Skip to main content

Malatesta's Italian American Pizza

3525 West Chester Pike, Newtown Square, PA 19073
610-557-1100
(5)

Order Ahead We open Tue at 3:00 PM

Full Hours
    Skip to first category
    specialty-grandma-pies

    Specialty Grandma Pies

    Clam Pie White Pizza

    Our original white pie topped with wild-caught chopped ocean clams.

    $36.00

    Clam Pie White Pizza
    Best seller

    Long Hot Pie

    Our original red pie topped with Italian long hots.

    $30.00

    Best seller

    Original White Pie

    Our original white pie is made with a blend of spices, garlic & olive oil, mozzarella cheese, fresh ricotta cheese, finished with pecorino Romano cheese.

    $25.75

    Clam Pie Red Pizza

    Our original red pie topped with wild-caught chopped ocean clam.

    $36.00

    Sausage Pie

    Our original red pie topped with sweet Italian sausage.

    $30.00

    Best seller

    Tomato Pie

    Our world-famous tomato pie finished with pecorino Romano cheese.

    $25.75

    Tomato Pie
    Best seller

    White Rosemary Potato Pie

    Our original white pie finished with fresh rosemary and thinly sliced red bliss potatoes.

    $30.00

    Original Red Pie

    Our original pie is made with mozzarella cheese on the bottom + our famous red sauce on top, finished with pecorino Romano cheese.

    $25.75

    Original Red Pie
    Best seller

    Balsamic White Pie

    Our original white pie finished with aged Modena balsamic glaze.

    $30.00

    Balsamic White Pie

    Pepperoni Pie

    Our original red pie topped with cup & char pepperoni.

    $30.00

    Pepperoni Pie
    round-bar-pie

    Round Bar Pie

    Bar Pie

    16-Inch round ultra-thin sourdough crust with mozzarella cheese on bottom and our famous sauce on top, then finished with grated pecorino Romano cheese and toppings of your choice. This style is known as "Bar pie".

    $25.75

    Bar Pie
    most-ordered

    Most Ordered

    Clam Pie White Pizza

    Our original white pie topped with wild-caught chopped ocean clams.

    $36.00

    Bar Pie

    16-Inch round ultra-thin sourdough crust with mozzarella cheese on bottom and our famous sauce on top, then finished with grated pecorino Romano cheese and toppings of your choice. This style is known as "Bar pie".

    $25.75

    Original White Pie

    Our original white pie is made with a blend of spices, garlic & olive oil, mozzarella cheese, fresh ricotta cheese, finished with pecorino Romano cheese.

    $25.75

    Long Hot Pie

    Our original red pie topped with Italian long hots.

    $30.00

    Sausage Pie

    Our original red pie topped with sweet Italian sausage.

    $30.00

    Clam Pie Red Pizza

    Our original red pie topped with wild-caught chopped ocean clam.

    $36.00

    White Rosemary Potato Pie

    Our original white pie finished with fresh rosemary and thinly sliced red bliss potatoes.

    $30.00

    Original Red Pie

    Our original pie is made with mozzarella cheese on the bottom + our famous red sauce on top, finished with pecorino Romano cheese.

    $25.75

    Balsamic White Pie

    Our original white pie finished with aged Modena balsamic glaze.

    $30.00

    Pepperoni Pie

    Our original red pie topped with cup & char pepperoni.

    $30.00

    Malatesta's Italian American Pizza - View Menu & Order Online - 3525 West Chester Pike, Newtown Square, PA 19073 - Slice

    SlicePANewtown Square19073 Malatesta's Italian American Pizza
    Price: $$