Skip to main content
Original Italian Pizza & Restaurant

Original Italian Pizza & Restaurant

1 Main St, Garnerville, NY 10923
845-305-6230

Open until 9:30 PM

Full Hours
  • 5% off online orders
Skip to first category
deals-and-coupons

Deals and Coupons

DealFeatured

Every Day #1

Feeds 5-6. Large pizza, garlic knots, 10 pieces of wings, zeppoles, & 2 liter soda.

$36.95

Deal

Big Game 3rd Down

Feeds 10-12. 1/2 tray of penne vodka, 1/2 tray of Chicken wings, 1/2 tray of mozzarella sticks, & 1.2 tray macaroni salad.

$165

new-york-style-pizza

New York Style Pizza

All pizzas can be made thin square or deep dish (only large size) for an additional charge.

Cheese Pizza

Tomato sauce, oregano & mozzarella cheese.

$13.99

Cauliflower Pizza

$16.99

Sicilian Pizza

$23.99

Sicilian Pizza

Gluten Free Pizza

$18.99

gourmet-pizza

Gourmet Pizza

All pizzas can be made thin square or deep dish (only large size) for an additional charge.

Grandma Pizza

Marinara sauce, fresh mozzarella, basil and oregano.

$18.99

Chipotle Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza

Chicken, bacon, ranch, chipotle sauce, lettuce & tomatoes.

$18.99

White Pizza

Mozzarella cheese topped with ricotta cheese.

$18.99

BBQ Chicken Pizza

Chicken cutlet tossed in BBQ sauce and mozzarella cheese.

$18.99

Veggie Pizza

Green peppers, mushrooms, broccoli, tomatoes, spinach and onions.

$18.99

Chicken Parmigiana Pizza

Chicken cutlet with marinara and mozzarella cheese.

$18.99

Ravioli Vodka Pizza

Ravioli mixed with vodka sauce topped with mozzarella cheese.

$18.99

Buffalo Chicken Pizza

Chicken cutlet mixed with buffalo sauce topped with mozzarella.

$18.99

Taco Pizza

Ground beef, lettuce, tomato, sour cream, cheddar cheese, and salsa.

$18.99

Fresca Pizza

Zucchini, tomatoes, onions & fresh mozzarella.

$18.99

Garlic Chicken Parm Pizza

Chicken cutlet, garlic parm sauce, & mozzarella cheese.

$18.99

Meat Lovers Pizza

Pepperoni, bacon, sausage and meatball topped with mozzarella cheese.

$18.99

Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza

Chicken cutlet, bacon, mozzarella cheese topped with ranch.

$18.99

Penne Vodka Pizza

Penne with our house vodka sauce topped with mozzarella cheese.

$18.99

Chicken & Broccoli Pizza

Chicken cutlet, broccoli, fresh mozzarella.

$18.99

OIP Salad Pizza

Romaine lettuce, black olives, mushrooms, tomatoes, onions, fresh mozzarella, parmesan cheese & balsamic.

$18.99

Heathers Vodka Pizza

Creamy vodka sauce, fresh mozzarella and basil.

$18.99

Hawaiian Pizza

Ham. pineapple, marinara sauce and mozzarella cheese.

$18.99

Bruschetta Pizza

Sauteed tomatoes, fresh mozzarella and chopped onions.

$18.99

Cheese Steak Pizza

Philly cheese steak, onions, mozzarella & American cheese.

$18.99

Chicken Vodka Pizza

Chicken cutlet vodka sauce and mozzarella cheese.

$18.99

Hot Honey Pepperoni Pizza

Pepperoni, mozzarella cheese, marinara & hot honey sauce.

$18.99

Stuffed Teriyaki Cheese Steak Pizza

Cheese steak, teriyaki sauce, & mozzarella cheese.

$30.95

Sweet Chili Chicken Pizza

Chicken cutlet, our secret sweet chili sauce & mozzarella cheese.

$18.99

cauliflower-gourmet-pizza

Cauliflower Gourmet Pizza

Cauliflower White Pizza

Mozzarella cheese topped with ricotta cheese.

$20.99

Cauliflower BBQ Chicken Pizza

Chicken cutlet tossed in BBQ sauce and mozzarella cheese.

$20.99

Cauliflower Veggie Pizza

Green peppers, mushrooms, broccoli, tomatoes, spinach and onions.

$20.99

Cauliflower Chicken Parmigiana Pizza

Chicken cutlet with marinara and mozzarella cheese.

$20.99

Cauliflower Ravioli Vodka Pizza

Ravioli mixed with vodka sauce topped with mozzarella cheese.

$20.99

Cauliflower Buffalo Chicken Pizza

Chicken cutlet mixed with buffalo sauce topped with mozzarella.

$20.99

Cauliflower Taco Pizza

Ground beef, lettuce, tomato, sour cream, cheddar cheese, and salsa.

$20.99

Cauliflower Fresca Pizza

Zucchini, tomatoes, onions & fresh mozzarella.

$20.99

Cauliflower Garlic Chicken Parm Pizza

Chicken cutlet, garlic parm sauce, & mozzarella cheese.

$20.99

Cauliflower Meat Lovers Pizza

Pepperoni, bacon, sausage and meatball topped with mozzarella cheese.

$20.99

Cauliflower Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza

Chicken cutlet, bacon, mozzarella cheese topped with ranch.

$20.99

Cauliflower Penne Vodka Pizza

Penne with our house vodka sauce topped with mozzarella cheese.

$20.99

Cauliflower Chicken & Broccoli Pizza

Chicken cutlet, broccoli, fresh mozzarella.

$20.99

Cauliflower OIP Salad Pizza

Romaine lettuce, black olives, mushrooms, tomatoes, onions, fresh mozzarella, parmesan cheese & balsamic.

$20.99

Cauliflower Heathers Vodka Pizza

Creamy vodka sauce, fresh mozzarella and basil.

$20.99

Cauliflower Hawaiian Pizza

Ham. pineapple, marinara sauce and mozzarella cheese.

$20.99

Cauliflower Bruschetta Pizza

Sauteed tomatoes, fresh mozzarella and chopped onions.

$20.99

Cauliflower Cheese Steak Pizza

Philly cheese steak, onions, mozzarella & American cheese.

$20.99

Cauliflower Chicken Vodka Pizza

Chicken cutlet vodka sauce and mozzarella cheese.

$20.99

Cauliflower Hot Honey Pepperoni Pizza

Pepperoni, mozzarella cheese, marinara & hot honey sauce.

$20.99

Cauliflower Chipotle Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza

Chicken, bacon, ranch, chipotle sauce, lettuce & tomatoes.

$20.99

Cauliflower Sweet Chili Chicken Pizza

Chicken cutlet, our secret sweet chili sauce & mozzarella cheese.

$20.99

gluten-free-gourmet-pizza

Gluten Free Gourmet Pizza

Gluten Free White Pizza

Mozzarella cheese topped with ricotta cheese.

$22.99

Gluten Free BBQ Chicken Pizza

Chicken cutlet tossed in BBQ sauce and mozzarella cheese.

$22.99

Gluten Free Veggie Pizza

Green peppers, mushrooms, broccoli, tomatoes, spinach and onions.

$22.99

Gluten Free Chicken Parmigiana Pizza

Chicken cutlet with marinara and mozzarella cheese.

$22.99

Gluten Free Ravioli Vodka Pizza

Ravioli mixed with vodka sauce topped with mozzarella cheese.

$22.99

Gluten Free Buffalo Chicken Pizza

Chicken cutlet mixed with buffalo sauce topped with mozzarella.

$22.99

Gluten Free Taco Pizza

Ground beef, lettuce, tomato, sour cream, cheddar cheese, and salsa.

$22.99

Gluten Free Fresca Pizza

Zucchini, tomatoes, onions & fresh mozzarella.

$22.99

Gluten Free Garlic Chicken Parm Pizza

Chicken cutlet, garlic parm sauce, & mozzarella cheese.

$22.99

Gluten Free Meat Lovers Pizza

Pepperoni, bacon, sausage and meatball topped with mozzarella cheese.

$22.99

Gluten Free Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza

Chicken cutlet, bacon, mozzarella cheese topped with ranch.

$22.99

Gluten Free Penne Vodka Pizza

Penne with our house vodka sauce topped with mozzarella cheese.

$22.99

Gluten Free Chicken & Broccoli Pizza

Chicken cutlet, broccoli, fresh mozzarella.

$22.99

Gluten Free OIP Salad Pizza

Romaine lettuce, black olives, mushrooms, tomatoes, onions, fresh mozzarella, parmesan cheese & balsamic.

$22.99

Gluten Free Heathers Vodka Pizza

Creamy vodka sauce, fresh mozzarella and basil.

$22.99

Gluten Free Hawaiian Pizza

Ham. pineapple, marinara sauce and mozzarella cheese.

$22.99

Gluten Free Bruschetta Pizza

Sauteed tomatoes, fresh mozzarella and chopped onions.

$22.99

Gluten Free Cheese Steak Pizza

Philly cheese steak, onions, mozzarella & American cheese.

$22.99

Gluten Free Chicken Vodka Pizza

Chicken cutlet vodka sauce and mozzarella cheese.

$22.99

Gluten Free Hot Honey Pepperoni Pizza

Pepperoni, mozzarella cheese, marinara & hot honey sauce.

$22.99

Gluten Free Chipotle Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza

Chicken, bacon, ranch, chipotle sauce, lettuce & tomatoes.

$22.99

Gluten Free Sweet Chili Chicken Pizza

Chicken cutlet, our secret sweet chili sauce & mozzarella cheese.

$22.99

pizza-by-the-slice

Pizza by the Slice

Cheese Pizza Slice

$3.70

Gourmet Pizza Slice

$4.85

Sicilian Pizza Slice

$4.25

Deep Dish Gourmet Pizza Slice

$4.95

One Topping Pizza Slice

$4.50

appetizers

Appetizers

Mussels

$16.99

Boneless Wings

$14.99

Fried Calamari

$14.99

Onion Rings

$7.99

Garlic Knots

$5.99

Mozzarella Sticks

$10.99

Garlic Bread

$6.99

Rice Ball

$8.99

Garlic Bread with Mozzarella Cheese

$6.99

Meatballs

$8.99

Chicken Tenders

$11.99

Sausage

$8.99

French Fries

$6.99

Fried Ravioli

$12.99

Curly Fries

$8.99

Jalapeno Poppers

$8.99

Garlic Fries

$8.99

Zucchini Sticks

$10.99

Chicken Wings

$15.99

soups

Soups

Chicken Soup

Chicken, fresh vegetables, and pasta in homemade chicken broth.

$6.95

Chicken Soup

Lentil Soup

Freshly cooked savory lentil soup.

$6.95

Pasta Fagioli Soup

Ditalini pasta, white cannellini beans, olive oil, onions, and seasonings simmered to perfection!

$6.95

Seafood Soup

$9.95

Italian Wedding Soup

Traditional Italian soup filled with green veggies and meat.

$6.95

salads

Salads

Available from 2:00 PM - 10:00 PM

House Salad

Iceberg lettuce, tomato, onion, cucumber & black olives.

$11.99

OIP Salad

Romaine lettuce, olives, tomatoes, red onions, mushrooms, fresh mozzarella, parmesan cheese.

$13.99

OIP Salad

Caesar Salad

Romaine lettuce, Caesar dressing, parmesan cheese & croutons.

$12.99

Buffalo Chicken Salad

Buffalo chicken, tomatoes and onions.

$15.99

Buffalo Chicken Salad

Caprese Salad

Fresh mozzarella, tomato, basil & olive oil.

$15.99

Caprese Salad

Greek Salad

Mixed greens, tomatoes, cucumbers, red onions, red peppers, kalamata olives, & feta cheese served with balsamic dressing.

$13.99

Eggplant Salad

House salad with eggplant, fresh mozzarella, and roasted red peppers.

$15.99

sliders

Sliders

Chicken Parm Slider

$6.99

Pepperoni Slider

$6.99

Grilled Chicken Slider

$6.99

Teriyaki Cheese Steak Slider

$6.99

Buffalo Chicken Slider

$6.99

Chicken Ala Vodka Slider

$6.99

Eggplant Slider

$6.99

Chicken Bacon Ranch Slider

$6.99

Eggplant Parm Slider

$6.99

calzones-strombolis

Calzones & Strombolis

Cheese Calzone

Mozzarella & ricotta cheese.

$9.99

Family Stromboli

Ham, salami, pepperoni, mozzarella & ricotta cheese.

$44.95

Stromboli

Ham, salami, sausage & mozzarella cheese.

$8.99

Stromboli
rolls

Rolls

Broccoli Roll

Broccoli, mozzarella, garlic & oil.

$7.99

Spinach Roll

Spinach, mozzarella cheese, garlic & oil.

$7.99

Sausage Roll

Ham, salami, pepperoni & mozzarella cheese.

$8.99

Buffalo Chicken Roll

Buffalo chicken mozzarella cheese.

$8.99

Chicken Roll

Chicken cutlet, marinara & mozzarella cheese.

$7.99

paninis

Paninis

All paninis served with fries or macaroni salad.

Grilled Chicken Panini

Grilled chicken, fresh mozzarella & roasted red peppers.

$13.99

Grilled Chicken Panini

Eggplant & Swiss Panini

Fried eggplant, Swiss & spinach.

$13.99

Buffalo Chicken Panini

Buffalo chicken cutlet, lettuce, tomatoes & fresh mozzarella.

$13.99

hot-heros

Hot Heros

Chicken Parmigiana Hero

Chicken cutlet, marinara sauce & mozzarella cheese.

$13.99

Chicken Parmigiana Hero

San Antonio Hero

Chicken cutlet, bacon, secret house BBQ sauce & mozzarella cheese.

$13.99

Chicken Vodka Hero

Chicken cutlet, vodka sauce, & mozzarella cheese.

$13.99

Santa Fe Hero

Chicken cutlet, bacon, Russian dressing & American cheese.

$13.99

Meatball Parm Hero

Meatball, marinara sauce & mozzarella cheese.

$13.99

Shrimp Parm Hero

Shrimp, marinara sauce & mozzarella cheese.

$13.99

Eggplant Parm Hero

Fried eggplant, marinara sauce & mozzarella cheese.

$13.99

Veal Parm Hero

Veal, marinara sauce & mozzarella cheese.

$13.99

Philly Cheese Steak Hero

Steak, onions & American cheese.

$13.99

Chicken Avocado Hero

Grilled chicken, lettuce, bacon, tomato, avocado, Swiss & mayo.

$13.99

Godfather Hero

Broccoli rabe in garlic & oil, fresh mozzarella cheese & grilled chicken.

$13.99

Chicken Bacon Ranch Hero

Grilled chicken, bacon, ranch & mozzarella cheese.

$13.99

Bella Chicken Hero

Grilled chicken, fresh mozzarella, roasted red peppers, olive oil & balsamic vinaigrette.

$13.99

Buffalo Chicken Hero

Chicken cutlet, & fresh mozzarella cheese tossed in buffalo sauce.

$13.99

cold-heros

Cold Heros

Now using Boars head.

Italian Combo Hero

Ham, salami, provolone, lettuce, tomato & onion.

$12.99

Chicken Cutlet Hero

Chicken cutlet, lettuce, tomato, mayo & American cheese.

$12.99

Turkey Hero

Turkey, lettuce, tomato, mayo & American cheese.

$12.99

Grilled Chicken Hero

Grilled chicken, fresh mozzarella & roasted red peppers.

$12.99

wraps

Wraps

The God Mother Wrap

Broccoli rabe in garlic, fresh mozzarella & grilled chicken.

$13.99

Southern Wrap

Grilled chicken, bacon, avocado, tomato, Swiss cheese & mayo.

$13.99

Greek Wrap

Grilled chicken, arugula, red onions, feta cheese & black olives.

$13.99

Pesto Wrap

Grilled chicken, fresh mozzarella & roasted red peppers tossed in pesto sauce.

$13.99

Turkey Club Wrap

Turkey, bacon, lettuce, tomato, & mayo.

$13.99

Chicken Cutlet Wrap

Chicken cutlet, lettuce, tomato, mayo & American cheese.

$13.99

Eggplant Wrap

Fried eggplant, fresh mozzarella, roasted red peppers & prosciutto.

$13.99

Sweet Chili Wrap

Grilled chicken, fresh mozzarella, & cilantro tossed in sweet chili.

$13.99

pasta-dishes

Pasta Dishes

All dinners served with salad & bread.

Pasta with Marinara

Smothered in our homemade marinara.

$16.99

Ravioli

Cheese ravioli with marinara sauce.

$16.99

Penne Vodka

Penne in our homemade vodka sauce.

$16.99

Ravioli ala Vodka

Cheese ravioli with vodka sauce.

$16.99

Fettuccine Alfredo

Fettuccine tossed with butter and parmesan cheese.

$16.99

Cavatelli with Broccoli Rabe, Garlic & Oil

Cavatelli pasta in garlic & oil.

$16.99

Baked Ziti

Penne pasta in house made marinara with melted mozzarella.

$16.99

Gnocchi ala Vodka

Potato pasta and our house made vodka sauce.

$16.99

Lasagna

With ground beef, ricotta cheese, melted mozzarella and marinara sauce.

$16.99

Tortellini Alfredo

Tortellini pasta & home made Alfredo sauce.

$16.99

entrees

Entrees

All dinner entrees served with bread, side salad & pasta.

Chicken Parmigiana

Chicken cutlet with homemade marinara sauce.

$22.95

Chicken Marsala

Made with our homemade brown gravy with fresh mushrooms.

$22.95

Chicken Alla Vodka

Chicken parm smothered in our homemade vodka sauce.

$22.95

Eggplant Parmigiana

Breaded eggplant in house marinara topped with shredded mozzarella cheese.

$22.95

Chicken Francese

Chicken parm smothered in our homemade francese sauce.

$22.95

Eggplant Rollatini

Breaded eggplant rolled in ricotta cheese topped with marinara sauce.

$22.95

Chicken Alfredo

Chicken cutlet in our house made creamy Alfredo sauce topped with parsley.

$22.95

Veal Parm

Veal breaded in marinara sauce topped with mozzarella cheese.

$22.95

seafood

Seafood

All dinner entrees served with bread, salad & pasta.

Shrimp Scampi

Shrimp with a garlic, white wine and butter sauce.

$22.99

Shrimp Parmigiana

Shrimp with our homemade marinara over penne.

$22.99

Shrimp Alfredo

Shrimp over penne with our homemade Alfredo sauce.

$22.99

Seafood Fra Diablo

Mussels, calamari & shrimp over spaghetti.

$22.99

kids-menu

Kids Menu

Kid's Chicken Fingers & Fries

Delicious chicken fingers.

$10.99

Kid's Baked Ziti

$10.99

Kid's Mozzarella Sticks & Fries

$10.99

Kid's Penne Vodka

$10.99

desserts

Desserts

Cannoli

Delicious tube of fried dough, filled with a sweet, creamy ricotta filling.

$4.25

Cannoli

Red Velvet Cake

$4.75

Brownie

Decadent chocolate brownie topped with chocolate frosting.

$3.95

Brownie

Oreo Cake

$4.75

Zeppoles

Crispy on the outside, yet light and fluffy on the inside. These mini Italian donut holes will become your new fave.

$6.99

Nutella Zeppoles

$10.99

Key Lime Pie

$4.75

Cannoli Zeppoles

$10.99

Tiramisu

$4.75

beverages

Beverages

Arizona

$1.75

Arizona

Snapple

Snapple small bottle.

$2.85

Snapple

Water

$1.50

Gatorade

$2.95

Soda

$2.85

Soda
lunch-salads

Lunch Salads

Only available 10:00 AM - 2:00 PM

House Salad Lunch

Iceberg lettuce, tomatoes, onions, cucumbers, black olives.

$8.99

OIP Salad Lunch

Romaine lettuce, olives, tomatoes, red onions, mushrooms, fresh mozzarella & parmesan cheese.

$10.99

Caesar Salad Lunch

Romaine lettuce, Caesar dressing, parmesan cheese & croutons.

$9.99

Buffalo Chicken Salad Lunch

Buffalo chicken, tomatoes and onions.

$12.99

Caprese Salad Lunch

Fresh mozzarella, tomato, basil & olive oil.

$11.99

Greek Salad Lunch

Arugula, red onions, cucumber, feta cheese, tomato & balsamic.

$10.99

Eggplant Salad Lunch

House salad with eggplant, fresh mozzarella and roasted red peppers.

$11.99

lunch-pasta-dishes

Lunch Pasta Dishes

Only available 10:00 AM - 2:00 PM
Lunch portions served with bread.

Pasta with Marinara Lunch

Smothered in our homemade marinara.

$12.99

Ravioli Lunch

Cheese ravioli with marinara sauce.

$12.99

Penne Vodka Lunch

Penne in our homemade vodka sauce.

$12.99

Ravioli ala Vodka Lunch

Cheese ravioli with vodka sauce.

$12.99

Fettuccine Alfredo Lunch

Fettuccine tossed with butter and parmesan cheese.

$12.99

Cavatelli with Broccoli Rabe, Garlic & Oil Lunch

Cavatelli pasta in garlic & oil.

$12.99

Baked Ziti Lunch

Penne pasta in house made marinara with melted mozzarella.

$12.99

Gnocchi ala Vodka Lunch

Potato pasta and our home made vodka sauce.

$12.99

Lasagna Lunch

With ground beef, ricotta cheese, melted mozzarella and marinara sauce.

$12.99

Tortellini Alfredo Lunch

Tortellini pasta & home made Alfredo sauce.

$12.99

lunch-entrees

Lunch Entrees

Only available 10:00 AM - 2:00 PM
Lunch portions served with bread.

Chicken Parmigiana Lunch

Chicken cutlet with homemade marinara sauce.

$14.99

Chicken Marsala Lunch

Made with our homemade brown gravy with fresh mushrooms.

$14.99

Chicken Alla Vodka Lunch

Chicken parm smothered in our homemade vodka sauce.

$14.99

Eggplant Parmigiana Lunch

Breaded eggplant in house marinara topped with shredded mozzarella cheese.

$14.99

Chicken Francese Lunch

Chicken parm smothered in our homemade francese sauce.

$14.99

Eggplant Rollatini Lunch

Breaded eggplant rolled in ricotta cheese topped with marinara sauce.

$14.99

Chicken Alfredo Lunch

Chicken cutlet in our house made creamy Alfredo sauce topped with parsley.

$14.99

Veal Parmigiana Lunch

Veal breaded in marinara sauce topped with mozzarella cheese.

$14.99

Original Italian Pizza & Restaurant - View Menu & Order Online - 1 Main St, Garnerville, NY 10923 - Slice

SliceNYGarnerville10923 Original Italian Pizza & Restaurant
Price: $$