Skip to main content
Day One Pizza

Day One Pizza

749 Park Ave, Columbus, WI 53925
920-623-2300

We're all about supporting local pizzerias - even those who are not Slice partners.
Give Day One Pizza a call to order. We hear their food's delish.

Menu
pizza
Pizza

Cheese Pizza

Classic cheese or create your own pizza.

$10.79

specialty-pizza
Specialty Pizza

The Works Pizza

Pepperoni, mild sausage, mushrooms, yellow onions, and green peppers.

$16.29


Veggie Works Pizza

Mushrooms, yellow onions, green peppers, black olives, and tomatoes.

$16.29


Meat Works Pizza

Pepperoni, mild sausage, beef, Canadian bacon, and bacon.

$16.29


Bacon Cheeseburger Pizza

Beef, yellow onions, our mozzarella cheese blend, cheddar, and bacon. Served with pickles on the side.

$16.29


BBQ Chicken Pizza

BBQ sauce, chicken, yellow onions, our mozzarella cheese blend, cheddar, and bacon.

$16.29


Creamy Chicken Alfredo Pizza

Creamy alfredo sauce, extra diced chicken, fresh diced Roma tomatoes, mushrooms, and our mozzarella cheese blend.

$16.29


Creamy Garlic Chicken Pizza

Creamy garlic white sauce, diced chicken, red onions, Roma tomatoes, our mozzarella cheese blend, and crispy bacon.

$16.29


Baked Potato Pizza

Creamy alfredo sauce, our mozzarella cheese blend, cheddar, bacon, and now with potato fries.

$16.29


Mac & Cheese Pizza

Amazing 6-cheese mac & cheese, cut from whole bricks of cheese, topped with our mozzarella blend and baked to perfection on our pizza crust.

$16.29


Meatball & Potato Fry Pizza

Meatballs, our mozzarella cheese blend, cheddar, potato fries, and bacon - our original, now with potato fries.

$16.29


Feta One Pizza

Creamy garlic white sauce, fresh cut spinach, red onions, fresh diced Roma tomatoes, our mozzarella cheese blend, and feta.

$16.29


Taco Grande Pizza

Taco bean sauce, beef, and cheddar; topped with lettuce, taco chips, cheddar, diced Roma tomatoes, yellow onions, and black olives, with taco sauce packets on the side.

$16.29

appetizers
Appetizers

Garlic Bread Sticks

Oft oven-baked breadsticks brushed with butter and our special blend of garlic and two cheeses. Includes one serving of our pizza sauce.

$5.49


Cinnamon Twist Bread Sticks

Soft oven-baked breadsticks brushed with butter and our special blend of cinnamon and sugar. Includes one serving of creamy white icing.

$5.49


Half & Half Sticks

A split order of garlic and cinnamon twist breadsticks.

$7.29


Cheddar Cheese Bread

Brushed with butter and our special blend of garlic and spices. Smothered in a combination of six melted kinds of cheese. Includes one serving of our pizza sauce.

$7.49


Spinach Cheese Bread

Our traditional cheddar cheese bread with chopped, fresh-cut baby spinach instead of cheddar. Includes one serving of our pizza sauce.

$8.49


Garlic Toast

$1.09


Boneless Chicken Pieces

Natural chunks of breaded, baked white meat chicken mildly seasoned for kids or grown-ups. Served with a side of Frank's buffalo wing sauce, ranch, honey mustard, BBQ, Frank's sweet chili, our new cheddar cheese sauce, or our new Sweet Baby Ray’s garlic parm sauce.

$4.69


Boneless Hot Wings

Natural chunks of breaded, baked white meat chicken seasoned with hot paprika chili pepper for a punch.

$7.79


Spicy Srirarcha Chicken Bites

Sriracha seasoned, boneless chicken bites baked in sesame breading.

$7.79


Sauce on the Side

$0.59

salads
Salads

Side Salad

A crisp blend of iceberg and romaine lettuce, shaved radishes, red cabbage, and carrots. Topped with diced tomato. Croutons and choice of dressing on the side.

$4.69


Chicken, Spinach & Feta Salad

Fresh cut spinach topped with grilled chicken, diced tomato, and feta. Served with croutons and your choice of dressing on the side. Tastes great with ranch.

$7.29


Columbus Salad

A garden-fresh blend of iceberg and romaine lettuce, shaved radishes, red cabbage, and carrots, topped with diced Roma tomato, crumbled cheddar, and real bacon. Served with croutons and your choice of dressing on the side.

$7.79

sandwiches
Sandwiches
Sandwiches are oven-toasted and served with harvest cheddar sun chips and pickles.

Honey Mustard Chicken Sandwich

Grilled chicken breast strips and hickory smoked bacon topped with crisp lettuce, fresh tomato, melted cheese, and Stephen’s favorite honey mustard dressing.

$7.49


BBQ Chicken Sandwich

Grilled chicken breast strips and hickory smoked bacon smothered with melted cheddar, sweet BBQ sauce and sprinkled with diced yellow onion.

$7.49


Ranch Chicken Sandwich

Grilled chicken breast strips, topped with fresh lettuce, tomato, and creamy ranch dressing.

$7.49


Meatball Sandwich

12 meatballs with hearty sauce and mozzarella cheese.

$7.49


Italian Beef Sandwich

Shaved Italian beef, green pepper, and yellow onion smothered in melted cheese. Served with au jus.

$7.49


Bacon, Lettuce & Tomato Sandwich

Hickory smoked bacon, crisp lettuce, tomatoes, and dressing toasted just right in our pizza oven.

$7.49


Pepperoni Melt Sandwich

Pepperoni and Canadian bacon under a hearty sauce smothered with melted mozzarella and cheddar.

$7.49

pasta
Pasta

Baked Mac & Cheese

Our amazing, 6-cheese mac & cheese, made right here in our kitchen. Inspired by Miss Sandy’sfamous mac & cheese, we use only Real Wisconsin Cheeses, with 0 grams of trans fat per serving.

$6.29


Lasagna Dinner

Pan of homestyle, oven baked lasagna served with garlic breadsticks or six slices of garlic toast.

$22.89


Lasagna

The single portion served with a slice of garlic toast.

$6.29


Baked Pasta Dinner

Pan of baked penne noodles with sauce, spicy Italian sausage, yellow onions, green peppers, and two melted kinds of cheese.sprinkle with basil. Served with garlic breadsticks six slices of garlic toast. Also available meatless.

$22.89

beverages
Beverages

Soda

$1.89

SliceWIColumbus53925 Day One Pizza
Price: $$