Skip to main content
Pudgie's Pizza & Subs

Pudgie's Pizza & Subs

215 Elmira Rd, Ithaca, NY 14850
607-289-3912

Open until 7:00 PM

Full Hours
    Skip to first category
    fresh-custom-made-pizza

    Fresh Custom Made Pizza

    Cheese Pizza

    Classic cheese or create your own pizza.

    $12.76

    Famous Sheet Cheese Pizza

    Classic cheese or create your own pizza.

    $25.49

    pizza-by-the-slice

    Pizza by the Slice

    Plain Cheese Pizza Slice

    $2.99

    Pepperoni Pizza Slice

    $3.09

    pizza-wing-combos

    Pizza & Wing Combos

    Party Package Special

    Sheet Pizza (32 Slices) - 20 Buffalo Style Wings & 2 Quarts of Soda.

    $50.94

    Snack Pack Special

    Medium Cheese Pizza (6 Slices) & 10 Buffalo Style Wings.

    $24.39

    Family Pack Special

    Large cheese pizza (12 slices)- 10 buffalo style wings & 1 quart of soda.

    $33.78

    slice-sub-specials

    Slice & Sub Specials

    Plain Slice Special

    2 Cheese Slices & 16 oz. Drink

    $6.49

    Stromboli Special

    Slice of Stromboli & 16 oz. Drink.

    $7.38

    Pepperoni Slice Special

    2 Pepperoni Slices & 16 oz. Drink.

    $6.69

    Deal of A Meal Special

    Any Hot or Large Cold Sub, Fries & 16 oz. Drink.

    $12.37

    Plain Pizza Slice, 3 Breadsticks & 16 oz. Drink Special

    $6.19

    garden-fresh-salads

    Garden Fresh Salads

    Buffalo Chicken Salad

    Crispy iceberg lettuce, tomatoes, onions, cheese with pieces of diced chicken, medium wing sauce, and your choice of bleu cheese or ranch dressing.

    $7.47

    Garden Salad

    Crispy iceberg lettuce, tomatoes, onions, and your choice of dressing.

    $5.89

    Chicken Salad

    Crispy iceberg lettuce, tomatoes, onions, cheese with pieces of diced chicken, and your choice of dressing.

    $7.47

    Side Salad

    Crispy iceberg lettuce, tomatoes, onions, and your choice of dressing.

    $4.15

    Chef Salad

    Crispy iceberg lettuce, tomatoes, onions, and cheese with sliced turkey & ham, and your choice of dressing.

    $7.47

    side-orders

    Side Orders

    Mozzarella Sitcks

    5 Pieces

    $6.49

    French Fries

    $2.59

    Chicken Fingers

    $8.29

    Breadsticks

    $3.94

    Fried Dough

    $3.42

    stromboli

    Stromboli

    Stromboli

    Great taste treat. Folded pizza dough, filled with pepperoni, sweet sausage, ham, green peppers, mozzarella & American cheese.

    $5.83

    wings

    Wings

    Tompkins county #1 choice.

    Pudgie’s Buffalo Style Chicken Wings

    $15.38

    Pudgie’s Boneless Wings

    $15.38

    cold-subs

    Cold Subs

    Cold Subs include mayo, lettuce, tomatoes, onion & Italian dressing.

    Turkey Sub

    Includes mayo, lettuce tomatoes, onion & Italian dressing.

    $6.99

    Cheese Sub

    Double American / Swiss cheese.

    $6.99

    Super Sub

    Boiled ham, Italian salami, capicola, and American cheese.

    $6.99

    Ham & Cheese Sub

    Includes mayo, lettuce tomatoes, onion & Italian dressing.

    $6.99

    Italian Sub

    Italian salami, capicola ham, and American cheese.

    $6.99

    hot-subs

    Hot Subs

    Hot Meatball Sub

    Seasoned ground beef in Pudgie’s spaghetti sauce. Covered with melted mozzarella cheese.

    $9.87

    Grilled Ham & Cheese Sub

    Grilled ham & cheese, served with lettuce, tomatoes, onions & mayonnaise.

    $9.87

    Pudgie Burger

    A great sandwich - over 1/3 lb., served on a toasted roll with melted cheese, lettuce, tomatoes, onions, and mayonnaise.

    $9.87

    Cheesesteak Sub

    Top sirloin steak thinly sliced and topped with melted cheese, lettuce, tomatoes, onions & mayonnaise.

    $9.87

    pasta

    Pasta

    Spaghetti

    $8.29

    Dinner

    Pasta, salad & breadsticks.

    $10.39

    Spaghetti with Meatballs

    $9.79

    Dinner with Meatballs

    Pasta, salad & breadsticks.

    $11.89

    Rigatoni

    $8.29

    Baked Pasta

    With melted mozzarella cheese.

    $9.29

    Rigatoni with Meatballs

    $9.79

    beverages

    Beverages

    Soda

    $2.07

    Water

    $2.07

    crowd-pleaser-catering

    Crowd Pleaser Catering

    Sheet of Breadsticks Catering

    $21.00

    Veggie Platter Catering

    12-hour notice required.

    $43.00

    Large Pasta Catering

    12-hour notice required.

    $40.55

    Sub Platter Catering

    $47.85

    Large Pasta with Meatballs Catering

    12-hour notice required.

    $45.55

    Family Pleaser Catering

    Large Pizza, 2 pastas, 2 salads and 2 large bread sticks.

    $35.97

    Large Garden Salad Catering

    $24.69

    Triple Treat Catering

    Three Medium pizzas with one topping each.

    $29.59

    Pudgie's Pizza & Subs - View Menu & Order Online - 215 Elmira Rd, Ithaca, NY 14850 - Slice

    SliceNYIthaca14850 Pudgie's Pizza & Subs
    Price: $$