Classic Pie -18"

House-made fresh tomato sauce, Grande mozzarella, oregano and aged parmesan. 18-inch, 8-slice.

Vodka Sauce Pie - 12"

Rich house-made vodka sauce, house-made mozzarella, and aged Parmesan on our classic crust. 12-inch, 6-slice pie.

Vodka Sauce Pie -18"

Rich creamy house-made Vodka-sauce, fresh mozzarella, and aged parmesan. 18-inch, 8-slice.

Arthur Ave Square

Sweet Italian sausage, house-made mozzarella, red peppers, pepperoncini, onions, aged parmesan, and evoo on our sheet pan crust square. 12x9-inch, 6-slice.

Margherita Pie -18"

House-made mozzarella, fresh basil, evoo , and tomato sauce on a classic crust. 18-inch, 8-slice.

Artichoke Square

Artichokes, fresh house-made mozzarella, creamy spinach sauce, and aged parmesan on our sheet pan crust square. 12x9-inch, 6-slice.

MVP Pie -18"

Marinara, vodka, and pesto sauces, house-made mozzarella, and aged parm on a classic crust. 18-inch, 8-slice.

Bianca Square

House-made fresh mozzarella, creamy ricotta, aged Parmesan, and evoo on our sheet pan crust square. 12x9-inch, 6-slice.

Bianca Pie - 18"

House-made fresh mozzarella, creamy ricotta, aged Parmesan, and evoo on our classic crust. 18-inch, 8-slice.

Buffalo Chicken Square

Fried chicken, marinara, Grande mozzarella, hot sauce, blue cheese, and scallions on our thin sheet pan crust square. 12x9-inch, 6-slice.

Arthur Ave Pie - 12"

Sweet Italian sausage, house-made mozzarella, roasted red peppers, pepperoncini, onions, aged parmesan, and evoo on our NY-style crust. 12-inch, 6-slice pie

Grandma Square

Lucille’s signature Grandma sauce, house-made mozzarella, evoo, aged parmesan, and fresh basil on our thin sheet pan crust square. 12x9-inch, 6-slice.

Artichoke Pie - 12"

Artichoke, house-made mozzarella, creamy spinach sauce, and aged parmesan on our NY-style crust. 12-inch, 6-slice pie.

MVP Square

Marinara, vodka, and pesto sauces, house-made mozzarella, and aged parmesan on our sheet pan crust square. 12x9-inch, 6-slice.

Bianca Pie - 12"

House-made fresh mozzarella, creamy ricotta, aged Parmesan, and EVOO on our classic crust. 12-inch, 6-slice pie.

Meatball & Burrata Square

All-beef meatballs (no pork), spicy arrabbiata grandma sauce, creamy burrata spread, fresh basil, and aged parmesan on our sheet pan crust square. 12x9-inch, 6-slice.

Buffalo Chicken Pie - 12"

Crispy fried chicken, marinara, Grande mozzarella, hot sauce, blue cheese, and scallions on our NY-style crust. 12-inch, 6-slice pie.

Rabe &Sausage Square

Broccoli rabe, sweet Italian fennel sausage, creamy house-made béchamel, house-made mozzarella and aged parmesan on our sheet pan crust square. 12x9-inch, 6-slice.

Classic Pie - 12"

House-made fresh tomato sauce, Grande mozzarella, oregano and aged parmesan. 12-inch, 6-slice pie.

Supreme Square

Loaded with charred pepperoni cups, Grande mozzarella, spicy garlic marinara sauce, and aged parmesan on our sheet pan crust square. 12x9-inch, 6-slice.

MVP Pie - 12"

Marinara, vodka, and pesto sauces, house-made mozzarella, and aged Parmesan on our classic crust. 12-inch, 6-slice pie.

Veggie Pesto Square

Pesto, house-made mozzarella, heirloom cherry tomatoes, black olives, roasted red peppers, and evoo on our sheet pan crust square. 12x9-inch, 6-slice.

Margherita Pie - 12"

House-made mozzarella, fresh basil, evoo , and tomato sauce on a classic crust. 12-inch, 6-slice pie.

Vodka Square

House-made vodka sauce, fresh house-made mozzarella, and aged parmesan on our thin sheet pan crust square. 12x9-inch, 6-slice.

Meatball & Burrata Pie - 12"

Beef meatballs, spicy arrabbiata tomato sauce, creamy burrata spread, fresh basil, and aged parmesan on our NY-style crust. (No pork) 12-inch, 6-slice pie.

Vegan Grandma

Lucille's signature Grandma sauce, Daiya vegan mozzarella, evoo, and fresh basil on our sheet pan crust vegan square. 12x9-inch, 6-slice.

Rabe & Sausage Pie - 12"

Broccoli rabe, sweet Italian fennel sausage, creamy béchamel, fresh homemade mozzarella, and aged parmesan on our NY-style crust. 12-inch, 6-slice pie.

Vegan Marinara

Lucille's signature Grandma tomato sauce, roasted garlic, and parsley on our sheet pan crust vegan square. 12x9-inch, 6-slice.

Supreme Pie - 12"

Crispy pepperoni cups, Grande mozzarella, spicy garlic Grandma sauce, and aged Parmesan.

Vegan Veggie Pesto

Pesto, Daiya vegan mozzarella, heirloom cherry tomatoes, black olives, red peppers, and evoo on our sheet pan crust vegan square. 12x9-inch, 6-slice.

Veggie Pesto Pie -12"

Pesto, house-made mozzarella, heirloom cherry tomatoes, black olives, roasted red peppers, and evoo on our NY-style crust. 12-inch, 6-slice pie.

Garlic Knots 6pc

Sourdough knotted with roasted garlic and spices, baked then tossed in garlic sauce and parmesan. Served with a side of homemade marinara. 6 pieces.

Chicken Wings 8pc

Jumbo wings tossed in hot buffalo or sweet bbq sauce, topped with scallions, served with ranch.

Riceballs 3pc

Fried rice balls (arancini) with shallots, mozzarella, and white wine, breaded and fried until crisp outside and creamy inside. Served with marinara.

Lasagna

House-made pasta & mozzarella, ricotta, parmesan. 16oz serving. Available Classic (vegeterian) or with Meatball & Sausage Bolognese. Join us near Yankee Stadium on the Manhattan side, or order pickup or delivery.

Mozzarella Sticks 3pc

House-made mozzarella, breaded and fried until golden and crispy. Served with a side of Lucille’s marinara.

Eggplant Parmesan

Breaded and fried house-cut eggplant topped with marinara sauce, homemade mozzarella, extra parmesan, and fresh basil. (Side dish portion.) 2 pieces.