Skip to main content
Toppers Pizza

Toppers Pizza

109 E College Ave, Appleton, WI 54911
920-730-7070

Order Ahead We open at 10:30 AM

Full Hours
    Skip to first category
    build-your-own-pizza

    Build Your Own Pizza

    Featured

    Build Your Own Za Pizza

    Your choice of crust, sauce, cheese and toppings.

    $9.99

    Build Your Own Za Pizza
    house-pizza

    House Pizza

    Featured

    Maui Topper Pizza

    Semi-sweet BBQ sauce topped with 100% real Wisconsin mozzarella cheese, Canadian bacon, pineapple and applewood smoked bacon.

    $13.99

    Maui Topper Pizza

    Featured

    Buffalo Chicken Pizza

    Mild buffalo ranch sauce topped with 100% real Wisconsin mozzarella cheese, applewood smoked bacon, diced buffalo chicken and finished with a drizzle of mild buffalo sauce and ranch.

    $13.99

    Buffalo Chicken Pizza

    Wisconsin Cheese-Maker Topper Pizza

    Developed in partnership with award winning Cheesemakers at Cedar Valley Cheese, this recipe features 100% real Wisconsin mozzarella, pepper jack, asiago, and smoked gouda. Try it with hand-pinched sausage and Applewood smoked bacon!

    $15.99

    Mac 'N Cheese Pizza

    Creamy cheese sauce layered with macaroni noodles, cheddar cheese and 100% real Wisconsin mozzarella cheese.

    $13.99

    Mac 'N Cheese Pizza

    Meat Topper Pizza

    Homemade pizza sauce topped with 100% real Wisconsin mozzarella cheese, pepperoni, Canadian bacon, hand-pinched Italian sausage and applewood smoked bacon.

    $13.99

    Toppers Classic Pizza

    Homemade pizza sauce topped with 100% real Wisconsin mozzarella cheese, pepperoni, hand-pinched Italian sausage, onions, green peppers and mushrooms.

    $13.99

    Smoky BBQ Chicken Pizza

    Chicken, onions, applewood smoked bacon, smoky BBQ sauce topped with pepper jack, mozzarella, and drizzled with more BBQ sauce.

    $13.99

    Old School Sausage & Pepperoni Pizza

    Homemade pizza sauce, mozzarella cheese, thick-cut spicy pepperoni, hand-pinched Italian sausage and garlic-roasted tomatoes.

    $13.99

    Ragin Pepperoni Pizza

    Homemade pizza sauce topped with 100% real Wisconsin mozzarella cheese, pepperoni, thick-cut spicy pepperoni and diced pepperoni.

    $13.99

    Ragin Pepperoni Pizza

    Veggie Classic Pizza

    Homemade pizza sauce topped with 100% real Wisconsin mozzarella cheese, green peppers, mushrooms, black olives, tomatoes and onions.

    $13.99

    Veggie Classic Pizza

    Loaded Tot-Zza Pizza

    Ranch sauce topped with 100% real Wisconsin mozzarella cheese, tater tots, applewood smoked bacon, green onions and drizzled with nacho cheese.

    $13.99

    Loaded Tot-Zza Pizza
    premium-pizza

    Premium Pizza

    Featured

    Buffalo Chicken Mac N Cheese Pizza

    Creamy cheese sauce layered with macaroni noodles, and topped with 100% real Wisconsin mozzarella cheese, cheddar cheese, diced buffalo chicken, applewood smoked bacon and drizzled with mild buffalo sauce.

    $15.99

    Buffalo Chicken Mac N Cheese Pizza

    The Stinger Pizza

    Pizza sauce topped with 100% Wisconsin mozzarella, hand-pinched sausage, pepperoni, sliced hot cherry peppers, and drizzled with sweet hot honey.

    $12.50

    Vegan Buffalo Chicken Less Topper Pizza

    Buffalo sauce, topped with Follow Your Heart Dairy-free Mozzarella, Greenleaf plant-based Chicken, green onions, and drizzled with dairy free ranch.

    $15.99

    Vegan Buffalo Chicken Less Topper Pizza

    Vegan Pesto Margherita Pizza

    Nut- and cheese-free pesto base sauce, smothered in Follow Your Heart Dairy-free Mozzarella and garlic roasted tomatoes.

    $13.99

    Wisconsin Curds 'N Bacon Pizza

    Ranch sauce topped with 100% real Wisconsin mozzarella cheese, golden beer-battered cheese curds, applewood smoked bacon, green onions, and drizzled with ranch sauce.

    $15.99

    Wisconsin Curds 'N Bacon Pizza

    Caulipower King Pizza

    Our homemade pizza sauce, smothered in 100% wisconsin mozzarella and pepper jack cheeses, topped with loads of pepperoni and hand-pinched sausage, on top of an award-winning gluten-free, 12" cauliflower crust made by the experts at caulipower®.

    $17.99

    Chicken Alfredo Cheesemaker Pizza

    White sauce topped with our 4-cheese Wisconsin cheesemaker blend, grilled chicken, diced tomatoes, mushrooms and Applewood smoked bacon.

    $15.99

    sides

    Sides

    Three Cheese Wisconsin Mac

    Noodles smothered in our signature bold creamy cheese sauce, and topped off with our blend of 100% real Wisconsin mozzarella and cheddar cheese.

    $6.99

    Loaded Tater Mac

    Our 3-Cheese Wisconsin Mac topped with tater tots, applewood smoked bacon, and green onions.

    $6.99

    Buffalo Chicken Mac

    Our 3-Cheese Wisconsin Mac topped with diced buffalo chicken, applewood smoked bacon, and drizzled with mild buffalo and ranch sauce.

    $6.99

    CBR Mac

    Our 3-Cheese Wisconsin Mac topped with sliced grilled chicken, applewood smoked bacon, diced tomatoes, and drizzled with ranch sauce.

    $6.99

    dipping-sauces

    Dipping Sauces

    Boom Boom Sauce

    $0.95

    Parmesan Garlic Sauce

    $0.95

    Ranch Sauce

    $0.95

    Sour Cream Sauce

    $0.95

    Garlic Sauce

    Vegan.

    $0.95

    Bleu Cheese Sauce

    $0.95

    Nacho Cheese Sauce

    $0.95

    Mild Buffalo Sauce

    Vegan.

    $0.95

    Marinara Sauce

    Vegan.

    $0.95

    Cream Cheese Icing

    $0.95

    Chipotle Ranch Sauce

    $0.95

    Dairy Free Ranch Sauce

    Vegan.

    $0.95

    topperstix

    Topperstix

    Featured

    Original Topperstix

    Our cheesy, buttery and garlicky Topperstix are perfect for sharing... or not. Your secret is safe with us. Your choice of dipping sauce. Made with 100% real Wisconsin mozzarella cheese.

    $8.99

    Original Topperstix

    Pepperonistix

    Our delicious Original Topperstix topped with loads of diced pepperoni. Made with 100% real Wisconsin mozzarella cheese.

    $9.99

    Pepperonistix

    Three Cheese Garlicstix

    Our delicious Original Topperstix topped with roasted garlic, asiago and cheddar cheese. Made with 100% real Wisconsin mozzarella cheese.

    $9.99

    Three Cheese Garlicstix

    Nachostix

    Our delicious Original Topperstix topped with ground beef, pepper jack, fire-roasted jalapenos, diced tomatoes and nacho cheese drizzle. Made with 100% real Wisconsin mozzarella Cheese.

    $9.99

    Nachostix

    Baconstix

    Our delicious Original Topperstix topped with loads of applewood smoked bacon. Made with 100% real Wisconsin mozzarella cheese.

    $9.99

    Baconstix

    Veganstix

    These cheesy, buttery, and garlicy Topperstix are made with Follow Your Heart Dairy-free Mozzarella, our homemade vegan friendly garlic sauce, and served with your choice of dippin’ sauces. Try our dairy free ranch!

    $10.99

    boneless-wings

    Boneless Wings

    Hot Honey Boneless Wings

    Our tender boneless wings; breaded, oven-roasted, and then tossed in hot honey.

    $7.99

    Mild Buffalo Boneless Wings

    Our tender boneless wings; breaded, oven-roasted, and then tossed in mild buffalo sauce. It is sniffles hot, but not tears in your eyes hot.

    $8.99

    Smoky BBQ Boneless Wings

    Our tender boneless wings; breaded, oven-roasted, and then tossed in smoky BBQ sauce. An amazing combination of sweet and smoky.

    $8.99

    Hot Buffalo Boneless Wings

    Our tender boneless wings; breaded, oven-roasted, and then tossed in hot buffalo sauce. For those who are not afraid of the burn.

    $8.99

    Boom Boom Boneless Wings

    Our tender boneless wings; breaded, oven-roasted, and then tossed in boom boom sauce. This sweet, spicy, and garlicky flavor is perfect on wings.

    $8.99

    Oven Roasted Boneless Wings

    Our tender boneless wings breaded and oven-roasted. Served sauceless, but not soulless.

    $8.99

    Parmesan Garlic Boneless Wings

    Our tender boneless wings; breaded, oven-roasted, and then tossed in parmesan garlic sauce. A classic savory favorite.

    $8.99

    bone-in-wings

    Bone In Wings

    Hot Honey Bone In Wings

    Our traditional bone-in wings oven roasted, and then tossed in hot honey.

    $7.99

    Boom Boom Bone In Wings

    Our traditional bone-in wings oven roasted, and then tossed in boom boom sauce. This sweet, spicy, and garlicky flavor is perfect on wings.

    $8.99

    Mild Buffalo Bone In Wings

    Our traditional bone-in wings oven roasted, and then tossed in mild buffalo sauce. It is sniffles hot, but not tears in your eyes hot.

    $8.99

    Smoky BBQ Bone In Wings

    Our traditional bone-in wings oven roasted, and then tossed in smoky BBQ sauce. An amazing combination of sweet and smoky.

    $8.99

    Hot Buffalo Bone In Wings

    Our traditional bone-in wings oven roasted, and then tossed in hot buffalo sauce. For those who are not afraid of the burn.

    $8.99

    Parmesan Garlic Bone In Wings

    Our traditional bone-in wings oven roasted, and then tossed in parmesan garlic sauce. A classic savory favorite.

    $8.99

    Oven Roasted Bone In Wings

    Our traditional bone-in wings, oven-roasted, and served sauceless, but not soulless.

    $8.99

    piggy-wings

    Piggy Wings

    Hot Honey Piggy Wings

    Our delicious, whole muscle pork shanks juicy & fall-off-the-bone tender oven roasted and tossed in hot honey.

    $10.99

    Boom Boom Piggy Wings

    Our delicious, whole muscle pork shanks juicy & fall-off-the-bone tender oven roasted, and then tossed in hot buffalo sauce. For those who are not afraid of the burn.

    $10.99

    Oven Roasted Piggy Wings

    Our delicious, whole muscle pork shanks juicy & fall-off-the-bone tender oven-roasted, and served sauceless, but not soulless.

    $10.99

    Smoky BBQ Piggy Wings

    Our delicious, whole muscle pork shanks juicy & fall-off-the-bone tender oven roasted, and then tossed in smoky BBQ sauce. An amazing combination of sweet and smoky.

    $10.99

    Mild Buffalo Piggy Wings

    Our delicious, whole muscle pork shanks juicy & fall-off-the-bone tender oven roasted, and then tossed in mild buffalo sauce. It is sniffles hot, but not tears in your eyes hot.

    $10.99

    Parmesan Garlic Piggy Wings

    Our delicious, whole muscle pork shanks juicy & fall-off-the-bone tender oven roasted, and then tossed in parmesan garlic sauce. A classic savory favorite.

    $10.99

    Hot Buffalo Piggy Wings

    Our delicious, whole muscle pork shanks juicy & fall-off-the-bone tender oven roasted, and then tossed in hot buffalo sauce. For those who are not afraid of the burn.

    $10.99

    plant-based-chicken

    Plant Based Chicken

    Oven Roasted Chicken Fingers

    A side of five plant-based breaded chicken tenders made by Greenleaf. Served with your choice of dippin' sauce.

    $10.99

    desserts

    Desserts

    Cinnamonstix

    Our craveable dessert stix are made with cinnamon sugar and drizzled with our delicious cream cheese icing.

    $8.99

    Cinnamonstix

    Lava Cake

    A pint of decadent chocolate frozen custard swirled with dark chocolate cake batter and chocolate chunks.

    $5.99

    Birthday Stix

    Our exclusive Birthday Stix are made with cinnamon sugar, drizzled with a generous amount of our delicious cream cheese icing and topped with colorful sprinkles.

    $9.99

    Almost S’mores

    A pint of rich vanilla frozen custard swirled with caramel, marshmallow and loaded with dark chocolate chips and graham cracker pieces.

    $5.99

    Vintage Vanilla

    A pint of Toppers version of Wisconsin's finest rich frozen vanilla custard. All you need is a spoon.

    $5.99

    drinks

    Drinks

    Soda

    $2.09

    Agua Fresca

    $2.99

    Minute Maid Lemonade

    $2.19

    Dasani Water

    $2.19

    Toppers Pizza - View Menu & Order Online - 109 E College Ave, Appleton, WI 54911 - Slice

    SliceWIAppleton54911 Toppers Pizza
    Price: $$