Skip to main content
Bagel Boss Cafe & Pizzeria

Bagel Boss Cafe & Pizzeria

263 1st Ave, New York, NY 10003
212-388-9292

Open until 5:00 PM

Full Hours

Delivery (25 - 40 min)

  • Free Delivery
  • 5% OFF online
top-items
Top Items

Two Eggs on Bagel Breakfast

$4.50


Bagel with a Schmear

$2.50


Flagel with a Schmear

$3.75


Bagels by the Dozen

$21.00


Muffin

$4.25


Our Classic Tuna Salad Sandwich

$8.99


Smoked Atlantic Nova Salmon Sandwich

$12.99


Regular Cream Cheese A La Carte

$6.00


Gatorade

$3.25


Iced Coffee

$4.50

pizza
Pizza

Regular Cheese Pizza

Classic cheese or create your own pizza.

$30.00


Sicilian Pie

Classic cheese or create your own pizza.

$35.00


One Topping Pizza

Classic cheese or create your own pizza.

$35.00

pizza-by-the-slice
Pizza by the Slice

Regular Cheese Pizza Slice

Classic cheese or create your own pizza.

$3.99


Sicilian Pizza Slice

Classic cheese or create your own pizza.

$4.75


One Topping Pizza Slice

$4.50

pizza-bagels
Pizza Bagels

Plain Pizza Bagel

$6.99


Whole Wheat Pizza Bagel

$6.99


Mini Pizza Bagels

$8.99

daily-specials
Daily Specials

Two Cheese Slice Pizza Special

Served with can of soda or small Poland spring water available from 10 am.

$8.99

breakfast-specials
Breakfast Specials

One Egg Any Style Breakfast Special

Served with your choice of bread, a 12 oz. coffee and a 6 oz. orange juice.

$5.50


Two Eggs Any Style Breakfast Special

Served with your choice of bread, a 12 oz. coffee and a 6 oz. orange juice.

$6.50


Homemade Challah French Toast Breakfast Special

Served with a 12 oz. coffee and a 4 oz. orange juice.

$9.25


Pancakes Breakfast Special

Served with a 12 oz. coffee and a 4 oz. orange juice.

$9.25


Egg Wrap Breakfast Special

Your choice of any of our famous egg wraps. Served with a 12 oz. coffee.

$12.50


Bagel All the Way Breakfast Special

Nova lox, cream cheese, lettuce, tomato and onion on your choice of bagel, bialy or roll. Served with your choice of side salad and a pickle.

$13.99


Hot Oatmeal Breakfast Special

$5.75

breakfast-wraps
Breakfast Wraps
Served with 12 oz. coffee & your choice of wrap.

Egg White Wrap Breakfast

With spinach and mushrooms.

$10.50


Classic Egg Wrap Breakfast

With sauteed onions, mushrooms and cheese.

$12.50


Farmers Wrap Breakfast

Eggs with veggie links, soy strips & cheese.

$10.50


Bagel Boss Favorite Wrap Breakfast

Eggs with potato & onions.

$10.50


Veggie Wrap

Eggs with broccoli, peppers, onions & mushrooms.

$10.50

breakfast-grill
Breakfast Grill

One Egg on Roll Breakfast

$4.99


One Egg on Bagel Breakfast

$3.75


Two Eggs on Bagel Breakfast

$4.50


Two Eggs on Roll Breakfast

$5.99


The Bagel Boss Plate Breakfast

2 eggs any style served with home fries, our famous bagel or bialy, orange juice, and coffee.

$8.99


French Toast Breakfast

$8.99


Butter Pancakes Breakfast

$8.99

omelettes
Omelettes

Three Eggs & Vegetables Omelette

Comes with home fries and your choice of either a bagel or bialy.

$11.99


Leo Omelette

With lox, eggs, and onions. Comes with home fries and your choice of either a bagel or bialy.

$12.99


Greek Omelette

Feta cheese, spinach, and tomato.

$12.99


Western Omelette

Red and green peppers, veggie sausage links, cheddar cheese, and salsa.

$12.99

bagels-with-a-schmear
Bagels with a Schmear

Bagel with a Schmear

$2.50


Bialy with a Schmear

$2.50


Flagel with a Schmear

$3.75


Peanut Butter Sandwich

$3.99


Peanut Butter & Jelly Sandwich

$4.50


Guacamole Salad

$5.50

bagels-flats
Bagels & Flats

Bagel

$1.75


Bagels by the Dozen

$21.00


Low Carb Bagel

$2.25


Mini Bagel

$1.50


Mini Bialy

$1.50


Bagel Chips

Assorted flavors.

$6.99


Rainbow Bagel

$4.50


Rainbow Mini Bagel

$2.50

flagels
Flagels

Flagel

$2.75

from-the-bakery
From The Bakery

Muffin

$4.25


Raspberry Cigar

$4.25


Cinnamon Bun Danish

$4.25


Linzer Tart

$4.25


Croissant

$4.25


Turnover

$4.25


Black & White Cookie

$4.25


Brownie

$4.75


Danish

$4.25


Chocolate Chip Cookie

$4.25


Chocolate Cigar

$4.25


Rainbow Bar

$4.75


Almond Horn

$4.75


Elephant Ears

$4.75


Chocolate Babka Muffin

$4.75


Cupcake

$4.75


Homemade Old Fashioned Rugelach

$18.99


French Cookies

Jelly filled.

$18.99


Challah Bread

$8.99


Challah Roll

$2.99

cookies
Cookies

Gluten Free Cookie Package

$8.99


Sugar Free Cookie Package

$8.99


Regular Cookie Package

$8.99


Halvah Bars

$4.75


Nuts & Candy Treat

$8.99


Gluten Free Chocolate Brownie Cookies

$8.99


Assorted Gluten Free Cookies

$18.99

the-soup-kettle
The Soup Kettle
Served with a complimentary bagel.

Split Pea Soup

Served with a complimentary bagel. Availability may vary.

$5.75


Mushroom Barley Soup

Please contact the restaurant for availability.

$5.75


Minestrone Soup

Please contact the restaurant for availability. Served with a complimentary bagel.

$5.75


Yankee Bean Soup

Please contact the restaurant for availability. Served with a complimentary bagel.

$5.75


Vegetable Soup

Please contact the restaurant for availability. Served with a complimentary bagel.

$5.75


Vegetable Noodle Soup

Please contact the restaurant for availability. Served with a complimentary bagel.

$5.75


Potato Leek Soup

Please contact the restaurant for availability. Served with a complimentary bagel.

$5.75


Lentil Soup

Please contact the restaurant for availability. Served with a complimentary bagel.

$5.75


Soup of the Day

Please contact the restaurant for availability. Served with a complimentary bagel.

$5.75


Gazpacho

Tomato base, cold soup.

$6.99

chips
Chips

Skinny Popcorn Original Chips

$3.25


Veggie Chips Sea Salt

$3.25


Veggie Straws Sea Salt Chips

$3.25


Pop Corners Chips

$3.25


Dirty Chips

$3.25


Pretzel Chips

$3.25


Pirate Booty Chips

$3.25


Pop Chips Sea Salt & Vinegar

$3.25


Pop Chips Sea Salt Potato

$5.50


Smart Puffs Cheese Puffs

$5.50

the-salad-maker
The Salad Maker

Tossed Garden Salad

$9.99


Athenian Greek Salad

$10.99


Classic Caesar Salad

$9.99


Baby Spinach, Pears & Strawberries Salad

$10.99


California Spring Mix Salad

$10.99


Chef's Salad

$10.99

specialty-side-salads
Specialty Side Salads

Israeli Salad

$5.99


Pasta Primavera Salad

$5.99


Greek Pasta Salad

$5.99


Sundried Tomato Pasta Salad

$5.99


Potato Salad

$5.99


Macaroni Salad

$5.99


Cole Slaw

$5.99


Tomato Onion Salad

$5.99


Tuscany Bean Salad

$5.99


Cucumber Onion Salad

$5.99


California Broccoli Salad

$5.99


Health Salad

$5.99


Cucumber Tomato Salad

$5.99


Mediterranean Health Salad

$5.99

fresh-fruit
Fresh Fruit

Fresh Banana

$1.75


Apple

$1.75


Pear

$1.75

calzones-rolls-strombolis
Calzones, Rolls & Strombolis

Calzone

Please contact the restaurant for today's selections.

$8.99


Veggie Roll

Please contact the restaurant for today's selections.

$8.99


Stromboli

Please contact the restaurant for today's selections.

$8.99

paninis
Paninis
Served with a side salad and a crisp pickle wedge garnish.

The Dylan Panini

Fried eggplant and marinara sauce with melted mozzarella.

$13.99


The Michelle Panini

Grilled veggies with mozzarella cheese.

$13.99


The Danny Boy Panini

Tuna with Swiss and coleslaw.

$13.99


The Jordan Panini

Fresh mozzarella cheese and tomatoes. Topped with basil and garlic.

$13.99


The Al Panini

Roasted peppers, eggplant, mozzarella cheese and olive tapenade.

$13.99


Sydney's Delite Panini

Mozzarella cheese, portobello mushrooms and sun-dried tomatoes.

$13.99

the-sandwich-maker
The Sandwich Maker
Served with a side salad & crisp pickle wedge. With your choice of bread.

Low Fat Spring Time Tuna Sandwich

With apples and cranberries.

$8.99


Our Classic Tuna Salad Sandwich

$8.99


Toasted Tuna Melt with Tomato Sandwich

$12.99


Low Fat Honey Mustard Tuna Salad Sandwich

$8.99


Whitefish Salad Sandwich

$10.99


Baked Salmon Salad Sandwich

$10.99


Our Classic Egg Salad Sandwich

$8.00


Egg, Onion, & Mushroom Salad Sandwich

$8.50


Low Fat Vegetable Egg White Salad Sandwich

Cholesterol free and low fat.

$9.00


Low Fat Spinach Egg White & Tuna Salad Sandwich

Cholesterol free and low fat.

$9.50


Low Fat Spinach Egg White Salad Sandwich

$9.50


Veggie Burger Sandwich

$12.99


Low Fat Vegetable Tuna Salad Sandwich

$9.50

master-smoked-fish-sandwiches
Master Smoked Fish Sandwiches
Served with crisp lettuce, ripe tomato slices, Bermuda onions, cream cheese, a pickle wedge garnish & a side salad. With your choice of bread.

Smoked Atlantic Nova Salmon Sandwich

$13.00


Smoked Atlantic Belly Lox Sandwich

$13.99


Baked Kippered Salmon Sandwich

$13.99


Smoked Sable Plate Sandwich

$13.99

entrees
Entrees

Cheese Lasagna

Per piece. With mozzarella cheese and ricotta cheese. Served with marinara sauce.

$10.99


Spinach Lasagna

Per piece. With mozzarella cheese and ricotta cheese. Served with marinara sauce.

$10.99


Homemade Sweet Noodle Pudding

Per piece. Made with crushed pineapples, cottage cheese, sour cream and noodles.

$10.99


Knish

$5.25


Blintz

Per piece. Served with sour cream.

$5.00


Homemade Potato Pancakes

Served with apple sauce.

$4.25


Potato & Onion Perogi

Served with sour cream.

$4.25


Creamy Macaroni & Cheese

Hot or cold.

$10.99


Penne alla Vodka

Hot or cold.

$10.99


Quiche

$11.99

fruit-smoothie-section
Fruit Smoothie Section

Berry Blast Smoothie

Contains strawberry, blueberry, and raspberry.

$9.50


Summer Love Smoothie

Contains strawberry, pineapple, and mango.

$9.50


Banana Split Smoothie

Contains strawberry, banana, and chocolate syrup.

$9.50


The East Villager Smoothie

Contains blueberry, pineapple, and banana.

$9.50


The Stuy Towner Smoothie

Contains banana, peanut butter, and chocolate syrup.

$9.50


Create Your Own Smoothie

Any 3 toppings.

$9.50

dessert
Dessert

Rice Pudding

$5.50


Chocolate Pudding

$5.50


Fruit Salad

$7.50


Fruit Parfait

$7.50


Diet Baked Apple

$5.50


Diet Baked Pear

$5.50

a-la-carte-cream-cheese
A La Carte Cream Cheese

Butter A La Carte

$5.99


Regular Cream Cheese A La Carte

$6.00


Vegetable Cream Cheese A La Carte

$6.50


Scallion Cream Cheese A La Carte

$6.50


Walnut Raisin Cream Cheese A La Carte

$6.50


Sun Dried Tomato Cream Cheese A La Carte

$6.50


Lite Scallion & Lox Cream Cheese A La Carte

$7.50


Nova Spread Cream Cheese A La Carte

$7.50


Plain Tofu Cream Cheese A La Carte

$7.00


Vegetable Tofu Cream Cheese A La Carte

$7.50


Scallion Tofu Cream Cheese A La Carte

$7.50


Hummus A La Carte

$7.50


Funfetti Cream Cheese A La Carte

$7.50


Strawberry Cream Cheese A La Carte

$6.50


Garlic & Herb Cream Cheese A La Carte

$6.50


Apple Cinnamon Farmer Cheese A La Carte

$6.50


1/2lb Apple Cinnamon Farmer Cheese A La Carte

$6.50

a-la-carte-salads
A La Carte Salads

Spring Time Tuna Salad with Apples & Cranberries A La Carte

$8.50


Our Classic Tuna Salad A La Carte

$8.50


Honey Mustard Tuna Salad A La Carte

$8.50


Vegetable Tuna Salad A La Carte

$8.50


Whitefish Salad A La Carte

$10.99


Baked Salmon Salad A La Carte

$10.99


Our Classic Egg Salad A La Carte

$6.50


Egg, Onion & Mushroom Salad A La Carte

$6.50


Vegetable Egg White Salad A La Carte

$7.00


Spinach Egg White Salad A La Carte

$7.00


Seafood Salad A La Carte

$10.99


Guacamole Salad A La Carte

$8.50

a-la-carte-master-smoked-fish
A La Carte Master Smoked Fish

Smoked Atlantic Nova Salmon A La Carte

$30.00


Baked Kippered Salmon A La Carte

$30.00


Smoked Sable Plate A La Carte

$30.00


Belly Lox A La Carte

$30.00

beverages
Beverages

Soda

$2.25


Fuze Lemon Iced Tea

$2.25


Poland Spring Water

$2.25


Tropicana Juice

$3.25


Orange Juice

$6.99


Gatorade

$3.25


Naked Juice

$5.50


Snapple

$3.25


Vitamin Water

$3.25


Pressed Coconut Water

$5.25


Sugar Free Lemonade

$3.25


Milk

$5.99


Half & Half

$4.99


Smart Poland Spring Water

$1.99


Sport Bottle Smart Water

$3.50


Smart Water

$3.50


Essentia Water

$3.25


Nesquick

$3.25


Yoohoo

$3.25


Starbucks Frappuccino Drink

$4.50


Sparkling Ice

$3.25


Hals Flavored Seltzer

$3.25


Seltzer

$2.25

coffee-bar
Coffee Bar

Box of Coffee

$26.99


Box of Tea

Hot water with assorted tea bags.

$26.99


Cappuccino

$4.50


Columbian Coffee

$2.99


French Vanilla Cappuccino

$4.50


Fresh Brewed Iced Tea

$4.50


Freshly Ground Coffee

Freshly ground and a whole bean by the pound.

$16.99


Gourmet Coffee

$2.99


Hot Chocolate

$4.50


Iced Coffee

$4.50


Sugar Free Lemonade

$4.50


Tea

$2.99

lunch-specials
Lunch Specials
Available all day.

1. Chopped Salad Lunch

Your choice of any six items. Available all day.

$10.99


2. Cheese Blintzes Lunch

Served with sour cream. Available all day.

$12.99


3. Potato Pierogies Lunch

Boiled or fried. Served with sour cream, applesauce, and sauteed onions. Available all day.

$11.99


4. Fresh Fish of the Day Lunch

Please contact the restaurant for today's selection. Served over rice with grilled vegetables. Available all day.

$14.50


5. Famous Tuna Salad Lunch

Your choice of one of our famous tuna salads. Served with your choice of side salad, pickle and a can of soda. Available all day.

$10.99


6. Hot Soup of the Day Lunch

Please contact the restaurant for today's selection. Served with your choice of bagel, bialy or roll. Available all day.

$5.75


7. Two Slices of Pizza Lunch

Served with a can of soda. Available all day.

$8.99

catering-breakfast
Catering Breakfast
Requires 12 hrs notice.

Breakfast Buffet Catering

Assorted fresh boss bagels, bialys, and flagels. Served with assorted pastry platter and a variety of cream cheeses, butter, and jelly. Includes bagel boss coffee, flavored tea, premium orange and apple juice, and paper and cutlery service.

$191.88


Yogurt Fruit Parfait Catering

Low-fat yogurt, honey crunch granola and mixed berries.

$64.99


Sliced Fruit Basket Catering

Mouthwatering fruit featuring cantaloupe, honeydew, watermelon, pineapple, strawberries, red and green grapes, and seasonal specialties.

$66.00


Cut Fruit in Deco Bowl Catering

Mouthwatering fruit featuring cantaloupe, honeydew, watermelon, pineapple, strawberries, red and green grapes, and seasonal specialties.

$34.99


Bagel Boss Nosh Catering

Mouthwatering slices of nova and belly lox with fresh assorted bagels and bialys, choice of 2 homemade cream cheeses, sliced tomato and Bermuda onion swirl.

$215.88


Cream Cheese Platter Catering

Your choice of 4 of our delicious assorted cream cheese spreads. Includes bagels & butter.

$69.99

catering-hot-breakfast
Catering Hot Breakfast
Requires 12 hrs notice.

Hot Breakfast Offering Catering

Farm fresh scrambled eggs or gourmet omelets, old-fashioned challah French toast or fluffy pancakes, Morningstar Farms vegetable links and savory home fries, served with assorted pastries, bagel boss coffee, flavored tea assortment, premium orange juice. Includes a basket of freshly sliced bagels, bialys and flagels, assorted cream cheeses, butter and jelly, complete paper and cutlery service.

$263.88

catering-specialty-green-salads
Catering Specialty Green Salads
Requires 12 hrs notice.

Asparagus Portobello Salad Catering

Field greens, red peppers, grape tomatoes, grilled portobello mushrooms, asparagus, and feta cheese.

$59.99


Caesar Salad Catering

Crispy romaine lettuce leaves stuffed with Bermuda onions and red Holland pepper strips, dusted with grated Parmesan cheese, and served with a garlic Parmesan dressing and homemade croutons.

$59.99


Classic Spinach Salad Catering

Field greens, red peppers, grape tomatoes, grilled portobello mushrooms, asparagus, and feta cheese.

$59.99


Greek Salad Catering

Crisp romaine and green leaf lettuce, ripe tomato wedges, Bermuda onion, cucumber slices, imported Greek olives and feta cheese chunks.

$59.99


California Spring Mix Salad Catering

Mesclun lettuce, plum tomato wedges, red onions, cucumber, Mandarin oranges, walnuts, and feta cheese with raspberry vinaigrette.

$59.99


Arugula Mango Salad Catering

Grape tomatoes, red peppers, freshly peeled mangos, cucumbers, and craisins.

$59.99


Baby Spinach Salad Catering

Sliced strawberries, pears, walnuts, and craisins.

$59.99


Basic Tossed Garden Salad Catering

With your choice of dressing.

$59.99

catering-hot-entrees
Catering Hot Entrees
Requires 12 hrs notice.

Honey Balsamic Glazed Salmon Catering

$139.99


Cajun Style Salmon Catering

$139.99


Salmon Primavera Catering

$139.99


Flounder Florentine Catering

$139.99


Flounder Marsala Catering

$139.99


Honey Lime Salmon Catering

$139.99


Flounder Parmigiana Catering

$139.99


Orange Salmon Catering

$139.99


Raspberry Salmon Catering

$139.99


Assorted Blintzes Catering

Cheese, cherry, blueberry and potato.

$69.99


Steamed Vegetables Catering

Includes basked of dinner rolls.

$64.99


Rice Pilaf Catering

Includes basked of dinner rolls.

$64.99


Grilled Vegetables in a Balsamic Glaze Catering

Includes basked of dinner rolls.

$84.99


Vegetable Lasagna Catering

Includes basked of dinner rolls.

$84.99


Spinach Lasagna Catering

Includes basked of dinner rolls.

$84.99


Fettuccine Alfredo Catering

Includes basked of dinner rolls.

$84.99


Penne a la Vodka in a Pink Cream Sauce Catering

Includes basked of dinner rolls.

$84.99


Baked Ziti Catering

Includes basked of dinner rolls.

$84.99


Pasta Primavera with Fresh Vegetables Catering

In a garlic shallot sauce. Includes a basket of dinner rolls.

$84.99


Eggplant Towers Catering

Includes a basket of dinner rolls.

$84.99


Eggplant Parmigiana Catering

Includes a basket of dinner rolls.

$84.99

catering-bagel-boss-gala-package
Catering Bagel Boss Gala Package
Requires 12 hrs notice.

Gold Package Catering

Selection of mouthwatering smoked fish, choice of 2 gourmet salads, choice of green salad, choice of 2 accompaniments, a variety of cream cheeses, lettuce, tomato and onion platter, baskets of assorted sliced fruit, baskets of bagels, bialys and flagels, ceremonial challah bread, assorted desserts, hot and cold beverage service. Includes complete paper service and fine plasticware, wait staff and short linen table coverings, and buffet tables with a skirt.

$1499.75

catering-desserts
Catering Desserts
Requires 12 hrs notice.

Pastries & Cakes Catering

Delicious old world rugelach, cookies, Danish and brownies, served on beautifully arranged platters.

$49.99

catering-beverages
Catering Beverages
Requires 12 hrs notice.

Orange Juice Catering

$6.99


Apple Juice Catering

$5.99


Soda Catering

$5.99


Polan Spring Water Catering

$2.25


Coffee To Go Box Catering

Served with all additions sugars, creamer, stir sticks & cups.

$26.99


Tea To Go Box Catering

Served with all additions sugars, creamer, stir sticks & cups. Hot water & assorted tea bags.

$26.99


Box of Hot Chocolate Catering

Comes with cups, sweeteners & milk.

$26.99


Box of Cappuccino Catering

Comes with milk, sweeteners, and cups.

$26.99


Box of French Vanilla Cappuccino Catering

Comes with milk, sweeteners, and cups.

$26.99


Box of Iced Coffee Catering

Comes with milk, sweeteners, and cups.

$26.99

catering-brunch-lunch
Catering Brunch & Lunch
Requires 12 hrs notice.

Cheese Platter Catering

An assortment of fine kosher sliced or cubed cheeses. Accompanied by a basket of bagel chips.

$64.99


Coffee Break Catering

Regular and decaf coffee, cut-up fresh fruit in a deco bowl, an assortment of cubed cheese and crackers, and a delicious platter or our fine pastries and cakes.

$209.85


Vegetable Crudite Basket Catering

A beautiful wicker basket filled with an assortment of crispy julienne vegetables, florets of broccoli and cauliflower, ripe cherry tomatoes and Holland pepper spears. Served with choice of dip.

$59.99


Any Occasion Platter Catering

Fresh hand-sliced Nova Scotia lox, classic tuna and egg salad, plain and scallion cream cheese, sliced tomato and onion, and assorted bagels, bialys, and flagels.

$18.99


Salad Platter a la Carte Catering

Your choice of 3 salads beautifully decorated on a platter. A perfect addition to our smoked fish medley.

$125.00


Overstuffed Sandwich Buffet Catering

Comes with a pickle, olive & relish tray.

$203.88


Bagel Boss Salad Medley Catering

Beautiful garnished platter with choice of 3 salads, and 2 garnished bowls of your choice. Includes garnished tomato, red Bermuda onion, cucumber and Greek olive platter, served with assorted bagels, bialys and flagels, sliced to order.

$191.88


Bagel Boss Smoked Fish Medley Catering

Includes a beautiful fillet or stuffed whitefish, surrounded by layers of the finest sable plate, kippered baked salmon and sliced of our own master smoked Nova and belly lox. Includes a bowl of tender marinated herring fillets in choice of sauce, choice of 3 cream cheese spreads and butter, and an assortment of bagels, bialys and flagels. Serve with garnished tomato, red Bermuda onion, cucumber and Greek olive platter.

$299.88

SlicePizza Places in New York, NY Bagel Boss Cafe & Pizzeria
Price: $$