Skip to main content
Benny's Pizzeria on the Square

Benny's Pizzeria on the Square

853 Castleton Ave, Staten Island, NY 10310
716-576-3854
New

Order Ahead We open at 11:00 AM

Full Hours
    Skip to first category
    deals-and-coupons

    Deals and Coupons

    DealFeatured

    Special 1

    Baked ziti, penne vodka, or penne broccoli with garlic & oil.

    $18.50

    Deal

    Special 3

    2 medium cheese pizzas, 10 garlic knots & one 2-liter soda.

    $28

    pizza

    Pizza

    1-Round Cheese Pizza

    Classic cheese or create your own.

    $8.00

    1-Round Cheese Pizza

    12-Meat Lover's Pizza

    Pepperoni, sausage, ham & meatballs.

    $22.00

    2-White Pizza

    Mozzarella & ricotta.

    $18.00

    13-Hawaiian Pizza

    Sauce, cheese, ham & pineapple.

    $20.00

    3-White Pizza with Broccoli

    Mozzarella & ricotta.

    $20.00

    14-Veggie Pizza

    Broccoli, spinach, mushrooms, onions, peppers, sauce & mozzarella cheese.

    $20.00

    3-White Pizza with Spinach

    Mozzarella & ricotta.

    $20.00

    15-Caesar Salad Pizza

    With grilled or fried chicken.

    $19.00

    4-Vodka Pizza

    Fresh mozzarella & basil.

    $17.00

    16-Personal Pizza

    $7.95

    5-Meatball, Onions & Ricotta Cheese Pizza

    $22.00

    17-Gluten Free Pizza

    Classic cheese or create your own pizza.

    $10.95

    6-Clams Pizza

    White or red.

    $21.00

    18-Round Chicken Parm Pizza

    $22.95

    7-1/2 Red & 1/2 White Pizza

    $17.00

    19-Chicken Vodka Pizza

    $22.95

    8-Chicken Francese Pizza

    $22.00

    20-Sicilian Square Pizza

    $25.00

    9-Buffalo Chicken Pizza

    $23.00

    20-Sicilian Vodka Pizza

    $31.00

    10-BBQ Chicken Pizza

    $23.00

    20-Sicilian White Pizza

    $31.00

    11-Margarita Pizza

    Fresh mozzarella, marinara & basil.

    $17.00

    20-Sicilian Buffalo Pizza

    $31.00

    gourmet-pizza

    Gourmet Pizza

    21-Buffalo Chicken Pizza

    $18.00

    25-Veggie Pizza

    $18.00

    22-Famous Chicken Caesar Pizza

    Grilled or fried.

    $18.00

    26-Philly Cheesesteak Pizza

    Sirloin steak, sauteed onions smothered with yellow American cheese.

    $18.00

    23-Chicken Parmigiana Pizza

    $18.00

    26-Firebird Pizza

    Grilled chicken, mozzarella cheese, roasted red peppers, jalapenos & pesto sauce.

    $18.00

    24-Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza

    $18.00

    gourmet-sicilian-pizza

    Gourmet Sicilian Pizza

    27- Belt Parkway Sicilian Pizza

    Thick crust Sicilian, fresh mozzarella cheese, marinara sauce, basil, oregano, pecorino romano cheese, and EVOO.

    $18.00

    30-Romano Sicilian Pizza

    Sausage, pepperoni, cheese, onion, potato, and meatballs (stuffed).

    $18.00

    28-Grandma Sicilian Pizza

    $18.00

    31-Thin Crust Sicilian Pizza

    With vodka sauce and topped with crispy chicken.

    $18.00

    29-Bruschetta Sicilian Pizza

    Fresh mozzarella, tomato & basil.

    $18.00

    appetizers

    Appetizers

    48-Rice Balls

    $5.95

    59-Beef Patty

    $4.00

    49-Rice Balls Parmigiana

    $6.50

    59-Beef Patty with Cheese

    $5.50

    50-Rice Ball sSpecial

    Tomato sauce, ricotta cheese & mozzarella.

    $7.50

    50-Rice Ball sSpecial

    60-Mozzarella Sticks

    $8.50

    51-Chicken Fingers

    $9.00

    61-Garlic Bread

    $4.50

    52-Chicken Wings

    $10.95

    61-Garlic Bread with Cheese

    $6.00

    53-Boneless Wings

    $9.95

    62-Chicken Parmigiana

    $8.50

    54-Fried Calamari

    $13.95

    63-Eggplant Parmigiana

    $8.50

    55-Buffalo Fried Calamari

    $14.95

    64-Meatball Parmigiana

    $8.50

    56-Fried Shrimp

    $13.50

    65-Jalapeno Peppers

    $7.50

    57-French Fries

    $5.50

    66-Bruschetta

    $10.50

    57-French Fries with Cheese

    $7.50

    67-Garlic Knots

    $6.50

    58-Onion Rings

    $7.50

    soups

    Soups

    150-Chicken Soup

    $6.50

    152-Menistroni Soup

    $6.50

    151-Lentil Soup

    $6.50

    salads

    Salads

    Choice of dressing: balsamic vianigrette, blue cheese, ranch, balsamic glaze, oil & vinegar, Italian dressing, ranch vinegar, raspberry & vinegar.

    72-Caesar Salad

    $7.59

    76-Buffalo Chicken Salad

    Tomato, black olives & onions.

    $13.95

    73-House Salad

    Peppers, onions, cucumbers, black olives & tomato.

    $7.95

    77-Greek Salad

    Lettuce, tomatoes, cucumbers, olives, onions, green peppers, feta cheese, oil vinegar & dressing.

    $9.95

    74-Caprese Salad

    Fresh tomatoes, basil, fresh mozzarella & roasted peppers.

    $13.00

    78-Spinach Salad

    Baby spinach, feta cheese, apple, walnuts, cranberries, and balsamic vianigrette.

    $8.50

    75-Apple Salad

    Iceberg lettuce, grapes grannt smith, walnuts, feta cheese, raspberry & vianigrette.

    $8.95

    side-orders

    Side Orders

    142-Grilled Chicken

    $8.50

    146-Side of Grilled Chicken

    $6.50

    143-Over Sauteed Spinach

    $8.50

    147-Broccoli Rabe with Sausage

    $11.50

    144-Sauted Broccoli Spinach

    $8.50

    147-Broccoli Rabe with Grilled Chicken

    $11.50

    145-Meatballs

    $8.50

    147-Broccoli Regular

    $8.50

    rolls-calzones

    Rolls & Calzones

    32-Chicken Roll

    $7.95

    40-Francese Roll

    $7.95

    33-Pepperoni Roll

    $6.95

    41-Crispy Chicken Roll

    $7.95

    34-Broccoli Roll

    $6.95

    42-Vodka Sauce Roll

    $7.95

    35-Meat Parmigiana Roll

    $6.95

    43-Cheese Calzone

    $7.95

    36-Eggplant Roll

    $6.95

    44-Ham Calzone

    $7.95

    37-Buffalo Chicken Roll

    $7.95

    45-Sausage Calzone

    $7.95

    38-Stromboli Roll

    $7.95

    46-Beatball Calzone

    $7.95

    39-Sauasge Peppers Roll

    $7.95

    47-Chicken Calzone

    $7.95

    heroes

    Heroes

    110-Roasted Beef Hero

    Fresh mozzarella, roasted peppers & balsamic glaze.

    $11.50

    120-Shrimp Parmigiana Hero with Tomato Sauce

    $11.95

    111-Home Hot Roastet Beef Hero

    With melted fresh mozzarella, fried onions & brown gravy on a toasted garlic hero.

    $11.50

    121-Shrimp Parmegiana Hero with Vodka Sauce

    $11.95

    111-Chicken Parmigiana Special Hero

    With ricotta, and vodka sauce in garlic bread.

    $11.50

    122-Meatball Parmigiana Hero with Tomato Sauce

    $11.95

    112-Chicken Francese Hero

    With fresh mozzarella.

    $11.50

    123-Meatball Parmigiana Hero with Vodka Sauce

    $9.95

    113-Chicken Marsala Hero

    $10.95

    124-Sausage, Peppers & Onions Hero

    $9.95

    114-Buffalo Chicken Hero

    With fresh mozzarella.

    $9.95

    125-Eggplant Parmigiana Hero

    $9.95

    115-Chicken Parmigiana Hero

    With tomato sauce.

    $11.95

    126-Peppers & Eggs Hero

    $9.00

    116-Chicken Parmegiana Hero with Vodka Sauce

    $11.00

    127-Potato & Eggs Hero

    $9.00

    117-Broccoli Rabe Hero with Grilled Chicken

    $10.95

    128-Philly Cheesesteak Hero

    Onions, peppers, mushrooms & American cheese.

    $11.95

    118-Broccoli Rabe Hero with Sausage

    $9.95

    129-Fried Eggplant Hero with Prosciutto

    Fresh mozzarella, roasted peppers & balsamic glaze.

    $11.95

    119-Fried Chicken Cutlet Hero

    Lettuce, tomato, onions & mayonnaise.

    $11.95

    burgers

    Burgers

    1/2 lb. burgers. All burgers are served with pickles, lettuce, tomatoes & onions. Choice of french fires or onion rings.

    68-Hamburger

    $10.50

    71-Benny's Burger

    Mushrooms, onions, bacon & cheese.

    $14.50

    69-Cheese Burger

    $11.00

    69-Cheese Burger

    72-Holy Cow Burger

    Yellow American cheese, sirloin steak, jalapeno & sauteed onions.

    $14.50

    70-Bacon Cheese Burger

    $12.00

    wraps

    Wraps

    99-Chicken Parmigiana Wrap

    Marinara sauce with mozzarella cheese.

    $10.95

    104-Vegetables Wrap

    Assorted sauteed vegetables with fresh mozzarella & glaze.

    $10.95

    100-Grilled Chicken Caesar Wrap

    Romaine lettuce & Caesar dressing.

    $10.95

    105-Sausage, Peppers & Onions Wrap

    $10.95

    101-Grilled Chicken Wrap

    Roasted peppers, fresh mozzarella & balsamic glaze.

    $10.95

    106-Meatball Parmigiana Wrap

    Marinara sauce & mozzarella.

    $10.95

    101-Fried Chicken Wrap

    Roasted peppers, fresh mozzarella & balsamic glaze.

    $10.95

    107-Philly Cheesesteak Wrap

    Peppers, onions, mushroom & American cheese.

    $10.95

    102-Chicken Francese Wrap

    With lemon & butter.

    $10.95

    108-Fried Eggplant Wrap

    Fresh mozzarella with roasted peppers & balsamic glaze.

    $10.95

    103-Chicken Fra Diavolo Wrap

    Spicy marinara sauce & mozzarella.

    $10.95

    109-Buffalo Cheesesteak Wrap

    Peppers, onions, mushrooms & American cheese.

    $10.95

    104-Buffalo Chicken Wrap

    With hot sauce, fresh mozzarella & blue cheese.

    $10.95

    pasta

    Pasta

    79-Penne

    $12.50

    85-Pasta with Marinara Sauce

    $9.00

    79-Linguine

    $12.50

    86-Pasta with Meat Sauce

    $11.95

    79-Ziti

    $12.50

    87-Pasta with Pesto Sauce

    $11.00

    79-Rigatoni

    $12.50

    88-Pasta with Vodka Sauce

    $10.50

    79-Fettuccine

    $12.50

    89-Pasta with Sweet Sausage

    $12.00

    79-Spaghetti

    $12.50

    90-Pasta with Bolognese Sauce

    $11.95

    79-Tortellini

    $12.50

    91-Baked Ziti

    $10.50

    79-Pasta with Alfredo Sauce

    $12.50

    92-Baked Ziti with Meatballs

    $12.95

    79-Pasta with Chicken

    $16.00

    93-Baked Ziti with Vodka Sauce

    $12.95

    80-Pasta with Butter Sauce

    $8.00

    94-Baked Ziti with Chicken Cutlet

    $14.00

    81-Pasta with Broccoli Rabe

    With sausage.

    $14.00

    95-Ravioli Marinara

    $13.95

    82-Pasta Chicken Broccoli

    $14.00

    96-Pasta with Vodka Sauce

    $13.95

    83-Pasta with Clams

    Red or white.

    $16.00

    97-Lasagna

    $14.00

    84-Pasta with Garlic Oil

    $9.00

    entrees

    Entrees

    With house salad or french fries or pasta.

    130-Chicken Marsala

    $16.00

    136-Sauasge, Peppers & Onions

    $14.95

    131-Chicken Parmigiana

    $16.00

    137-Eggplant Parmigiana

    $13.95

    132-Chicken Francese

    $16.00

    138-Eggplant Rollatini

    With stuffed ricotta and mozzarella cheese.

    $14.95

    133-Grilled Chicken

    Roasted peppers & fresh mozzarella.

    $15.50

    139-Benny's Seafood Combo

    $18.00

    134-Chicken Picara

    White wine, caper & lemon sauce.

    $14.00

    140-Shrimp Clam Mossel

    $17.00

    135-Meatball Parmigiana

    $14.95

    141-Calamari Marinara

    Over red or white sauce.

    $16.00

    desserts

    Desserts

    Cheesecake

    $5.50

    Cannoli

    $5.50

    Zeppole

    $5.50

    beverages

    Beverages

    Soda

    $2.95

    Snapple

    $2.50

    Iced Tea

    $3.95

    Stewarts

    $2.50

    Manhattan Special

    $3.00

    Gatorade

    $2.50

    Water

    $1.50

    Fountain Soda

    $2.75

    lunch-specials

    Lunch Specials

    Only available Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday

    Penne with Vodka Sauce Lunch Special

    $9.95

    Sauce, Onions & Peppers Hero Lunch Special

    With french fries.

    $9.95

    Linguine with Broccoli, Garlic & Oil Lunch Special

    $9.95

    Chicken Wrap Lunch Special

    Grilled or fried. Fresh mozzarella & roasted peppers with french fries.

    $9.95

    Chicken Parmigiana Hero Lunch Special

    With french fries.

    $9.95

    Vegetable Wrap Lunch Special

    With french fries. Sauted with mozzarella cheese.

    $9.95

    Potatoes & Egg Hero Lunch Special

    With french fries.

    $9.95

    Any Pasta with Marinara Sauce Lunch Special

    With soda.

    $9.95

    Chicken Fingers Lunch Special

    With french fries.

    $9.95

    Fettuccine Alfredo Lunch Special

    With soda.

    $9.95

    Meatballs Parmigiana Hero Lunch Special

    With french fries.

    $9.95

    Personal Pizza with 1 Topping & Can of Soda Lunch Special

    With soda.

    $9.95

    Eggplant Parmigiana Hero Lunch Special

    With french fries.

    $9.95

    Chicken Caesar Salad Lunch Special

    Grilled or crispy.

    $9.95

    Baked Ziti Lunch Special

    With soda.

    $9.95

    Cheese Burger Deluxe Lunch Special

    Lettuce, tomato & onions with french fries.

    $9.95

    Rice Balls Lunch Special

    With soda.

    $9.95

    2 Pizza Slices with Can of Soda Lunch Special

    $7.50

    Grilled Chicken Wrap Lunch Special

    Peppers & onions with french fries.

    $9.95

    2 Square Pizza Slices with Can of Soda Lunch Special

    $7.50

    Eggplant Rollatini Lunch Special

    Mozzarella & ricotta. With soda.

    $9.95

    catering-menu

    Catering Menu

    Please order 2-3 day before.

    Shrimp Francese Catering

    $70.00

    Eggplant Parmigiana Catering

    $50.00

    Buffalo Wings Catering

    $60.00

    Chicken Parmigiana Catering

    $60.00

    Wraps Catering

    Wraps come with fries.

    $70.00

    Baked Ziti Catering

    $45.00

    French Fries Catering

    $30.00

    Lasagna Catering

    $50.00

    Mini Rice Balls Catering

    $45.00

    Meatballs Catering

    $65.00

    Mozzarella Sticks Catering

    $45.00

    Chicken Picatta Catering

    $70.00

    Garlic Knots Catering

    $45.00

    Eggplant Rollatini Catering

    $65.00

    Chicken Fingers Catering

    $45.00

    Shrimp Clam Mussels Catering

    $70.00

    Onion Rings Catering

    $45.00

    Fried Calamari Catering

    $45.00

    Caesar Salad Catering

    Comes with bread.

    $35.00

    Calamari Marinara Catering

    $60.00

    House Salad Catering

    Comes with bread.

    $35.00

    Baked Glenn Catering

    $55.00

    Apple Salad Catering

    Comes with bread.

    $35.00

    Pesto Pasta Catering

    $60.00

    Buffalo Salad Catering

    Comes with bread.

    $35.00

    Chicken Francese Catering

    $50.00

    Spinach Salad Catering

    Comes with bread.

    $35.00

    Alfredo Pasta Catering

    $50.00

    Antipasto Salad Catering

    Comes with bread.

    $35.00

    Vodka Pasta Catering

    $60.00

    Cold Heroes Catering

    $60.00

    Marinara Pasta Catering

    $60.00

    Chicken Marsala Catering

    $45.00

    Broccoli Rabe Catering

    $60.00

    Manicotti Catering

    $50.00

    Zeppoles Catering

    $30.00

    Sausage, Peppers & Onion Catering

    $55.00

    Hot Heros Catering

    $40.00

    Sausage & Broccoli Rabe Catering

    $60.00

    Benny's Pizzeria on the Square - 853 Castleton Ave, Staten Island, NY 10310 - Menu, Hours, & Phone Number - Order Delivery or Pickup - Slice

    SliceNYStaten Island10310 Benny's Pizzeria on the Square
    Price: $$