Skip to main content
Benny's Pizza

Benny's Pizza

968 Columbus Ave, Marysville, OH 43040
937-644-0881

We're all about supporting local pizzerias - even those who are not Slice partners.
Give Benny's Pizza a call to order. We hear their food's delish.

Nearby Pizzerias on Slice
logo
Jet's Pizza
26 Troy Rd, Delaware, OH
Open Now$1 Delivery
logo
Romeo's Pizza
1832 Columbus Pike, Delaware, OH
New
Open NowPickup Only
logo
Jet's Pizza
5691 Woerner Temple Rd, Dublin, OH
Open Now$3.99 Delivery
logo
Luna Pizza Kitchen
5380 Tuttle Crossing Blvd, Dublin, OH
Open Now$4.99 Delivery
logo
La Pizza Italian Kitchen
5043 Tuttle Crossing Blvd, Dublin, OH
Open NowPickup Only
logo
Jet's Pizza
3864 Hard Rd, Dublin, OH
Open Now$3.99 Delivery
logo
Zuko's Pizza
4333 Cosgray Rd, Hilliard, OH
Open NowPickup Only
logo
Black Dog Pizzeria
5923 Karric Square Dr, Dublin, OH
New
Open NowPickup Only
logo
Jet's Pizza
3858 Main St, Hilliard, OH
Open Now$3.99 Delivery
logo
Luigi's Pizza
5370 Cemetery Rd, Hilliard, OH
Open NowPickup Only
logo
Jet's Pizza
6489 Pullman Dr, Lewis Center, OH
New
Open Now$3.99 Delivery
logo
Cottage Inn Pizza
4674 Cemetery Rd, Hilliard, OH
Open Now$6.90 Delivery
logo
Borgata Pizza Cafe
2285 W Dublin Granville Rd 113, Worthington, OH
Open Now$6.90 Delivery
logo
Papa Giorgios
5216 Bethel Center Mall, Columbus, OH
Open Now$4.65 Delivery
logo
Jet's Pizza
4740 Reed Rd, Upper Arlington, OH
Open Now$3.99 Delivery
logo
Romeo's Pizza
8929 S Old State Rd, Lewis Center, OH
Open Now$4.49 Delivery
logo
W.G. Grinders Catering - Upper Arlington
2820 Fishinger Rd, Columbus, OH
Open Now$4.95 Delivery
logo
Buca Di Beppo
60 E Wilson Bridge Rd, Worthington, OH
New
Open NowPickup Only
logo
Jet's Pizza
8627 Sancus Blvd, Columbus, OH
Open Now$3.99 Delivery
logo
Cousin Vinny's Pizza
4658 Kenny Rd, Columbus, OH
Open NowPickup Only
logo
Dough Boyz Pizza
338 Hubbard Rd, Galloway, OH
Open NowPickup Only
logo
Jet's Pizza
660 High St, Worthington, OH
Open Now$3.99 Delivery
logo
Brio Italian Grille
1500 Polaris Pkwy, Columbus, OH
New
Open Now$4.99 Delivery
logo
Big Tony's Pizza
1097 Worthington Woods Blvd, Columbus, OH
Open Now$4.99 Delivery
logo
Moretti's Of Arlington
2124 Tremont Center, Upper Arlington, OH
Open NowPickup Only
View More Pizzerias on Slice
Menu
bennys-famous-signature-pizza
Benny's Famous Signature Pizza

Basic Cheese Pizza

Classic cheese or create your own pizza.

$6.65

gluten-free-crust-pizza
Gluten Free Crust Pizza

Basic Cheese Gluten Free Pizza

Classic cheese or create your own gluten-free pizza.

$11.70

specialty-pizza
Specialty Pizza

5 Meat Pizza

Spicy smoked sausage, pepperoni, meatballs, capicola ham, Italian sausage and provolone cheese.

$11.25


All The Way Pizza

Pepperoni, Italian sausage, mushroom, onion, green pepper, banana pepper and provolone cheese.

$11.25


Smoked BBQ Chicken Pizza

Smoked BBQ Chicken Robin’s BBQ sauce, smoked chicken, provolone & cheddar cheese, bacon and red onion.

$11.25


Greek Pizza

Garlic olive oil, provolone & feta cheese, spinach, black olives, tomato and red onion.

$11.25


Southwest Smoked Pizza

This pizza starts with a spicy tequila BBQ sauce and is topped with cheddar & provolone cheese, spicy smoked sausage, smoked beef brisket, red pepper, green pepper, red onion and banana pepper.

$11.25


Beef & Lamb Pizza

Our famous pizza crust topped with your choice of chicken or beef & lamb, house-made cucumber sauce, provolone cheese, feta cheese, spinach, tomato and red onion.

$11.25


Chicken Gyro Pizza

Our famous pizza crust topped with your choice of chicken or beef & lamb, house-made cucumber sauce, provolone cheese, feta cheese, spinach, tomato and red onion.

$11.25


Chicken Ranchero Pizza

Oven roasted chicken breast, bacon, creamy ranch dressing, red onion and tomato.

$11.25


Cheeseburger Pizza

Our famous pizza crust topped with black Angus hamburger, ketchup, mayonnaise, cheddar & provolone cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion, and pickle. Crushed potato chips may be added to this pizza for no extra charge!

$11.25


Chicken Portabella Pizza

Our famous pizza crust topped with a garlic olive oil base, oven roasted chicken, fresh portabella mushrooms, provolone cheese, spinach, red pepper, and red onion. Served with garlic peppercorn mayonnaise on the side.

$11.25


Veggie Pizza

Mushroom, onion, green pepper, banana pepper, tomato and provolone cheese.

$11.25


Hawaiian Pizza

Ham, pineapple, green pepper, onion and provolone cheese.

$11.25


BLT Pizza

Loads of bacon, provolone & cheddar cheese, lettuce, tomato and mayonnaise.

$11.25


Beef Taco Pizza

Taco beef, cheddar & provolone cheese, onion, lettuce, tomato and black olives.

$11.25


Garbage Pizza

Pepperoni, Italian sausage, spicy smoked sausage, onion, mushroom, green pepper, ham, tomato, black olives, green olives, bacon, pineapple, banana pepper, jalapeño pepper and provolone cheese. Anchovies by request only.

$19.95

appetizers
Appetizers

Loaded Fries

Beer battered fries loaded with cheddar & provolone cheese, bacon, and red onion. Served with ranch or BBQ sauce on the side.

$7.99


Garlic Bread with Cheese

Delicious garlic bread with cheese served with a side of hot marinara sauce.

$3.99


Crab Smothered Mushrooms

Fresh jumbo mushroom caps smothered with our creamy crabmeat recipe. Topped with provolone & parmesan cheese and baked to perfection.

$10.49


Chicken Tenders

Five chicken tenders served with BBQ sauce or your choice of dressing.

$7.99


Braided Pretzel Twists

Two warm, soft baked braided pretzel twists served with beer cheese and your choice of cream cheese or mustard.

$6.49


Bistro Garlic Bread

Benny’s French bread topped with spinach dip, feta, provolone & parmesan cheese with marinara on the side for dipping.

$5.29


Smoked Chicken

Your choice of smoked chicken or brisket piled high on tortilla chips with cheddar & provolone cheese, green pepper, red onion, lettuce, jalapeño, tomato and chives. Served with salsa, queso sauce and sour cream on the side.

$10.99


Brisket Nachos

Your choice of smoked chicken or brisket piled high on tortilla chips with cheddar & provolone cheese, green pepper, red onion, lettuce, jalapeño, tomato and chives. Served with salsa, queso sauce and sour cream on the side.

$10.99


Benny’s Boneless Wings

Your choice of smoked chicken or brisket piled high on tortilla chips with cheddar & provolone cheese, green pepper, red onion, lettuce, jalapeño, tomato and chives. Served with salsa, queso sauce and sour cream on the side.

$6.99


Benny’s Pizza Skins

A personal pizza crust topped with potatoes, cheddar & provolone cheese, bacon and red onion. Garnished with sour cream & chives.

$10.79


Amazing Reuben Dip

Another home run by Benny’s Pizza... this creamy dip is made with deli fresh corned beef, cream cheese, sauerkraut and Swiss cheese. Served with crunchy rye bread, tortilla chips and thousand island dressing on the side. We knocked it out of the park with this one.

$10.29


Breaded Mushrooms

Deep fried breaded mushrooms served with peppercorn horseradish sauce and ranch on the side.

$7.99


Baked Spinach Dip

Our house-made creamy baked spinach dip topped with provolone, feta & parmesan cheese. Served with tortilla chips, pita bread wedges and crackers.

$9.99


Combo Platter

Great for sharing! A sampling of BBQ ribs, Buffalo wings and traditional potato skins. Served with ranch dressing and sour cream on the side.

$11.49


Traditional Potato Skins

Six traditional potato skins topped with cheddar & provolone cheese and hickory smoked bacon. Served with sour cream on the side.

$9.29

salads
Salads

Honey Mustard Chicken Salad

Tender smoked chicken breast tossed in honey mustard sauce on a bed of iceberg and romaine lettuce with bacon, cheddar & provolone cheese, tomato, red onion, chives, pita bread wedges and your choice of dressing.

$10.29


BBQ Chicken Cobb Salad

Iceberg and romaine lettuce, smoked bbq chicken, cheddar & provolone cheese, bacon, diced egg, tomato, red onion, roasted corn and your choice of dressing.

$9.99


Chef Salad

Iceberg and romaine lettuce topped with Swiss, cheddar & provolone cheese, turkey, ham, onion, green pepper, tomato, egg wedges, croutons and your choice of dressing.

$7.69


Beef Taco Salad

Iceberg and romaine lettuce topped with provolone & cheddar cheese, seasoned ground beef or smoked chicken, onion, tomato, black olives, sour cream and house-made nacho chips for dipping. Served with salsa on the side.

$9.99


Chicken Taco Salad

Iceberg and romaine lettuce topped with provolone & cheddar cheese, seasoned ground beef or smoked chicken, onion, tomato, black olives, sour cream and house-made nacho chips for dipping. Served with salsa on the side.

$9.99


Greek Salad

Spinach, feta cheese, black olives, tomato, cucumber, red onion and egg wedges. Served with red wine vinaigrette and house-made cucumber dressing on the side.

$5.29


Antipasto Salad

Iceberg and romaine lettuce topped with salami, ham, capicola ham, provolone cheese, fresh mushrooms, black olives, tomato, red onion and your choice of dressing.

$7.69


Southwest Chicken Cobb Salad

Mixed greens topped with provolone cheese, blackened chicken, tomato, bacon, roasted corn, diced egg, red onion, red pepper, and croutons.

$9.99

sides
Sides

Southwest 7 Layer Salad

Mixed greens, cheddar & provolone cheese, nacho chips, bacon, corn, tomato, red onion, cucumber and green pepper with cilantro ranch dressing.

$2.49


Classic 7 Layer Salad

Mixed greens, peas, bacon, tomato, cheddar & provolone cheese, cucumber, green pepper and red onion tossed with classic ranch dressing.

$2.49


Buffalo Chicken Macaroni & Cheese

$4.49


House-Made Coleslaw

$2.49


House-Made Macaroni Salad

$2.49


Naples Pasta Salad

Naples Pasta Salad 2.49 Corkscrew pasta, old-world style pepperoni, salami, capicola ham, red & green pepper, provolone cheese and red onion.

$2.49


Beer Battered Fries

Enough to share!

$3.99

bennys-wings
Benny's Wings
Signature hickory smoked.

Wings

$6.99

strombolis
Strombolis

Traditional Stromboli

Your favorite pizza topping rolled into our famous dough with provolone cheese. Served with a side of pizza sauce.

$10.29

sandwiches
Sandwiches

Texas Tacos

Two soft pitas stuffed with your choice of smoked chicken or brisket, cheddar & provolone cheese, lettuce and house-made pico de gallo. Served with cilantro ranch and nacho chips on the side.

$10.79


Gyro

Pita bread stuffed with beef and lamb, lettuce, tomato, red onion, feta cheese and house-made cucumber sauce. Served with chips on the side.

$8.29


Belgian Waffle Grilled Cheese Sandwich

Two grilled Belgian sugar pearl waffles as buns with applewood ham, capicola, hickory smoked bacon, cheddar & provolone cheese and a side of mayonnaise or sweet chili mayonnaise. Served with a side of chips.

$10.49


Blackened Perch Sandwich

European perch dusted in Cajun corn meal and topped with provolone cheese, lettuce, tomato and red onion. Served with tartar sauce and chips on the side. If you loved our Walleye then this sandwich is for you!

$10.29


Pork Loin Sandwich

Tender pork loin sautéed with portabella mushrooms, onions, and au jus loaded onto a toasted kaiser bun with melted provolone cheese. It’s then topped with lettuce & tomato and served with a side of peppercorn mayonnaise and chips.

$10.49


Hickory Smoked Brisket Sandwich

Your choice of our hickory smoked brisket or chicken smothered in your choice of Robin’s BBQ, zesty chipotle BBQ, or au jus with cheddar cheese, lettuce and red onion. Served with a side of chips.

$10.49


Chicken Sandwich

Your choice of our hickory smoked brisket or chicken smothered in your choice of Robin’s BBQ, zesty chipotle BBQ, or au jus with cheddar cheese, lettuce and red onion. Served with a side of chips.

$10.49


Buffalo Wrap

Hickory smoked chicken smothered in Buffalo or BBQ sauce and wrapped in a flour tortilla with cheddar & provolone cheese, tomato and lettuce. Served with chips and a side of ranch dressing.

$9.99


BBQ Chicken Wrap

Hickory smoked chicken smothered in Buffalo or BBQ sauce and wrapped in a flour tortilla with cheddar & provolone cheese, tomato and lettuce. Served with chips and a side of ranch dressing.

$9.99


Southwest Club Wrap

Chicken breast strips, ham and bacon wrapped in a warm flour tortilla with cheddar & provolone cheese, lettuce, tomato and our famous Tucson mayonnaise. Served with a side of chips.

$9.99


Club Sandwich

Turkey, bacon, ham, Swiss cheese, lettuce, tomato and mayonnaise on your choice of sourdough or wheat bread. Served with a side of chips.

$8.99

subs
Subs

Reuben Sub

Tender corned beef, Swiss cheese and sauerkraut loaded onto a sub bun and baked to perfection! Thousand island dressing served on the side. Available on toasted rye upon request.

$8.39


Meatball Sub

Italian meatballs and marinara sauce with melted provolone cheese.

$8.39


Smoked Applewood Ham & Cheese Sub

Tender applewood smoked ham stacked with melted provolone cheese, lettuce, and tomato. Mayonnaise served on the side.

$7.79


Chicken Salad Sub

Our delicious house-made chicken salad with melted provolone cheese, lettuce, and tomato.

$8.29


Italian Sub

Loaded with pepperoni, applewood smoked ham, salami, provolone cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion, banana pepper and Italian dressing.

$7.89


Pizza Sub

Filled with Benny’s famous pizza sauce, provolone cheese and one of your favorite pizza toppings.

$6.99


Veggie Sub

Filled with mushrooms, black olives, provolone cheese, green pepper, lettuce, tomato, onion, banana pepper and Italian dressing.

$6.99


Turkey Sub

Stuffed with hardwood smoked turkey, provolone cheese, lettuce, tomato, red onion and mayonnaise on the side.

$8.39

quesadillas
Quesadillas

Chicken Quesadilla

A crispy baked flour tortilla stuffed with chicken breast, provolone & cheddar cheese, onion and green pepper. Garnished with shredded lettuce, black olives, sour cream and salsa on the side.

$9.29


Cheese Quesadilla

A crispy baked flour tortilla stuffed with cheddar and provolone cheese. Garnished with shredded lettuce, black olives, sour cream and salsa on the side.

$7.99


BBQ Brisket Quesadilla

Our amazing house-smoked brisket served with Robin’s BBQ sauce, cheddar & provolone cheese, hickory smoked bacon, tomato, and red onion stuffed in a crispy flour tortilla. Served with sour cream and cilantro ranch on the side.

$10.29

bennys-signature-dishes
Benny's Signature Dishes

Chicken Parmesan Dinner

A breaded chicken breast covered with marinara and provolone cheese. Served with your choice of linguini alfredo or linguini marinara and a side of Texas toast.

$12.49


Italian Foldover

Our delicious pizza crust stuffed with ham, salami, pepperoni and provolone cheese. Once baked to a golden brown, we open it up and add lettuce, tomato, banana pepper, red onion and Italian dressing. Served with pizza sauce on the side.

$10.49


Fire-Braised Pork Loin Dinner

Our sliced, fire-braised pork loin covered in caramelized onions and your choice of au jus or BBQ sauce. Served with a choice of side dish, a slice of garlic Texas toast and peppercorn horseradish on the side.

$12.99


House-Made Lasagna

A generous portion of our house-made lasagna (made with our incredible Italian sausage!) served with a house salad and Texas garlic toast.

$12.99


Robin’s BBQ Ribs - Ribs Only

These perfectly seasoned, hickory smoked ribs are basted with your choice of Robin’s own secret recipe BBQ sauce or Chipotle BBQ sauce. Rib dinners are served with a choice of side, coleslaw and a slice of Texas toast.

$13.99


Robin’s BBQ Ribs - Ribs Dinner

These perfectly seasoned, hickory smoked ribs are basted with your choice of Robin’s own secret recipe BBQ sauce or Chipotle BBQ sauce. Rib dinners are served with a choice of side, coleslaw and a slice of Texas toast.

$16.49


Rib Appi-Teaser

$7.99


Cajun Perch Dinner

European Perch dusted in Cajun cornmeal and topped with sautéed mushrooms, onion, red pepper and green pepper. Served with choice of one side and a slice of Texas toast.

$12.99

desserts
Desserts

Buckeye Pie

This delicious pie features dark chocolate and peanut butter mousse topped with peanut butter cups!

$5.99


Belgian Sugar Pearl Waffle & S’mores Sundae

Pearl Belgian waffle topped with s’mores ravioli, vanilla ice cream, whipped cream, chocolate sauce and caramel sauce.

$5.99

SliceOHMarysville43040 Benny's Pizza
Price: $$