12" Pizza
The Rustic Pizza
Tomato Sauce, Mozzarella, Basil, Olive Oil, baked on our leopard-spotted sourdough crust.
$15.99
The Bianca Pizza
White pizza. Mozzarella, parmigiano reggiano, fresh garlic, ricotta, rosemary, olive oil, baked on our leopard-spotted sourdough crust.
$16.99
Sonny Boy Pizza
Pepperoni pizza. Tomato sauce, mozzarella, pepperoni, baked on our leopard-spotted sourdough crust.
$15.99
The Godfather Pizza
This one runs the family. White alfredo base, grande mozz, fig jam, and crispy bacon, finished with prosciutto and a hot honey drizzle that hits hard. Baked on our leopard-spotted sourdough crust. '' Sweet salty, rich- respect the pie.
$16.99
Goodfella Pizza
Sausage pizza. Tomato sauce, mozzarella, sausage, baked on our leopard-spotted sourdough crust.
$16.99
Build Your Own Pizza
Cheese Pizza & choose your toppings.
$15.99
The Don Meatza Pizza
Meat pizza. Tomato sauce, mozzarella, pepperoni, sausage, soppressata, sautéed onions, baked on our leopard-spotted sourdough crust.
$16.99
Mr. Big Deal Pizza
Ranch sauce base. Mozzarella, dill pickles, fresh herbs, and a sriracha kick on our house-made sourdough crust.
$16.99
Mellow Mushroom Pizza
White pizza. Mozzarella, parmigiano reggiano, baby bella mushrooms, ricotta, rosemary, olive oil, baked on our leopard-spotted sourdough crust.
$16.99
Mr. Big Deal Pizza with Bacon
Ranch sauce base. Mozzarella, dill pickles, fresh herbs, and a sriracha kick on our house-made sourdough crust.
$19.99
Wiseguy Pizza
Tomato sauce, mozzarella, sauteed roasted yellow onion, red & green peppers, homemade Italian sausage, baked on our leopard-spotted sourdough crust.
$16.99
The Gloria Pizza
Tomato Sauce, Garlic Basil, Olive Oil, baked on our leopard-spotted sourdough crust.
$15.99
The Riggs Pie
The hog 95.7". Tomato sauce, mozzarella, pepperoni, fresh garlic, dollops of ricotta, finished with a hot honey drizzle, baked on our leopard-spotted sourdough crust.
$16.99
The Trenton Job Pizza
Mozzarella down first, then topped with our house tomato sauce and finished with drizzle of olive oil. An old-school, up-side-down pie that puts the sauce where it steals the show.
$16.99
Garden State Pizza
Veggie pizza. Tomato sauce, mozzarella, zucchini, mushrooms, onion, bell pepper, garlic, cherry tomatoes, baked on our leopard-spotted sourdough crust.
$16.99
Starters
The Dockside Calamari
Lightly breaded calamari, fried crisp, served with homemade marinara sauce Straight off the boardwalk… without the sand.
$14.99
Frankie's Mussels
Half pound of premium New Zealand green mussels, presented in a boat with our house-made sauce and plenty for dipping, served with warm sourdough baguette.
$10.99
The Cheese Job
Garlic Cheese Curds. Golden fried garlic cheese curds, served with homemade marinara sauce and grated parmesan Illegal how good these are.
$10.99
Crunchy Capo Wings
Ultra-crispy, double-fried jumbo wings with that signature shatter crunch you hear on the first bite. Coated in a light rice-based breading for a ridiculously crisp finish, then fried to perfection.
$13.99
The Secret Meatballs
Two house made large meatballs, crafted from a premium blend of beef and veal (no pork) and folded with our signature mix of fresh soft bread and croissant crumb, baked and finished in our slow-simmered tomato sauce
$10.99
Tony Ravioli
Handmade breaded ravioli, toasted golden brown, served with homemade marinara sauce and grated parmesan.
$11.99
Breakfast Sides
Home Fries Breakfast
$3.99
Short Stack of Pancakes Breakfast
$5.99
Sourdough Toast Breakfast
$2.99
Egg Breakfast
$1.99
Taylor Ham Breakfast
$2.99
Bagel with Plain Cream Cheese Breakfast
$3.99
Bacon Breakfast
$2.99
Cheese Breakfast
$0.99
Sausage Patties Breakfast
$2.99
Breakfast Omelettes
The Boardwalk Classic Breakfast
Three free-range eggs filled with pork roll (Taylor Ham), aged cheddar, and caramelized onions.
$14.99
The Garden State Breakfast
Three free-range eggs with tomatoes, zucchini, mushrooms, onions, caramelized onions, and bell peppers.
$14.99
The Creamy Pig Breakfast
Three free-range eggs with bacon, roasted mushrooms, and Swiss cheese, finished with a light garlicAlfredo drizzle.
$15.99
The Turnpike Omelette Breakfast
Three free-range eggs with your choice of cheese: Pepper Jack, Cheddar, American, or Swiss.
$13.99
Breakfast Starters & Sweets
Butter French Toast Breakfast
Baked sourdough French toast with syrup, whipped cream and warm butter drizzle.
$8.99
Cranberry Orange Scone Breakfast
$6.99
Fresh Sourdough Cinnamon Roll Breakfast
$5.99
Baker’s Daily Scone Breakfast
$6.99
Blueberry Lemon Scone Breakfast
$6.99
Biscuits & Gravy Breakfast
2 warm, buttermilk biscuits with sausage gravy.
$4.99
Chocolate Chip Scone Breakfast
$6.99
Breakfast Platters
The Baker’s Breakfast
Three eggs any style, bacon or sausage, sourdough toast, home fries.
$11.99
The Rustic Platter Breakfast
Two eggs any style, home fries, sourdough toast.
$5.99
Avocado Sunrise Platter Breakfast
Sunny-side eggs in avocado halves, everything seasoning, home fries, sourdough toast.
$13.99
Breakfast Eggs Benedict Sourdough Style
Classic Benedict Breakfast
Two poached eggs over toasted sourdough, Taylor ham, hollandaise sauce. Served with mixed greens
$14.99
Smoked Salmon Benedict Breakfast
Two poached eggs over toasted sourdough, smoked salmon, hollandaise sauce. Served with mixed greens.
$16.99
Kaiser Roll Breakfast Sandwiches
Classic Breakfast Kaiser
Two fried eggs, bacon or sausage, American cheese on a Kaiser roll. Served with home fries.
$8.99
Veggie Breakfast Kaiser
Two fried eggs, peppers, onions, cheddar on a Kaiser roll. Served with home fries.
$8.99
Taylor Ham, Egg & Cheese Kaiser Breakfast
Two fried eggs, Taylor ham, American cheese on a Kaiser roll. Served with home fries.
$9.99
Classic Bagel & Lox Breakfast
Nova Scotia smoked salmon, lemon dill cream cheese, capers, red onion, baby bib lettuce on a NY-style bagel. Served with home fries or mixed greens.
$13.99
Breakfast Sourdough Pancakes
Classic Pancake Stack Breakfast
$10.99
Chocolate Chip Pancake Stack Breakfast
$11.99
Entrees
The Capone
Full pound of premium New Zealand green mussels simmered in our house-made San Marzano Diablo sauce, wrapped in fettuccine made with premium Italian pasta. Hot as hell - you call the shots.
$19.99
The Sunday Sit-Down
Spaghetti with hand-smashed San Marzano tomato sauce, garlic, basil, sea salt, topped with two large house-made beef & veal meatballs.
$19.99
The Ricotta Racket
Stuffed gnocchi. Ricotta-stuffed gnocchi, creamy parmesan garlic sauce, crispy garlic chips.
$18.99
The Florentine Boss Pasta
Pan-seared chicken cutlet topped with creamy garlic spinach, prosciutto, & melted mozzarella, finished with our house saltimboc-ca sauce over fettuccine. A rich, full-flavor classic that runs the show.
$17.99
Coastal Florentine
Jumbo shrimp sauteed with garlic, fresh spinach, & prosciutto, fin-ished in our signature saltimbocca sauce & served over fettuccine. Light , savory & straight from the coast.
$21.99
Salads
The House Hit Salad
Mixed greens, tomatoes, onions, house dressing Simple. Clean. Does the job.
$6.99
The Caesar Contract Salad
Romaine, croutons, parmesan, house Caesar You order it every time for a reason.
$7.99
Chef's Choice - The Heavy Hitters
The Don Parm
Hand-smashed, thin fried chicken cutlet, tomato sauce, mozzarella, parmesan Pounded thin, fried hard, respected by all.
$18.99
The Chicken Martini à la Marsala
24-hour marinated, thin-pounded locally farm-raised, all-natural Florida pork, panko-crusted and flash-fried until golden, finished in a rich Marsala wine reduction with wild mushrooms and blistered hot cherry tomatoes, served over fettuccine made with premium Italian pasta. Shaken in the pan — not stirred. No shortcuts. All family. Choice of pork or chicken. The Hothead - 19.99 Full pound of premium New Zealand green mussels simmered in our house-made San Marzano Diablo sauce, wrapped in fettuccine made with premium Italian pasta. Sweet • Sweet heat • Hot as hell — you call the shots. Pasta Availability—Spaghetti, Fettuccine, Ziti - that’s it. Don’t ask. The Lemon Enforcer – $19.99 Hand-smashed, thin chicken cutlet, double-fried, 24- hour house brined, finished with a lemon buttery sauce and capers Crispy, juicy, and makes you sit up straight. The Smokehouse Underboss (Pork Osso Buco)– $20.99 Locally sourced, all-natural pork osso buco, housesmoked and slow-braised until fall-off-the-bone tender, finished in its natural reduction and served with garlic smashed potatoes. Clean ingredients. No shortcuts. All family. The Undercover Vodka - 18.99 Golden panko-crusted chicken cutlet, topped with our house-made San Marzano tomato vodka sauce, finished
$19.99
The Lemon Enforcer
Hand-smashed, thin chicken cutlet, double-fried, 24-hour house brined, finished with a lemon buttery sauce and capers Crispy, juicy, and makes you sit up straight.
$19.99
The Undercover Vodka
Golden panko-crusted chicken cutlet, topped with our house-made San Marzano tomato vodka sauce, finished with Grande mozzarella and fresh basil, served over fettuccine made with premium Italian pasta.
$18.99
The White Suit
Chicken Fettuccine Alfredo. Fettuccine tossed in creamy Alfredo, topped with tender chicken Smooth, rich, and way too easy to crush.
$18.99
The Hothead
Full pound of premium new zealand green mussels simmered in our house-made San Marzano Diablo sauce, wrapped in fettuccine made with premium Italian pasta.
$19.99
The Smokehouse Underboss
Pork osso buco. Locally sourced, all-natural pork osso buco, house-smoked and slow-braised until fall-off the bone tender, finished in its natural reduction and served with garlic smashed potatoes.
$22.99
Drink
Soda
$2.99
Apple Juice
$1.99
Coffee
$2.99
Single Espresso
$3.99
Orange Juice
$2.99
Double Espresso
$5.99
Lunch Salads
The House Hit Salad Lunch
Mixed greens, tomatoes, onions, house dressing Simple. Clean. Does the job.
$5.99
The Caesar Contract Salad
Mixed greens, tomatoes, onions, house dressing.
$6.99
Lunch Signature Sandwiches
The Turnpike BALT Sandwich Lunch
Rustic Avo BALT. Thick-cut crispy bacon, fresh avocado, lettuce & tomato, herb mayo on sourdough bread.
$15.99
The Hot-Head from Hoboken Sandwich Lunch
Eggplant parmesan. French eggplant, breaded to perfection, marinara, parmesan and mozzarella cheese. Cheese served on an 8 inch sub roll.
$13.99
Brick City Enforcer Sandwich Lunch
Fried chicken sandwich. Pickle-brined crispy chicken breast, lettuce, tomato, pickles, slaw, comeback sauce served on a Kaiser roll.
$16.99
Little Mikey from Mulberry Street Sandwich Lunch
Chicken parmesan. Fresh chicken breast breaded to perfection, marinara, parmesan and mozzarella cheese. Cheese served on an 8 inch sub roll.
$13.99
The Consigliere Sandwich Lunch
Meatball parmesan. Three succulent meatballs, marinara, parmesan and mozzarella cheese served on an 8 inch sub roll.
$13.99
The Rustic Italian Hot Dog Lunch
Two fried hot dogs loaded up the right way - Peppers & onions, crispy potatoes, all packed into a Fresh, Jersey-style roll.
$13.99
Kids
Little Paulie’s Pasta with Tomato Sauce
Pasta with tomato sauce or garlic butter.
$9.99
Little Paulie’s Pasta with Garlic Butter
$9.99
16'' Pizza
The Rustic Pizza
Cheese Pie. Tomato Sauce, Mozzarella, Basil Olive Oil, on Rustic's N.Y. Style Crust featuring a crisp outside with a soft, chewy interior.
$24.99
Wiseguy Pizza
Tomato Sauce, Mozzarella, Sauteed Roasted Yellow Onion, Red & Green Peppers, Homemade Italian Sausage, on Rustic's N.Y. Style Crust featuring a crisp out-side with a soft, chewy interior.
$26.99
The Gloria Pizza
Tomato Pie. Tomato Sauce, Garlic, Basil, Olive Oil, on Rustic's N.Y. Style Crust featuring a crisp out-side with a soft, chewy interior.
$25.99
The Riggs Pie
"The Hog 95.7" Tomato Sauce, Mozzarella, Pepperoni, Fresh Garlic, Dollops of Ricotta, finished with a Hot Honey Drizzle, on Rustic's N.Y. Style Crust featuring a crisp outside with a soft, chewy interior.
$26.99
Sonny Boy Pizza
Pepperoni Pie. Tomato Sauce, Mozzarella, Pepperoni, on Rustic's N.Y. Style Crust featuring a crisp outside with a soft, chewy interior.
$25.99
The Trenton Job Pizza
Mozzarella down first, then topped with our house tomato sauce and finished with drizzle of olive oil. An old-school, upside-down pie that puts the sauce where it steals the show.
$23.99
Goodfella Pizza
Sausage Pie. Tomato Sauce, Mozzarella, Sausage, on Rustic's N.Y. Style Crust featuring a crisp out- side with a soft, chewy interior.
$26.99
Garden State Pizza
Veggie Pie-Tomato Sauce, Mozzarella, Zucchini, Mushrooms, Onion, Bell Pepper, Garlic, Cherry Tomatoes, on Rustic's N.Y. Style Crust featuring a crisp outside with a soft, chewy interior.
$26.99
The Don Meatza Pizza
Meat pizza. Tomato sauce, mozzarella, pepperoni, sausage, soppressata, sautéed onions, baked on our leopard-spotted sourdough crust.
$26.99
The Bianca Pizza
White Pizza. Mozzarella, Parmigiano Reggiano, Fresh Garlic, Ricotta, Rosemary, Olive Oil, on Rustic's N.Y. Style Crust featuring a crisp outside with a soft, chewy interior.
$26.99
Mellow Mushroom Pizza
White Pizza. Mozzarella, Parmigiano Reggiano, Baby Bella Mushrooms, Ricotta, Rosemary,Olive Oil, on Rustic's N.Y. Style Crust featuring a crisp out-side with a soft, chewy interior.
$26.99
The Godfather Pizza
This one runs the family.White Alfredo base, Grande mozz, fig, and crispy bacon, finished with prosciutto & a hot honey drizzle that hits hard. on Rustic's N.Y. Style Crust featuring a crisp outside with a soft, chewy interior.
$26.99
Mr. Big Deal Pizza
Ranch sauce base. Mozzarella, Dill pickles,Fresh Herbs, & a Sriracha kick on our house-made sour-dough crust.
$26.99
The Pineapple Express Pizza
Pepperoni, Jalapenos, Pineapple, Mozzarella, Tomato Sauce, on Rustic's N.Y. Style Crust featuring a crisp outside with a soft, chewy interior.
$26.99
The Sailor Man Pizza
AKA Popeye. Alfredo Sauce, Fresh Garlic, Spinach, Mozzarella, Dollops of Ricotta, Chicken, on Rustic's N.Y. Style Crust featuring a crisp outside with a soft, chewy interior.
$26.99
The Big Russian Pizza
Vodka Sauce, Mozzarella, Parmesan, Choice of Chicken or Meatballs, Basil, on Rustic's N.Y. Style Crust featuring a crisp outside with a soft, chewy interior.
$24.99
Nonna's Leftovers Pizza
Meatballs, Sausage, Cherry Tomatoes, Mozzarella, Dollops of Ricotta, Tomato Sauce on Rustic's N.Y. Style Crust featuring a crisp outside with a soft, chewy interior.
$26.99
Build Your Own Pizza
Cheese Pie, and choose your topping(s), starting at
$24.99