hero

Bexley Pizza Plus

2651 E Main St, Columbus, OH 43209

Open NowFull HoursAre you the owner?

We're all about supporting local pizzerias - even those who are not Slice partners.
Give Bexley Pizza Plus a call to order. We hear their food's delish.

Menu
create-your-own-pizza
  • Base Cheese Pizza $4.90 +
    Our special recipe red or our garlic white sauce with a blend of mozzarella and provolone cheese prepared on the hand-rolled, medium-thick crust.
  • One Topping Pizza $5.40 +
  • Two Toppings Pizza $6.40 +
  • Three Toppings Pizza $7.40 +
  • Four Toppings Pizza $8.40 +
  • Five Toppings Pizza $9.40 +
  • Six Toppings Pizza $10.40 +
specialty-white-pizza
Garlic white sauce with a 100% real cheese blend of provolone & mozzarella.
  • White Pizza $5.40 +
    Our garlic white sauce with provolone & mozzarella.
  • Chicken Broccoli Pizza $8.40 +
    Chicken breast, broccoli & asiago cheese.
  • Steak Portabella $9.40 +
    Shaved prime steak, portabella mushrooms, extra cheese & fresh basil.
  • Philly Steak Pizza $9.40 +
    Shaved Philly steak, mushrooms, green peppers & onions.
  • Chicken Florentine Pizza $10.40 +
    Chicken breast, spinach, fresh mushrooms, shaved parmesan & fresh basil.
  • Veggie Blanco Pizza $10.40 +
    Artichoke hearts, green peppers, fresh white mushrooms, black olives, & Roma tomatoes.
  • CO2 Pizza $9.40 +
    Chunky sausage, onions, caramelized onions & fresh basil.
specialty-red-pizza
Our special recipe red sauce with a 100% real cheese blend of provolone & mozzarella.
  • Maximum Pep Pizza $6.40 +
    A heavy combo of pepperoni & mini pepperoni.
  • Six Cheese Pizza $7.40 +
    Provolone, mozzarella, Swiss, Colby, shaved parmesan & Romano.
  • Margherita Pizza $7.40 +
    Roma tomatoes, fresh garlic & fresh basil.
  • All American Pizza $7.40 +
    Ground beef, bacon and your choice of Colby or Swiss.
  • Hawaiian Pizza $7.40 +
    Colby, Canadian bacon & pineapple.
  • Greek Pizza $8.40 +
    Artichoke hearts, black olives, sun-dried tomatoes & feta.
  • Lorraine Pizza $8.40 +
    Spinach, bacon, onions & Swiss.
  • Mega Meat Pizza $8.40 +
    Mini pepperoni, ground beef, chunky sausage & bacon.
  • Three Mushroom Pizza $8.40 +
    Blanched & fresh white mushrooms & portabella mushrooms with your choice of feta or extra cheese
  • Ultimate Pizza $8.40 +
    Blanched & fresh white mushrooms with pepperoni & mini pepperoni.
  • Redeye Pizza $9.40 +
    Pepperoni, roasted red peppers, red onions, hot peppers, mini pepperoni
  • Pizzazz $9.40 +
    Pepperoni, chunky sausage, portabella mushrooms, green peppers & mini pepperoni
  • Chicken Cacciatore Pizza $9.40 +
    Chicken breast, green peppers, onions, fresh garlic & Roma tomatoes.
  • Farmer's Market Pizza $9.40 +
    Spinach, broccoli, fresh white mushrooms, Roma tomatoes & feta
  • Primavera Plus Pizza $9.40 +
    Artichoke hearts, spinach, Roma tomatoes, fresh garlic & fresh basil.
  • Veggie Pizza $9.40 +
    Mushrooms, green peppers, onions, Roma tomatoes, extra cheese.
  • Cap Pizza $9.40 +
    Mushrooms, green peppers, onions, Roma tomatoes, extra cheese.
  • Chicken Carbonara Pizza $10.30 +
    Carbonara sauce, chicken, applewood smoked bacon, capicola, roasted red peppers, shaved parmesan & fresh basil.
  • Supreme Pizza $10.30 +
    Black olives, onions, Mexican beef or Mexican chicken, Roma.
  • Mexican Pizza $10.30 +
    Black olives, onions, Mexican beef or Mexican chicken, Roma tomatoes, jalapeno peppers & Colby.
salads
  • Caesar Salad $6.40
    Romaine lettuce, Roma tomatoes & asiago cheese.
  • Greek Salad $6.40
    Romaine lettuce, feta, green olives & Roma tomatoes.
  • Chef Salad $6.40
    Iceberg lettuce, provolone, mozzarella, pepperoni, black olives, pepperoncinis & roma tomatoes.
  • Deluxe Chef Salad $8.60
    Iceberg lettuce, Colby, provolone, mozzarella, bacon, chicken, black olives, Roma tomatoes & pepperoncinis.
  • Side Salad $3.65
    Iceberg lettuce, Roma tomatoes & pepperoncinis
  • Party Salad $22.75
    Choose from Chef, Greek or Caesar.
subs
  • Italian Sub $3.30 +
    Ham, pepperoni, salami & provolone with lettuce, tomato, hot peppers & Italian dressing.
  • Super Italian Sub $8.15
    Our Italian sub with double meat & cheese.
  • Veggie Sub $6.55
    Mushrooms, green peppers, onions & provolone with lettuce, tomato, hot peppers & Italian dressing.
  • Meatball Sub $6.55
    Italian meatballs, Our special recipe sauce, provolone & spices.
  • Ham & Cheese Sub $6.55
    Ham & your choice of provolone, Colby or Swiss with lettuce, tomato & mayonnaise.
  • Turkey & Cheese Sub $6.55
    Turkey breast & your choice of provolone, Colby or Swiss with lettuce, tomato & mayonnaise.
  • Chicken Sub $7.75
    Two grilled chicken breast with provolone, lettuce, tomato & mayonnaise.
  • Chicken Parmesan Sub $7.75
    Two grilled chicken breast, Our special recipe red sauce, provolone & spices.
  • Club Sub $7.75
    Turkey breast, ham, salami, pepperoni, bacon & provolone with lettuce, tomato & ranch dressing.
  • Steak & Cheese Sub $8.75
    Shaved Philly steak & your choice of provolone, Colby or Swiss with lettuce, tomato & mayonnaise.
  • Original Pizza Sub $7.20
    Our special recipe red sauce with provolone, mozzarella, pepperoni & spices. Served open-face.
  • New Spicy Italian Sub $7.75
    Our Italian sub bun covered with fresh lettuce, tomato, hot peppers & Italian dressing.
  • Garlic Bread with Cheese Sub $3.95
    Our Italian sub bun covered with a fresh garlic spread, provolone, mozzarella & spices. Served open-face.
desserts-chips
  • Cheesecake $4.85
    Plain or Oreo.
  • Cookies $1.10
    Fresh baked chocolate-chocolate chunk cookies with macadamia nuts.
  • Brownies $2.20
  • Chips $0.50
beverages
  • Soda $1.00 +
    Pepsi, Diet Pepsi, Sierra Mist, Diet Sierra Mist, Dr. Pepper, Diet Dr. Pepper, Mug Root Beer, Mountain Dew.
  • Water $1.50
  • Kid's Cup $0.95
  • Kid's Milk $0.95

FAQ

SliceRestaurants in Columbus Bexley Pizza Plus
Price: $$