Skip to main content
Old City Pizza

Old City Pizza

76 Pearl St, Buffalo, NY 14202
716-274-2300
New

Order Ahead We open at Tue at 11:00 AM

Full Hours
  • 5% off online orders
NY Health ScoreNew Window Icon
Skip to first category

House Favorites

These are the shop recommendations for a great meal experience.

Pollo Parm Alla Vodka Sandwich

Breaded chicken cutlet, mozzarella, provolone, & vodka sauce. Served on house-made focaccia.

Original price was $22.00

Discounted price is $20.90

pizza

Pizza

Quatro Formaggi Pizza

4 cheese! San marzano tomato, mozzarella, provolone, herbed ricotta, and parmigiano reggiano.

Original price was $18.00

Discounted price is $17.10

Fichi & Prosciutto Pizza

Fig & prosciutto! Red wine fig reduction, goat cheese, lemon dressed arugula, prosciutto, balsamic reduction, and parmigiano reggiano.

Original price was $22.00

Discounted price is $20.90

Pepperoni Pizza

San marzano tomato, mozzarella, pepperoni, oregano, parmigiano reggiano.

Original price was $20.00

Discounted price is $19.00

Bianca Broccolini & Salsiccia Pizza

White pizza with broccolini and sausage! Garlic confit, mozzarella, italian sausage, broccolini, and caramelized onions.

Original price was $22.00

Discounted price is $20.90

Margherita Classica

The classic! San marzano tomato, fresh mozzarella, basil, parmigiano reggiano, EVOO

Original price was $20.00

Discounted price is $19.00

Funghi Al Tartufo Pizza

Mushroom and white truffle oil! Three cheese cream, sauteed cremini & portabella mushrooms, mozzarella, truffle oil, & fresh herbs.

Original price was $21.00

Discounted price is $19.95

Diavola Pizza

Spicy salami! San marzano tomato, calabrian chili, mozzarella, spicy soppressata, italian sausage, parmigiano reggiano, fresh parsley.

Original price was $22.00

Discounted price is $20.90

Pollo Alla Milanese Pizza

Chicken milanese! San marzano tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, breaded chicken cutlet, roasted tomatoes, arugula, lemon vinaigrette, balsamic reduction, and parmigiano reggiano.

Original price was $23.00

Discounted price is $21.85

Salsiccia Piccante Pizza

Sausage & peppers! Garlic confit, house pickled banana peppers, italian sausage, herbed ricotta, and parsley.

Original price was $22.00

Discounted price is $20.90

Pomodori & Carciofi Pizza

Roasted tomato and artichoke! Garlic confit, mozzarella, roasted tomato, marinated artichoke, caramelized onions, herbed ricotta, and balsamic reduction. Finished with arugula.

Original price was $22.00

Discounted price is $20.90

salads

Salads

Old City Salad

Hearty greens, red onion, mozzarella, cherry tomatoes, house vinaigrette. Add chicken cutlet.

Original price was $15.00

Discounted price is $14.25

Arugula Salad

Baby arugula, shaved red onions, roasted tomato, parmigiano reggiano, crispy pancetta, lemon vinaigrette.

Original price was $16.00

Discounted price is $15.20

Caprese Salad

Seasoned tomato, fresh mozzarella, basil, balsamic reduction, EVOO. Add chicken cutlet

Original price was $16.00

Discounted price is $15.20

Caesar Classica Salad

Romaine hearts, house caesar dressing, focaccia croutons, parmigiano reggiano, lemon, EVOO.

Original price was $15.00

Discounted price is $14.25

sandwiches

Sandwiches

Pollo Parm Alla Vodka Sandwich

Breaded chicken cutlet, mozzarella, provolone, & vodka sauce. Served on house-made focaccia.

Original price was $22.00

Discounted price is $20.90

Polpette Panino Sandwich

Meatball sandwich! House-made meatballs, pomodoro sauce, mozzarella, and provolone. Baked on house-made focaccia.

Original price was $24.00

Discounted price is $22.80

Panini Con Salumi Sandwich

Italian cold sub! Ham, prosciutto, capicola, soppressata, fresh mozzarella, lettuce, tomato, onion,& house vinaigrette. Served on a house-made bomber roll.

Original price was $22.00

Discounted price is $20.90

Club Italiano Sandwich

Turkey, crispy pancetta, garlic aioli, lettuce, tomato, and onion. Served on a house-made bomber roll.

Original price was $17.00

Discounted price is $16.15

pasta

Pasta

Linguini Alla Napolenta

House-made linguini, pomodoro sauce, parmigiano reggiano, EVOO.

Original price was $16.00

Discounted price is $15.20

Linguini Alla Crema

House-made linguini, three cheese cream sauce, parmigiano reggiano, EVOO

Original price was $18.00

Discounted price is $17.10

Fusilli Alla Vodka

House-made fusilli, vodka sauce, parmigiano reggiano, & EVOO.

Original price was $18.00

Discounted price is $17.10

additions

Additions

Breaded Chicken Cutlet

Original price was $9.00

Discounted price is $8.55

Herbed Ricotta Cheese

Original price was $5.00

Discounted price is $4.75

House-Made Meatballs

Original price was $9.00

Discounted price is $8.55

Al Forno - Baked Parm

Original price was $6.00

Discounted price is $5.70

Italian Sausage Crumbles

Original price was $7.00

Discounted price is $6.65

Side Salad

Original price was $8.00

Discounted price is $7.60

Old City Pizza - View Menu & Order Online - 76 Pearl St, Buffalo, NY 14202 - Slice

Price: $$