Skip to main content
Benny's Pizza

Benny's Pizza

18 W Rd, Pleasant Valley, NY 12569
845-723-3100

Open until 9:00 PM

Full Hours
    Skip to first category
    appetizers

    Appetizers

    Beef Patty

    $4.99

    Garlic Bread Sticks

    $5.99

    Beef Patty with Cheese

    $5.99

    Garlic Bread Sticks with Cheese

    $6.99

    Boneless Wings

    $9.99

    Garlic Knots

    $4.99

    Chicken Fingers

    $10.99

    Mozzarella Sticks

    $8.99

    Chicken Fingers & Fries

    $12.99

    Onion Rings

    $6.50

    French Fries

    $5.99

    Chicken Quesadilla

    $13.99

    Fried Calamari

    $13.99

    Steak Quesadilla

    $14.99

    Fried Zucchini

    $8.99

    Toasted Ravioli

    $8.99

    Garlic Bread

    $5.99

    Wings

    $9.99

    Garlic Bread with Cheese

    $7.50

    pizza

    Pizza

    Cheese Pizza

    Classic cheese or create your own pizza.

    $10.99

    Gluten Free Cheese Pizza

    $13.99

    Sicilian Cheese Pizza

    Thick crust square pizza with tomato sauce, mozzarella,

    $19.99

    Cauliflower Crust Cheese Pizza

    $13.99

    specialty-pizza

    Specialty Pizza

    BBQ Pizza

    BBQ chicken cutlet, mozzarella & BBQ sauce.

    $13.99

    Mediterranean Pizza

    Mozzarella, eggplant, olives, peppers, olive oil & artichoke hearts.

    $13.99

    Buffalo Chicken Pizza

    Chicken cutlet, buffalo sauce & mozzarella.

    $13.99

    Penne Vodka Pizza

    Mozzarella, penne with vodka sauce & parmesan cheese.

    $13.99

    Carbonara Pizza

    Ham, bacon, ricotta, mozzarella & parmesan. (no sauce)

    $13.99

    Pesto Pie

    White pie with puree of fresh basil, garlic and olive oil with mozzarella and fresh tomatoes.

    $13.99

    Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza

    Chicken cutlet, bacon, mozzarella, marinara sauce with ranch dressing.

    $13.99

    Philly Cheesesteak Pizza

    Steak, peppers, onions & American cheese.

    $13.99

    Chicken Marsala Pizza

    Chicken cutlet, marsala wine sauce with mushrooms.

    $13.99

    Primavera Pizza

    Ricotta, mozzarella, broccoli, mushrooms, spinach & garlic.

    $13.99

    Chicken Parm Pizza

    Chicken cutlet, mozzarella, marinara sauce.

    $13.99

    Salad Pizza

    Lettuce, tomato, red onions & feta cheese.

    $13.99

    Florentine Pizza

    Mozzarella, fresh spinach, mushrooms, garlic, mist of olive oil, artichoke hearts.

    $13.99

    The Classic Pizza

    Pepperoni, sausage, bacon, peppers, onions, mushrooms & mozzarella.

    $13.99

    Hawaiian Pizza

    Ham & pineapple.

    $13.99

    Tortellini Carbonara Pie

    Tortellini with bacon, in a light pink cream sauce.

    $13.99

    Hot Pie

    This is hot! spicy sausage, jalapeno peppers, mozzarella over our spicy sauce.

    $13.99

    Veggie Pie

    Broccoli, peppers, spinach & onions.

    $13.99

    Lasagna Pizza

    Ground meat, ricotta, mozzarella & tomato sauce.

    $13.99

    White Pie

    Ricotta, mozzarella & parmesan.

    $13.99

    Margherita Pizza

    Plum tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, parmesan, fresh basil & olive oil.

    $13.99

    Stuffed Pizza

    Pepperoni, ham, sausage & mozzarella,

    $21.99

    Meal Lover's Pizza

    Sausage, pepperoni, meatballs.

    $13.99

    Stuffed Veggie Pizza

    Broccoli, mushrooms, peppers, onions & mozzarella.

    $21.99

    sicilian-square-pizza

    Sicilian & Square Pizza

    Grandma's Pizza

    Thin crust, fresh crushed tomatoes, basil, olive oil, grated parmesan over fresh mozzarella.

    $21.99

    Bennys Square Pie

    Upside down sicilian, fresh mozzarella under tomato sauce & parmesan.

    $24.99

    BBQ Sicilian Pizza

    Chicken cutlet, BBQ sauce & mozzarella.

    $24.99

    Buffalo Sicilian Pizza

    Chicken cutlet, buffalo sauce & mozzarella.

    $24.99

    soups

    Soups

    Chicken Noodle Soup

    Clear chicken broth with pieces of chicken and noodles.

    $7.99

    Minestrone Soup

    Italian vegetable soup made with tomato broth and pasta.

    $7.99

    Lentil Soup

    Freshly cooked savory lentil soup.

    $7.99

    Pasta e Fagioli Soup

    Classic Italian soup with beans and pasta.

    $7.99

    salads

    Salads

    Antipasto Salad

    Salami, olives, ham, vegetables with a sprinkle of mozzarella.

    $12.99

    Garden Salad

    Lettuce, tomatoes, carrots, onions & cucumber.

    $8.50

    Caesar Salad

    Lettuce with croutons.

    $8.99

    Greek Salad

    Lettuce, tomato, black olives & feta cheese.

    $12.99

    Chef Salad

    Lettuce, tomatoes, ham, turkey & a sprinkle of mozzarella.

    $12.99

    side-orders

    Side Orders

    Broccoli Garlic & Oil

    $9.99

    Side of Sausage

    $6.99

    Broccoli Rabe

    $9.99

    Spinach Garlic & Oil

    $9.99

    Side of Meatballs

    $6.99

    calzones

    Calzones

    All Served with sauce.

    Cheese Calzone

    $8.99

    Sausage Calzone

    $10.99

    Chicken Calzone

    $11.99

    Spinach Calzone

    $10.99

    Pepperoni Calzone

    $10.99

    rolls

    Rolls

    All served with sauce.

    Chicken Roll

    $9.99

    Spinach Roll

    $9.99

    Pepperoni Roll

    $9.99

    Stromboli

    Sausage, pepperoni, ham & cheese.

    $11.99

    Sausage & Peppers Roll

    $9.99

    cold-wedges

    Cold Wedges

    Ham & Cheese Wedge

    Ham, cheese, shredded lettuce, tomatoes & mayo.

    $10.99

    Salami & Cheese Wedge

    Salami, cheese, shredded lettuce, tomatoes & mayo.

    $10.99

    Italian Combo Wedge

    Ham, salami, cheese, shredded lettuce, tomato, oil, vinegar.

    $12.99

    Turkey & Cheese Wedge

    Turkey cheese, shredded lettuce, tomatoes & mayo.

    $10.99

    hot-wedges

    Hot Wedges

    Buffalo Jack Wedge

    Breaded chicken cutlet, buffalo sauce, melted mozzarella.

    $10.99

    Philly Cheesesteak Wedge

    With peppers & onions.

    $11.99

    Chicken Club Wedge

    Breaded chicken cutlet, bacon, lettuce, tomatoes, mayo.

    $10.99

    Sausage & Peppers Wedge

    $10.99

    Chicken Francese Wedge

    $10.99

    Sausage Parm Wedge

    $10.99

    Chicken Parm Wedge

    $10.99

    Shrimp Parmigiana Wedge

    $11.99

    Eggplant Parm Wedge

    $10.99

    Veal Parm Wedge

    $11.99

    Meatball Parm Wedge

    $10.99

    sandwiches

    Sandwiches

    Ham & Cheese Sandwich

    Ham, cheese, lettuce, tomatoes & mayo.

    $10.99

    Italian Combo Sandwich

    Ham, salami, prosciutto, provolone, lettuce, tomatoes, roasted red peppers, oil & vinegar,

    $12.99

    Italian Combo Sandwich

    Turkey Sandwich

    Turkey cheese, shredded lettuce, tomatoes & mayo

    $10.99

    Chicken bacon ranch

    $12.99

    wraps

    Wraps

    Served with fries.

    Buffalo Chicken Wrap

    Crispy chicken tossed in buffalo sauce with lettuce, tomatoes

    $10.99

    Grilled Chicken Wrap

    Grilled chicken, lettuce, tomatoes.

    $10.99

    Chicken Bacon Ranch Wrap

    Crispy chicken, bacon, ranch, cheddar, lettuce & tomatoes.

    $10.99

    Chicken Bacon Ranch Wrap

    Turkey Wrap

    Lettuce, tomatoes, mayo & American cheese.

    $10.99

    Chicken Wrap

    Crispy chicken, lettuce, tomatoes.

    $10.99

    pasta

    Pasta

    Pasta Alfredo

    $15.99

    Pasta with Broccoli, Garlic & Oil

    $13.99

    Baked Ziti

    Tomato sauce, ricotta & mozzarella.

    $12.99

    Pasta with Garlic & Oil

    $10.99

    Cheese Ravioli

    $13.99

    Penne Siciliana

    Penne, tomato sauce, eggplant with pecorino romano.

    $14.99

    Lasagna

    $15.99

    Penne Vodka

    $14.99

    Pasta with Meat Sauce

    $13.99

    Stuffed Shells

    $13.99

    Pasta Marinara

    $10.99

    Tortellini Carbonara

    $14.99

    entrees

    Entrees

    Served over Pasta with Side Salad & Bread. (No Substitutions)

    Chicken Scarpariello

    Chicken, sausage, onions, peppers & white wine sauce.

    $20.99

    Chicken Parmigiana

    With tomato sauce & melted mozzarella.

    $19.99

    Eggplant Rollatini

    $19.99

    Veal Parmigiana

    With tomato sauce & melted mozzarella.

    $19.99

    Chicken Francese

    Over white wine lemon sauce.

    $19.99

    Eggplant Parmigiana

    With tomato sauce & melted mozzarella.

    $19.99

    Veal Francese

    Over white wine lemon sauce.

    $19.99

    Penne A La Rosa

    Chicken breast with broccoli in a light pink sauce.

    $19.99

    Chicken Marsala

    Sauteed mushrooms & marsala wine.

    $19.99

    Piccata

    Sauteed in artichoke, capers, lemon & white wine sauce.

    $19.99

    Veal Marsala

    Sauteed mushrooms & marsala wine.

    $19.99

    Sorrentino

    Served with eggplant, prosciutto, in a rich tomato sauce & melted mozzarella.

    $20.99

    seafood

    Seafood

    Served over Pasta with Side Salad & Bread. (No Substitutions)

    Linguini with Red Clam Sauce

    Sauteed clams with garlic, parsley & olive oil.

    $20.99

    Shrimp Francese

    Battered shrimp in a lemon butter & white wine sauce.

    $20.99

    Linguini with White Clam Sauce

    Sauteed clams with garlic, parsley & olive oil.

    $20.99

    Shrimp Parmigiana

    $20.99

    Seafood Pasta

    Shrimp, clams & mussels in a pink herbed sauce over linguini.

    $24.99

    Shrimp Scampi

    Shrimp sauteed in garlic butter & white wine sauce.

    $20.99

    kids-menu

    Kids Menu

    Kid's Pasta

    $7.99

    desserts

    Desserts

    Cannoli

    Delicious tube of fried dough, filled with a sweet, creamy ricotta filling.

    $5.99

    Tiramisu

    A delicious coffee-flavored italian dessert. Ladyfingers dipped in coffee, layered with a whipped mixture of eggs, sugar & Mascarpone cheese, flavored with cocoa.

    $6.99

    Cheesecake

    Classic cheesecake with a rich, dense, smooth, and creamy consistency.

    $5.99

    Zeppoli

    Italian palm-sized funnel cakes.

    $5.99

    beverages

    Beverages

    Soda

    $3.25

    Sports Drink

    $3.50

    Water

    $3.00

    Tea

    $3.75

    pasta-catering

    Pasta Catering

    Pasta Alfredo Catering

    $46.00

    Pasta with Red Clam Sauce Catering

    $61.00

    Baked Ziti Catering

    $46.00

    Pasta with White Clam Sauce Catering

    $61.00

    Cheese Ravioli Catering

    $46.00

    Pasta with Broccoli Garlic & Oil Catering

    $61.00

    Chicken Francese Catering

    $61.00

    Pasta with Garlic & Oil Catering

    $46.00

    Chicken Marsala Catering

    $61.00

    Penne Vodka Catering

    $46.00

    Chicken Piccata Catering

    $61.00

    Sausage & Peppers Catering

    $46.00

    Chicken Scarpariello Catering

    $61.00

    Stuffed Shells Catering

    $46.00

    Eggplant Rollatini Catering

    $46.00

    Veal Peppers Catering

    $61.00

    Lasagna Catering

    $51.00

    Veal Marsala Catering

    $61.00

    Pasta Marinara Catering

    $41.00

    parmigiana-catering

    Parmigiana Catering

    Chicken Parmigiana Catering

    $61.00

    Sausage Parmigiana Catering

    $61.00

    Eggplant Parmigiana Catering

    $61.00

    Shrimp Parmigiana Catering

    $61.00

    Meatball Parmigiana Catering

    $61.00

    Veal Parmigiana Catering

    $61.00

    sides-catering

    Sides Catering

    Chicken Tenders Catering

    $46.00

    Mozzarella Sticks Catering

    $51.00

    Garlic Knots Catering

    $31.00

    salads-catering

    Salads Catering

    Garden Salad Catering

    $26.00

    Greek Salad Catering

    $46.00

    Chicken Salad Catering

    $51.00

    Caesar Salad Catering

    $31.00

    Antipasto Salad Catering

    $51.00

    cold-heroes-catering

    Cold Heroes Catering

    American Combo Hero Catering

    $18.00

    Italian Combo Hero Catering

    $19.00

    Benny's Pizza - 18 W Rd, Pleasant Valley, NY 12569 - Menu, Hours, & Phone Number - Order Delivery or Pickup - Slice

    SliceNYPleasant Valley12569 Benny's Pizza
    Price: $$