Skip to main content
Original Italian Pizza

Original Italian Pizza

205 S Keystone Ave, Sayre, PA 18840
570-888-9167

We're all about supporting local pizzerias - even those who are not Slice partners.
Give Original Italian Pizza a call to order. We hear their food's delish.

Nearby Pizzerias on Slice
logo
Louies Hanover Square
102 S Main St, Horseheads, NY
Open Now$4.90 Delivery
logo
Bella's Deli Subs & Pizza
132-138 W Main St, Endicott, NY
Open Now$2 Delivery
logo
The Original Italian Pizza
25 Washington Ave, Endicott, NY
Open Now$6.90 Delivery
logo
Bella's Deli
26555 PA-267, Friendsville, PA
New
Open NowPickup Only
logo
Stone Bend Farm
196 Porter Hill Rd, Newfield, NY
New
Open NowPickup Only
logo
Oakdale Pizza
601-635 Harry L Dr, Johnson City, NY
Open Now$4.90 Delivery
logo
Pudgie's Pizza & Subs
215 Elmira Rd, Ithaca, NY
New
Open Now$3 Delivery
logo
Pizza Nia's
65 Rotary Ave, Binghamton, NY
Open NowPickup Only
logo
More Than Pizza Ithaca
215 E State St, Ithaca, NY
New
Open Now$4.95 Delivery
logo
Marrakech
111 E State St, Ithaca, NY
Open Now$4.90 Delivery
logo
Eta Pie
1006 W Seneca St, Ithaca, NY
Open Now$4.95 Delivery
logo
Mama Teresa's Pizzeria
139 College Avenue, Ithaca, NY
Open Now$3.99 - $10.99 Delivery
logo
Enzo Pizzeria & Italian Halal Grill
319 College Avenue, Ithaca, NY
Open Now$2.99 - $9.99 Delivery
logo
Ned’s Pizza NY College Town
139 Dryden Rd, Ithaca, NY
New
Open Now$3.90 Delivery
logo
Pizza Plus (Best of Halal)
47 Court St, Binghamton, NY
Open NowPickup Only
logo
Endzones Speciality Calzones
79 Court St, Binghamton, NY
New
Open NowPickup Only
logo
Ned's Pizza NY
840 Hanshaw Rd, Ithaca, NY
Open Now$4.90 Delivery
logo
Sicilian Delight
40 Catherwood Rd, Ithaca, NY
Open Now$3.50 Delivery
logo
Fox's Pizza Den
8824 NY-415, Campbell, NY
Open Now$4 Delivery
logo
Antonios Pizzeria & Restaurant
600 Hunter Hwy, Tunkhannock, PA
Open NowPickup Only
logo
Momo's Cafe
1173 Auburn Rd, Locke, NY
Open NowPickup Only
logo
A Pizza & More
104 Main St, Cortland, NY
Open Now$2 Delivery
logo
Conrads Pizza
1340 W Main St, Susquehanna, PA
Open NowPickup Only
logo
Angry Oven Pizzeria
25 E Steuben St, Bath, NY
Open NowPickup Only
logo
Big D & Chef T's
14 Liberty St, Bath, NY
Open Now$2.50 - $5 Delivery
logo
Pantheon
3599 NY-79, Harpursville, NY
Open NowPickup Only
logo
Luigi's Pizza
6 Main St, McGraw, NY
New
Open NowPickup Only
logo
Original New York Pizzeria
117 Main St, Moravia, NY
Open NowPickup Only
View More Pizzerias on Slice
Menu
pizza
Pizza

Cheese Pizza

Classic cheese or create your own pizza.

$11.49

Sheet Pizza

$20.49

specialty-pizza
Specialty Pizza

Garlic Pizza

$13.95

Margarita Pizza

Fresh garlic, olive oil, fresh basil, fresh Roma tomato sauce, romano & fresh mozzarella.

$16.95

White Pizza

Ricotta cheese & garlic base.

$16.50

Four Cheese Pizza

Mozzarella, cheddar, American, ricotta.

$18.95

Vegetable Pizza

Fresh vegetables.

$16.50

BBQ Chicken Pizza

Bbq base & chicken tender pieces.

$18.95

Hawaiian Pizza

Ham & pineapple.

$16.50

Tomato Pie

Marinara sauce, romano cheese, olive oil, & basil.

$10.95

Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza

Chicken tender pieces, bacon, ranch dressing.

$18.95

Pesto Pizza

Pesto base, fresh roma tomatoes, & mozzarella.

$16.95

Townie Pizza

Grilled chicken & broccoli.

$18.95

Taco Pizza

Taco meat, lettuce, tomato, cheddar, mozzarella, taco chips, & hot sauce packets.

$18.95

Original Italian Special Pizza

Sweet peppers, mushrooms, onions, black olives, pepperoni, & sausage.

$18.95

Breakfast Pizza

Egg, ham, bacon, sausage, american, mozzarella, & cheddar.

$18.95

Buffalo Wing Pizza

Cheese, buffalo wing pieces & hot sauce.

$18.95

Sicilian Pizza

Thick, square pan pizza.

$16.95

Meat Lovers Pizza

Pepperoni, sausage, ham, & bacon.

$18.95

Stuffed Pizza

Pepperoni, sausage, ham, & bacon.

$22.95

Steak Pizza

With onions & banana peppers.

$18.95

Italian Sub Pizza

Ham, salami. Lettuce, tomato, onion, provolone, mozzarella, romano cheese, oregano, Italian dressing.

$22.95

Pepperoni Galore Pizza

Mounds & mounds of pepperoni.

$18.95

pizza-by-the-slice
Pizza By The Slice

Garlic Pizza Slice

$2.00

Pepperoni Galore Pizza Slice

Mounds & mounds of pepperoni.

$2.50

Cheese Pizza Slice

$2.00

Margarita Pizza Slice

Fresh garlic, olive oil, fresh basil, fresh Roma tomato sauce, romano & fresh mozzarella.

$2.50

White Pizza Slice

Ricotta cheese & garlic base.

$2.50

Four Cheese Pizza Slice

Mozzarella, cheddar, American, ricotta.

$2.50

Vegetable Pizza Slice

Fresh vegetables.

$2.50

BBQ Chicken Pizza Slice

Bbq base & chicken tender pieces.

$2.50

Hawaiian Pizza Slice

Ham & pineapple.

$2.50

Tomato Pie Slice

Marinara sauce, romano cheese, olive oil, & basil.

$2.50

Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza Slice

Chicken tender pieces, bacon, ranch dressing.

$2.50

Pesto Pizza Slice

Pesto base, fresh roma tomatoes, & mozzarella.

$2.50

Townie Pizza Slice

Grilled chicken & broccoli.

$2.50

Taco Pizza Slice

Taco meat, lettuce, tomato, cheddar, mozzarella, taco chips, & hot sauce packets.

$2.50

Original Italian Special Pizza Slice

Sweet peppers, mushrooms, onions, black olives, pepperoni, & sausage.

$2.50

Breakfast Pizza Slice

Egg, ham, bacon, sausage, american, mozzarella, & cheddar.

$2.50

Buffalo Wing Pizza Slice

Cheese, buffalo wing pieces & hot sauce.

$2.50

Sicilian Pizza Slice

Thick, square pan pizza.

$2.50

Meat Lovers Pizza Slice

Pepperoni, sausage, ham, & bacon.

$2.50

Italian Sub Pizza Slice

Ham, salami. Lettuce, tomato, onion, provolone, mozzarella, romano cheese, oregano, Italian dressing.

$2.50

Steak Pizza Slice

With onions & banana peppers.

$2.50

appetizers
​Appetizers

French Fries

$2.99

Garlic Bread

$3.50

Cheese Fries

$4.50

Garlic Cheese Bread

$4.50

Pizza Fries

$4.95

Garlic Knots

$2.00

Loaded Fries

$6.25

Bruschetta

$5.50

Onion Rings

$5.00

Chicken Fingers

$6.50

Deep Fried Cauliflower

$5.50

Buffalo Style Chicken Fingers

$7.00

Deep Fried Mushrooms

$5.50

Steamed Clams Served with Butter

$7.95

Broccoli & Cheese Poppers

$5.95

Shrimp Cocktail

$8.95

Jalapeno Poppers

$5.95

Artichoke & Spinach Dip

$8.95

Toasted Ravioli

$5.95

Fried Calamari

$8.95

Mozzarella Sticks

$5.95

Calamari Fra Diovlo

$9.95

Rice Balls

$6.50

Caprese

Fresh mozzarella, fresh roma tomatoes, roasted peppers, olives, fresh basil, topped with balsamic glaze and olive oil.

$7.95

soups
Soups

Soup of the Day

Please call the restaurant for today's selection.

$4.45

French Onion Soup

$4.95

salads
Salads

Chef Salad

Ham, salami, turkey, provolone cheese, tomato, and onions.

$8.95

Caesar Salad With Chicken

$7.95

Tuna Salad

Provolone cheese, tomatoes, and onions.

$8.95

Caesar Salad With Shrimp

$10.95

Antipasto Salad

Pickled veggies, ham, salami, provolone cheese, tomatoes, and onions.

$8.95

Summer Salad

Walnuts, craisins, tomatoes, onions, gorgonzola cheese, over a bed of lettuce.

$7.95

Steak Salad

Our original Pittsburgh style steak salad with tomatoes, onions, mozzarella cheese, & french fries.

$9.45

Summer Salad With Chicken

Walnuts, craisins, tomatoes, onions, gorgonzola cheese, over a bed of lettuce.

$9.95

Grilled Chicken Salad

Grilled chicken, banana peppers, black olives tomatoes, onions, and mozzarella cheese.

$8.95

California Cobb Salad

Marinated chicken, bacon, avocado, hard boiled egg, tomato, crumbly blue cheese, pickled red onions, on a bed of romaine.

$9.95

Grilled Buffalo Chicken Salad

Grilled chicken, hot sauce, banana peppers, black olives, tomatoes, onions, and mozzarella cheese.

$8.95

Chicken Almondo Salad

Roasted peppers, sliced almonds, oranges, dried cranberries, tomatoes, greek olives on bed of romaine.

$9.95

Buffalo Tender Salad

Chicken tender pieces, hot sauce, banana peppers, black olives, tomatoes, onions, mozzarella cheese.

$8.95

Mediterranean Salad

Greek olives, cucumbers, tomatoes, chickpeas, pickled red onions on bed of romaine.

$7.95

Chicken Bruschetta Salad

$8.95

Mediterranean Salad With Marinated Chicken

Greek olives, cucumbers, tomatoes, chickpeas, pickled red onions on bed of romaine.

$9.95

Caesar Salad

$5.95

sides
Sides

Side Salad

$2.50

Marinara Sauce

$1.00

Alfredo Sauce

$2.50

Veggies

$2.50

Meatballs

$3.00

Extra Dressing

$0.50

Sausage

$3.00

Rice

$2.50

French Fries

$2.50

Bread

$1.50

Garlic Mash Potato

$2.50

Garlic Knots

$2.00

wings
Wings

Buffalo Wings

Served with blue cheese & celery.

$5.49

Char Grilled Wings

Served with blue cheese & celery.

$5.99

Grilled Wings

Served with blue cheese & celery.

$5.49

Boneless Wings

Served with blue cheese & celery.

$5.49

Char Buffalo Wings

Served with blue cheese & celery.

$5.99

calzone
Calzone

Ricotta Cheese & Mozzarella Cheese Calzone

$6.95

stromboli
Stromboli

Pepperoni, Ham, Mozzarella Cheese Stromboli

$6.95

specialty-stromboli
Specialty Stromboli

Vegetarian Stromboli

Broccoli, mushroom, & sweet peppers.

$7.95

Townie Stromboli

Grilled chicken and broccoli.

$7.95

Hawaiian Stromboli

Pineapple and ham.

$7.95

Buffalo Stromboli

Chicken wing pieces, hot sauce, and blue cheese.

$7.95

Cordon Blue Stromboli

Grilled chicken and ham.

$7.95

Steak Stromboli

Steak, sweet peppers, onions, mushrooms, and marinara sauce.

$7.95

Chicken Fajita Stromboli

Grilled chicken, onions, sweet peppers, mushrooms.

$7.95

Sausage Roll

Sausage link, sweet peppers, onions.

$7.95

cold-subs
Cold Subs

Italian Sub

Salami, ham, cheese.

$7.00

Ham & Cheese Sub

$7.00

Italian Mix Sub

Salami, capicola, ham, cheese.

$7.00

Tuna & Cheese Sub

$7.00

Roast Beef & Cheese Sub

$7.00

Cold Combo Sub

Roast beef, ham, turkey & cheese.

$7.50

Turkey & Cheese Sub

$7.00

Veggie Sub

Sweet pepper, mushroom & black olive.

$5.50

hot-subs
Hot Subs

Combo Sub

Mushrooms, onions, sweet peppers, sausage & sauce.

$7.00

Pizza Sub

Baked mozzarella & sauce sub with choice of pepperoni or mushroom.

$6.00

Meatball Sub

Meatballs & sauce.

$6.50

Fish Sub

Haddock, lettuce, tomato, onion, mayo & oil.

$8.00

Meatball Parmigiana Sub

Meatballs, sauce & mozzarella cheese.

$7.00

Cheese Burger Sub

American cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion, mayo & oil.

$7.00

Sausage Sub

Sausage & sauce.

$6.50

Pizza Burger Sub

Baked mozzarella cheese & sauce.

$7.00

Sausage Parmigiana Sub

Sausage, sauce & mozzarella cheese.

$7.00

Sauteed Veggie Sub

Mushroom, sweet peppers, black olive, lettuce, tomato, onion, mayo & oil.

$6.00

Sausage, Peppers & Onions Sub

Sausage, sweet peppers, onions.

$7.00

BBQ Chicken Sub

$7.00

Eggplant Parmigiana Sub

Eggplant, sauce & mozzarella cheese.

$7.00

Garden BBQ Chicken Sub

Lettuce, tomato, onions, mayo & oil.

$7.50

Chicken Parmigiana Sub

Chicken, sauce & mozzarella cheese.

$7.50

Chicken Finger Sub

Lettuce, tomato, onion, mayo & oil.

$7.50

Veal Parmigiana Sub

Veal, sauce & mozzarella cheese.

$7.75

Buffalo Chicken Finger Sub

Hot sauce, lettuce, tomato, onion, mayo & oil.

$8.00

Fried Ham & Cheese Sub

Fried ham & melted American cheese.

$7.00

BLT Sub

Bacon, lettuce, tomato, mayo & oil.

$7.00

Garden Fried Ham & Cheese Sub

Fried ham & melted American cheese with lettuce, tomato, onion, mayo & oil.

$7.50

wraps
Wraps

Chicken Wrap

Lettuce, tomato, cucumber, and ranch dressing.

$6.50

Buffalo Chicken Steak

Hot sauce, lettuce, tomatoes, and blue cheese.

$6.50

Chicken Steak Wrap

Sweet peppers, sauteed onions, lettuce, and spicy ranch.

$6.50

Veggie Wrap

Sweet peppers, mushrooms, black olives, lettuce, tomato, onions, Italian dressing.

$6.50

Steak Wrap

Sweet peppers, sauteed onions, lettuce, and spicy ranch.

$6.50

Sauteed Veggie Wrap

Fried sweet peppers, mushrooms, onions black olives, lettuce, tomato, Italian dressing & mayo.

$6.50

Turkey Wrap

Bacon, lettuce, tomato, cucumber, and ranch dressing.

$6.50

entrees
Entrees

Chicken Piccata

Lemon garlic butter sauce.

$16.95

Chicken Cutlet Bruschetta

Chicken breast lightly pounded and breaded fried to perfection and topped with fresh tomato bruschetta and balsamic demiglaze.

$16.95

Veal Piccata

Lemon garlic butter sauce.

$17.95

Grilled Salmon

Topped with mango salsa.

$17.45

Chicken Marsala

Demiglaze, marsala, and mushrooms.

$16.95

Haddock

Beer battered, broiled, or fried.

$13.95

Veal Marsala

Demiglaze, marsala, and mushrooms.

$17.95

Delmonico

Grilled to perfection.

$18.95

pasta-entrees
Pasta Entrees

Fettuccine Alfredo

$12.95

Tortellini Alfredo With Chicken

$16.95

Fettuccine Alfredo with Broccoli

$14.95

Tortellini Alfredo With Shrimp

$18.95

Fettuccine Alfredo with Mushroom

$14.95

Spaghetti Alla Puttanesca

Black olives, mushrooms, meat sauce, sweet peppers, & tomato sauce with a hint of cream.

$14.95

Fettuccine Alfredo with Chicken

$15.95

Shrimp Scampi

$17.95

Fettuccine Alfredo with Shrimp

$17.95

Shrimp Fra Diavlo

Shrimp sauteed with spicy tomato sauce over a bed of linguine.

$17.95

Cheese Ravioli

$12.95

Fish with Spaghetti

Beer battered, broiled, or fried.

$12.95

Pasta Bolognese

Fresh ground beef, peas, carrots, sauteed in fresh marinara sauce over rigatoni.

$12.95

Fish with French Fries

Beer battered, broiled, or fried.

$12.95

Gnocchi

$10.95

Chicken Riggies

Chicken breast tossed with onions, hot peppers & tomato sauce with a hint of cream over a bed of rigatoni.

$15.95

Gnocchi With Ricotta

$11.95

Penne Vodka

Penne pasta tossed with marinara and cream sauce.

$12.95

Gnocchi With Baked Mozzarella

$11.95

Penne Vodka With Chicken

Penne pasta tossed with marinara and cream sauce.

$15.95

Cheese Tortellini

$12.45

Penne Vodka With Shrimp

Penne pasta tossed with marinara and cream sauce.

$17.95

Tortellini Alfredo

$13.95

Spaghetti Caprese

Spaghetti tossed with fresh garlic, olive oil, fresh grape tomato, tomato sauce topped with fresh basil and fresh mozzarella.

$16.95

Tortellini Alfredo With Broccoli

$15.95

Chicken Cacciatore

Chicken sauteed with sweet peppers, onions, garlic, marinara over a bed of pasta.

$16.95

Tortellini Alfredo With Mushroom

$15.95

pasta-dishes
Pasta Dishes

Pasta With Tomato Sauce

Spaghetti, linguine, fettuccine, rigatoni, angel hair, penne.

$9.95

Pasta With Sausage

Spaghetti, linguine, fettuccine, rigatoni, angel hair, penne.

$12.95

Pasta With Garlic & Oil

Spaghetti, linguine, fettuccine, rigatoni, angel hair, penne.

$9.95

Pasta With Red Clam Sauce

Spaghetti, linguine, fettuccine, rigatoni, angel hair, penne.

$12.95

Pasta With Mushrooms

Spaghetti, linguine, fettuccine, rigatoni, angel hair, penne.

$11.45

Pasta With White Clam Sauce

Spaghetti, linguine, fettuccine, rigatoni, angel hair, penne.

$12.95

Pasta With Meat Sauce

Spaghetti, linguine, fettuccine, rigatoni, angel hair, penne.

$11.95

Pasta With Chicken

Spaghetti, linguine, fettuccine, rigatoni, angel hair, penne.

$13.95

Pasta With Meatballs

Spaghetti, linguine, fettuccine, rigatoni, angel hair, penne.

$12.95

Pasta With Shrimp

Spaghetti, linguine, fettuccine, rigatoni, angel hair, penne.

$14.95

baked-dishes
Baked Dishes

Baked Ziti

$12.95

Chicken Parmesan

Served with spaghetti.

$14.95

Stuffed Shells

$12.95

Veal Parmesan

Served with spaghetti.

$15.95

Combo Platter

Stuffed shell, lasagna, & chicken parm.

$13.95

Eggplant Parmesan

Served with spaghetti.

$11.95

Lasagna

$12.95

philly-cheese
Philly Cheese

Chicken Steak

$6.00

Garden Chicken Cheese Steak

Lettuce, tomato, onion, mayo & oil.

$7.00

Steak

$6.50

Buffalo Chicken Cheese Steak

Hot sauce, and blue cheese.

$7.00

Chicken Cheese Steak

$6.50

Garden Buffalo Chicken Cheese Steak

Hot sauce, lettuce, tomato, onion, mayo & oil.

$7.45

Cheese Steak

$7.00

Cheese Steak Special

Sweet peppers, onions, mushroom & sauce.

$7.75

Pizza Steak

Mozzarella cheese & sauce.

$7.25

Chicken Cheese Steak Special

Sweet peppers, onion, mushroom & sauce.

$7.25

Garden Cheese Steak

Lettuce, tomato, onion, mayo & oil.

$7.50

kids-menu
Kid's Menu

Kid's Slice of Pizza with Fries

$4.50

Kid's Spaghetti With Marinara

$4.50

Kid's Chicken Fingers & Fries

$5.95

Kid's Cheese Ravioli

$4.95

Kid's Spaghetti With Butter

$4.50

desserts
Desserts

Classic Cannoli

$4.00

Chocolate Cake

$4.00

Chocolate Cannoli

$4.00

Cheese Cake

$4.00

Tiramisu

$4.00

Gelato

$2.50

beverages
​Beverages

Soda

Pepsi, diet pepsi, mountain dew, sierra mist, root beer, orange crush, cherry pepsi, ginger ale, dr. Pepper, diet mountain dew.

$1.99

Espresso

$1.95

Gatorade

Fruit punch, orange, lemon lime, cool blue.

$1.99

Cappuccino

$2.95

Pure Leaf Tea

Sweet, unsweetened, honey green, peach, raspberry, lemon.

$2.50

Chocolate Milk

$1.95

Coffee

$1.95

White Milk

$1.95

Hot Tea

$1.95

Bottle Water

$1.50

Hot Chocolate

$1.95

SlicePASayre18840 Original Italian Pizza
Price: $$