Skip to main content
Butera's of Sayville

Butera's of Sayville

100 Main St, Sayville, NY 11782
631-201-0388

Closed until 12:00 PM

Full Hours

    Opening at 12:00 PM

    pizza
    Pizza
    One-half of a 12'' pizza served with a side salad.

    Grilled Pizza of the Day

    Grilled crisp pizza with today’s topping.

    $16.00


    Margherita Pizza

    $16.00


    Pepperoni Pizza

    $16.00


    Rustica Pizza

    $16.00


    Tilapia Tricolor Pizza

    $16.00

    antipasti
    Antipasti

    Mozzarella Caprese

    Fresh mozzarella, tomato, roasted red peppers, and red onion garnished with fresh basil and extra virgin olive oil.

    $25.00


    Calamari Fritti

    Marinara sauce and lemon.

    $28.00

    Calamari Fritti

    Calamari “Sicilian Lifeguard” Style

    Spicy cherry peppers, capers, marinara sauce.

    $30.00


    Prince Edward Island Mussels

    Fresh tomatoes and basil in a garlic wine sauce.

    $28.00


    Baked Littleneck Clams

    Littleneck clams baked whole, topped with seasoned breadcrumbs and herbs.

    $26.00


    Scampi Limoncello

    Sauteed jumbo shrimp in a lemon, garlic and Limoncello sauce topped with toasted almonds.

    $31.00


    Stuffed Mushrooms

    Spinach, sundried tomatoes, diced fresh mozzarella, breadcrumb and cheese.

    $22.00


    Mozzarella Fritta

    Fresh mozzarella julienne zucchini prosciutto “San Danielle” style frisee tomato.

    $27.00


    Eggplant Rollatini

    Breaded eggplant rolled with herb ricotta & prosciutto, topped with marinara sauce & melted mozzarella cheese.

    $24.00

    sides
    Sides

    Broccoli

    Fresh, cut daily, steamed broccoli with olive oil and garlic.

    $12.00


    Spinach

    $12.00


    Escarole

    $12.00


    Mashed Potatoes

    $12.00


    Broccoli Rabe

    Broccoli rabe, also known as rapini, is beloved for its slightly nutty flavor.

    $15.00


    Roasted Potatoes

    $12.00


    Grilled Italian Sausage

    $12.00


    Chicken Meatballs Marinara

    $12.00

    Chicken Meatballs Marinara
    insalata
    Insalata
    All salads served with house vinaigrette unless otherwise noted.

    Mixed Salad

    Mixed greens, tomatoes, red onions, olives and cucumbers.

    $18.00


    Gorgonzola Salad

    Mixed greens, red onions, olives, tomatoes, gorgonzola cheese, and walnuts.

    $26.00


    Caesar Salad

    Crisp romaine, caesar dressing, croutons, shaved padano, and anchovies.

    $26.00


    Warm Goat Cheese Salad

    Mixed greens, tomatoes, red onions, and olives, with warmed bread crumb, crusted goat cheese medallions, topped with toasted almonds.

    $26.00


    Mushrooms & Asparagus Salad

    Sauteed mushrooms, and asparagus with roasted peppers, and mixed greens.

    $30.00

    salad-entrees
    Salad Entrees

    Grilled Shrimp Salad

    Mixed greens, fresh mozzarella cheese, tomatoes, onions and toasted almonds with a citrus shallot vinaigrette dressing.

    $40.00

    Grilled Shrimp Salad

    Warm Frisee, Spinach & Chicken Salad

    Sliced grilled chicken, roasted peppers, mixed greens, and smoked mozzarella tossed with a warm white wine vinaigrette.

    $30.00


    Warm Grilled Scallop Salad

    Shiitake mushrooms, cannellini beans, fresh tomatoes, and mixed greens tossed with warm white wine vinaigrette.

    $45.00

    Warm Grilled Scallop Salad

    Crispy Calamari Caesar Salad

    Crispy fried calamari over a traditional Caesar salad.

    $31.00

    pasta
    Pasta

    Pasta Marinara

    Italian tomatoes, olive oil, basil and garlic. Linguine, penne or rigatoni.

    $28.00


    Pasta Arrabiata

    Italian tomatoes, olive oil, cherry peppers and basil pesto.

    $29.00


    Pasta Vodka

    Tomato cream sauce accented with bacon and prosciutto. Linguine, penne or rigatoni.

    $30.00


    Spaghetti & Meatballs

    Chicken meatballs in marinara sauce.

    $31.00

    Spaghetti & Meatballs

    Linguine with Clams

    Fresh clams, garlic, extra virgin olive oil in a red or white clam sauce.

    $38.00


    Linguine Shrimp, Mushroom & Escarole

    Garlic wine sauce.

    $40.00


    Rigatoni Broccoli Rabe & Chicken Meatballs

    Fresh tomatoes & cannellini beans in garlic & oil.

    $38.00


    Rigatoni Butera

    Crumbled veal sausage and sweet peas in a tomato cream sauce topped with grana padano.

    $38.00


    Rigatoni Chicken & Spinach

    Diced chicken and fresh spinach in a tomato cream sauce.

    $34.00


    Rigatoni Chicken & Shrimp Vodka

    Tomato cream sauce accented with bacon and prosciutto.

    $40.00


    Rigatoni Chicken Meatball & Sausage

    Classic bolognese sauce.

    $38.00


    Rigatoni Chicken, Mushroom & Sun Dried Tomato

    Crumbled chicken sausage or sliced grilled chicken, with mushrooms, sun-dried tomatoes, and spinach in a garlic wine sauce.

    $36.00

    Rigatoni Chicken, Mushroom & Sun Dried Tomato

    Penne Eggplant

    Caramelized onions and fresh mozzarella cheese in a marinara sauce.

    $34.00


    Penne Sausage, Escarole & Cannellini Beans

    italian sausage or crumbled chicken sausage in a tomato garlic wine sauce.

    $34.00

    on-the-lighter-side-dishes
    On The Lighter Side Dishes
    With ingredients & sauces lowe in fat.

    Penne Primavera Lighter Side

    Lightly sauteed vegetables in a white wine or marinara sauce.

    $30.00


    Linguine Grilled Chicken & Mushrooms Lighter Side

    Julienne carrots and sweet peas in a white wine sauce.

    $34.00


    Linguine Shrimp & Scallops Lighter Side

    Broccoli, spinach and fresh tomatoes in a white wine sauce.

    $45.00


    Linguine Shrimp & Grilled Chicken Lighter Side

    Arugula and fresh tomatoes in a white wine sauce.

    $42.00

    baked-pasta
    Baked Pasta
    Pan baked lasagna: a new quick light take on lasagna, prepared stovetop with fresh Mafalda pasta.

    Pan Baked Chicken Meatball Lasagna

    Pink sauce with ricotta mozzarella cheese.

    $38.00


    Pan Baked Veal Lasagna

    Spinach in a pink sauce with ricotta and mozzarella cheese.

    $40.00


    Pan Baked Seafood Lasagna

    Shrimp, scallops, and calamari in a marinara sauce with ricotta and mozzarella cheese.

    $44.00


    Pan Baked Lasagna Classico

    Bolognese sauce, ricotta and mozzarella cheese.

    $36.00


    Baked Cheese Ravioli

    Marinara sauce with mozzarella cheese.

    $34.00


    Rigatoni Caprese

    Pan baked rigatoni with ricotta in a marinara sauce with melted mozzarella cheese.

    $32.00

    pollo-entrees
    Pollo Entrees

    Chicken, Spinach & Roasted Pepper

    Mozzarella cheese.

    $36.00


    Chicken Gorgonzola

    Grilled chicken breast, gorgonzola cheese, caramelized onions, fresh tomatoes and melted mozzarella cheese.

    $36.00


    Chicken Parmesan

    Breaded chicken cutlet with marinara sauce and melted mozzarella cheese.

    $34.00


    Chicken Scarpariello

    Chicken breast chunks, Italian sausage, cherry peppers, potatoes, garlic, rosemary, white wine & vinegar. On the bone upon request.

    $38.00


    Chicken Piccata

    Sauteed chicken breast, mushrooms, tomatoes and capers in a lemon wine sauce.

    $36.00


    Chicken Francese

    Mushrooms in a lemon wine sauce.

    $36.00


    Chicken Marsala

    Mushrooms in a marsala wine sauce.

    $38.00


    Chicken Sorrentino

    Eggplant, prosciutto and mozzarella cheese in a red wine sauce.

    $38.00


    Chicken Tricolor

    Lemon wine sauce topped with a tricolor salad.

    $34.00

    carne-entrees
    Carne Entrees

    Veal Parmesan

    Marinara sauce and mozzarella cheese.

    $44.00


    Veal Piccata

    Mushrooms, tomatoes and capers in a lemon wine sauce.

    $44.00


    Veal Francese

    Mushrooms in a lemon wine sauce.

    $44.00


    Veal Marsala

    Mushrooms in a marsala wine sauce.

    $44.00


    Veal Chop ''Caprese'' Style

    Breaded butterflied veal rib chops with tomatoes, garlic & wine sauce & melted fresh mozzarella cheese.

    $60.00


    Veal Chop ''Milanese'' Style

    Breaded butterflied veal rib chops topped with tricolor salad.

    $60.00


    Sirloin Steak Gorgonzola

    Sliced sirloin steak with a dry vermouth gorgonzola cream sauce.

    $58.00


    Sirloin Steak Marsala

    Sliced sirloin steak with roasted peppers and a marsala cream sauce.

    $58.00


    Sirloin Steak Pizzaiola

    Sliced sirloin steak with peppers & onions in a tomato garlic wine sauce.

    $58.00


    Sirloin Steak Toscana

    Sliced sirloin steak garnished with spinach in garlic & oil and a red wine demi-glace sauce.

    $58.00

    Sirloin Steak Toscana
    eggplant-entrees
    Eggplant Entrees

    Eggplant Napoleon

    Breaded eggplant layered with herb ricotta, marinara sauce and melted mozzarella cheese.

    $34.00


    Eggplant Parmesan

    Breaded eggplant with marinara sauce and mozzarella.

    $34.00

    pesce-entrees
    Pesce Entrees

    Shrimp Marinara

    Fresh basil.

    $38.00


    Shrimp Parmesan

    Breaded marinara sauce and mozzarella cheese.

    $42.00


    Shrimp Butera

    Tomatoes, garlic, and wine sauce with bacon, sweet peas, and a splash of cream.

    $42.00


    Shrimp Limoncello

    Lemon, garlic and limoncello sauce, topped with toasted almonds.

    $42.00


    Seafood Marinara

    Shrimp, scallops, calamari, mussels and clams in a marinara sauce. Fra diavolo or white wine sauce upon request.

    $56.00


    Calamari Marinara

    Sauteed calamari in a marinara sauce.

    $36.00


    Tilapia Oreganata

    Baked herb & bread crumb topped tilapia filet in a light wine sauce.

    $38.00


    Tilapia Livornese

    Sauteed tilapia in tomatoes, garlic, and wine sauce with olives, capers, red onions, and basil.

    $38.00


    Lump Crab Crusted Tilapia

    Lump crab herb & baked crumb tomatoes, lemon wine sauce.

    $40.00


    Grilled Salmon Medallions

    Herb & bread crumb crust, garnished with grilled asparagus & a dijon wine sauce.

    $48.00


    Basa Marachiara

    Light tomato, garlic, and wine sauce with diced fresh mozzarella cheese and basil.

    $38.00


    Basa Filet

    Shiitake mushrooms and fresh tomato in a lemon wine sauce, topped with almond pangritata.

    $38.00

    kids-menu
    Kids Menu

    Kid's Pasta in Marinara Sauce

    In marinara sauce.

    $8.00


    Kid's Pasta in Butter Sauce

    In butter sauce.

    $8.00


    Kid's Cheese Ravioli in Marinara Sauce

    In marinara sauce.

    $9.00


    Kid's Chicken Fingers with French Fries

    With french fries.

    $9.00


    Kid's French Fries with Melted Mozzarella Cheese

    With melted mozzarella cheese.

    $6.00


    Kid's Focaccia Pizza

    Focaccia.

    $9.00

    desserts
    Desserts

    Apple Crostada

    A free form flaky crust encasing a warm apple filling garnished with caramel sauce.

    $9.00


    Amaretto & Almond Cake

    Served warm with vanilla ice cream and a delicate amaretto sauce.

    $9.00


    Tiramisu

    Mascarpone cream, ladyfingers & espresso, sprinkled with chocolate.

    $9.00


    Fudge Brownie Butera

    Rich chocolate brownie topped with vanilla ice cream, whipped cream & chocolate syrup.

    $9.00


    Chocolate Chip Pie

    A timeless classic served warm with vanilla ice cream.

    $9.00


    Cannoli

    A traditional favorite with Butera's own homemade filling.

    $8.00


    Tartufo

    Chocolate encrusted ice cream with cherries & nuts.

    $8.00


    Butera Brownie

    Brownies served warm with 4 scoops of vanilla ice cream, whipped cream, candied walnuts & maraschino cherries. For 2 pieces.

    $20.00

    Butera Brownie
    lunch-grilled-pizzas
    Lunch Grilled Pizzas
    Only available 11:30 AM - 4:00 PM
    One half of a 12'' pizza served with a side salad.

    Margherita Pizza Lunch

    Marinara and melted fresh mozzarella.

    $13.00


    Pepperoni Pizza Lunch

    Our traditional Margherita with imported pepperoni.

    $14.00


    Rustica Pizza Lunch

    Homemade crumbled chicken sausage, melted fresh mozzarella and grape tomatoes.

    $14.00

    lunch-salads
    Lunch Salads
    Only available 11:30 AM - 4:00 PM

    Grilled Shrimp Salad Lunch

    Jumbo shrimp with mixed greens, diced fresh mozzarella, tomato, onion, and toasted almonds over bruschetta points with a citrus shallot vinaigrette.

    $19.00


    Warm Frisee, Spinach & Chicken Salad Lunch

    Sliced grilled chicken, roasted peppers, mixed greens, and smoked mozzarella tossed with a warm white wine vinaigrette.

    $16.00


    Warm Grilled Scallop Salad Lunch

    Jumbo sea scallops with shiitake mushrooms, cannellini beans, fresh tomato and mixed greens tossed with a warm white wine vinaigrette.

    $20.00


    Crispy Calamari Caesar Salad Lunch

    Crispy fried calamari over traditional Caesar salad.

    $16.00


    Mushroom, Asparagus & Grilled Chicken Salad Lunch

    Sauteed mushrooms and asparagus with sliced grilled chicken mixed greens and roasted peppers with our house vinaigrette.

    $18.00


    Tilapia Tricolor Salad Lunch

    Grilled tilapia fillet served with fresh tomato salsa and a tricolor salad.

    $12.00


    Soup & Salad Lunch

    A bowl of our hearty soup of the day complete with your choice: a small goat cheese, gorgonzola, Caesar or mixed salad.

    $13.00

    lunch-grilled-burgers
    Lunch Grilled Burgers
    Only available 11:30 AM - 4:00 PM
    All burgers served with a side salad or french fries.

    Char Grilled Chicken Veggie Burger Lunch

    Freshly ground chicken, fresh diced zucchini, red peppers, carrot and onions on a focaccia burger roll.

    $14.00


    Sauteed Mushroom Burger Lunch

    Chargrilled beef burger with sauteed mushrooms, melted mozzarella cheese and basil pesto on a focaccia burger roll.

    $14.00


    Italian Cheeseburger Lunch

    Char grilled beef burger with sautéed peppers and onions topped with melted provolone on a focaccia burger roll.

    $14.00


    Gorgonzola Burger Lunch

    Chargrilled beef burger with fresh tomato, caramelized onions, bacon, melted mozzarella and gorgonzola on a focaccia burger roll.

    $14.00

    lunch-wraps
    Lunch Wraps
    Only available 11:30 AM - 4:00 PM
    All burgers served with a side salad or french fries.

    Grilled Chicken Caesar Wrap Lunch

    Sun-dried tomato wrap with grilled chicken and Caesar salad.

    $14.00


    Chicken Cutlet Wrap Lunch

    Fresh mozzarella, baby arugula, red onion and tomatoes with Italian dressing and pesto on an herb wrap.

    $14.00


    Steak Wrap Lunch

    Sliced grilled sirloin, sautéed mushrooms, caramelized onions and mesclun with sun-dried tomato pesto on a sun-dried tomato wrap.

    $17.00


    Grilled Chicken & Smoked Mozzarella Wrap Lunch

    With fresh spinach, roasted peppers and basil pesto mayonnaise on a black bean wrap.

    $14.00


    Grilled Chicken, Prosciutto & Fresh Mozzarella Wrap Lunch

    With mixed greens, herb ricotta and sun-dried tomato pesto on a herb wrap.

    $14.00

    lunch-focaccia-sandwiches
    Lunch Focaccia Sandwiches
    Only available 11:30 AM - 4:00 PM

    Grilled Eggplant Focaccia Sandwich Lunch

    Served open-faced with caramelized onion and marinara sauce on focaccia.

    $12.00


    Grilled Sirloin Steak Focaccia Sandwich Lunch

    Sliced and served with crispy onions and melted mozzarella on focaccia.

    $17.00


    Grilled Chicken Focaccia Sandwich Lunch

    Served open-faced atop focaccia with tomato salsa.

    $13.00


    Chicken Parmesan Focaccia Sandwich Lunch

    Breaded chicken breast, marinara and melted mozzarella on focaccia.

    $14.00


    Grilled Chicken Gorgonzola Focaccia Sandwich Lunch

    Gorgonzola, fresh tomato, caramelized onions and melted mozzarella on focaccia.

    $14.00


    Prosciutto, Fresh Mozzarella, Roasted Pepper Focaccia Sandwich Lunch

    With mixed greens and Italian dressing on focaccia.

    $14.00


    Grilled Chicken Sorrentino Focaccia Sandwich Lunch

    Eggplant, prosciutto, marinara sauce and melted mozzarella on focaccia.

    $14.00


    Grilled Chicken, Spinach, Roasted Pepper Focaccia Sandwich Lunch

    With melted mozzarella on focaccia.

    $14.00


    Grilled Tilapia Fillet Focaccia Sandwich Lunch

    Roasted pepper, sun-dried tomato and mixed greens on focaccia.

    $14.00


    Shrimp Marechiara Focaccia Sandwich Lunch

    Served open-faced with a tomato garlic wine sauce and fresh mozzarella on focaccia.

    $18.00

    lunch-heroes
    Lunch Heroes
    Only available 11:30 AM - 4:00 PM

    Sausage & Broccoli Rabe Hero Lunch

    Grilled Italian or crumbled chicken sausage paired with sauteed broccoli rabe on a hero.

    $14.00


    Sausage & Peppers Hero Lunch

    Grilled Italian or crumbled chicken sausage smothered in sauteed peppers & onions on a hero.

    $14.00


    Fried Calamari ''Po Boy'' Hero Lunch

    Fried calamari tossed in our famous spicy ''Sicilian Lifeguard'' sauce on a hero.

    $15.00

    Fried Calamari ''Po Boy'' Hero Lunch

    Basa Filet Hero Lunch

    Lightly breaded and fried fillet of basa with mixed greens, tomato, red onion and a homemade tartar sauce on a hero.

    $14.00

    lunch-pasta-dishes
    Lunch Pasta Dishes
    Only available 11:30 AM - 4:00 PM

    Rigatoni Broccoli Lunch

    Sautéed in a garlic sauce.

    $14.00


    Pan Baked Rigatoni Lunch

    Tossed with marinara, ricotta and melted mozzarella.

    $14.00


    Rigatoni Alla Vodka Lunch

    In a tomato cream sauce, accented with bacon and prosciutto.

    $14.00


    Penne Chicken Meatball Marinara Lunch

    With our famous chicken meatballs.

    $14.00

    Penne Chicken Meatball Marinara Lunch

    Rigatoni Alla Rosa Lunch

    Crumbled chicken sausage and spinach in a pink sauce.

    $14.00


    Penne Primavera Lunch

    Fresh seasonal vegetables sautéed in a white wine or marinara sauce.

    $14.00

    lunch-packages
    Lunch Packages
    Only available 11:30 AM - 4:00 PM
    Available during weekdays lunch service only.

    Lunch Package #1

    House salad with house vinaigrette, one choice of entree served with potato & sautéed vegetables & cheesecake. Includes unlimited soda, coffee, or tea & fresh baked focaccia & garlic knots.

    $240.00


    Lunch Package #2

    House salad with house vinaigrette, penne marinara, one choice of entree served with potato & sautéed vegetables & cheesecake. Includes unlimited soda, coffee, or tea & fresh baked focaccia & garlic knots.

    $260.00

    SliceNYSayville11782 Butera's of Sayville
    Price: $$
    Cuisine: grilled pizza