Skip to main content
Gotham Pizza

Gotham Pizza

1667 1st Ave, New York, NY 10028
218-514-6578

Order Ahead We open Tue at 10:30 AM

Full Hours
    Skip to first category
    popular-items

    Popular Items

    Regular Cheese Pie

    Real parmigiano-reggiano cheese.

    $12.95

    Regular Cheese Pie

    Pepperoni Pie

    Pepperoni pizza.

    $17.45

    Pepperoni Pie
    pizza-pies

    Pizza Pies

    Regular Cheese Pie

    Real parmigiano-reggiano cheese.

    $12.95

    Regular Cheese Pie

    House Special Pie

    Everything on it!

    $19.95

    BBQ Chicken Pizza

    $18.95

    Regular Pie with One Topping

    Real Parmigiano-Reggiano cheese.

    $17.45

    Margherita Pie

    Fresh mozzarella, Homemade marinara sauce with onions, Extra virgin olive oil, and fresh basil.

    $16.95

    Margherita Pie

    Margherita Pie with One Topping

    Fresh mozzarella, Homemade marinara sauce with onions, Extra virgin olive oil, and fresh basil.

    $19.95

    Pepperoni Pie

    Pepperoni pizza.

    $17.45

    Pepperoni Pie

    Pepperoni Pizza with One Topping

    Pepperoni pizza.

    $16.95

    White Pie

    Mozzarella cheese and ricotta cheese.

    $15.95

    White Pie

    White Pizza with One Topping

    Mozzarella cheese and ricotta cheese.

    $16.95

    Chicken Pie

    Chicken cutlet pizza.

    $17.95

    Chicken Pie

    Chicken Pizza with One Topping

    $20.95

    Buffalo Chicken Pie

    Buffalo chicken with ranch.

    $18.95

    Buffalo Chicken Pie

    Buffalo Chicken Pizza with One Topping

    Buffalo chicken with ranch.

    $23.45

    Vegetable Pie

    All vegetable toppings.

    $18.95

    Vegetable Pie

    Vegetable Pizza with One Topping

    All vegetable toppings.

    $23.45

    square-pizza-pies

    Square Pizza Pies

    Grandma Pizza

    Homemade marinara sauce with onions, Mozzarella, Extra virgin olive oil, and fresh basil.

    $25.95

    Grandma Pizza

    Grandma Pizza with One Topping

    Homemade marinara sauce with onions, Mozzarella, Extra virgin olive oil and fresh basil.

    $28.45

    Sicilian Pizza

    Sicilian pie.

    $21.95

    Sicilian Pizza

    Sicilian Pizza with One Topping

    Sicilian pie.

    $24.45

    pizza-by-the-slice

    Pizza By The Slice

    Regular Pizza Slice

    Real parmigiano-reggiano cheese.

    $3.00

    Chicken Pizza Slice

    Chicken cutlet slice.

    $4.25

    Margherita Pizza Slice

    Fresh mozzarella, Homemade marinara sauce, Extra virgin olive oil, and fresh basil.

    $4.00

    Buffalo Chicken Pizza Slice

    Breaded buffalo chicken cutlet with ranch slice.

    $5.00

    Pepperoni Pizza Slice

    Pepperoni pizza slice.

    $4.00

    BBQ Chicken Pizza Slice

    $5.00

    White Pizza Slice

    Mozzarella cheese and ricotta cheese.

    $3.75

    square-pizza-by-the-slice

    Square Pizza by the Slice

    Square Grandma Pizza Slice

    Homemade marinara sauce, Mozzarella, Extra virgin olive oil, and fresh basil.

    $4.00

    salads

    Salads

    House Salad

    Lettuce, tomatoes, cucumber, black olives, onions and carrots.

    $5.95

    Caesar Salad

    Romaine lettuce, fresh romano cheese, cucumbers and croutons.

    $6.95

    garlic-knots

    Garlic Knots

    Garlic Knots

    $1.50

    beverages

    Beverages

    Soda

    $2.00

    Water

    $2.00

    salads-catering

    Salads Catering

    House Salad Catering

    Lettuce, tomatoes, cucumber, black olives, onions and carrots.

    $40.00

    Caesar Salad Catering

    Romaine lettuce, fresh romano cheese, cucumbers, and croutons.

    $50.00

    Gotham Pizza - 1667 1st Ave, New York, NY 10028 - Menu, Hours, & Phone Number - Order Delivery or Pickup - Slice

    SliceNYNew York10028 Gotham Pizza
    Price: $$