10% Off Online!
Bagels & Co
391 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10024
646-760-3570View Full Hours$10 MinimumMenu
Pizza
Margherita Cheese Pizza$2600
Classic cheese or create your own pizza. Fresh mozzarella cheese, plum tomatoes & fresh basil.
Gluten Free Plain Cheese Pizza$1000
Classic cheese or create your own pizza.
Specialty Pizza
Marinara Pizza$2600
Mozzarella cheese & tomato sauce.
Broccoli Garden Pizza$2600
Fresh broccoli & mixed vegetables.
Caponata Pizza$2600
Roasted eggplant, garlic & fresh herbs.
Caesar Salad Pizza$2600
Romaine lettuce, croutons & Caesar dressing.
Hawaiian Pizza$2600
Grilled fresh pineapple.
Onions & Peppers Pizza$2600
Caramelized red onions & roasted peppers.
Olimato Pizza$2600
Kalamata olives, plum tomatoes & fresh basil.
Pesto & Tomato Pizza$2600
Ricotta pesto & plum tomatoes.
Pomodoro Pizza$2600
Penne pasta, tomato sauce & mixed fresh herbs.
Savory Tomato Pizza$2600
Caramelized onions, plum tomatoes & mixed fresh herbs.
Spinach & Ricotta Pizza$2600
Fresh spinach, ricotta cheese & plum tomatoes.
Tonno Pizza$2600
Tuna, peppers, scallions, fresh basil & cilantro.
Wild Mushrooms Pizza$2600
Portobello, shiitake & cremini mushrooms.
White Pizza$2600
Pizza by the Slice
Marinara Pizza Slice$275
Mozzarella cheese & tomato sauce.
White Pizza Slice$375
Pesto & Tomato Pizza Slice$375
Ricotta pesto & plum tomatoes.
Caponata Pizza Slice$375
Roasted eggplant, garlic & fresh herbs.
Savory Tomato Pizza$375
Caramelized onions, plum tomatoes & mixed fresh herbs.
Hawaiian Pizza Slice$375
Grilled fresh pineapple.
Tonno Pizza Slice$375
Tuna, peppers, scallions, fresh basil & cilantro.
Onions & Peppers Pizza Slice$375
Caramelized red onions & roasted peppers.
Spinach & Ricotta Pizza Slice$375
Fresh spinach, ricotta cheese & plum tomatoes.
Margherita Pizza Slice$375
Fresh mozzarella cheese, plum tomatoes & fresh basil.
Wild Mushrooms Pizza Slice$375
Portobello, shiitake & cremini mushrooms.
Olimato Pizza Slice$375
Kalamata olives, plum tomatoes & fresh basil.
Broccoli Garden Pizza Slice$375
Fresh broccoli & mixed vegetables.
Pomodoro Pizza Slice$375
Penne pasta, tomato sauce & mixed fresh herbs.
Caesar Salad Pizza Slice$375
Romaine lettuce, croutons & Caesar dressing.
Appetizers
French Fries$475
Cheese Fries$525
Onion Rings$475
Potato Cigars$500
Fried filo dough filled with potato.
Turkish Style Borekas$450
Cheese, spinach cheese & potatoes.
Spicy Fries$475
Mozzarella Sticks$550
Nachos with Hot Cheese$600
Borekas$150
Cheese, spinach cheese, potatoes & mushrooms.
Breakfast Menu
Two Eggs & Two Pancakes Breakfast$795
Two Pancakes & Banana Breakfast$550
Three Pancakes & Banana Breakfast$795
Spinach & Feta Omelette Breakfast$1095
Served with home fries & Israeli salad or Greek salad.
Mushroom Omelette Breakfast$995
Served with home fries & Israeli salad or Greek salad.
Two Eggs Any Style Breakfast$995
Served with home fries & Israeli salad or Greek salad.
Greek Omelette Breakfast$995
Served with home fries & Israeli salad or Greek salad.
Spanish Omelette Breakfast$995
Served with home fries & Israeli salad or Greek salad.
Eggs with Grilled Veggies Breakfast$995
Served with home fries & Israeli salad or Greek salad.
Lox, Egg & Onion Omelette Breakfast$1095
Served with home fries & Israeli salad or Greek salad.
Greek Wrap Breakfast$995
Served with home fries & Israeli salad or Greek salad. Scrambled eggs, spinach, tomatoes & feta cheese.
French Toast with Fruit Salad Breakfast$795
Two Pancakes with Fruit Salad Breakfast$795
Two Pancakes, Two Eggs, Home Fries & Small Coffee Breakfast$1095
Sabih Breakfast$795
Boiled eggs, fried eggplant, Israeli salad, hummus, pickle & tahini.
Israeli Panini Breakfast$795
Mozzarella cheese, plain cream cheese & 3 vegetable toppings.
Bagels
Bagel$125
Baguette$175+
Bakers Bagels$1500
Receive a free bagel with this order.
Croissant$275
Knishes & Blintzes
Spinach Knish$400
Potato Knish$400
Cherry Cheese Blintz$525
Kasha Knish$400
Blueberry Cheese Blintz$525
Spreads
Butter on a Bagel$175
Butter & Jelly on a Bagel$200
Plain Cream Cheese on a Bagel$300
Scallion Cream Cheese on a Bagel$400
Chocolate Chip Cream Cheese on a Bagel$450
Hot Pepper Cream Cheese on a Bagel$450
Lox Spread Cream Cheese on a Bagel$450
Tofu Plain Spread on a Bagel$450
Tofu Scallion Spread on a Bagel$450
Jelly on a Bagel$175
Peanut Butter & Jelly on a Bagel$300
Vegetable Cream Cheese on a Bagel$400
Blueberry Cream Cheese on a Bagel$450
Garlic & Herb Cream Cheese on a Bagel$450
Kalamata Olive Cream Cheese on a Bagel$450
Sun Dried Tomato Cream Cheese on a Bagel$450
Tofu Vegetable Spread on a Bagel$450
Walnut & Raisin Cream Cheese on a Bagel$450
Spreads by the Lb.
Spring Tuna Salad$450+
Jelly$350+
Plain Cream Cheese$250+
Scallion Cream Cheese$300+
Hard Cheese$325+
Lox Cream Cheese$350+
Walnut Cream Cheese$350+
Tofu Vegetable Spread$350+
Hummus$325+
Matbuha$325+
Scallion Egg Salad$350+
Avocado Salad$350+
Veggie Tuna Salad$450+
Chopped Herring$450+
White Fish Salad$600+
Nova Lox$1075+
Kippered Salmon$1075+
Butter$350+
Vegetable Cream Cheese$300+
Olive Cream Cheese$300+
Garlic Cream Cheese$350+
Tomato Cream Cheese$350+
Tofu Spread$350+
Tofu Scallion Spread$350+
Baba Ganoush$325+
Egg Salad$350+
Egg White Spinach$350+
Tuna Salad$450+
Spicy Tuna Salad$450+
Low Fat Tuna Salad$450+
Pickled Herring$450+
Baked Salmon Salad$600+
Sable$1075+
Soups
Served with a free bagel.
Soup of the Day$575
Please call the restaurant for today's selection.
Salads
Create Your Own Salad$675
Bowl of greens, cucumbers, carrots & onions.
Fruit Salad$675+
Israeli Salad$675+
Caesar Salad$750
Greek Salad$675+
Calzones
Cheese Calzone$650
Three Topping Calzone$750
Egg & Cheese Sandwiches
Bagel with Egg Sandwich$400
Bagel with Egg Whites Sandwich$525
Croissant with Eggs Sandwich$500
Croissant with Egg White Sandwich$625
Two Slices of Cheese on a Bagel Sandwich$275
Bagel with Egg & Cheese Sandwich$450
Croissant with Eggs & Cheese Sandwich$550
Croissant with Egg Whites & Cheese Sandwich$650
Grilled Cheese Sandwich$475
Bagel with Egg Whites & Cheese Sandwich$550
Sandwiches
Nova Scotia Salmon Sandwich$975
White Fish Salad Sandwich$800
Tuna A La Chef's Sandwich$675
Vinaigrette dressing, no mayo.
Herring Sandwich$675
Hummus Sandwich$525
Spanish Eggplant Sandwich$525
Sable Sandwich$925
Tuna Salad Sandwich$675
Vegetable Tuna Salad Sandwich$675
Egg Salad Sandwich$550
Baba Ganoush Sandwich$525
Sandwich Platters
Served with your choice of Israeli, Greek or fruit salad & a bagel.
Nova Scotia Salmon Sandwich Platter$1625
White Fish Salad Sandwich Platter$1450
Tuna A La Chef's Sandwich Platter$1325
Vinaigrette dressing, no mayo.
Herring Sandwich Platter$1275
Hummus Sandwich Platter$1175
Spanish Eggplant Sandwich Platter$1175
Sable Sandwich Platter$1575
Tuna Salad Sandwich Platter$1325
Vegetable Tuna Salad Sandwich Platter$1325
Egg Salad Sandwich Platter$1225
Baba Ganoush Sandwich Platter$1175
Paninis
Open Faced Cheese Melt Panini$700
Open Faced Tuna Melt Panini$875
Tuna, mozzarella cheese, lettuce & tomatoes.
Greek Supreme Panini$700
Feta cheese, tomatoes, mixed olives & roasted peppers.
Open Faced Pizza Bagel Panini$700
Triple Cheese Deluxe Panini$700
Mozzarella cheese, feta cheese & American cheese with tomatoes & sauteed red onions.
French Connection Panini$700
Grilled vegetables, zucchini, onions, mushrooms, peppers & tomatoes with melted cheese.
Wraps & Quesadillas
Avocado Wrap$800
Grilled Vegetable Wrap$725
Egg Salad Wrap$650
Mozzarella Wrap$700
Lettuce, tomatoes & onions.
Falafel Wrap$700
Tuna Salad Wrap$775
Mediterranean Wrap$700
Quesadilla$800
Wrap with 2 kinds of cheese & vegetables.
Caesar Salad Wrap$700
Chef's Daily Specialties
Fish of the Day$1075
Please call the restaurant for today's selection.
Filet of Fish$775
Veggie Burger$675
Lasagna$675+
Baked Ziti$675+
Spaghetti Marinara$675+
Hot Pasta Dish$675+
Rice$475+
Fish of the Day Platter$1550
Please call the restaurant for today's selection. Served with two sides.
Filet of Fish Platter$1250
Served with two sides.
Veggie Burger Platter$1150
Served with two sides.
Baked Ziti with Vegetable$675+
Pasta Salad$650+
Home Fries$475+
Coleslaw$375+
Baked Goods
Black & White Cookie$275
Muffin$275
Variety of Cookies$300
Raisin Challah$600
Yogurt, Fruit & Granola Cup$475
Danish$275
Donuts$275
Choice of vanilla or chocolate.
Variety of Rugelach$350
Plain Challah$550
Whole Wheat Challah$600
Israeli Menu
Falafel in Pita$600
Malawach$600
Israeli filo dough filled with boiled egg & veggies.
Egg Salad in Pita$600
Shakshuka$1295
Israeli salad on bagel or pita.
Falafel Plate$750
6 Falafel balls, hummus, tahini, Israeli salad, pickles & pita.
Tuna in Pita$700
Hummus Plate$600
Hummus, tahini & pita.
Beverages
Soda$175+
Iced Coffee$325+
Iced Flavored Coffee$350+
Flavored Iced Latte$450+
Lemon Dasani Sparkling$175
Seltzer$175+
Fresca$175
Snapple$225
Smoothie$450+
Iced Tea$325+
Iced Latte$450+
Poland Spring Water$150+
Hals New York Lemon Seltzer$225
Tropicana Juice$275
Catering
Shakshuka Catering$4500+
Eggs cooked with tomatoes, garlic, herbs & peppers.
Omelette Catering$4000+
Mushrooms, cheese, spinach & vegetable.
Homemade Fries Catering$3500+
Baked potatoes with our special spices, onions & peppers.
Coleslaw Catering$4000+
Bagel & Bialy Catering$1500+
Assorted bagels cut into quarters.
Bakery Basket Catering$3500+
Homemade baked cookies, danishes or muffins.
Homemade Blintzes Catering$4500+
Filled with soft sweet cream cheese.
Burekas Catering$3500+
Assorted burekas filled with cheese, spinach, potatoes, peppers & mushrooms.
Homemade Pancakes Catering$4000+
Banana, blueberry or plain.
Orange Juice Catering$800
Soda Catering$400
Water Catering$400
Cream Cheese Platter Catering$5000+
Assorted cream cheeses: plain, vegetable, scallion, olive or lox spread.
Hard Cheese Platter Catering$4000+
Mozzarella, American, muenster & Swiss cheese.
Combo Platter Catering$6000+
Egg salad, tuna salad & white fish salad.
Smoked Fish Platter Catering$13500+
Whole white fish, sable & lox (only small platter has lox & sable)
Vegetable Platter Catering$4000+
Stick or sliced: cucumbers, tomatoes, red onions, carrots & peppers.
Mediterranean Salad Platter Catering$4000+
Tahini, hummus, baba ganush, turkish salad, matbucha or spanish eggplant.
Fruit Platter Catering$5000+
Assorted seasonal fruits.
Omelette Wraps Platter Catering$5500+
Spinach, cheese, scallions or vegetable (wrapped with lettuce, tomatoes, red onions & home fries.)
Assorted Wraps Platter Catering$6500+
Assorted wraps: egg salad, tuna salad, whitefish salad, baked salmon salad, grilled vegetable & hummus, hard cheese.
Stuffed Sandwiches Catering$4000+
Homemade focaccia bread filled with pesto sauce, mozzarella cheese, melanzane sauce, eggplant, avocado or tuna.
Salad Bowl Catering$5000+
Greek, Israeli, Caesar, Israeli tuna or garden salad.
Pasta Catering$5000+
Pesto sauce, vodka sauce, primavera, marinara sauce, funghi, aglio olio or Alfredo sauce.
Lasagna Catering$5000+
Marinara sauce & cheese, vegetable, spinach or eggplant.
Homemade Quiche Catering$4500+
Mushrooms & spinach, zucchini & yellow squash, broccoli & more.
20'' Plain Pizza Catering$2000
20'' One Topping Pizza Catering$2600
20'' Whole Wheat Plain Pizza Catering$2800
20'' One Topping Whole Wheat Plain Pizza Catering$3400
Your Cart
ASAP Delivery
Update
delivery
pickup
We can’t tell if the restaurant delivers to your location unless you provide us with an address.
Edit Address
Your cart is empty. Select from the menu to start an order!
Let Us Help You
Pizzeria Owners
Grow your business with easy online ordering, personalized marketing, and larger orders more often. We list your menu on Slice for free!
Browse Pizza Delivery or Pickup by City
