Papa's Italian Restaurant
132 W Main St, Florence, CO 81226719-784-7888View Full Hours$0 MinimumMenu
Pizza
Authentic New York style, hand-tossed pizza. Topped with a four cheese blend & your choice of marinara or our signature white sauce.
Cheese Pizza$949+
Marinara sauce and a blend of mozzarella cheese, provolone cheese, romano cheese & parmesan cheese. Classic cheese or create your own pizza.
Custom Creation Pizza with Four Toppings$1199
With your choice of our signature sauces.
Custom Creation Pizza with One Topping$1349
With your choice of our signature sauces.
Gluten Free Pizza$1549
With up to four toppings, and your choice of our signature sauces. Prepared in an environment where gluten is present.
Specialty Pizza
Authentic New York style, hand-tossed pizza. Topped with a four cheese blend & your choice of marinara or our signature white sauce.
Pepperoni Pizza$1049+
Pepperoni, marinara sauce & four cheese blend.
Supreme Pizza$1239+
Sausage, pepperoni, olives, green peppers, mushrooms, onions, marinara sauce & four cheese blend
Southwest Sausage Pizza$1199+
By popular demand sausage, Pueblo green chile, green peppers, onions, garlic & four cheese blend.
White Wedding Pizza$1199+
Chicken, bacon, artichoke hearts, spinach, signature white sauce & four cheese blend.
Carnivore Pizza$1249+
Eat it before it eats you! Sausage, pepperoni, hamburger, Canadian bacon, bacon, marinara sauce & four cheese blend!
Florence Med Pizza$1219+
Spinach, olives, onions, artichoke hearts, tomatoes, garlic, feta cheese, signature white sauce & four cheese blend.
Hawaiian Pizza$1099+
Surf's up! Canadian bacon, pineapple, marinara sauce & four cheese blend.
White Rabbit Pizza$1219+
Spinach, onions, mushrooms, green peppers, Roma tomatoes, garlic, signature white sauce & four cheese blend.
Margherita Pizza$1099+
Roma tomatoes, fresh basil, marinara sauce & four cheese blend.
Du Jour Pizza$1199+
Ask your server about our pizza du jour! A specialty pizza from the creative souls of our chefs.
Pizza by the Slice
Cheese Pizza Slice$269
Pepperoni Pizza Slice$269
Du Jour Pizza Slice$299
Supreme Pizza Slice$299
Appetizers
From garlic knots to nachos, serving you classic Italian choices & other delicious favorites.
Garlic Knots$569
A papa's favorite! Warm, delicious knotted bread slathered in our signature white sauce, topped with fresh roasted garlic & parmesan cheese.
Boom Sticks with Cheese Only$499
Boom Sticks$659
Hot, fresh bread stuffed with jalapenos, mozzarella cheese & bacon.
Pretzel Bites$549
Soft, warm & salty bites with mild spicy cheese dipping sauce. Perfect for sharing!
Breadsticks$499
Baked to golden perfection & topped with our signature white sauce & parmesan cheese. Your choice of marinara sauce or ranch dipping sauce.
Stuffed Mushrooms$579
Tasty sausage, cheese, onions, garlic, oregano and other spices.
Unloaded Nachos$449
Loaded Nachos$799
Crispy chips with cheese sauce loaded with hamburger, green peppers, onions, olives and Pueblo green chiles.
Meatball Sliders$899
Handmade meatballs nestled in a garlic knot & topped with melted cheese.
Boba Feta$639
Hot, fresh bread stuffed with feta cheese, mozzarella cheese and spinach.
Soups
Soup of The Day$629
Hot, homemade, heavenly! Please call the restaurant for today's selection.
Salads
Made with baby spinach & romaine lettuce, red, green & dark leaf lettuce.
Side Salad$429
Topped with cheese, tomatoes & onions.
Supreme Salad$869
Great for sharing! Topped with cheese, onions, green peppers, mushrooms, olives & mozzarella cheese.
Antipasto Salad$649+
Topped with pepperoni, Canadian bacon, artichoke hearts, green peppers, olives, onions & cheese.
Calzones
Hand-tossed dough wrapped around our freshest ingredients and baked to golden perfection. Includes a side of marinara sauce.
Carnivore Calzone$1199
Sausage, pepperoni, Canadian bacon, hamburger, marinara sauce & four cheese blend.
Supreme Calzone$1149
Sausage, pepperoni, olives, green peppers, mushrooms, onions, marinara sauce & four cheese blend.
White Rabbit Calzone$1099
Spinach, mushrooms, green peppers, onions, garlic, Italian seasoning & signature white sauce.
Caprese Calzone$1049
Spinach, onions, tomatoes, mushrooms, basil & four cheese blend. Drizzled with balsamic dressing.
Customer Creation Calzone$1199
Create your perfect calzone! Filled with choice of marinara sauce or our signature white sauce and up to four fillings.
Zeppelins
8'' Toasted hoagie rolls with specialty fillings. Served with small side salad.
Colorado Chicken Philly Zeppelin$849
Chicken, Pueblo green chiles, onions, green peppers & cheese sauce.
Chicken Parmesan Zeppelin$849
Chicken, green peppers, marinara sauce, & parmesan cheese.
Meatballs Zeppelin$849
Grandma Bruno’s meatballs, marinara sauce & parmesan cheese.
Deli Zeppelin$849
Pepperoni, Canadian bacon, lettuce. tomatoes, onions, mayo, pepperoncini & cheese. Drizzled with Italian dressing.
Pasta Dishes
Served with side salad & a garlic knot.
The Feisty Sicilian$1249
Angel hair noodles topped with grandma Bruno's secret spaghetti sauce & hearty serving of meatballs. Mangia! Mangia!
Pasta with Veggies$1099
Angel hair noodles, choice of specialty white or red sauce and sauteed fresh veggies.
Fettuccine Alfredo$1099
Creamy, rich alfredo sauce sleeping with a garlic knot on a fettuccine bed.
Kids Menu
For kid's 12 years old & under.
Kid's Pouch of Delicious Treasures$649
Mini calzone with up to three toppings.
Kid's Cables & Globes$649
Angel hair noodles with two meatballs. Choose from signature white or marinara sauce.
Kid's Fountain Drink$159
Kid's Juice$199
Kid's Chocolate Milk$199
Kid's Milk$199
Desserts
Zeppolis$599
Cinnamon & sugar italian mini-donuts, caramel-drizzled. Deliciousness!
Ice Cream by the Scoop$169+
with your choice of flavor.
Brownie Sundae$579
Two scoops of your favorite ice cream topped with brownie bites and whip cream & drizzled with chocolate syrup.
Beverages
Fountain Drinks$199+
Soda$229
Rocky Mountain Natural Soda$300
Italian Phizz$299
Flavor topped with whipped cream.
Milkshakes$399
Made with your choice of ice cream. A fantastically frozen delight!
Floats$389
Two scoops of ice cream in your favorite soda.
Water$100
Your Cart
ASAP Delivery
Update
We can’t tell if the restaurant delivers to your location unless you provide us with an address.
Edit Address
Your cart is empty. Select from the menu to start an order!
Let Us Help You
Pizzeria Owners
Grow your business with easy online ordering, personalized marketing, and larger orders more often. We list your menu on Slice for free!
