Cosimo's

Cosimo's

1217 Route 300, Newburgh, NY 12550
845-567-1556

We're all about supporting local pizzerias - even those who are not Slice partners.
Give Cosimo's a call to order. We hear their food's delish.

Menu
pizza
Pizza

Pizza

Create your own pizza.

$2.50

appetizers
Appetizers

Arancini

Italian rice balls, prosciutto, manchego, peas, pomodoro.

$9.00


Fried Calamari

Seasoned calamari, spicy pomodoro sauce.

$14.00


Tomato Bruschetta

Vine ripened tomatoes, torn basil, grilled peasant bread, evoo, fiore di latte mozzarella.

$9.00


Caprese

Sliced housemade mozzarella, vine ripened tomatoes, torn basil, evoo, fire roasted peppers.

$13.00


Crispy Mozzarella

Prosciutto wrapped mozzarella, italian bread crumbs, tomato basil sauce

$10.00


Antipasto Misto

Calabrese soppressata, prosciutto, provolone, olives, artichoke hearts, grilled vegetables, housemade mozzarella, fire roasted peppers, parma ham, long hot peppers & herbed ricotta.

$16.00


Stuffed Portobello

Roasted portobello mushroom, caramelized shallots, spinach, roma tomatoes.

$12.00


Fiery Lobster Baguette

Maine lobster, charred scallion & parmigiano gratinato, spicy scampi sauce

$15.00


Waffle Potatoes With Gorgonzola

Rosemary garlic fries and creamy gorgonzola sauce.

$10.00


Casinos

Baby clams, jalapeno smoked bacon, bell pepper, compound butter, fresh bread crumbs, grilled lemon.

$13.00


Brick Oven Garlic Bread

Garlic & herb brushed foccacia.

$8.00


Hvcc Meatball

Hudson valley cattle company ground beef, herbed ricotta, slow roasted tomato sauce.

$12.00


Crispy Polenta

Calabrese soppressata, hudson valley baby kale, pan sauce, parmigiano.

$11.00

soups-salads
Soups & Salads

Pasta Fagioli Soup

Hearty tuscan bean soup with ditalini pasta and parmigiano.

$4.00


House Salad Soup

Mixed greens, red onions, julienned carrots, cucumber, honey balsamic vinaigrette.

$6.00


Caesar Salad Soup

Romaine lettuce and seasoned croutons tossed in our caesar dressing, topped with shaved parmesan.

$7.00


Romano Chicken Chop Chop Soup

Romaine, romano crusted chicken, chicpeas, egg, tomato, bacon, creamy parmigiano dressing.

$14.00


Grilled Chicken Paillard Soup

Flash grilled pesto basted chicken, topped with field greens, red onion, tomatoes, prosecco vinaigrette & shaved pecorino.

$14.00


Pizza Insalata

Wood fired pizza crust, crisp romaine, marinated tomatoes, shaved pecorino romano, balsamic vinaigrette.

$14.00


Harvest Salad

Hudson valley apples, dried cranberries, walnuts, feta, radicchio, romaine, black currant vinaigrette

$14.00


Honey Ginger Salad

Grilled chicken, napa cabbage, cilantro, julienned carrots, spring onion, greens, crispy wontons, flamed sugar peanuts, honey ginger dressing.

$14.00


Blackened Steak Soup

Bibb lettuce, crispy pancetta, cherry tomato, cajun filet tips, fried onion, creamy gorgonzola dressing.

$16.00


Mediterranean Salad

Bibb lettuce, roasted red peppers, calamata olives, tomatoes, mediterranean vinaigrette, feta cheese.

$14.00


Toscano Pear

Arugula, local pears, shaved pecorino toscano, prosecco vinaigrette.

$13.00


Kale & Beet

Roasted heirloom beets, baby kale, pistachio, goat cheese, champagne vinaigrette.

$13.00

brickoven-flatbreads
Brickoven Flatbreads

The Spicy New Yorker

Fiery plum tomato sauce, toasted garlic, fresh mozzarella cheese.

$12.00


Truffle Portobello

Portobello mushrooms, goat cheese, truffle oil, mozzarella, baby arugula, shaved parmigiano.

$14.00


Prosciutto & Fig

Port soaked fig jam, prosciutto di parma, gorgonzola & mozzarella cheese, baby arugula, balsamic glaze.

$14.00


Pomodorini

Mozzarella, basilico, evoo, diced roma tomatoes, parmigiano.

$13.00

sandwiches
Sandwiches

Pan Fried Tomato Fresca Sandwich

Breaded vine ripened tomato, prosciutto di parma, fresh mozzarella, house pesto, grilled baguette.

$14.00


Chicken & Broccoli Rabe Sandwich

Chicken cutlet, sauteed broccoli rabe, long, hot peppers, provolone, italian bun.

$13.00


Grilled Sausage & Broccoli Rabe Sandwich

Grilled spicy sausage, sautéed broccoli rabe, sharp provolone, brick oven bread.

$13.00


Grilled Chicken Sandwich

Vine ripened tomato, bibb lettuce, avocado, grilled scallion, dijonaise, grilled piadina bread.

$11.00


Turkey Artichoke Sandwich

Smoked turkey, artichoke pesto, grilled bermuda onion, toasted fontina cheese, grilled piadina bread.

$12.00


B.a.l.t. Sandwich

Smoked turkey, jalapeno smoked bacon, avocado, bibb lettuce, beefsteak tomato, mayo, brioche bun.

$10.00


Open Faced Meatball Sandwich

Sliced meatballs, tomato basil sauce, herbed ricotta cheese, grilled baguette.

$12.00


Grilled Eggplant Sandwich

Marinated eggplant, sun-dried tomatoes, arugula, goat cheese, grilled piadina bread.

$13.00


Cbo Burger Sandwich

Angus burger, jalapeño smoked bacon, wood fired bermuda onion, provolone, chef’s mayo, italian bun.

$14.00


Steak Sizzler Sandwich

Rosemary marinated ny strip, colorful bell peppers, gorgonzola spread, crispy cajun onions, grilled baguette.

$14.00


Arugula & Prosciutto Sandwich

Prosciutto, baby arugula, vine ripened tomato, fresh mozzarella, basil, brick oven bread.

$12.00


Mediterranean Tuna Sandwich

House made albacore tuna salad, olives, toasted organic 7 grain bread.

$10.00


Sriracha Chicken Wrap

Crispy chicken, sriracha sauce, avocado, chopped romaine, diced tomato, creamy parmigiano dressing, herb garlic wrap.

$9.00


Maialino Sandwich

House braised pork, long hot peppers, vine ripened tomato, cacciocavalo cheese, italian bun.

$12.00

pasta
Pasta

Al Pomodoro Pasta

Plum tomatoes, fresh basil, extra virgin olive oil and garlic.

$12.00


Boscaiola Pasta

Smoked ham, peas, caramelized shallots, wild mushrooms, parmigiano cream sauce

$12.00


Shrimp Saute

Calamata olives, sauteed shrimp, sun-dried tomatoes a touch of pesto & shaved parmigiano cheese.

$19.00


Sausage & Broccoli Rabe Pasta

Fennel sausage, broccoli rabe, toasted garlic, pecorino romano, chili flakes, evoo

$17.00


Sun-dried Tomatoes Alla Vodka Pasta

Sun-dried tomatoes, mushrooms, sautéed onions, vodka tomato cream sauce.

$16.00


Eggplant Siciliano Pasta

Brick oven roasted eggplant, pepperoncino flakes, plum tomato sauce, toasted garlic and fresh mozzarella .

$16.00

signature-pasta
Signature Pasta

Shrimp Cappellini Pasta

Pan-seared jumbo shrimp, toasted garlic, fiery cherry tomato broth.

$20.00


Grilled Chicken Penne Pasta

Roma tomatoes, homemade pesto, grilled chicken, fresh mozzarella, arugula, calamata olives.

$17.00


Spicy Chicken Fusilli Pasta

Grilled chicken, spicy scallion cream sauce, fontina cheese.

$16.00


Rigatoni Alla Buttera Pasta

Sweet sausage, peas, rosemary, tomato cream sauce.

$17.00


Sausage And Ricotta Fusilli Pasta

Roasted peppers, plum tomato sauce, sautéed onions, artisanal sausage, herbed ricotta.

$18.00


Pork Pappardelle Pasta

Slow braised pork ragu, pappardelle pasta, evoo, shaved ricotta salata.

$17.00

carne
Carne

Double Cut Pork Chop

Argrodolce peppers, skillet potatoes.

$27.00


Herb Baked Shrimp

Jumbo shrimp, garlic & herb crumbs, charred scallion wild rice, sauteed baby kale.

$27.00


Citrus Basil Salmon

Broccoli rabe, tuscan white beans, citrus basil emulsion.

$23.00


Hour Pork Cacciatore

Chianti braised pork, caramelized peppers & onions, portobello mushrooms, rich tomato sauce, creamy caciocavallo polenta.

$18.00


Simply Grilled Swordfish

Charred scallion wild rice, baby kale salad, house made battuto.

$25.00


Wood Fired Snapper

San marzano tomato glaze, kalamata olives, capers, creamy polenta, roasted brussels sprouts.

$25.00


Herb Roasted Chicken

Mashed potatoes, baby spinach, pan jus.

$17.00


Lobster Risotto

Maine lobster, caramelized scallions, roasted cherry tomatoes, chili oil, toasted garlic, baby spinach.

$28.00


Crispy Skin Chicken

Boneless half chicken, marsala portobello mushrooms, crispy polenta, baby spinach.

$20.00


Veal Milanese

Pan fried veal cutlet, blistered cherry tomatoes & shaved brussels sprouts, pesto whipped potato.

$22.00


Chicken Scarpariello

Murray’s chicken, fennel sausage, cherry peppers, fennel skillet potatoes.

$20.00

casareccia
Casareccia

Paccheri Pa-ker-ee Arrabiata

Oversized rigatoni, spicy san marzano tomato sauce, charred onion, pancetta, ricotta salata.

$17.00


Portobello Ravioli

Portobello mushroom & spinach ravioli, caramelized shallots, roasted cherry tomatoes, wild mushrooms, sherry brown butter.

$18.00


Cavolfiore

Wood roasted cauliflower, alp’s sausage, cherry tomatoes, ziti alla romana, swiss chard, white wine brodetto.

$18.00

italian-classics
Italian Classics

Pasta Della Nonna

Rigatoni, meatballs, tomato basil sauce, melted mozzarella.

$16.00


Ravioli Con Mozzarella

Oven baked cheese ravioli, tomato basil sauce, melted mozzarella.

$16.00


Seafood Fra Diavolo

Sauteed shrimp, calamari, clams, pappardelle pasta, fiery plum tomato sauce.

$21.00


White Clam Sauce

Clams, crisp garlic,white wine broth, fresh herbs, roma tomatoes, linguini pasta.

$19.00


Chicken Francaise

Hudson valley egg battered chicken breast, rich lemon butter sauce, spaghettini, parmigiano.

$18.00

sides
Sides

Tuscan Fries

$6.00


Crispy Polenta

$5.00


Brussels Sprouts

$5.00


Mashed Potatoes

$6.00


Skillet Potatoes With Caramelized Fennel

$6.00


Italian Croquettes

$6.00


Colorful Swiss Chard

$6.00


Spicy Italian Long Hots

$7.00


Polpette Chef’S Meatballs

$7.00


Charred Scallion Wild Rice

$6.00


Wood Roasted Cauliflower

$5.00


Creamy Caciocavallo Polenta

$6.00


Mediterranean Grilled Vegetables

$7.00


Baby Spinach With Toasted Garlic

$6.00


Broccoli Rabe With Toasted Garlic

$7.00

dolci
Dolci

Apple Pizzette

Amaretto soaked apples, brick oven pizza dough, jane’s cinnamon ice cream, a lot of caramel.

$9.00


Nutella Pots De Creme

Rich Nutella custard, house-made marshmallow “fluff”, cannoli chips.

$9.00


Warm Chocolate Lava Cake

Individual chocolate souffle, jane’s cappuccino crunch ice cream.

$8.00


Cannoli

Flaky shell filled with chocolate chip canolli cream.

$5.00


Tartufo

Vanilla & chocolate ice cream, dark chocolate coating, cherry & shaved almond center.

$8.00


Cheesecake

Ny style cheese cake, amarena cherries.

$8.00


Flourless Chocolate Cake

Rich dark chocolate cake, jane’s vanilla ice cream, fresh whipped cream.

$9.00


Pizzeppole Cake

Fried pizza dough balls, cinnamon sugar, caramel sauce.

$7.00


Jones Farm Carrot Cake

Walnuts, rich cream cheese frosting.

$9.00


Carrot Cake

Walnuts, rich cream cheese frosting.

$9.00


Limoncello Tartufo

Vanilla gelato, sugared lemon crust, limoncello liqueur center.

$8.00


Sorbet

Presented in natural shell, orange, lemon, pineapple, coconut, peach.

$6.00

wood-fired-pizza
Wood Fired Pizza

Create Your Own Pizza

Classic cheese or create your own pizza.

$11.00


Napoletana Pizza

San marzano tomato sauce, basilico, fiore di latte, mozzarella, evoo.

$12.00


Portobello Mixer Pizza

Grilled portobello mushrooms, sun-dried tomatoes and fontina cheese topped with roasted peppers.

$14.00


All’ Uovo Pizza

Slivered potato, grilled scallion, parma ham, pecorino & mozzarella cheeses, long hot peppers, hudson valley egg.

$15.00


Grilled Chicken Pizza

Caramelized onions, artichoke hearts, calamata olives, fontina & mozzarella cheese.

$14.00


Broccoli Pie

Broccoli florets, roasted garlic, mozzarella and herbed ricotta cheese.

$12.00


Spicy Fennel Sausage Pizza

Hot peppers, wood fired onions, tomato basil sauce, and fresh mozzarella cheese.

$14.00


Mozzarella Fresca Pizza

Plum tomato sauce, house-made mozzarella, fresh basil and sliced prosciutto.

$14.00


Spinach And Bacon Pizza

Herbed ricotta, mozzarella cheese, fresh tomatoes and spinach, topped with smoked bacon.

$13.00


Southwestern Pizza

Spicy chipotle glazed chicken, fresh tomatoes, scallions, mozzarella & cheddar cheeses, and roasted red onions.

$14.00


Formaggi Pizza

Mozzarella, provolone, fontina, parmigiano and gorgonzola cheese.

$13.00


Shrimp Scampi Pizza

Baby arugula, provolone, mozzarella, sun-dried tomatoes, scallions and roasted garlic, topped with shaved parmigiano cheese.

$16.00


Quattro Stagio Ni Pizza

Quarters of smoked ham, olives, artichoke hearts and mushrooms on a bed of mozzarella cheese and tomato basil sauce.

$13.00


La Grigliata Pizza

Roasted zucchini & squash, hudson valley kale, roma tomatoes, roasted garlicc, evoo.

$12.00


Nick’s Pie Pizza

Calabrese soppresatta, marinated sun-dried tomatoes, hudson valley baby kale, pecorino & fresh mozzarella.

$14.00


Meatball Pizza

Sliced meatballs, san marzano tomato sauce, herbed ricotta cheese, mozzarella.

$13.00


Grilled Eggplant Pizza

Marinated eggplant, fresh roma tomatoes, calamata olives, roasted garlic, mozzarella and goat cheese.

$14.00


Grilled Eggplant Pizza (Copy)

Calzone alla cosimoricotta, mozzarella, provolone and parmigiano cheese, served with our tomato basil sauce.

$14.00

SlicePizza Places in Newburgh, NY Cosimo's
Price: $$