Skip to main content

Off the bay Sayville

220 North Main Street, Sayville, NY 11782
516-650-2389
New

Order Ahead We open at 12:00 PM

Full Hours
    NY Health ScoreNew window icon
    Skip to first category
    for-the-table

    For The Table...

    Steakhouse Bacon

    thick cut slab bacon, brown sugar glaze, pickled vegetable

    $16.00

    Grilled Octopus

    marinated octopus, warm farro salad, pepper agrodolce

    $24.00

    Fried Calamari

    spicy pomodoro, lemon & confit garlic aioli

    $18.00

    Bacon Jam Burger Sliders

    aged cheddar, toasted brioche, bacon & onion jam, pickle

    $18.00

    Mussels Arrabbiata

    nova scotia mussels, OTB spicy pomodoro, basil, parsley

    $15.00

    Bay Fries

    seasoned & hand cut served with our famous fry sauce

    $15.00

    Twice Baked Potato

    braised short rib, aged cheddar, sour cream, chive

    $18.00

    soups

    Soups

    French Onion Soup

    garlic crostini, melted swiss & gruyere

    $11.00

    Seafood Chowder

    tomato broth, shrimp, mussels, clams

    $15.00

    New England Clam Chowder

    local clams, bacon lardons, cream, fresh herbs

    $14.00

    salads

    Salads

    Burrata Salad

    arugula, fresh burrata, pickled red onion, lemon thyme vinaigrette, roasted beets

    $16.00

    The Bay Salad

    market greens, cajun shrimp, roasted carrot, bacon, buttermilk ranch

    $28.00

    Caesar Salad

    romaine, housemade caesar, shaved parmesan, garlic crostini

    $14.00

    on-bread

    On Bread

    Buttermilk Chicken Sandwich

    toasted brioche, buttermilk fried chicken, house cabbage slaw, spicy aioli

    $22.00

    French Dip

    slow roasted prime ribeye, swiss & gruyere, au jus

    $32.00

    Off The Bay Steakhouse Burger

    short rib & brisket blend, toasted brioche, caramelized pork belly, aged cheddar, bibb lettuce, tomato, pickle, spicy aioli

    $25.00

    Lobster Roll

    Maine lobster, citrus seafood aioli, fresh herbs, scallion

    $38.00

    Shrimp Po' Boy

    crispy cajun jumbo shrimp, tomato, lettuce, tartar sauce

    $28.00

    entres

    Entrées

    Grilled Swordfish

    8oz skin off swordfish steak, peperonata, fresh lemon, served with pepper agrodolce

    $36.00

    Lobster Tagliatelle

    1¼ lb Maine lobster, lemon cream sauce, blistered cherry tomato, herbs

    $48.00

    Prime Rib

    slow roasted prime ribeye, au poivre sauce

    $48.00

    Fish & Chips

    fresh Atlantic hake, malt vinegar, tartar, lemon

    $28.00

    Best Chicken On The Block

    frenched Bell and Evans Chicken, lemon & white wine au jus, pepper agrodolce

    $26.00

    sides

    Sides

    Charred Broccolini

    with crispy garlic

    $14.00

    Risotto

    add lobster MP

    $12.00

    Roasted Tricolor Carrots

    in a sweet and savory herb butter

    $12.00

    Off the bay Sayville - View Menu & Order Online - 220 North Main Street, Sayville, NY 11782 - Slice

    Price: $$