Skip to main content
Best Pizza is currently ONLY available for PICKUP orders.
Best Pizza

Best Pizza

52 Main St, New Paltz, NY 12561
845-305-5380

Open until Sat at 2:00 AM

Full Hours
  • 5% off online orders
20-pies
20” Pies

Cheese Pizza

house made mozzarella, tomato sauce, grana padano, fresh basil

$23.00

Cheese Pizza

White Pizza

seasoned ricotta, house mozzarella, pecorino romano, caramelized onions, sesame seed crust

$26.00

White Pizza

Grandma Pizza

square, house mozzarella, crushed plum tomato, garlic, basil, anchovy

$25.50

Grandma Pizza
heros
Heros

Chicken Parm Hero

fried chicken thighs, house mozzarella, spicy marinara sauce

$12.00


Meatball Hero

grass fed beef, grandma sauce, provolone

$13.00


Eggplant Hero

roasted eggplant, house mozzarella, cherry tomatoes, giardiniera

$11.00

buffalo-wings
Buffalo Wings
with bleu cheese

Mild Wings

$7.95


Medium Wings

$7.95


Hot Wings

$7.95

sides
Sides

Garlic Knots

served with spicy marinara sauce

$3.25


Side of Meatballs

grass fed beef, grandma sauce

$10.00

Side of Meatballs

Spiced Mixed Pickles

carrot, fennel, red onion, eggplant, XO sauce (not vegan)

$6.00

Spiced Mixed Pickles

Raw Dough

one 20" house dough

$6.50

salads
Salads

Romaine

the pizzeria classic, red wine vinaigrette

$10.00


Arugula

fennel, chickpeas, golden raisin, lemon dressing

$11.00

drinks
Drinks

Drink

$2.25


Water

$1.75

SliceNYNew Paltz12561 Best Pizza
Price: $$
Cuisine: grandma pizza