Skip to main content
Pizza Star Old Fashioned Tomato Pie is currently ONLY available for PICKUP orders. Delivery is not available until Thu at 10:00 AM.
Pizza Star Old Fashioned Tomato Pie

Pizza Star Old Fashioned Tomato Pie

400 NY-211 Middletown, Middletown, NY 10940
845-614-9520

Open until Thu at 9:30 PM

Full Hours
  • 10% off online orders
Skip to first category
deals-and-coupons

Deals and Coupons

CouponFeatured

$2 OFF Any Order of $20 or More

$2

Deal

Large Pizza, 12 Wings, 12 Garlic Knots, 2 Liter Soda Pick Up

Pick up only

$33.99

pizza

Pizza

Cheese Pizza

$10.99

Cheese Pizza

Cauliflower Crust Pizza

$13.99

Gluten Free Pizza

$13.99

Thin Crust Old Fashioned Tomato Pizza

$17.99

Thin Crust Old Fashioned Tomato Pizza
gourmet-pizza

Gourmet Pizza

California Pizza

Crispy chicken, diced tomatoes, bacon, ranch dressing & mozzarella cheese (no sauce)

$13.99

Eggplant Rollatini Pizza

Tomato sauce, ricotta cheese, layers of eggplant & mozzarella cheese.

$13.99

Chicken A La Vodka Pizza

Chicken sauteed in vodka sauce, pancetta & mozzarella cheese.

$13.99

Stuffed Pizza

Pepperoni, sausage, peppers, onions & ham on stuffed crust.

$13.99

Friday In Vatican Pizza

Eggplant, grilled portabella mushrooms, & sauteed broccoli rabe in balsamic sauce.

$13.99

Chicken Parmigiana Pizza

$13.99

Grandma Pizza

Pesto sauce, fresh mozzarella, fresh marinara sauce & basil.

$13.99

Grandma Pizza

Buffalo Chicken Pizza

$13.99

White Pizza

Ricotta cheese, mozzarella cheese & fresh garlic.

$13.99

White Pizza

BBQ Chicken Pizza

$13.99

Upside Down Pizza

$13.99

Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza

$13.99

Margherita Pizza

Chunky tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella, basil, E.V.O.O

$13.99

Chicken Romano Pizza

Chicken, spinach, mushrooms with pink vodka sauce.

$13.99

Classica Pizza

Chicken, fresh mozzarella, balsamic glaze & basil.

$13.99

Chicken Bruschetta Pizza

Fresh chopped tomatoes, garlic, basil & olive oil.

$13.99

Grandma Pizza with Vodka Sauce

Includes vodka sauce, fresh mozzarella, E.V.O.O

$13.99

Chicken Honey Mustard Pizza

Chicken, fresh tomato & honey mustard.

$13.99

Thai Chili Chicken Pizza

$13.99

Chicken Marsala Pizza

$13.99

Traditional Pizza

Sausage, peppers & onions.

$13.99

Chicken Broccoli Alfredo Pizza

$13.99

Baked Ziti Pizza

$13.99

Star Special Pizza

Pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, peppers & onions.

$13.99

Penne Vodka Pizza

$13.99

White Provolone Pizza

Ricotta & mozzarella.

$13.99

House Special Pizza

Grilled chicken, mozzarella, cheddar cheese, tomatoes, scallions, onions, ranch dressing.

$13.99

House Special Pizza

Chicken Avocado Pizza

Baby spinach, shop tomato, avocado, grill chicken and a touch of ranch dressing.

$13.99

Spicy Chicken Taco Pizza

Lettuce, tomatoes, ranch, hot sauce & light mayo.

$13.99

White Broccoli Pizza

$13.99

Spicy Beef Taco Pizza

Lettuce, tomatoes, ranch, hot sauce & light mayo.

$13.99

Four Cheese Pizza

$13.99

Super Cheesesteak Pizza

Cheesesteak, peppers, mushrooms, onions, tomato sauce, American & mozzarella cheese.

$13.99

Lasagna Pizza

$13.99

Hawaiian Pizza

Red or white. Pineapple & ham topped with mozzarella cheese.

$13.99

Garlic Bread Pizza

$13.99

Veggie Pizza

Broccoli, eggplant, mushrooms, onions, green peppers & black olives.

$13.99

pan-pizza

Pan Pizza

Plain Pan Pizza

$17.99

Vegetable Special Pan Pizza

$25.99

Chicken Bacon Ranch Pan Pizza

$25.99

Chicken Marsala Pan Pizza

$25.99

Chicken Broccoli Tomatoes Pan Pizza

$25.99

Meat Lover's Pan Pizza

$23.99

Fresh Mozzarella Tomatoes Basil Pan Pizza

$25.99

BBQ Chicken Pan Pizza

$23.99

Chicken Broccoli Alfredo Pan Pizza

$23.99

Buffalo Chicken Pan Pizza

$23.99

square-sicilian-pizza

Square Sicilian Pizza

Plain Sicilian Pizza

$18.99

Meat Lover's Sicilian Pizza

$24.99

Grandma Thin Crust Pizza

$18.99

BBQ Chicken Sicilian Pizza

$24.99

Vegetable Special Sicilian Pizza

$26.99

Buffalo Chicken Sicilian Pizza

$24.99

Brooklyn Thin Crust Pizza

Fresh mozzarella, fresh basil, plum tomato & extra virgin olive oil on top

$22.99

Chicken Bacon Ranch Sicilian Pizza

$24.99

Chicken Broccoli Alfredo Sicilian Pizza

$24.99

specials

Specials

Two Large Plain Pies, 18 Wings, 12 Garlic Knots & 2 Liter Soda Family Combo Special

$49.99

Large Pie, 12 Wings, 6 Garlic Knots & 2 Liter Soda Football Special

$29.99

appetizers

Appetizers

Fried Calamari

$14.99

Fried Calamari

Appetizer For Two

Mozzarella sticks, chicken fingers, fried mushrooms & zucchini stick.

$14.99

Onion Rings

$9.99

Onion Rings

Perogies

With sour cream.

$9.25

Mozzarella Sticks

$10.50

Mozzarella Sticks

Ranch Perogies

Bacon ranch & mozzarella.

$10.25

Garlic Bread

$6.75

Jalapeno Poppers

$9.25

Garlic Bread with Cheese

$7.75

Sicilian Calamari

Fried calamari sautéed with hot cherry peppers topped w/ balsamic glaze

$14.99

Fried Mushrooms

With sauce.

$10.25

Fried Mushrooms

Buffalo Garlic Knots

$8.99

French Fries

$6.25

Bacon Ranch Garlic Knots

$8.99

Planet Fries

With Jalapenos, bacon, ranch, mozzarella cheese.

$8.99

Pizza Garlic Knots

$8.99

Garlic Knots

With a side of sauce.

$5.75

Garlic Knots

Gravy Cheese Fries

with brown gravy and mozzarella cheese.

$9.99

Zucchini Sticks

With sauce.

$9.99

Ranch Fries

With ranch, mozzarella, am, and ranch.

$9.99

Bruschetta

Tomatoes, basil & onion.

$8.99

Buffalo Fries

With ranch, hot sauce & mozzarella

$9.99

Jamaican Beef Patty

$5.00

Jamaican Beef Patty

Fried Ravioli

$9.99

Chicken Fingers & Fries

$11.75

Buffalo Wings

$9.99

Rice Ball

Rice, cheese, sauce, peas, ground beef rolled & lightly fried.

$7.99

Boneless Wings

$14.99

Calamari & Marinara Sauce

$12.99

salads

Salads

Antipasto Salad

Ham, salami & provolone cheese.

$13.99

Crispy Chicken Avocado Caprese Salad

Avocado, tomato, basil, chicken, fresh balsamic glaze

$16.99

Caesar Salad

$11.25

Grilled Shrimp Over Salad

$15.99

Tossed Salad

$10.99

Tuna Salad

$13.50

Chicken Caesar Salad

$13.99

Di Procida Salad

Grilled shrimp & calamari, tomato, onions, romaine lettuce, cucumbers, green olives & homemade dressing

$17.99

Grilled Chicken Salad

$14.50

Chicken Greek Salad

Feta cheese, grape leaves & pita bread.

$13.99

Chef Salad

Ham, turkey, provolone cheese, boiled egg.

$14.50

Chicken Bacon Ranch Salad

$14.99

Buffalo Chicken Salad

Breaded or grilled chicken, buffalo sauce & ranch

$13.25

Cajun Chicken Salad

$14.99

Caprese Salad

Fresh mozzarella, tomato, roasted peppers salad

$13.75

Mandarin Chicken Salad

Grilled chicken, mandarin, walnuts, cranberries, bed of spinach with balsamic vinaigrette.

$14.99

Cranberry Walnuts Salad

Baby spring greens, dried cranberries, a crumble of tangy feta cheese, and toasted walnuts, smothered with red raspberry vinaigrette dressing

$13.50

Salmon Salad

Roasted peppers, fresh mozzarella cheese and grilled salmon.

$14.99

L'Insalata Romana

Grilled mushrooms & grilled chicken strips w/roasted red peppers, fresh mozzarella, served over bed of romaine lettuce

$14.50

soups

Soups

Pasta Fagioli Soup

$6.99

Chicken Tortellini Soup

$6.99

Minestrone Soup

$6.99

Chicken Noodle Soup

$6.99

Lentil Soup

$6.99

Cream Roasted Peppers with Chicken Soup

$6.99

sides

Sides

Broccoli Rabe

$7.25

Sausage

$5.99

Broccoli

$6.50

Spinach

$6.25

Meatballs

$5.99

stromboli-calzones

Stromboli & Calzones

Supreme Stromboli

Sausage, pepperoni, peppers, salami & onions

$13.99

Cheese Calzone

Mozzarella and ricotta cheese.

$13.99

Steak, Pepper & Onion Stromboli

$13.99

Buffalo Chicken Calzone

$13.99

Buffalo Chicken Stromboli

$13.99

BBQ Chicken Calzone

$13.99

BBQ Chicken Stromboli

$13.99

Chicken Bacon Ranch Calzone

$13.99

Chicken Bacon Ranch Stromboli

$13.99

Teriyaki Chicken Calzone

$13.99

Teriyaki Chicken Stromboli

$13.99

Thai Chili Chicken Calzone

$13.99

Thai Chili Chicken Stromboli

$13.99

pizza-rolls

Pizza Rolls

Sausage Pizza Roll

$8.99

Thai Chili Chicken Pizza Roll

$8.99

Pepperoni Pizza Roll

$8.99

Steak, Pepper, Onion Pizza Roll

$8.99

Buffalo Chicken Pizza Roll

$8.99

BBQ Chicken Pizza Roll

$8.99

Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza Roll

$8.99

Teriyaki Chicken Pizza Roll

$8.99

panini

Panini

All Paninis come with French fries.

Vernon Panini

Grilled chicken, eggplant, fresh mozzarella & roasted peppers

$12.99

Station Panini

Grilled chicken, sautéed broccoli rabe & provolone cheese

$12.99

Grilled Cheese Pesto Panini

Grilled chicken, portobello mushrooms & cheese

$12.99

Alexander Panini

Breaded chicken, mayo, fresh mozzarella, roasted red peppers & spinach.

$12.99

Caprese Panini

Tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, basil & balsamic.

$12.99

The Grilled Capuano Panini

Grilled chicken breast, provolone cheese & spinach sautéed in olive oil with Italian seasonings.

$12.99

Godfather Panini

Grilled chicken, portabella mushrooms, eggplant & fresh mozzarella

$12.99

Tactical Panini

Chicken tender, tossed in BBQ, cheddar, bacon, sautéed onions on buttered panini

$12.99

Grilled Chicken Balsamic Panini

Grilled chicken, fresh mozzarella, roasted peppers

$12.99

Star Panini

Topped with roasted peppers, mozzarella, mixed greens, dressed with a balsamic glaze

$12.99

Eggplant Panini

Basil, fresh mozzarella, with balsamic vinaigrette.

$12.99

Chicken Capaci Panini

Grilled chicken with pesto mayo, spinach & provolone

$12.99

Grilled Sausage & Spinach Panini

Grilled Italian sausage, provolone cheese, minced garlic & chopped spinach sautéed in olive oil with Italian seasonings.

$12.99

Turkey Panini

Turkey, sweet cheese and mayo.

$12.99

wraps

Wraps

All Wraps come with French fries.

Grilled Chicken Broccoli Rabe Wrap

With fresh mozzarella.

$12.99

Mateo Wrap

Grilled chicken sautéed spinach, mushrooms, onions & feta cheese

$12.99

Buffalo Chicken Wrap

$12.99

Anabelle Chicken Wrap

Roasted red pepper, spinach, garlic & fresh mozzarella

$12.99

Chicken Bacon & Ranch Wrap

$12.99

Goshen Wrap

Breaded chicken vodka sauce & melted mozzarella cheese

$12.99

Brooklyn Wrap

Grilled chicken, fresh mozzarella, roasted peppers.

$12.99

Chicken Capaci Wrap

Grilled chicken with pesto mayo, spinach & provolone

$12.99

Grilled Chicken Wrap

Lettuce, tomatoes, onions, mayo.

$12.99

Tuna Wrap

$12.99

Chicken Caesar Wrap

$12.99

Italian Wrap

$12.99

Cheesesteak Wrap

Lettuce, tomatoes, onions.

$12.99

Chicken Fajita Wrap

Chicken, sauteed green peppers & onions, provolone cheese.

$12.99

Veggie Wrap

Fresh tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, sautéed spinach, broccoli, onions & mushrooms

$12.99

Chicken Quesadilla

Grilled chicken, mozzarella cheddar cheese, mayo, French fries.

$12.99

Chicken Spinach Wrap

Sautéed spinach, mushrooms & melted provolone

$12.99

hot-subs

Hot Subs

Served on toasted bread.

Veal Parm Sub

With fresh mozzarella.

$12.99

Meatball Parm Sub

$11.25

Eggplant Parmigiana Sub

$11.25

Sausage Parm Sub

$11.25

Sausage & Egg Sub

$12.99

Ravi Special Sandwich

Fresh garlic, fresh mozzarella cheese, cheesesteak, spinach & roasted peppers

$13.99

Peppers & Egg Sub

$10.99

Sausage, Peppers, & Onions Sub

$11.99

Chicken Parm Sub

$11.99

Shrimp Parmigiana Sub

$12.99

Chicken California Sub

Lettuce, tomatoes, mayo & onions

$12.25

Hot Roast Beef Sub

With brown gravy & mozzarella

$13.99

Breaded Eggplant Sub

Fresh mozzarella, ham & roasted red peppers

$11.99

Brandon's Special Sandwich

With grilled chicken, spinach, pepper, garlic, tomato sauce & melted mozzarella

$12.99

Crispy Fried Chicken Sub

American cheese, lettuce, tomatoes, onions, bacon, ranch dressing.

$11.99

cold-subs

Cold Subs

All cold subs come with lettuce, tomato, onions. With choice of cheese.

Italian Sub

Ham, provolone, salami.

$11.99

Prosciutto Sub

Fresh mozzarella and roasted peppers.

$11.99

Ham & Cheese Sub

$11.99

Turkey Sub

Provolone cheese and bacon with lettuce, tomatoes, and onions.

$11.99

Salami & Cheese Sub

$11.99

Tuna Hoagie

$11.99

Turkey & Cheese Sub

$11.99

philly-cheesesteaks-chicken-cheesesteaks

Philly Cheesesteaks & Chicken Cheesesteaks

Philly Cheesesteak

$11.99

House Cheesesteak

Mushrooms, peppers & onions

$12.99

Philly Chicken Cheesesteak

$12.99

Cheesesteak California

Mayo.

$12.99

Buffalo Cheesesteak

With hot sauce, blue cheese & mozzarella.

$12.99

Ronald Special Cheesesteak

Spinach, roasted peppers, garlic, tomato sauce & mozzarella cheese.

$12.99

burgers

Burgers

Served with coleslaw, pickles & French fries.

Gyro with French Fries

Beef or Chicken.

$12.99

Texas Burger

With onion rings, bacon, bbq sauce & provolone.

$15.99

Grilled Chicken

Roasted red peppers, fresh mozzarella & grilled tomatoes

$12.99

Double Bacon Cheeseburger

Fried onions, cheddar cheese & mushrooms.

$17.99

Bacon Cheeseburger

$14.99

Cheeseburger Deluxe

Fries, lettuce, tomatoes & onions

$12.99

Chipotle Burger

With sautéed onions, mushrooms & swiss cheese

$15.99

Opa Opa Cheeseburger

Fried onions, mushrooms & green peppers.

$13.99

pasta

Pasta

All Entrees come with a side of salad & homemade Italian Bread.

Pasta with Meat Sauce

$15.99

Cavatelli with Sweet Italian Sausage

Sautéed sweet Italian sausage, broccoli rabe & garlic white wine sauce

$18.99

Pasta with Vodka Sauce

$15.99

Gnocchi Sorrento

Potato gnocchi topped with mozzarella in a marinara sauce

$16.99

Fettuccine Alfredo

$15.99

Rigatoni Francescana

Rigatoni pasta with mushrooms & ground beef, blended with mozzarella in a pink cream sauce

$18.99

Pasta with Marinara Sauce

Red sauce and garlic.

$14.99

Penne Argentina

Penne pasta with diced eggplant, mushrooms & prosciutto, blended with mozzarella in a pink sauce

$18.99

Pasta with Tomato Sauce

Smooth red sauce.

$14.99

Farfalle Bolognese

Ground beef, green peas, and mushrooms in a hearty tomato sauce

$17.99

Pasta with Meatball

$16.99

Penne Rustica

Chicken, sun dried tomatoes, spinach, garlic, and oil sauce.

$18.99

Pasta with Sausage

$16.99

Cavatelli with Shrimp

Sun-dried tomatoes, spinach & lemon francese sauce.

$18.99

Stuffed Shells

$15.99

Penne a La Vodka Sauce

$15.99

Fettuccini Alfredo Sarpino

Sautéed chicken, mushrooms, roasted peppers, asparagus & alfredo sauce

$17.99

Fettuccine Primavera

$16.99

italian-pasta

Italian Pasta

All Entrees come with a side of salad & homemade Italian Bread.

Italian Pasta with Meatballs

$16.99

Italian Pasta with Vodka Sauce

$15.99

Italian Pasta with Sausage, Peppers & Onions

$15.99

Italian Pasta with Bolognese

$15.99

Italian Pasta with Meat Sausage

$15.99

baked-pasta-dinners

Baked Pasta & Dinners

Comes with a side salad & homemade Italian Bread. Whole wheat penne additional charge.

Baked Manicotti

$16.99

Baked Ziti Sicilian Style

Eggplant & ricotta cheese in tomato sauce & melted mozzarella

$16.99

Baked Cheese Ravioli

$16.99

Ravioli Firenze

Cheese filled pasta in a pink cream sauce with fresh spinach & mozzarella

$18.99

Eggplant Rollatini

$16.99

Rigatoni Moschettiere

Rigatoni tossed in a creamy sauce of broccoli, mushrooms, onions, morsels of chicken, herbs & parmigiana cheese

$19.99

Eggplant Parmigiana

$17.99

Farfalle Capriccioso

Bowtie pasta sauteed with broccoli rabe & chunks of fresh sausage in a garlic oil sauce

$19.99

Baked Ground Beef Lasagna

$17.99

Tortellini Di Parma

Tortellini pasta sauteed with mushrooms & prosciutto di parma in a light creamy pink sauce

$19.99

Baked Ziti

In a tomato sauce with ricotta & melted mozzarella

$16.99

steaks

Steaks

Italian bread, vegetable, rice.

Grilled NY Strip

Grilled NY strip topped with broccoli rabe, fresh garlic, hot pepper flakes & freshly squeezed lemon juice, served with roasted potatoes.

$25.99

Steak Congiatto

Grilled NY strip steak topped with roasted wild mushrooms in a truffle demi-glazed served over sautéed spinach & roasted potatoes.

$25.99

NY Strip Gorgonzola

Grilled NY strip topped with melted gorgonzola cheese & herb demi-glaze, served with sautéed spinach & roasted potatoes.

$25.99

chicken

Chicken

Comes with a side salad & homemade Italian Bread. Comes with pasta.

Chicken Parmigiana

$19.99

Chicken Carini

Artichokes & shrimp sautéed in a white wine sauce, served with sun-dried tomatoes, asparagus & roasted potatoes.

$19.99

Chicken Piccata

Slices of chicken sautéed in a white wine sauce with capers.

$19.99

Chicken Milanese

Evoo breaded chicken car-grilled served with baby arugula, red onions, and cherry tomatoes, tossed with lemon & olive oil with shaved grana padana, served with roasted potatoes & balsamic glaze.

$19.99

Chicken Cacciatore

With peppers and mushrooms, onions & red sauce.

$19.99

Chicken Venice

Char-grilled seasoned with herbs, topped with sautéed broccoli, roasted garlic & EVOO, served with roasted potatoes.

$19.99

Chicken Francese

Sauteed in butter, lemon & fresh garlic.

$19.99

Chicken Foresta

Fresh tomatoes, sun-dried tomatoes, spinach, sauteed in a white wine sauce, topped with melted mozzarella cheese, served over bowtie pasta.

$19.99

Chicken Marsala

With mushrooms & marsala wine.

$19.99

Chicken Siciliano

Mushrooms & prosciutto, sautéed in a marsala wine sauce, topped with mozzarella over bowtie pasta.

$19.99

Chicken Alfredo

Sliced chicken with broccoli & with peas in alfredo sauce.

$19.99

Chicken Cordon Bleu

Breaded chicken, ham, swiss cheese & light brown sauce.

$19.99

Chicken Broccoli

Sauteed in a light marinara sauce.

$19.99

Chicken Oreganate

Sauteed with baby shrimp, tomatoes, seasoned, bread crumbs & mozzarella in a white wine sauce over pasta.

$19.99

Chicken Saltimbocca

W/prosciutto, spinach sauteed & topped with mozzarella in white wine sauce.

$19.99

Chicken Sanpaolo

Sautéed Chicken Breast with Fresh Tomatoes, roast red peppers, fresh mozzarella, artichokes, spinach & lemon white wine sauce.

$19.99

Chicken Palermo

Portobello mushrooms & roasted peppers sautéed in a marsala demi glazed topped with melted mozzarella, served with asparagus & roasted potatoes.

$19.99

veal

Veal

Comes with a side salad & homemade Italian Bread. Comes with pasta.

Veal Parmigiana

$19.99

Veal Saltimbocca

With prosciutto, spinach sauteed & topped with mozzarella in white wine sauce.

$19.99

Veal Piccata

Slices of chicken sautéed in a white wine sauce with capers.

$19.99

Veal Carini

Artichokes & shrimp sautéed in a white wine sauce, served with sun-dried tomatoes, asparagus & roasted potatoes.

$19.99

Veal Cacciatore

With peppers and mushrooms, onions & red sauce.

$19.99

Veal Cabriella

Roasted garlic in a white wine sauce, topped with spinach, prosciutto & melted mozzarella cheese over bowtie pasta.

$19.99

Veal Francese

Sauteed in butter, lemon & fresh garlic.

$19.99

Veal Milanese

Evoo breaded chicken car-grilled served with a baby arugula, red onions, cherry tomatoes, tossed with lemon & olive oil with shaved grana padana, served with roasted potatoes & balsamic glaze.

$19.99

Veal Marsala

With mushrooms & marsala wine.

$19.99

Veal Foresta

Fresh tomatoes, sun-dried tomatoes, spinach, sauteed in a white wine sauce, topped with melted mozzarella cheese, served over bowtie pasta.

$19.99

Veal Broccoli

Sauteed in a light marinara sauce.

$19.99

Veal Siciliano

Mushrooms & prosciutto, sautéed in a marsala wine sauce, topped with mozzarella over bowtie pasta.

$19.99

seafood

Seafood

Comes with a side salad & homemade Italian Bread. Comes with pasta.

Shrimp Parmigiana

$19.99

Clams & Shrimp

Red Sauce.

$19.99

Shrimp Piccata

Slices of chicken sauteed in a white wine sauce with capers.

$19.99

Calamari Marinara

Lightly sauce.

$18.99

Shrimp Cacciatore

With peppers, mushrooms, onions & red sauce.

$19.99

Mussels

$18.99

Shrimp Marsala

With mushrooms & marsala wine.

$19.99

Louisiana Pasta

With shrimp & chicken.

$19.99

Shrimp Alfredo

$19.99

Linguine White Wine Clam Sauce

$20.99

Shrimp Broccoli

Sauteed in a light marinara sauce.

$19.99

Fresh Salmon Palermo

Salmon, fresh tomato, asparagus, roasted peppers, in a white wine garlic lemon sauce.

$21.99

Shrimp Saltimbocca

With prosciutto, spinach sauteed & topped with mozzarella.

$19.99

Salmon Pistachio

Pistachio crusted salmon drizzled with a scampi citrus wine sauce, served with roasted.

$20.99

Shrimp Marinara

$19.99

Salmon Michelangelo

Topped with roasted garlic, basil, cherry tomatoes & grilled asparagus with roasted potatoes in a white wine sauce with a touch of marinara.

$21.99

Shrimp Fra Diavolo

Hot spicy sauce.

$19.99

Salmon Dijon

Salmon topped with portobello mushrooms, sun-dried tomatoes, lump crabmeat & grilled asparagus in a dijon cream sauce over linguini.

$22.99

Shrimp Scampi

White wine, garlic and lemon.

$19.99

Farfalle Salmon

Grape tomatoes, asparagus in a pink sauce.

$20.99

Mussels & Clams

Red Sauce.

$19.99

Misto Di Mare

Clams, mussels, calamari & shrimp in a fra-diavolo sauce over linguini.

$22.99

kids-menu

Kid's Menu

Kid's Spaghetti with Tomato Sauce

$6.99

Kid's Ravioli

$7.99

Kid's Spaghetti with Sausage

$7.99

Kid's Chicken Fingers with French Fries

$7.99

Kid's Spaghetti with Meatball

$7.99

desserts

Desserts

Cheesecake

$6.99

Molten Lava Cake

$6.99

Cannoli

$6.50

Carrot Cake

$6.99

Cinna Bites

$6.99

Deep Fried Oreo Cookies

$6.99

Zeppole

$6.99

Chocolate Cake

$6.99

Tiramisu Cup

$6.99

Chocolate Mousse

$6.99

Toasted Almond Cup

$6.99

Red Velvet Cake

$6.99

Nutella Bites

$7.99

beverages

Beverages

Soda

$1.60

Unsweet Tea

$2.90

Snapple

$2.90

Sweet Tea

$2.90

Raspberry Tea

$2.90

Peach Tea

$2.90

special-lunch-menu

Special Lunch Menu

Only available 10:00 AM - 3:00 PM
Homemade Italian bread. Served with choice of pasta

Clam Sauce Lunch

Red or white sauce.

$10.50

Pasta with Meatballs Lunch

$10.50

Manicotti Lunch

$10.50

Pasta with Sausage Lunch

$10.50

Pasta with Meat Sauce Lunch

$10.50

Pasta with Broccoli Lunch

Red or white sauce.

$10.50

Ravioli Lunch

$10.50

Pasta with Tomato Sauce Lunch

Smooth red sauce.

$10.50

Penne Vodka Lunch

$10.50

Pasta with Marinara Sauce Lunch

Red sauce w/chunks of tomatoes & garlic

$10.50

Chicken Parmigiana Lunch

$10.50

appetizers-catering

Appetizers Catering

Mozzarella Sticks Catering

$45.99

Buffalo Wings Catering

Mild, medium, or hot.

$50.99

Garlic Bread with Cheese Catering

$16.99

Chicken Fingers Catering

$47.99

Garlic Knots Catering

$25.99

Pierogies Catering

$50.99

Sausage Catering

with pepper and onions.

$45.99

Fried Calamari Catering

$65.99

Meatballs Catering

$40.99

salads-catering

Salads Catering

House Salad Catering

$46.99

Antipasto Salad Catering

$46.99

Caesar Salad Catering

$46.99

mix-wraps-platter

Mix Wraps Platter

Grilled Chicken Garden Wrap Catering

$69.99

Grilled Chicken Caesar Wrap Catering

$69.99

Turkey Garden Wrap Catering

$69.99

Buffalo Chicken Wrap Catering

$69.99

Cheesesteak Wrap Catering

$69.99

chicken-suisina-classica-catering

Chicken & Suisina Classica Catering

Chicken Parmigiana Catering

$50.00

Chicken Marsala Catering

$50.00

Chicken Francese Catering

$50.00

Chicken Piccata Catering

$50.00

vegetables-catering

Vegetables Catering

Roast Vegetables Catering

$49.99

Eggplant Rollatini Catering

$50.00

Eggplant Parmigiana Catering

$49.99

pasta-catering

Pasta Catering

Ravioli Firenze Catering

$50.00

Cheese Ravioli Catering

$50.00

Penne Vodka Catering

$50.00

Stuffed Shells Catering

$50.00

Rigatoni Vodka Catering

$50.00

Vernon Baked Ziti Catering

Ground beef and ricotta.

$50.00

Tortellini Vodka Sauce Catering

$50.00

Lasagna Catering

Ground beef, layered pasta, and ricotta cheese.

$50.00

Baked Ziti Catering

$50.00

mix-cold-italian-sub-catering

Mix Cold Italian Sub Catering

Ham, Salami, Provolone, OV Sandwich Catering

$59.97

Ham, Capicola, Salami, Pepperoni, Provolone Sub Catering

with mayo.

$59.97

Ham, Swiss, OV Catering

$59.97

BLT Sub Catering

with mayo.

$59.97

Smoked Turkey Catering

with mayo.

$59.97

mix-hot-italian-sub-catering

Mix Hot Italian Sub Catering

Eggplant Parmigiana Hot Sub Catering

$59.97

Cheesesteak Hot Sub Catering

$59.97

Meatball Parmigiana Hot Sub Catering

$59.97

Chicken Cheesesteak Hot Sub Catering

$59.97

Sausage, Peppers & Onions Hot Sub Catering

$59.97

Buffalo Cheesesteak Hot Sub Catering

$59.97

Chicken Parmigiana Hot Sub Catering

$59.97

panini-catering

Panini Catering

Eggplant, Tomatoes, Basil, & Fresh Mozzarella Panini Catering

$79.99

The Grilled Capuano Panini Catering

$79.99

Turkey Club Panini Catering

$79.99

Grilled Sausage & Spinach Panini Catering

$79.99

dessert-catering

Dessert Catering

NY Cheesecake Catering

$55.00

Mixed Desserts Catering

$55.00

Cannoli Catering

$55.00

Pizza Star Old Fashioned Tomato Pie - View Menu & Order Online - 400 NY-211 Middletown, Middletown, NY 10940 - Slice

SliceNYMiddletown10940 Pizza Star Old Fashioned Tomato Pie
Price: $$