Skip to main content
72nd Eatery

72nd Eatery

261 Columbus Ave, New York, NY 10023
212-721-7800

Order Ahead We open at 7:00 AM

Full Hours
  • 5% off online orders
Skip to first category
your-favorite-sandwiches

Your Favorite Sandwiches

Smoked Turkey Melt

Grilled Vegetable Ratatouille, Melted Swiss cheese and Pesto Mayo on Focaccia Bread.

$12.95

Pico De Gallo Chicken

Grilled Chicken, Cheddar, Avocado, Lettuce, Tomato with Herb Mayo on Sourdough Bread.

$12.95

Sierra Turkey

Fresh Roasted Turkey with Pepper Jack Cheese and South Western Chipotle sauce on Five Grain Bread.

$12.95

Traditional Tuna Salad

White Albacore Tuna tossed with Mayo and Celery. Topped with Roasted Red Peppers, Plum Tomatoes and Leaf Lettuce. Served on a Whole Grain Baguette.

$12.95

Italian Club

Turkey Ham, Genoa Salami, Provolone Cheese, Red Onion, Garlic and Aioli on Napolitano Italian Bread.

$12.95

California Turkey Pita

Smoked Turkey with Avocado, Tomato, Sprouts, Cucumber and Lemon Herb Dressing on a Whole Wheat Pita. Low-Cal.

$12.95

Chicken Milano

Charbroiled Chicken Breast with Fresh Mozzarella and Pesto Mayo on Romano Focaccia.

$12.95

All Natural Turkey Pita

Smoked Turkey with Tomatoes and Organic Mesclun Greens, Low Fat Mayo on a Whole Wheat Pita. Low-Cal.

$12.95

Cubano

Roasted Ham, Fresh Turkey, Swiss Cheese, Dill Pickle chips and Russian Dressing on Crespino Flat Bread.

$12.95

Tuna Pita

White Albacore Tuna Salad Sliced Tomatoes, Mixed Greens on a Whole Wheat Pita. Low-Cal.

$12.95

Tuscan Melt

Fresh Mozzarella, Tomatoes and Fresh Basil with Pesto Mayo on Napoli Flat Bread.

$12.95

Hickory Smoked Turkey Pita

Smoked Turkey, Green Leaf Lettuce, Plum Tomato with Honey Mustard on a Whole wheat Pita. Low-Cal.

$12.95

Tuna Melt

Albacore Tuna Salad with Roasted Red Peppers and American Cheese on Five Grain Whole Wheat Flat Bread.

$12.95

Our Gourmet Suggestion

Imported Smoked Norwegian Salmon with Chive Cream Cheese and Cucumber on Russian Black Bread.

$12.95

Grilled Chicken Tijuana

Mexican grilled Chicken Breast, grilled Peppers & Onions, Chipotle BBQ Sauce and Monterey Jack on Rustic Focaccia.

$12.95

Tuna Salad Club

Albacore tuna salad, sliced hard boiled egg, plum tomato, green leaf lettuce on white toast.

$12.95

Baked Chicken Parmigiana

Tender Breaded Chicken Cutlet with Homemade Marinara Sauce, Mozzarella Cheese and Fresh Basil in an Italian Hero.

$12.95

Chicken Salad Club

Crispy bacon, plum tomato, green leaf lettuce on white toast.

$12.95

Chicken Italiano

Grilled Chicken Breast, Fresh Mozzarella, Sweet Peppers, Lemon Roasted Garlic Spread and Caramelized Onions.

$12.95

Avocado BLT Club

Fresh ripe avocado, crispy bacon, plum tomato, green leaf lettuce on white toast with mayonnaise.

$12.95

Our New York Signature Sandwich

Lean Steamed corned Beef or Pastrami Sliced to Order and Piled High on Jewish Rye Bread, Served with Gulden's Deli Mustard, Coleslaw and Kosher Pickles.

$12.95

Turkey Triple Decker

$12.95

Grilled Chicken Breast

Muenster Cheese Arugula, Tomatoes, Sliced Apples, and Dijonnaise Dressing on a Ciabatta Roll.

$12.95

Turkey Bacon Guacamole

Real Turkey Breast, Crispy Smoked Bacon, Pepper Jack Cheese, Guacamole and Ranch in a Sourdough Panini.

$13.95

Applewood Smoked Turkey Breast & Brie Cheese

with Honey Mustard, Plum Tomatoes and Leaf Lettuce on a crispy Parisian Baguette.

$12.95

Turkey Avocado

Turkey Breast, Avocado, Lettuce, and Tomato with Herb Mayo on Sourdough Bread.

$13.95

burgers

Burgers

Burger Deluxe

Served with our Steak Fries, Lettuce, Tomato, Sliced Red Onion and Kosher Dill Pickle.

$13.95

Mexican Burger

Our chef's Homemade Mexican Style Beef Burger, Served With Pico Gallo, guacamole, pepperjack, lettuce, tomato and pickle. Served with Spicy Steak Fries.

$14.95

Hickory BBQ Bacon Cheddar Burger

An Unforgettable Burger Grilled with Our Special Hickory BBQ Sauce, Smothered with Caramelized Onions and Topped with Crispy, Bacon and Cheddar Cheese. Served with Steak Fries.

$14.95

Chicken Quesadilla

$12.95

Santa Fe Burger

Think Tex-Mex. Our Burger with Chipotle Sauce, Crispy Bacon, Pepper Jack Cheese and Salsa. Served with Spicy Steak Fries.

$14.95

Vegetable Quesadilla

Comes with Cheese, all Veggies.

$11.95

Turkey Burger

Our Turkey Burger Seasoned and Grilled Perfectly. Topped with Avocado, Pico de Gallo, Provolone Cheese, Lettuce and Tomato on a toasted bun. Served with Steak Fries.

$14.95

Cheese Quesadilla

$12.95

Veggie Burger

Our chef's Homemade Vegetarian Delight. Served on Toasted Multi Grain Baguette with Pesto Sauce, Lettuce, and Tomato served With Your Choice of Steak Fries or Grilled Vegetables.

$14.95

Beef Quesadilla

$14.95

Beef Burger

$14.95

from-our-grill

From Our Grill

Grilled Cheese

$5.95

Fish Fillet on Sole Deluxe

Served on a Toasted Seeded Bun with Lettuce, Tomatoes, Tartar Sauce and Crispy Fries.

$14.95

Grilled Cheese with Steak Fries

$9.95

Crispy Chicken Fingers

Served with Sweet Potato Fries, Barbeque Sauce and our Homemade Honey Mustard Sauce.

$14.95

Reuben

Corned Beef or Fresh Turkey Served Open Face with Sauerkraut, Melted Swiss on Jewish Rye.

$14.95

Louisiana Hot Chicken Wings

with Steak Fries & Maytag Blue Cheese Dressing,

$14.95

Tuna Melt

Our Albacore Tuna Salad served Open Face with Melted American or Swiss cheese on White Bread.

$12.95

Kebab

Charcoal Broiled chunks of Chicken Kabob over Rice. Served with BBQ Sauce or Lemon Juice.

$14.95

Philly Cheese Steak

Prime Roast Beef, Grilled Mushrooms, Peppers and Onions with Melted Cheese on a Semolina Hero.

$12.95

BLT- Bacon Lettuce Tomato

Bacon, Lettuce, Tomato

$8.95

Grilled Chicken Deluxe

Served on a Toasted Seeded Bun with Lettuce, Tomatoes and Crispy Stick Fries.

$14.95

entree-salads

Entree Salads

Gotham Chopped Salad

Chicken Breast, Country Ham, Hard Boiled Eggs, Bacon, Tomatoes, Cheddar & Swiss cheese over Iceberg Lettuce.

$14.95

Greek Salad

$11.95

Grilled Chicken over Caesar

Chicken Breast over our Crisp Refreshing Caesar Salad.

$14.95

Spinach Salad

$11.95

South Western Chicken

Slow Roasted Cajun Chicken with Sante Fe Corn Salad. Served over Organic Baby Greens.

$14.95

Arugula Salad

$11.95

Oriental Chicken Salad

Tender Chicken in a Light Ginger Sesame dressing with Chinese Noodles, Oriental Vegetables and Water Chestnuts over our House Salad. Low Fat.

$14.95

hearty-breakfast

Hearty Breakfast

Egg Sandwich

2 Eggs (any style) on a Roll.

$4.50

Egg Platter

2 Eggs (Served any style) includes Potatoes & Toast.

$5.95

Egg Sandwich with Bacon

2 Eggs (any style) on a Roll.

$6.50

Egg Platter with Bacon

2 Eggs (Served any style) includes Potatoes & Toast.

$7.95

Egg Sandwich with Ham

2 Eggs (any style) on a Roll.

$5.50

Egg Platter with Ham

2 Eggs (Served any style) includes Potatoes & Toast.

$7.95

Egg Sandwich with Sausage

2 Eggs (any style) on a Roll.

$5.50

Egg Platter with Sausage

2 Eggs (Served any style) includes Potatoes & Toast.

$7.95

egg-white-wraps

Egg White Wraps

Whole Wheat, White, Flour, Spinach, Sun Dried Tomato.

Western

Onion, peppers, ham.

$10.95

California

Mushrooms, tomatoes, low fat cheese.

$10.95

Meat Lovers

Bacon, ham or sausage.

$10.95

Garden

Broccoli, spinach, mushrooms.

$10.95

Greek

Feta cheese and tomatoes.

$10.95

Florentine

Fresh Spinach, Tomatoes, Feta Cheese.

$10.95

omelettes

Omelettes

Made with 2 Eggs.

Cheese Sandwich

American or Swiss.

$7.95

California Sandwich

Mushrooms, Tomatoes, Low-Fat Cheese.

$9.95

Cheese Platter

American or Swiss.

$9.95

California Platter

Mushrooms, Tomatoes, Low-Fat Cheese.

$9.95

Western Sandwich

Onion, peppers, Ham.

$9.95

Garden Sandwich

Broccoli, Spinach, Mushrooms.

$9.95

Western Platter

Onion, peppers, Ham.

$9.95

Garden Platter

Broccoli, Spinach, Mushrooms.

$9.95

Meat Lovers Sandwich

Bacon, Ham, Sausage.

$9.95

Florentine Sandwich

Spinach, Tomatoes, Feta Cheese.

$9.95

Meat Lovers Platter

Bacon, Ham, Sausage.

$9.95

Florentine Platter

Spinach, Tomatoes, Feta Cheese.

$9.95

Greek Sandwich

Feta Cheese, Tomatoes.

$9.95

Lox Sandwich

Onion, Scallion.

$9.95

Greek Platter

Feta Cheese, Tomatoes.

$9.95

Lox Platter

Onion, Scallion.

$9.95

griddle-delights

Griddle Delights

Available in Whole Wheat.

Cinnamon Challah French Toast

$9.95

Fluffy Buttermilk Pancakes

$9.95

lite-fit-breakfast

Lite & Fit Breakfast

Available in Whole Wheat.

Hot Oatmeal

includes 3 toppings. Your choice of Fresh Apple, Raisins, Granola, Honey, Brown Sugar, Fresh Strawberry, Cinnamon.

$3.50

Fresh Fruit Salad

Seasonal Fruits & Melon with Mixed Berries.

$5.95

freshly-baked-bagels

Freshly, Baked Bagels

Plain, Onion, Everything, Poppy, Cinnamon Raisin, Sesame, Pumpernickel, Whole Wheat, Multi-Grain.

Plain

$1.75

Lox Spread

$4.95

Butter / Jelly

$1.95

Vegetable Cream cheese

$3.25

Peanut Butter

$3.95

Scallion Cream Cheese

$3.25

Cream Cheese

$3.25

Smoked Norwegian Salmon w/ Cream cheese

$14.95

pastry-cookies-bars

Pastry, Cookies & Bars

Available in Whole Wheat.

Muffins

Honey Raisin Bran, Orange Cranberry, Banana Walnut, Old Fashioned Blueberry, Chocolate Chip, Corn.

$3.25

Scones

Blueberry, Chocolate Chip, Cranberry, Raisin.

$4.25

Fat-Free Muffins

High Fiber Bran, Blueberry, Triple Berry, Corn.

$3.25

Cinnamon Bun

$4.25

Croissants

Plain, Filled (Chocolate, Apple, Almonds).

$3.25

Bars

$4.25

Danishes

Cinnamon, Raisins, Cheese, Apple Turnover.

$4.25

Cookies

$4.25

Yogurt Loaf

Banana Walnut, Lemon King, Double Chocolate, Marble.

$4.25

chicken

Chicken

Whole Chicken

with 2 sides.

$24.95

Meat Loaf

with 2 sides.

$14.95

Half Chicken

with 2 sides.

$15.95

Chicken Breast

with 2 sides.

$12.95

Dark Chicken

with 2 sides.

$10.95

Baked Salmon

With 2 sides.

$15.95

sides

Sides

House Salad

$5.95

White Basmati Rice

$4.50

Corn Niblets

$4.50

Vegetable Biryani Rice

$4.50

Potato Salad

$5.95

Tuna Salad

$7.95

Cream Spinach

$4.95

Brasilian Chicken

$6.95

Mashed Potatoes

$5.95

Sundered Pasta

$5.95

White Rice

$5.95

MAngo Salsa Bears

$4.50

Black Bean

$5.95

Cous Cous

With Vegetable

$6.95

Sweet Corn

$5.95

Coleslaw Salad

$5.95

Coleslaw

$5.95

Side Tuna Salad

$6.95

Creama Spinach

$5.95

Side Italian Tuna Salad

$6.95

Veg Biryani Rice

$5.95

Side Pasta

$5.95

Mac N Cheese

$5.95

potato-chips

Potato Chips

Cape Cod

(Original, Reduced Fat, BBQ, Sea Salt & Vinegar).

$1.95

Doritos

(Nacho Cheese and Cool Ranch).

$1.95

Baked Lays

(Original, Sour Cream & Onion).

$1.95

hot-beverages

Hot Beverages

Columbian House Blend

$2.75

Mochacinno

$4.95

Decaf House Blend

$2.75

Cappuccino

$4.95

Hazelnut Decaf Blend

$2.75

Cafe Latte

$3.95

Tea

$2.75

Americano

$3.95

Herbal Tea

$2.25

Cafe Au Lait

$3.95

Hot Chocolate

$3.50

Espresso

$2.95

cold-beverages

Cold Beverages

Iced Coffee Of Tea

$3.95

Vitamin Water

$3.50

Iced Decaf

$3.95

Freshly Made Lemonade

$2.95

Iced Cappuccino

$3.95

Snapple

$2.95

Iced Machacinno

$4.50

Naked

$4.95

Freshly Squeezed Orange Juice

$3.95

Figi

$2.95

Iced Latte

$4.95

Polana Spring

$1.50

Iced Chocolate

$4.50

Bottle Soda

$2.95

Levita

$4.50

Can Soda

$1.85

Vita Coco

$3.95

Pellegrino

$4.85

Nesquik

$3.95

Red Bull

$4.95

Tropicana

$2.95

Apple Juice

$3.25

Gatorade

$2.95

Stewarts Soda

$2.95

soups

Soups

Chicken Noodle Soup

$6.95

Vegetable Lentil Soup

$6.95

Split Soup

$6.95

Lentil Soup

$6.95

classic-sandwiches

Classic Sandwiches

Rueben our NY Signature Sandwich

$14.95

California Turkey Pita

$12.95

Grilled Chicken Breast Sandwich

$12.95

Tuna Pita

$12.95

Applewood Turkey

$12.95

Traditional Neva Salmon

$14.95

Pico De Gallo

$12.95

Turkey Triple Decker

$13.95

Turkey Avocado

$12.95

Avocado BLT

$12.95

Traditional Tuna Salad

$12.95

build-a-sandwich

Build A Sandwich

Pastrami Sandwich

$12.95

Chicken Breast Sandwich

$8.95

Corned Beef Sandwich

$12.95

Chicken Salad Sandwich

$8.95

Turkey Breast Sandwich

$8.95

Tuna Salad Sandwich

$8.95

Black Forest Ham Sandwich

$8.95

Cheese Sandwich

$8.95

your-favorite-sandwich

Your Favorite Sandwich

Smoked Turkey Melt Sandwich

$12.95

Tuscan Sandwich

$12.95

Jerry Turkey Sandwich

$12.95

Grilled Chicken Tijuana Sandwich

$12.95

Italian Club Sandwich

$12.95

Baked Cheese Parm Sandwich

$12.95

Chicken Milano Sandwich

$12.95

Turkey Bacon Sandwich

$12.95

Cubano Sandwich

$12.95

Chicken Italiane Sandwich

$12.95

fries

Fries

Sweet Potato Fries

$3.95

Home Fries

$3.95

Curly Fries

$3.95

Steak Fries

$3.95

French Fries

$3.95

72nd Eatery - View Menu & Order Online - 261 Columbus Ave, New York, NY 10023 - Slice

SliceNYNew York10023 72nd Eatery
Price: $$