AJ's Pizza

12 Main St, Butler, NJ 07405

Currently ClosedFull HoursAre you the owner?

We're all about supporting local pizzerias - even those who are not Slice partners.
Give AJ's Pizza a call to order. We hear their food's delish.

Cheese Pizza$6.50 +
Classic cheese or create your own pizza.
Cauliflower Crust Pizza$14.00
Gluten Free Pizza$9.00
Sicilian Pizza$14.50
Pan Pizza$14.50
Grandma Pizza$18.00
Thin crust Sicilian with fresh mozzarella, plum tomatoes, basil, olive oil & garlic.
Chicken Vodka Pizza$10.50 +
Sun­-Dried Tomato Pizza$8.50 +
Roasted Peppers Pizza$8.50 +
Chicken Teriyaki Pizza$11.50 +
Red onions & pineapple.
Breaded Ancho Chipotle Chicken Pizza$9.50 +
White Pizza$8.00 +
Mozzarella & ricotta cheese.
White Spinach Pizza$9.50 +
White Broccoli Pizza$9.50 +
Hawaiian Pizza$9.50 +
Ham & pineapple.
Eggplant Pizza$8.00 +
Eggplant Rollatini Pizza$9.00 +
Grilled Chicken Pizza$9.00 +
Breaded Chicken Pizza$9.00 +
BBQ Chicken Pizza$9.50 +
Baked Ziti Pizza$8.75 +
Penne Vodka Pizza$10.00 +
Cheese Tortellini Alfredo Pizza$10.00 +
Vodka Sauce Pizza$8.00 +
Cheeseburger Pizza$9.00 +
Chicken Francese Pizza$10.00 +
Five Cheese Pizza$9.50 +
Ricotta, cheddar, provolone, Swiss & mozzarella cheese.
Margherita Pizza$9.00 +
Shrimp Scampi Pizza$10.00 +
Plum Tomato & Basil Pizza$7.50 +
Bruschetta Pizza$8.75 +
Cheese Steak Pizza$10.00 +
Mushrooms, onions, peppers & potatoes.
French Fries Pizza$8.00 +
Curly Fries Pizza$8.00 +
Chicken Balsamico Pizza$11.50 +
Fresh mozzarella & roasted peppers.
Macaroni & Cheese Pizza$10.00 +
Fat AJ’s Pizza$11.50 +
Our fresh dough topped w/ pizza sauce, steak, chicken fingers, french fries, mozzarella sticks, onion rings, mozzarella cheese & American cheese).
Cheese Steak Special Pizza$11.00 +
Steak, garlic butter, steak fries, mozzarella cheese, American cheese & brown gravy.
Salad Pizza$8.50 +
Very little sauce, eggplant, fresh mozzarella, lettuce, tomatoes, red onions, oil & white vinegar.
Pesto Pizza$8.25 +
Greek Pizza$9.00 +
Spinach, feta & mozzarella cheese.
AJ’s Special Pizza$11.00 +
Meatball, pepperoni, sausage, olives, extra cheese, bacon, fresh mushrooms, peppers & onions.
AJ’s Veggie Pizza$9.50 +
Broccoli, olives, onions, mushrooms, peppers & spinach.
AJ’s Meat Lovers Pizza$9.50 +
Meatballs, sausage, ham, bacon & pepperoni.
Mixed Greens Salad Pizza$9.00 +
Fresh mixed greens tossed w/ fresh mozzarella, olive oil, salt & pepper.
Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza$11.00 +
Boom Boom Chicken Pizza$11.50 +
Sliced hot cherry peppers & bacon.
Mediterranean Pizza$9.00 +
Fresh spinach, tomatoes & olive oil topped with mozzarella cheese.
Creamy Spinach Artichoke Pizza$13.00 +
Creamy alfredo sauce, artichoke hearts, spinach, and mozzarella cheese.
Cheese Pizza Slice$2.00
Sicilian Pizza Slice$2.25
White Pizza Slice$3.00
Chicken Pizza Slice$3.50
Eggplant Rollatini Pizza Slice$3.00
Chicken Francese Pizza Slice$3.00
Penne Vodka Pizza Slice$3.00
Grandma Pizza Slice$3.00
Mac & Cheese$6.00
Mac & Cheese with Bacon$7.00
Broccoli Cheddar Bites$7.00
Mac & Cheese Bites$7.00
Eggplant Rollatini$8.00
Shrimp Cocktail$6.50
Fried Mushrooms$7.00
Creamy Corn Nuggets$7.00
Mozzarella Sticks$7.50
Buffalo Mozzarella Sticks$8.00
New Zealand Green Shell Mussels$10.00
Hor or sweet.
Black Shell Mussels$9.50
Hor or sweet.
Fried Calamari$8.50
Hor or sweet.
Fried Shrimp$8.00
Hor or sweet.
Wings$5.00 +
Boneless Wings$5.00 +
Cheese Steak Eggrolls$7.00
Zucchini Sticks$6.00
Chicken Nuggets$4.75
Chicken Fingers with Fries$8.75
Buffalo Fingers$7.75
Popcorn Chicken$6.75
Buffalo Popcorn Chicken$7.75
Popcorn Shrimp$8.00
Buffalo Popcorn Shrimp$9.00
Fried Banana Pepper Rings$8.50
French Fries$2.00 +
Sweet Potato Fries$3.00 +
French Fries with Cheese$4.50
French Fries with Gravy$4.50
French Fries with Cheese & Gravy$5.50
French Fries with Cheddar Cheese & Bacon$6.00
French Fries with Cheese & Vodka Sauce$5.50
Pizza Fries$5.50
Curly Fries$3.00 +
Steak Fries$3.00 +
French Bread Pizza$3.00 +
Garlic Bread with Cheese$3.50 +
Garlic Knots$3.00
Buffalo Garlic Knots$4.50
Potato Skins with Cheddar & Bacon$9.00
Potato Skins with Cheddar & Broccoli$9.00
Battered Spicy Pub Pickles$7.00
Onion Rings$3.00 +
Fried Ravioli$7.00
Jalapeño Poppers$7.00
Zuppa Di Clams$9.00
White scampi or marinara.
Sampler #1$9.00
3 chicken fingers, 3 mozzarella sticks, 3 poppers.
Sampler #2$9.00
4 Corn nuggets, 3 mac & cheese bites, and 3 fried pickles.
Sauteed Broccoli$5.00
Sauteed Broccoli with Chicken$7.50
Sauteed Spinach$5.00
Sauteed Spinach with Chicken$7.50
Sauteed Broccoli Rabe$6.00
Sauteed Broccoli Rabe with Chicken$8.25
Pizza Potato Skins$7.00
Pizza Potato Skins with Topping$8.00
Chicken Noodle Soup$5.00
Cheese Tortellini Soup$5.00
Chicken & Wild Rice Soup$5.00
Pasta Fagioli Soup$5.00
House Salad$5.50 +
House Salad with Grilled Chicken$9.00 +
Antipasto Salad$8.00 +
Chef Salad$8.25 +
Caesar Salad$6.50 +
Caesar Salad with Grilled Chicken$10.00 +
Fresh Mozzarella, Tomato & Basil Salad$7.25 +
Fresh Mixed Greens Salad$8.25 +
With feta & prosciutto salad.
Calamari Salad$10.50 +
Shrimp Salad$10.50 +
Seafood Salad$11.00 +
Grilled Chicken & Cranberries Salad$9.50 +
Grilled chicken over mixed greens w/ sliced almonds & raspberry vinaigrette.
Greek Salad$8.50 +
Grilled Chicken & Artichoke Salad$9.50 +
Grilled chicken over romaine lettuce w/ red onions, roasted peppers, artichokes & fresh mozzarella.
BBQ Grilled Chicken Salad$9.50 +
BBQ grilled chicken over romaine lettuce w/ cucumbers, tomatoes, red onions, cheddar cheese & ranch dressing.
Grilled Chicken Fresh Apple Craisin Salad$10.75 +
Grilled chicken over mixed greens w/ tomatoes, red onions, frosted pecans, craisins, goat cheese & fresh apple slices.
Grilled Chicken Mandarin Salad$10.75 +
Grilled chicken over mixed greens w/ tomatoes, red onions, goat cheese, craisins & mandarin oranges.
Buffalo Chicken Salad$9.00 +
All Calzones & Stromboli are baked fresh to order.
Cheese Calzone$6.00
Ham & Cheese Calzone$6.75
Chicken Calzone$9.50
Buffalo Chicken Calzone$10.00
Steak Calzone$9.50
Veggie Calzone$9.50
Mushrooms, olives, peppers, onions, spinach & broccoli.
Meat Lovers Calzone$9.50
Ham, bacon, pepperoni, meatballs & sausage.
AJ’s Special Calzone$11.00
Meatball, pepperoni, sausage, olives, extra cheese, bacon, fresh mushrooms, peppers & onions.
Fat AJ’s Stromboli$11.00
Eggplant Calzone$8.50
Mac & Cheese Calzone$10.00
Pepperoni Roll$3.50
Broccoli Roll$3.50
Spinach Roll$3.50
Chicken Roll$5.00
All wraps are made fresh to order on either white or whole wheat wrap.
Tuna Salad Wrap$8.00
With lettuce & tomatoes.
Chicken Caesar Wrap$8.00
Grilled chicken w/ romaine lettuce, croutons & caesar dressing.
Buffalo Chicken Wrap$8.00
Lettuce, tomatoes & bleu cheese dressing.
Cheese Steak Wrap$8.00
Mushrooms, peppers, onions, potatoes & American cheese.
Chicken Teriyaki Wrap$8.00
Red onions, pineapples, American cheese & teriyaki sauce.
Chicken Parm Wrap$8.00
Vodka sauce wrap breaded chicken w/ vodka sauce & mozzarella cheese.
Turkey & Cheese Wrap$8.00
Lettuce, tomatoes, onions & American cheese.
Grilled Chicken Wrap$8.00 +
Fresh mozzarella, roasted peppers & balsamic vinaigrette.
Breaded Chicken Wrap$8.00
Lettuce, tomatoes & onions.
Italian Wrap$8.00
Lettuce, tomatoes, onions, oil & vinegar.
Eggplant Wrap$8.00
Fresh mozzarella, roasted peppers & balsamic vinaigrette.
Hot Veggie Wrap Fried Eggplant$8.00
Grilled broccoli, spinach, mushrooms & peppers.
Roast Beef & Cheese Wrap$8.00
Lettuce, tomatoes, onions & American cheese.
Salad Wrap$8.00
Mixed greens, tomatoes, cucumbers, red onions, black olives, goat cheese & raspberry vinaigrette.
Chicken Bruschetta Wrap$8.00
Your choice of breaded or grilled chicken, topped w/ fresh-homemade bruschetta w/ your choice of dressing.
All subs are available as a wrap or panini. Ask for: lettuce, tomato, onions, mayo, mustard, oil & vinegar.
Italian Sub$5.75 +
Ham & Cheese Sub$5.25 +
Salami & Cheese Sub$5.25 +
Grilled Chicken Sub$5.75 +
Lettuce & tomato.
Grilled Chicken Sub with Broccoli Rabe$8.00 +
Fresh mozzarella & roasted peppers.
Buffalo Chicken Cutlet Sub$6.00 +
Breaded Chicken Cutlet Sub$5.75 +
With lettuce & tomato.
BLT Sub$5.75 +
Veal Cutlet Sub$7.75 +
With lettuce & tomato.
Eggplant Sub$7.00 +
Fresh mozzarella & roasted peppers.
Tuna Sub$5.75 +
Tuna Melt Sub$6.25 +
Turkey Sub$6.00 +
Turkey & Cheese Sub$6.50 +
Three Cheese Sub$5.75 +
American, provolone & Swiss.
Prosciutto Sub$7.50 +
Fresh mozzarella & roasted peppers.
Prosciutto & Provolone Sub$5.50 +
Chicken BLT Sub$6.75 +
Fresh Mozzarella & Roasted Peppers Sub$5.25 +
Roast Beef Sub$6.25 +
Roast Beef & Turkey Sub$6.75 +
All subs are available as a wrap or panini.
Shrimp Parmigiana Sub$7.00 +
Chicken Parmigiana Sub$6.25 +
Chicken Parm Sub with Alfredo Sauce$7.25 +
Chicken Parm Sub with Vodka Sauce$7.25 +
Grilled Chicken Parm Sub$6.25 +
Boom Boom Chicken Parm Sub$7.25 +
Buffalo Chicken Parm Sub$6.50 +
Veal Parmigiana Sub$8.25 +
Eggplant Parmigiana Sub$5.50 +
Meatball Sub$4.75 +
Meatball Parmigiana Sub$5.25 +
Sausage Sub$4.75 +
Italian Hot Dog Sub$6.25 +
Marinara, mushrooms, peppers, onions, potatoes & mozzarella cheese.
Sausage Parmigiana Sub$5.25 +
Sausage & Peppers Sub$5.25 +
Sausage, Peppers & Onion Sub$5.75 +
Pepper & Egg Sub$5.25 +
Pepper, Egg & Cheese Sub$5.75 +
Sausage, Peppers, Egg & Cheese Sub$6.50 +
Ham, Egg & Cheese Sub$6.25 +
Egg & Cheese Sub$5.25 +
Bacon Egg & Cheese Sub$6.00 +
Chicken Francese Sub$8.75 +
Fresh mozzarella.
Chicken Marsala Sub$8.75 +
Fresh mozzarella.
Grilled Chicken Teriyaki Sub$6.50 +
Your choice of cheese.
Buffalo Chicken Cutlet Sub$6.75 +
Melted cheddar & ranch or bleu cheese.
Hot Roast Beef Sub$7.25 +
Mozzarella cheese & gravy.
Grilled Chicken Ancho Chipotle Sub$6.75 +
Your choice of cheese.
Hot Turkey Sub$7.00 +
Mozzarella cheese & gravy.
Grilled Chicken Balsamico Sub$8.75 +
Grilled chicken marinated in balsamic dressing w/ melted mozzarella cheese & roasted peppers on toasted Italian bread.
Grilled Chicken Pesto Sub$8.75
Goat cheese & roasted peppers on fresh ciabatta bread.
Sweet BBQ Cheese Steak Sub$6.75 +
Cheddar cheese.
Buffalo Chicken Cheese Steak Sub$6.75 +
Provolone, lettuce & bleu cheese.
Fat AJ’s #1$7.75 +
Chicken cutlet w/ french fries, mozzarella sticks, American cheese, onion rings & mayo.
Fat AJ’s #2$7.75 +
Steak w/ chicken cutlet, french fries, mozzarella sticks, American cheese, onion rings & mayo.
Fat AJ’s #3$7.75 +
Chicken fingers w/ mozzarella sticks, french fries, marinara or honey mustard.
Fat AJ’s #4$7.75 +
Steak w/ mozzarella sticks, french fries & marinara sauce.
Fat AJ’s #5$7.75 +
Steak w/ chicken fingers, mozzarella sticks, french fries, lettuce & ketchup.
Fat AJ’s #6$7.75 +
Steak w/ bacon, egg, lettuce, tomato, mayo, ketchup, American cheese & french fries.
All Paninis are made fresh to order & grilled on our freshly baked ciabatta bread.
Prosciutto Panini$8.75
Fresh mozzarella, sun-dried tomato & olive oil.
Chicken Caesar Panini$8.75
Grilled chicken w/ romaine lettuce, croutons & caesar dressing.
Fresh Mozzarella, Tomato, Basil & Balsamic Vinaigrette Panini$8.75
Grilled Chicken Panini$8.75 +
Fresh mozzarella, roasted peppers & balsamic vinaigrette.
Grilled Chicken Pesto Panini$8.75
Sun-dried tomato & goat cheese.
Grilled Chicken Mixed Green Panini$8.75
Fresh mozzarella, mixed greens & balsamic vinaigrette.
Turkey, Bacon, Cheddar Cheese & Sun ­Dried Tomato Panini$8.75
Honey mustard or deli mustard.
Roast Beef Panini$8.75
Cheddar cheese, lettuce, tomato, red onions & thousand island dressing.
Steak, Fresh Mozzarella & Roasted Peppers Panini$8.75
Mixed greens, tomato & balsamic vinaigrette.
Cheese Steak Panini$8.75
Mushrooms, peppers, onions, potatoes & American cheese.
Tuna Salad Panini$8.75
Our special recipe tuna topped w/ leaf lettuce, tomato, red onion, salt & pepper.
Veggie Panini$8.75
Mixed greens, roasted peppers, feta cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion & chipotle mayo.
Prosciutto Pesto Panini$8.75
Goat cheese & sun-dried tomatoes.
All gyros come with lettuce, tomato, red onion & tzatziki sauce.
Grilled Cheese$4.50
Gyro with Cheese$7.25
Grilled Chicken Gyro$6.75
Grilled Chicken Gyro with Cheese$7.25
Steak Sandwich$5.25 +
Cheese Steak$6.25 +
Chicken Cheese Steak$6.25 +
Pizza Steak$6.75 +
Cheese Steak on Garlic Bread$7.75 +
Mozzarella cheese, potato & brown gravy.
Steak, Egg & Cheese Sandwich$7.25 +
8 oz. Certified Angus beef.
Bacon Cheeseburger$9.00
Pizza Burger$8.75
Grilled Mushroom Swiss Burger$9.50
Double Cheeseburger$12.00
Grilled Cheeseburger Burger$8.50
Grilled on fresh sliced white bread w/ American cheese.
Boom Boom Burger$9.00
Topped with boom boom sauce & melted mozzarella cheese.
5 Cheese Burger$9.50
Topped with American, mozzarella, provolone, Swiss, & cheddar cheese.
Fat Burger #1$10.00
Steak, steak fries, onions, American cheese & chipotle mayo.
Fat Burger #2$10.00
With French fries, mozzarella sticks, onion rings, American cheese & mayo.
Fat Burger #3$10.00
With chicken fingers, mozzarella sticks, onion rings, American cheese, lettuce, tomato & mayo.
Fat Burger #4$10.00
With chicken fingers, mozzarella sticks, marinara sauce & mozzarella cheese.
Create Your Own Fat Burger$10.00
Disco Burger$10.00
Burger topped w/ steak fries, mozzarella cheese & gravy.
Teriyaki Cheeseburger$10.00
Burger topped w/ grilled red onions, pineapple, teriyaki sauce & your choice of cheese.
Egg & Cheeseburger$9.50
Egg & Cheeseburger with Bacon$10.50
Chipotle Burger$9.50
Ancho chipotle sauce & your choice of cheese.
Cowboy Burger$10.00
Swiss, jalapeños, BBQ sauce, onions & bacon.
Mac & Cheese Burger$10.50
Homemade mac & cheese, & two beer-battered onion rings.
Pesto Burger$10.50
Fresh mozzarella, roasted peppers & pesto.
Greek Burger$10.00
Lettuce, tomato, red onion, tzatziki sauce, and feta cheese.
Your choice of spaghetti, penne, capellini, rigatoni, fettuccine. Also available: whole grain penne or linguine & gluten-free penne.
Marinara Sauce$8.50
Butter Sauce$8.50
Meat Sauce$9.50
Primavera Sauce$10.50
Cream or marinara.
Garlic & Oil$8.50
Broccoli, Garlic & Oil$9.50
Vodka Sauce with Shrimp$14.50
Vodka Sauce$10.50
Vodka Sauce with Chicken$13.50
Alfredo Sauce$10.50
Alfredo Sauce with Chicken$13.50
Alfredo Sauce with Shrimp$14.50
Pasta with Three Meatballs$11.50
Pasta with Three Sausages$11.50
Pesto Sauce$11.50
Stuffed Rigatoni Marinara$9.50
Stuffed Rigatoni with Vodka Sauce$12.50
Baked Lasagna$10.00
Meat or cheese.
Baked Ziti$9.50
Baked Ziti with Ricotta$10.50
Baked Ziti with Three Meatballs$12.50
Baked Ziti with Three Sausages$12.50
Baked Stuffed Shells$9.50
Ravioli$9.50 +
Cheese, meat or spinach.
Baked Ravioli$8.50
Tortellini Marinara$9.50
Cheese or meat.
Tortellini Alfredo$11.50
Tortellini with Vodka Sauce$11.50
Cavatelli Marinara$9.50
Cavatelli & Broccoli$10.50
Cavatelli & Broccoli with Chicken$13.50
Cavatelli with Broccoli Rabe$15.50
Chicken or shrimp.
Gnocchi Marinara$9.50
Potato pasta.
Eggplant Rollatini$12.50
With pasta.
Eggplant Parmigiana$10.50
With pasta.
Your choice of linguine, spaghetti, penne, capellini, rigatoni, fettuccine. Also available: whole grain penne or linguine & gluten free penne.
Side of Pasta Marinara$4.25
Side of Baked Pasta Marinara$4.25
Side of Meat Sauce Pasta$5.50
Side of Garlic & Oil Pasta$5.50
Side of Vodka Sauce Pasta$5.50
Side of Pasta with Meatballs$4.50
Side of Pasta with Three Sausages$4.50
Chicken or veal served with side salad or side pasta.
Parmigiana Breaded Cutlets$13.50
Topped with marinara & mozzarella cheese.
Sautéed with mushrooms in a Marsala wine sauce.
Dipped in egg batter & sautéed in a white wine lemon sauce.
Chicken Scampi$13.50
Fresh chicken cutlets lightly breaded & sautéed in a garlic lemon sauce.
Chicken Cacciatore$13.50
Chunks of fresh chicken sautéed with mushrooms, potatoes, peppers & onions in a fresh marinara sauce.
Sautéed w/ mushrooms, peppers, onions in a white wine oregano sauce.
Topped with spinach, roasted peppers & mozzarella cheese, sautéed in an oil & garlic sauce with a touch of marinara.
Sautéed with capers in a lemon sauce.
Sautéed cutlets topped with spinach, prosciutto & mozzarella cheese in an oil & garlic sauce with a touch of marinara.
Sautéed cutlets topped with sliced tomato & mozzarella cheese in an oil & garlic sauce with a touch of marinara.
AJ’s Sautéed with mushrooms, roasted peppers & artichoke hearts in an oil & garlic sauce with a touch of marinara.
Chicken Rollatini$16.50
Fresh chicken cutlets stuffed with spinach, roasted peppers, mozzarella cheese & sautéed in a mushroom garlic sauce.
Three Seasons$14.50
One piece breaded chicken cutlet, one piece breaded veal cutlet, two pieces breaded shrimp topped with marinara & mozzarella cheese.
Topped w/ eggplant, ham, fresh marinara, provolone & mozzarella cheese.
Served over linguine with a side salad.
Shrimp Parmigiana$16.50
Breaded shrimp topped w/ marinara & mozzarella cheese.
Shrimp Francese$16.75
Shrimp dipped in egg batter & sautéed in a white wine lemon sauce.
Shrimp Scampi$16.75
Shrimp lightly breaded & sautéed in a garlic lemon sauce.
Shrimp Marinara$15.00
Shrimp sautéed in a fresh marinara sauce.
Shrimp Fra Diavlo$16.75
Shrimp sautéed w/ hot peppers in a fresh marinara sauce.
Shrimp Vodka$16.75
Shrimp sautéed in a creamy pink vodka sauce.
Shrimp & Broccoli Rabe$16.75
Shrimp & broccoli rabe sautéed in oil & garlic w/ a touch of marinara.
Linguine with Clam Sauce$12.75
Served in a white or red sauce w/ fresh garlic over linguine.
Mussels over Linguine$12.75
Black shell mussels sautéed in fresh marinara (hot, medium, or sweet).
Fried Calamari over Linguine$14.50
Breaded calamari served in a fresh marinara sauce (hot, medium or sweet).
Zuppa Di Clams$16.50
Little neck clams sautéed in a fresh marinara or a white scampi sauce.
Zuppa Di Pesce$23.50
Mussels, clams, shrimp & calamari sautéed in a fresh marinara or a white scampi sauce.
Calamari Marinara$14.50
Calamari sautéed in a fresh marinara sauce.
S’mores Pies$6.00
Tiramisu Cup$4.00
Ice Cream$3.50
Vanilla or chocolate.
Carrot Cake$4.75
Mud Cake$4.75
Orange Juice$2.50
Apple Juice$2.50
Soda$2.00 +
Boylans Soda$2.25
Red Bull$3.00
Gold Peak Unsweetened Iced Tea$2.50
Gold Peak Sweet Tea$2.50
Honest Tea Half & Half$2.50
Vitamin Water$2.25
Gold Peak Green Tea$2.50
Mexican Coke$2.25