95


Meatball Hero

Homemade meatballs with sauce.

$6.95


Eggplant Hero

Hand breaded eggplant with sauce.

$6.50


Pastrami Hero

Thin sliced pastrami with brown spicy mustard.

$7.95


Grilled Cheese Sandwich

With melted American cheese. Choice of bread.

$4.95

specialty-sandwiches
Specialty Sandwiches

Texas Ranger Sandwich

Chicken cutlet, bacon, BBQ sauce & melted cheese.

$7.95


Jay's American Combo Sandwich

Turkey, ham, American and swiss.

$6.95


Chicken Cordon Bleu Sandwich

Fried chicken cutlet with ham, melted swiss cheese, and honey mustard dressing.

$6.95


Turkey Sombrero Sandwich

Turkey breast smothered with melted cheddar and topped with chili.

$6.95


Honey of a Sandwich

Honey turkey, honey ham, Muenster cheese, lettuce and honey mustard dressing.

$6.95


Texas Ranger Hero

Chicken cutlet, bacon, BBQ sauce & melted cheese.

$8.95


Jay's American Combo Hero

Turkey, ham, American and Swiss.

$7.95


Leo's Eggplant Tower Hero

Fresh fried eggplant, topped with Jay's zesty marinara sauce, roasted peppers and smothered with melted mozzarella cheese.

$7.95


Jay's Italian Combo Hero

Ham, salami, pepperoni, provolone.

$7.95


Sir Wrap A Lot

Grilled chicken, sauteed mushrooms and spinach topped with melted cheddar cheese. All wrapped or toasted on the panini grill.

$8.95


Sundried Tomato Overdose Hero

Grilled chicken, feta cheese, spinach and sundried tomatoes with jay's special dressing in a sundried tomato wrap. Served cold or warm.

$8.95


Bleu Bayou Sandwich

Turkey topped with bacon & melted cheese & then smothered in bleu cheese.

$7.95


Mexican Cheese Steak Sandwich

Roast beef with melted jalapeno cheese and salsa.

$7.95


Leo's Eggplant Tower Sandwich

Fresh fried eggplant, topped with Jay's zesty marinara sauce, roasted peppers and smothered with melted mozzarella cheese.

$6.95


Jay's Italian Combo Sandwich

Ham, salami, pepperoni, provolone.

$6.95


Bleu Bayou Hero

Turkey topped with bacon & melted cheese & then smothered in bleu cheese.

$8.95


Mexican Cheese Steak Hero

Roast beef with melted jalapeno cheese and salsa.

$8.95


Turkey Sombrero Hero

Turkey breast smothered with melted cheddar and topped with chili.

$7.95


Honey of a Hero

Honey turkey, honey ham, Muenster cheese, lettuce and honey mustard dressing

$7.95


Italian Stallion Hero

Meatballs, eggplant, roasted peppers, tomato sauce. With melted cheese.

$8.95


Cuban Sandwich

Ham, pork, Swiss, pickles, mustard & mayo on buttered bread pressed on the Panini grill. Mmmm...Good!

$8.95

hamburgers
Hamburgers
Hand-crafted burgers are sure to please.

Hamburger

Moist & juicy.

$4.99


BBQ Bacon Burger

With cheese.

$6.99


Pepperoni Pizza Burger

With sauce, cheese and pepperoni.

$6.99


Italian Dog

With peppers, onions, and potatoes in a hoagie roll.

$5.95


Cheeseburger

With melted American cheese.

$5.99


Deluxe Burger

Lettuce, tomato, onion and of course, French fries.

$7.99


Hot Dog

Boars Head brand hot dog. Chili, onions, and kraut available.

$2.25