Skip to main content
Shelly Pie Pizza

Shelly Pie Pizza

912 Penn Ave, Turtle Creek, PA 15145
412-646-2560

Open until 8:00 PM

Full Hours
    Skip to first category
    traditional-pizza

    Traditional Pizza

    Hand-tossed pizza with a choice of red or white sauce.

    Traditional Cheese Pizza

    Classic cheese or create your own pizza.

    $8.24

    Traditional Cheese Pizza
    sicilian-pizza

    Sicilian Pizza

    Sicilian Cheese Pizza

    Thick crust square pizza with tomato sauce, mozzarella, and basil.

    $8.24

    specialty-pizza

    Specialty Pizza

    Out traditional with various toppings. No substitutions.

    Hawaiian Pizza

    Ham, pineapple, and cheese with pizza sauce.

    $11.74

    Buffalo Chicken Pizza

    Grilled or fried chicken and cheese with ranch sauce.

    $10.99

    Buffalo Chicken Pizza

    BBQ Chicken Pizza

    Grilled or fried chicken and cheese with BBQ sauce.

    $10.99

    Tomato & Spinach Pizza

    Tomato, spinach, and cheese with our white sauce.

    $11.74

    Tomato & Spinach Pizza

    EBUT Pizza

    Pepperoni, sausage, mushroom, onion, green pepper & cheese.

    $18.49

    EBUT Pizza

    Gluten Free Pizza

    A 12" gluten free pizza crust toppeed with sauce & our cheese blend.

    $13.24

    sicilian-specialty-pizza

    Sicilian Specialty Pizza

    No substitutions.

    Hawaiian Sicilian Pizza

    Ham, pineapple, and cheese with pizza sauce.

    $11.24

    Buffalo Chicken Sicilian Pizza

    Grilled or fried chicken and cheese with ranch sauce.

    $18.75

    Buffalo Chicken Sicilian Pizza

    BBQ Chicken Sicilian Pizza

    Grilled or fried chicken with BBQ sauce.

    $9.49

    Tomato & Spinach Sicilian Pizza

    Tomato, spinach, and cheese with our white sauce.

    $11.24

    Tomato & Spinach Sicilian Pizza

    EBUT Sicilian Pizza

    Pepperoni, sausage, mushroom, onion, green pepper & cheese.

    $17.24

    fried-appetizers

    Fried Appetizers

    French Fries

    Crispy and golden.

    $4.40

    Provolone Sticks

    Served with a side of marinara sauce.

    $9.14

    Breaded Mushrooms

    Served with ranch dressing.

    $8.10

    Chicken Finger Basket

    Served with french fries & choice of dipping sauce.

    $11.10

    Hot Pepper Cheese Balls

    Served with ranch dressing.

    $8.10

    Clams Basket

    Served with french fries & choice of dipping sauce.

    $11.10

    Battered Onion Rings

    Served with dipping sauce.

    $8.65

    Shrimp Basket

    Served with french fries & choice of dipping sauce.

    $11.10

    Breaded Fried Pickles

    Served with ranch dressing.

    $8.10

    Breaded Fried Pickles

    Zucchini Planks

    Served with ranch, marinara or horsey sauce.

    $10.90

    Zucchini Planks

    Broccoli Bacon Cheddar Puffs

    "Served with ranch dressing.

    $8.10

    Chicken Wings

    Served with choice of sauce or dry seasoning.

    $10.14

    Chicken Wings
    specialty-appetizers

    Specialty Appetizers

    Polenta Asiago

    Polenta topped with marinara sauce & melted asiago cheese.

    $10.14

    Polenta Asiago

    Buffalo, Bacon & Cheese Fries

    French fries topped with buffalo sauce, or a blend of cheese and bacon.

    $10.65

    Buffalo, Bacon & Cheese Fries

    Stuffed Banana Peppers

    Banana peppers stuffed with sausage and topped with tomato sauce & our blend of cheeses.

    $10.65

    Stuffed Banana Peppers

    Chili, Bacon & Cheese Fries

    French fries topped with chili, our blend of cheeses and bacon.

    $10.65

    Chili, Bacon & Cheese Fries

    Banana Peppers Oil & Garlic

    Banana peppers sauteed in oil & garlic and topped with asiago cheese.

    $10.65

    Regular Potato Skins

    Potato skins loaded with cheddar cheese and bacon served with a side of sour cream.

    $10.65

    Regular Potato Skins

    Italian Greens & Beans

    Fresh spinach and cannelloni beans sauteed with onion oil and garlic.

    $10.40

    Pizza Potato Skins

    Potato skins loaded with a blend of cheeses and pepperoni served with a side of marinara sauce.

    $10.65

    Garlic Knots

    Our dough twisted into knots and deep-fried. We toss them in garlic butter sauce and parmesan cheese.

    $3.65

    Pub Pretzels

    5 pub pretzels served with choice of mustard (yellow, spicy or honey) or cheese sauce.

    $9.65

    Cinnamon Sugar Knots

    Our dough twisted into knots and deep-fried. We toss them in butter sauce, cinnamon & sugar.

    $3.65

    Breadsticks

    Served with choice of marinara, ranch or garlic butter sauce.

    $8.65

    Breadsticks

    Garlic Parmesan, Bacon & Cheese Fries

    French fries topped with garlic butter sauce, parmesan cheese, our blend of cheeses, and bacon.

    $10.65

    Garlic Parmesan, Bacon & Cheese Fries

    Breadsticks with Cheese

    Served with choice of marinara, ranch or garlic butter sauce.

    $9.65

    soups

    Soups

    Homemade Italian Wedding Soup

    $5.15

    Homemade Chili

    Please call the restaurant for today's selection.

    $5.15

    Soup of the Day

    Please call the restaurant for today's selection.

    $5.15

    pick-up-soups

    Pick Up Soups

    Only available for pickup
    Pick up only.

    Homemade Italian Wedding Soup To Go Only

    Traditional Italian soup filled with green veggies and meat.

    $12.14

    Homemade Chili To Go Only

    $12.14

    Soup of the Day To Go Only

    Please call the restaurant for today's selections.

    $12.14

    salads

    Salads

    Tossed Salad

    Mixed greens, tomatoes, cucumbers, black olives & croutons.

    $6.65

    Turkey Club Salad

    A larger version of the tossed salad topped with turkey, bacon, cheddar cheese, and croutons.

    $14.24

    Antipasto Salad

    A larger version of the tossed salad topped with ham, salami, capicola, pepperoni, and our blend of cheese.

    $14.24

    Chicken Salad

    A larger version of the tossed salad topped with grilled or fried chicken, french fries, and our blend of cheeses.

    $14.75

    Chef Salad

    A larger version of the tossed salad topped with ham, turkey, American and swiss cheese, and a hard-boiled egg.

    $14.24

    Steak Salad

    A larger version of the tossed salad topped with a 6 oz. sirloin steak, french fries and our blend of cheeses.

    $17.00

    sides

    Sides

    French Fries

    Our delicious French fries are deep-fried 'till golden brown, with a crunchy exterior and a light fluffy interior. Seasoned to perfection!

    $4.40

    Mashed Potatoes

    Creamy potatoes meet milk, butter, salt, and pepper before being whipped to perfection.

    $4.40

    Coleslaw

    Finely shredded raw cabbage & dressing. A hit at both the picnic table and the dining room table.

    $4.40

    Coleslaw

    Side of Pasta

    $6.65

    Veggie of the Day

    $4.40

    Macaroni & Cheese

    Cooked macaroni pasta and cheese sauce. Family favorite recipe, loved by both children and adults.

    $6.65

    extras

    Extras

    Extra Dressing

    $0.75

    Extra Dressing

    Pizza Sauce

    $0.75

    Garlic Butter Sauce

    $0.75

    Shredded Cheese

    $2.09

    Dipping Sauce

    $0.75

    Cheese Sauce

    $2.09

    Tomato Sauce

    $0.75

    Crumbled Bleu Cheese

    $2.09

    Marinara Sauce

    $0.75

    shellzone

    Shellzone

    Shellzone

    Our version of the calzone. Filled with our blend of cheeses and ricotta, served with a side of sauce.

    $13.75

    hoagies

    Hoagies

    Italian Hoagie

    Ham, salami, capicola, pepperoni, and our blend of cheeses topped with lettuce, tomato, onion, and our Italian dressing.

    $9.65

    Veggie Hoagie

    Grilled mushrooms, onions, green peppers, and black olives topped with our blend of cheeses, lettuce, tomato, and Italian dressing.

    $8.65

    Steak Hoagie

    Shaved steak topped with grilled onions, our blend of cheeses, lettuce, tomato, and our Italian dressing.

    $9.65

    Chicken Parmesan Hoagie

    Golden fried chicken tenders topped with our homemade tomato sauce and our blend of cheeses.

    $9.65

    Magoo Hoagie

    Shaved steak topped with mushrooms, pepper rings, our blend of cheeses, and our Italian dressing.

    $9.65

    Eggplant Parmesan Hoagie

    Thin sliced eggplant topped with our homemade tomato sauce and our blend of cheeses.

    $8.65

    Meatball Hoagie

    Italian meatballs topped with our homemade tomato sauce and our blend of cheeses.

    $9.65

    Turkey Hoagie

    Turkey topped with our blend of cheeses, lettuce, tomato, onion, and our Italian dressing.

    $9.65

    Hot Sausage Hoagie

    Hot sausage topped with green peppers, onions, and our blend of cheeses.

    $9.65

    burgers-sandwiches

    Burgers & Sandwiches

    All burgers & sandwiches are served with french fries.

    Burger

    A fresh ground beef burger topped with lettuce, tomato, and onion.

    $12.40

    Burger

    Rachel Sandwich

    Turkey breast topped with swiss cheese and coleslaw on grilled marble rye.

    $12.90

    Maddie Mac Burger

    1 all-beef patty, special sauce, lettuce, cheese, pickles, and eggplant.

    $13.40

    Fish Sandwich

    A large breaded fish served on 1/2 a hoagie roll served with a choice of tartar or cocktail sauce.

    $14.40

    Patty Melt Burger

    Our 1/2 pound burger topped with American cheese and sauteed onion on grilled marble rye.

    $13.40

    Chicken Sandwich

    Your choice of grilled or fried. With lettuce, tomato and onions, Try it buffalo or cajun style.

    $12.40

    Grilled Cheese Sandwich

    Texas toast grilled with American cheese.

    $8.65

    Hot Turkey Sandwich

    Served on Texas toast with choice of mashed potatoes or french fries.

    $12.40

    Tuna Melt Sandwich

    Homemade tuna salad served on grilled Texas toast and topped with American cheese.

    $12.14

    Hot Meatloaf Sandwich

    Served on Texas toast with choice of mashed potatoes or french fries.

    $12.40

    Reuben Sandwich

    Tender, thinly sliced corned beef topped with swiss cheese, sauerkraut, and Thousand Island dressing on grilled marble rye.

    $12.90

    Hot Roast Beef Sandwich

    Served on Texas toast with choice of mashed potatoes or french fries.

    $12.40

    clubs

    Clubs

    All clubs are served with french fries.

    American Club

    Turkey, ham, American and swiss cheese, lettuce, tomato, and mayo on Texas toast.

    $12.90

    Italian Club

    Ham, salami, capicola, provolone cheese, lettuce, tomato, and balsamic mayo on grilled garlic Texas toast.

    $12.90

    Turkey & Bacon Club

    Turkey, bacon, American cheese, lettuce, tomato, and mayo on Texas toast.

    $12.90

    entrees

    Entrees

    All Entrees are served with your choice of a side salad or a cup of soup & fresh italian bread (upon request).

    Pasta with Homemade Tomato Sauce

    Smooth. Served with a choice of pasta and a meatball.

    $14.20

    Pasta with Homemade Tomato Sauce

    Lasagna

    Layers of noodles, ricotta cheese, our blend of cheeses, and homemade tomato sauce. We top it with more cheese and a meatball. Try it with our pepperoni sauce for an additional charge.

    $17.75

    Lasagna

    Pasta Marinara

    Chunky. Served with a choice of pasta and a meatball.

    $14.20

    Cheese Ravioli

    Ricotta stuffed pasta pockets topped with our homemade tomato sauce, a meatball, and our blend of cheeses.

    $15.50

    Gluten Free Pasta Marinara

    Chunky. Gluten-free pasta topped with marinara.

    $14.20

    Stuffed Shells

    Ricotta stuffed pasta shells topped with our homemade tomato sauce, a meatball, and our blend of cheeses.

    $15.50

    Pasta Arrabiata

    Spicy. Served with a choice of pasta and a meatball.

    $14.20

    Gnocchi

    Small potato dough dumplings topped with homemade tomato sauce, a meatball & our blend of cheeses.

    $15.50

    Pasta Oil & Garlic

    A shelly pie twist on an oil & garlic recipe, topped with fresh chopped spinach, tomatoes, and parmesan cheese.

    $14.20

    Fettuccini Alfredo

    Rich, creamy alfredo sauce tossed with fettuccini noodles.

    $15.50

    Pasta Bolognese

    Served with a choice of pasta and our homemade meat sauce.

    $15.20

    Meatball Parmesan

    4 large meatballs served on a small bed of pasta and topped with homemade tomato sauce and our blend of cheeses.

    $15.50

    Pasta Bleu

    Bleu cheese cream sauce tossed with artichokes and crumbled sausage over your choice of pasta.

    $17.75

    Shrimp Scampi

    Large shrimp tossed in our garlic butter sauce served over a bed of pasta.

    $19.50

    Shrimp Scampi
    more-entrees

    More Entrees

    All dishes are served with your choice of potato or pasta.

    Grilled Chicken Breast

    Grilled chicken lightly seasoned. Try it Cajun style!

    $14.24

    Chicken Parmesan

    Golden fried or grilled chicken topped with our homemade sauce and our signature blend of cheeses.

    $15.24

    Chicken Marsala

    Pan-seared chicken in rich marsala wine and mushroom sauce.

    $15.24

    Chicken Finger Dinner

    5 chicken tenders served with a choice of dipping sauce.

    $15.75

    Chicken Piccata

    Pan-seared chicken in white wine, lemon cream sauce topped with capers.

    $15.24

    Chicken Piccata

    Eggplant Parmesan

    Thin sliced, breaded, and fried to perfection. We top it with homemade tomato sauce and our blend of cheeses.

    $15.75

    desserts

    Desserts

    Raspberry Swirl Cheesecake

    $8.19

    Raspberry Swirl Cheesecake

    NY Style Cheesecake

    Classic New York cheesecake with a creamy satiny texture.

    $9.19

    NY Style Cheesecake

    Carrot Cake

    Moist cake, spiced with cinnamon and frosted with cream cheese frosting.

    $7.20

    Carrot Cake
    beverages

    Beverages

    Fountain Soda

    Nothing like a cold soda to go with your pizza.

    $3.75

    Hot Tea

    $3.75

    Fresh Brewed Iced Tea

    $3.75

    Hot Chocolate

    $3.75

    Coffee

    $3.75

    Shelly Pie Pizza - 912 Penn Ave, Turtle Creek, PA 15145 - Menu, Hours, & Phone Number - Order Delivery or Pickup - Slice

    SlicePATurtle Creek15145 Shelly Pie Pizza
    Price: $$