Skip to main content
Pontillo's Pizzeria-WEBSTER The Original Recipe!

Pontillo's Pizzeria-WEBSTER The Original Recipe!

807 Ridge Rd, Webster, NY 14580
585-371-5725

Open until 11:00 PM

Full Hours
  • 5% off online orders
best-sellers
Best Sellers

Chicken Fingers

Crispy chicken fingers come with one house-made Blue Cheese sauce and one savory sauce of your choice

$8.75

Chicken Fingers

Mozzarella Sticks

Battered Mozzarella sticks come with one classic Pontillo's red sauce

$8.75

Mozzarella Sticks

Fried Mushrooms

Crispy fried mushrooms come with one side of our house-made Blue Cheese sauce

$8.75

Fried Mushrooms

Chocolate Chip Cookies

Famous Dave's chunky chocolate chip cookies, a bite above the rest!

$2.96

Chocolate Chip Cookies

Garlic Bread

Signature white garlic sauce, a dash of oregano, drizzled with extra virgin olive oil, blanketed with our classic Mozzarella and Parmesan cheese

$8.00

Garlic Bread

Breadsticks

Delightfully smothered in our signature white garlic sauce, garnished with Parmesan cheese, a dash of oregano, and our classic Mozzarella cheese

$11.00

Breadsticks

Fried Dough

Pontillo's classic homemade fried dough, original recipe since 1947!

$5.00

Fried Dough

Fries

Salted freshly made french fries come with one side of ketchup

$5.00

Fries

Pizza Logs

Pizza Logs come with one classic Pontillo's red sauce

$8.75

Pizza Logs

Garlic Knots

Pontillo's famous garlic knots!

$9.00

Garlic Knots
build-your-own-cheese-pizza
Build your own - Cheese pizza

Cheese Pizza

Cheese or create your own pizza. With Mozzarella cheese.

$13.00

Cheese Pizza
pontillos-prime-time-specialty-pizzas
Pontillo's Prime Time Specialty Pizzas

The White Italiano Pizza

House-made garlic sauce, fresh green spinach, white Ricotta cheese, roasted red peppers, or freshly sliced tomatoes.

$19.25

The White Italiano Pizza

The 1947 Supreme Pizza

Original recipe red sauce, fresh onions, pepperoni, Italian sausage, sweet green peppers, fresh mushrooms, and black olives.

$20.50

The 1947 Supreme Pizza

The Stakeout Country Pizza

Sweet sauce, shaved steak, fresh onion, and sweet green peppers.

$18.00


Classic Margarita Pizza

Original recipe red sauce, old-world fresh Mozzarella, sliced tomatoes, and fresh basil.

$16.75

Classic Margarita Pizza

The Bomb Pizza

Original red sauce, meatballs with fresh Ricotta cheese.

$15.50


The Flyin Hawaiian Pizza

Original recipe red sauce, savory slices of ham, and chunks of pineapple.

$15.50

The Flyin Hawaiian Pizza

Buffalo Chicken Pizza

Plump chunks of chicken with your choice of house-made Pontillo's mild, medium, hot, country sweet, or bbq sauce.

$15.50


The Ponti Parm Pizza

Original recipe red sauce with your choice of chicken or eggplant topped with rich Parmesan cheese.

$15.50


The 4 Amigos Pizza

Original recipe red sauce, topped with Mozzarella, Ricotta, Provolone cheese, garnished with Parmesan.

$14.25


The Thick Sicilian Pizza

Original recipe red sauce topped with fresh banana peppers, onions, pepperoni, finished off with a generous dash of old-fashioned Romano cheese. This pizza does NOT have Mozzarella cheese!

$18.00


Better than Breakfast Pizza

Eggs, a blend of 3 kinds of cheeses, and the toppings of your choice.

$15.50

Better than Breakfast Pizza
pontillos-pickers
Pontillo's Pickers

Cheese Fries

Crispy cheese fries topped with our classic Mozzarella cheese

$6.00


Mega Fries

Crispy mega fries loaded with Mozzarella, Cheddar cheese, a dash of bacon, comes with a side of ranch dressing

$6.00

Mega Fries

Chicken Fingers

Crispy chicken fingers come with one house-made Blue Cheese sauce and one savory sauce of your choice

$8.75

Chicken Fingers

Mozzarella Sticks

Battered Mozzarella sticks come with one classic Pontillo's red sauce

$8.75

Mozzarella Sticks

Fried Mushrooms

Crispy fried mushrooms come with one side of house-made Blue cheese sauce

$8.75

Fried Mushrooms

Cheese Garlic Bread

Signature white garlic sauce, a dash of oregano, drizzled with extra virgin olive oil, blanketed with our classic Mozzarella and Parmesan cheese

$8.00

Cheese Garlic Bread

Breadsticks

Delightfully smothered in our signature white garlic sauce, garnished with Parmesan cheese, a dash of oregano, and our classic Mozzarella cheese

$11.00

Breadsticks

Fried Cauliflower

Crispy fried cauliflower comes with one side of house-made Blue cheese sauce

$8.75


Fries

Salted freshly made french fries come with one side of ketchup

$5.00

Fries

Pizza Logs

Pizza Logs come with one classic Pontillo's red sauce

$8.75

Pizza Logs

Garlic Knots

Pontillo's famous garlic knots!

$9.00

Garlic Knots
wings
Wings

Wings

Classic jumbo chicken wings with your choice of any of our savory sauces.

$10.00

Wings

Boneless Wings

Classic boneless wings with your choice of any of our savory sauces.

$10.00

salads
Salads

NEW! Chef's Salad

Classic lettuce, ham, turkey, Provolone, Cheddar, Swiss cheese, Cherry tomatoes, Garbanzo beans, Sliced hard-boiled eggs, croutons.

$10.50

NEW! Chef's Salad

NEW! Garden Salad

Spring mixed lettuce, Cherry tomatoes, Garbanzo beans, cucumber slices, onion, croutons.

$10.50

NEW! Garden Salad

NEW! Grilled Chicken Caesar Salad

Fresh mushrooms, sliced onion, bacon, grilled chicken, croutons, and a dash of our classic Pontillo's Parmesan cheese

$10.50

NEW! Grilled Chicken Caesar Salad
calzones
Calzones

Mozzarella Buffalo Chicken Calzone

Diced chicken and Mozzarella cheese, with your choice of savory sauce mild, medium, country sweet BBQ, or hot.

$13.75

Mozzarella Buffalo Chicken Calzone

Three Cheese Calzone

A blend of Mozzarella, Ricotta, and our classic Pontillo's Parmesan cheese.

$11.75

Three Cheese Calzone
cold-subs
Cold Subs

American Assorted (Ham and Turkey) Sub

$8.55


Ham Sub

$8.55


Turkey Sub

$8.55

hot-subs
Hot Subs

Steak Sub

Pontillo's classic shaved steak

$8.55

Steak Sub

Firesteak & Cheese Sub

Sauteed steak and our Pontillo's signature hot sauce

$8.55


Meatball Sub

Classic Pontillo's meatballs with red sauce

$8.55

Meatball Sub

Chicken Parmesan Sub

Breaded chicken with classic Pontillo's red sauce

$8.55

Chicken Parmesan Sub

Buffalo Chicken Sub

With your choice of mild, medium, BBQ, country sweet, or hot sauce.

$8.55

desserts
Desserts

Chocolate Chip Cookies

Famous Dave's chunky chocolate chip cookies, a bite above the rest!

$2.96

Chocolate Chip Cookies

Fried Dough

Pontillo's classic homemade fried dough, original recipe since 1947!

$5.00

Fried Dough
beverages
Beverages

Soda

Ice cold Pepsi products

$4.75

Soda
SliceNYWebster14580 Pontillo's Pizzeria-WEBSTER The Original Recipe!
Price: $$