Magic Pies
Sweet Caroline Whole Pie
$34.99
My Michelle Whole Pie
$37.99
Bianca Pie
$34.99
Upside Down Pie
$28.99
Caprese Pie
$37.99
Lady Whole Pie
$34.99
Cecilia Pie
$34.99
Heart Shaped Pizza Valentines Days
$29.99
Emily Pie
$34.99
Upside Down Vodka Pepperoni Pie
$34.99
Rhiannon Pie
$41.99
Roxanne Whole Pie
$37.99
Veronica Pie
$34.99
Eva Whole Pie
$34.99
Vodka Pie
$34.99
Nikita Whole Pie
$34.99
Gloria Whole Pie
$34.99
Rosalita Whole Pie
$41.99
My Sharona Pie
$37.99
Eleanor Rigby Whole Pie
$34.99
Brooklyn Style Round with Pepperoni Pie
$29.99
Layla Whole Pie
$37.99
Proud Mary Whole Pie
$28.99
Stella Whole Pie
$34.99
Janie's Got a Gun Pie
$34.99
Sheena Whole Pie
$37.99
Brooklyn Style Round Pie
$22.99
American Girl Pie
$37.99
Angie Pie
$41.99
Mrs. Robinson Whole Pie
$37.99
Beth Pie
$41.99
Magic Pie Slices
Rosalita Pizza Slice
$9.99
Brooklyn Style Round Pizza Slice
$3.99
My Michelle Pizza Slice
$9.99
Mrs. Robinson Pizza Slice
$8.99
My Sharona Pizza Slice
$9.99
Gloria Pizza Slice
$6.99
Veronica Pizza Slice
$6.99
Eva Pizza Slice
$6.99
Upside Down with Pepperoni Pizza Slice
$5.99
Nikita Pizza Slice
$6.99
Stella Pizza Slice
$6.99
Angie Pizza Slice
$9.99
Rhiannon Pizza Slice
$9.99
Janie's Got a Gun Pizza Slice
$6.99
Eleanor Rigby Pizza Slice
$6.99
Cecilia Pizza Slice
$6.99
Layla Pizza Slice
$8.99
Bianca Pizza Slice
$6.99
Lady Pizza Slice
$6.99
Proud Mary Pizza Slice
$4.99
Sheena Pizza Slice
$9.99
Roxanne Pizza Slice
$8.99
Gluten Free Pies
Gluten Free Angie Pie
$29.99
Gluten Free Gloria Pie
$36.99
Gluten Free Emily Pie
$29.99
Gluten Free Janie's Got a Gun Pie
$35.99
Gluten Free Mrs. Robinson Pie
$29.99
Gluten Free Lady Pie
$35.99
Gluten Free Hey Delilah Pie
$36.99
Gluten Free Stella Pie
$34.99
Gluten Free Upside Down Pie
$33.99
Gluten Free Pepperoni Pie
$31.99
Gluten Free My Sharona Pie
$34.99
Gluten Free Rosalita Pie
$29.99
Gluten Free Proud Mary Pie
$28.99
Gluten Free Roxanne Pie
$24.99
Gluten Free Sheena Pie
$34.99
Gluten Free Sweet Caroline Pie
$24.99
Gluten Free Nikita Pie
$34.99
Gluten Free Caprese Pie
$29.99
Gluten Free Beth Pie
$29.99
Gluten Free Eleanor Rigby Pie
$29.99
Gluten Free Cecilia Pie
$29.99
Gluten Free Veronica Pie
$24.99
Gluten Free Eva Pie
$29.99
Gluten Free Bianca Pie
$29.99
Salads
Original Greek Salad
$18.99
House Salad
$16.99
Nonna's Favorite Salad
$18.99
Classic Caesar Salad
$16.99
Caprese Salad
$17.99
Sides
Fried Chicken Cutlet
$11.99
Garlic Bread
$7.99
Mozzarella Sticks
$14.99
Mac n' Cheese Side
$14.99
Fried Ravioli
$17.99
Grilled Chicken
$11.99
Eggplant Rollatini
$13.99
Truffle Mac & Cheese
$19.99
Sausage & Peppers Side
$13.99
Nonna's Famous Meatballs
$13.99
The Bomb Parm
Cecilia Parm
$22.99
The Bomb Parm on Individual House Salad
$24.99
Eva Parm
$22.99
The Bomb Parm On Hero Bread
$18.99
Janie's Got a Gun Parm
$22.99
The Bomb Parm On Pasta
$24.99
The Bomb Parm on Caesar Salad
$24.99
Pasta
Pasta With Sauce
$18.99
Chicken Marsala With Spaghetti
$22.99
Pasta With Oil & Garlic
$18.99
Spaghetti Bolognese
$22.99
Penne alla Vodka
$20.99
Baked Ziti
$22.99
Spaghetti & Meatballs
$25.99
Desserts
Tiramisu
$9.99
Chocolate Brownie with Nuts
$9.99
Chocolate Mousse
$9.99
Italian Cheesecake
$9.99
Drinks
Diet Coke
$4.99
Boylans Root Beer
$5.99
Coke
$4.99
Hal’s Seltzer Assorted Flavors
$5.99
Sprite
$4.99
Martinelli 100% Apple Juice
$5.99
Poppi Assorted Flavors
$5.99
Water
$2.99