Skip to main content

Tolleson's Pizzeria

419 N Main St, Newark, NY 14513

We're all about supporting local pizzerias - even those who are not Slice partners.
Give Tolleson's Pizzeria a call to order. We hear their food's delish.

Specialty Pizzas

Philly Steak Pizza

Shaved steak sweet and sour onions green peppers mozzarella cheese.


Buffalo Chicken Pizza

Fried chicken buffalo sauce and mozzarella cheese.


Five Cheese Pizza

American swiss mozzarella and parmesan.


Supreme Pizza

Pepperoni ham sausage, onion.


Veggie Lovers Pizza

Onions green peppers mushrooms.


Cheeseburger Pizza

A dill and ketchup based sauce American cheese. mozzarella cheese.


Ham & Swiss Pizza

Ham, swiss cheese and mozzarella cheese.


Taco Pizza

Taco sauce, taco meat onions tomatoes cheddar mozzarella.


Breakfast Pizzas

Cheese Pizza Slice


Pepperoni Pizza Slice


Specialty Pizza Slice


Mexican Dishes


Hand or soft, beef or chicken side salsa.


Taco Tots

Cheddar cheese taco meat lettuce and tomato. side salsa and sour cream.



Bacon and chicken buffalo chicken steak or taco.



Bean and cheese with meat hot sauce, cheddar lettuce tomato.


Pasta & Dinners

Tolleson's Plate


Fish Fry


Shrimp Dinner


SliceNYNewark14513 Tolleson's Pizzeria
Price: $$