hero

Salvatore's Old Fashioned Pizzeria

205 S Main St, Newark, NY 14513

Open NowFull HoursAre you the owner?

We're all about supporting local pizzerias - even those who are not Slice partners.
Give Salvatore's Old Fashioned Pizzeria a call to order. We hear their food's delish.

Menu
our-famous-pizza
  • Salvatore’s Pizza $14.95 +
  • Manhattan NY Style Pizza $19.95
  • Salvatore’s Sheet Pizza $25.95
specialty-pizza
  • Salvatore’s Supreme Pizza $19.95 +
  • The Salvatore Pizza $19.95 +
    Tomato sauce base, lots of mozzarella, pepperoni, fresh mushrooms & giant italian sausage.
  • Linda Da’ Veggie Pizza $19.95 +
    Tomato sauce base, lots of mozzarella, diced onions, green peppers, fresh mushrooms & black olives.
  • Chicken Charlie Pizza $19.95 +
    Blue cheese base, your choice of wing sauce with diced chicken fingers & lots of mozzarella.
  • The Breath Mint Pizza $19.95 +
    Our garlic pizza, olive oil base, fresh garlic, onions, sliced tomatoes & lots of mozzarella.
  • Meathead Pizza $19.95 +
    Tomato sauce base, lots of mozzarella, pepperoni, giant Italian sausage, meatballs & bacon.
  • Steak Boomba Pizza $19.95 +
    Tomato sauce base or sweet country base, steak with grilled peppers & onions, with lots of mozzarella.
  • Alfredo Not My Brother Pizza $19.95 +
    Alfredo sauce base, diced grilled chicken, artichokes, roasted red peppers, olives, & asiago cheese.
  • SoccerSam’s Low Fat Pizza $19.95 +
    Multi-grain dough, no mozzarella, extra tomato sauce, diced onions & green peppers, fresh mushrooms.
  • Uncle Rico’s BBQ Chicken Pizza $19.95 +
    BBQ base sauce, diced grilled chicken, roasted red peppers, diced onions covered with cheddar cheese
  • Mama Toni’s Plate Pizza $19.95 +
    Mama Toni’s beef hot sauce base, hamburger, fries, diced onions, mac salad covered with cheddar cheese.
  • The Taco Pizza $19.95 +
    Salsa sauce base, cheddar cheese, diced onions, seasoned beef, lettuce, tomato and sour cream.
  • Breakfast Pizza $19.95 +
    (Meat or veggie).eggs, Cheddar and mozzarella. Veggie: onion, peppers & mushrooms. Meat: sausage, ham & bacon. (pre-order, pre-pay)
appetizers
  • Fries $4.95
    Fresh cut style, lightly salted
  • Pizza Fries $5.95
    Covered with pizza sauce & mozzarella
  • Loaded Fries $7.95
    With chili, bacon & melted cheddar
  • Onion Rings $5.95
    Thick cut onions - beer battered
  • Garlic Bread $5.95
    Giant loaf with melted mozzarella
  • Hot Soup $3.95
    Grandma carmella's italian recipes
  • Chili $4.95
    Our same recipe since 1978
  • Fried Mushrooms $4.95
    With a choice of one sauce
  • Chicken Fingers $6.95 +
    With blue cheese & fries, choice of wing sauce
  • Mozzarella Sticks $5.95 +
    With a side of tomato sauce
  • Sausage Slingers $10.95
    Chunks of Italian sausage, choice of wing sauce
  • Potato Skins $9.95
    With bacon & melted cheddar cheese
  • Pizza Skins $9.95
    With mozzarella, pepperoni & pizza sauce
  • Fried Calamari $11.95
    Flash fried calamari, side tomato sauce
  • Buffalo Calamari $12.95
    Choice of wing sauce with blue cheese
  • Sicilian Calamari $13.95
    Kalamata olives, peppers, asiago
fresh-salads
  • Macaroni Salad $3.95
    Made with Hellmann's mayonnaise
  • Side Salad $4.55
    With romaine mix, tomatoes, carrots, cucumbers, and onions
  • Tossed Salad $7.55
    With romaine mix, tomatoes, carrots, cucumbers, and onions
  • Tuna Topped Salad $9.95
    Our tossed salad covered with tuna fish with hellmann's mayo
  • Caesar Salad $9.95
    Tossed salad, mushrooms, croutons, bacon, asiago & caesar dressing
  • Antipasto Salad $9.95
    Tossed salad, ham, provolone, salami, pepperoni, pepperoncini & black olives
  • Greek Salad $9.95
    Our tossed salad with feta cheese, kalamata olives & greek dressing
  • Grilled Chicken Salad $10.55
    Our tossed salad with sliced grilled chicken and mozzarella cheese
  • Buffalo Chicken Salad $10.55
    Tossed salad, chicken fingers covered with mild wing sauce & cheddar
  • Cajun Chicken Salad $10.55
    Our tossed salad w/ sliced grilled cajun chicken breast & cheddar cheese
  • Calamari Salad $11.55
    Our tossed salad covered with fried calamari
  • Buffalo Calamari Salad $11.55
    Tossed salad covered with calamari, choice of wing sauce & blue cheese
  • Sicilian Calamari Salad $12.55
    Our tossed salad covered with fried calamari, asiago cheese, kalamata olives, peppers and balsamic italian dressing
salvadores-wings
  • Jumbo Fresh Wings & Boneless Wings $7.95 +
    Served with bleu cheese and choice of sauce*
  • Wing Mac Snack $9.95
    Wings with mac salad & bread
  • Sweet Country Breaded Wings $13.95
    Rochester style
cold-subs
  • Italian Sub $5.95 +
  • Assorted Sub $5.95 +
  • Roast Beef Sub $5.95 +
  • Baked Ham Sub $5.95 +
  • Genoa Sub $5.95 +
  • Salami Sub $5.95 +
  • Tuna Fish Sub $5.95 +
  • Ham Sub $5.95 +
  • Cappicola Sub $5.95 +
  • Turkey Sub $5.95 +
  • Breast Sub $5.95 +
  • Cheese Sub $5.95 +
  • Veggie Sub $5.95 +
hot-subs
  • Shaved Steak Sub $6.95 +
  • Meatball Sub $6.95 +
  • Italian Sausage Sub $6.95 +
  • Pizza Sub $6.95 +
  • BLT Sub $6.95 +
  • Eggplant Parm Sub $6.95 +
  • Chicken Parm Sub $6.95 +
  • Grilled Chicken Sub $6.95 +
  • Chicken Finger Sub $6.95 +
  • Buffalo Chicken Sub $6.95 +
  • Hamburger Sub $6.95 +
  • Big Bertha Fish Sub $6.95 +
pub-burgers
  • Burger $6.55
  • Cheeseburger $6.95
  • Italian Burger $6.95
  • Salvie Burger $6.95
  • BBQ Burger $6.95
  • Blue Cheeseburger $6.95
  • Swiss Burger $6.95
  • Mushroom Burger $6.95
  • Double Burger $7.95
  • Double Cheeseburger $8.55
  • Salvie Plates $12.95
  • Red Hot Burger $4.95
salvadores-chicken
  • Breaded Chicken Sandwich $8.95
    With fresh cut style fries and custom dressed
  • Grilled Chicken Sandwich $9.95
    With fresh cut style fries and custom dressed
  • Chicken Cordon Blue Sandwich $9.95
    Choice of chicken, swiss cheese & ham with fries
  • Chicken Fingers $6.95 +
    Choice of sauce, blue cheese & fresh cut style fries
italian-pasta-dinners
  • Baked Pasta $10.95
    With mozzarella, choice of pasta with tomato sauce
  • Pasta & Meatballs $11.95
    Choice of pasta with tomato sauce & 2 meatballs
  • Stuffed Shells $11.95
    5 ricotta filled shells, mozzarella & tomato sauce
  • Eggplant Parm $12.95
    Breaded with mozzarella, tomato sauce & pasta
  • Chicken Parm $13.95
    Breaded with mozzarella, tomato sauce & pasta
  • Grilled Chicken Parm $13.95
    Grilled with mozzarella, tomato sauce & pasta
  • Haddock Parm $14.95
    Fried haddock with mozzarella, tomato sauce & pasta
salvie-plates
  • Hot Dog $12.95
  • Hamburger $12.95
  • Cheeseburger $12.95
  • Italian Sausage $12.95
  • Chicken Fingers $12.95
  • Grilled Chicken $12.95
  • Shaved Steak $12.95
  • Fish Fry Plate $12.95
  • Grilled Veggie $12.95
fish-shrimp
  • Big Bertha’s Fish Sub $10.95
    Fried haddock on large sub bread custom dressed
  • Haddock Fish Fry $12.95
    Haddock, fries, coleslaw or mac salad, roll & tartar.
  • Haddock Parmesan $14.95
    With tomato sauce & melted mozzarella with side of pasta.
  • Shrimp Dinner $12.95
    Breaded shrimp, fresh-cut style fries & choice of two sauces
  • Salvatore Style Shrimp Dinner $13.95
    Covered with sweet country sauce. Side mac salad & fries.
  • Fried Calamari $11.95
    Flash fried breaded calamari served with side of tomato sauce.
  • Buffalo Calamari $12.95
    Fried breaded calamari with choice of wing sauce & blue cheese
  • Sicilian Calamari $13.95
    Kalamata olives, asiago cheese, peppers & balsamic italian
kids-menu
  • Kids Pasta $6.95
  • Kids Mac Cheese $6.95
  • Kids Chicken Fingers $6.95
  • Kids Pizza Fingers $6.95
  • Kids Sub Roll $6.95
fresh-desserts
  • Cookies $1.35
  • 5 Pack Cookies $6.00
  • Cannoli $2.95
    Ricotta filled
  • 5 Pack Cannoli $12.95
  • Italian Cheesecake $4.95
  • Carrot Cake $4.95
  • Peanut Butter Pie $4.95
cold-drinks
  • Soda $2.25 +
  • Bottled Water $2.25
  • Gatorade $2.35
  • Tea $2.35
  • Juice $2.20
  • AMP Energy $3.50
  • Kickstart Energy $2.50
  • Milk $2.20
  • Sobe Type Drinks $2.50

FAQ

SliceRestaurants in Newark Salvatore's Old Fashioned Pizzeria
Price: $$