Skip to main content
Setauket Pastaria

Setauket Pastaria

4082 Nesconset Hwy, Setauket-East Setauket, NY 11733
631-476-8600

Open until 10:45 PM

Full Hours

$2.50 Delivery (30 - 45 min)

$15 min spend

  • Part of Slice Rewards
create-your-own-pizza
Create Your Own Pizza

Create Your Own Cheese Pizza

Classic cheese or create your own pizza.

$7.50

pizza
Pizza

Cheese Pizza

Classic cheese or create your own pizza.

$15.50

Cheese Pizza

Sicilian Cheese Pizza

Classic cheese or create your own pizza.

$19.00

Sicilian Cheese Pizza

Grandma's Pizza

Cooked in an olive oil-coated pan topped with classic cheese and tomato sauce.

$19.00


Old Fashioned Sicilian Pizza

Cooked in the olive oil-coated pan and topped with classic cheese.

$19.50


Stuffed Meat Pizza

Meatball, ham, sausage, pepperoni, and mozzarella cheese.

$30.00

specialty-pizza
Specialty Pizza

Margherita Pizza

Tomato sauce, cheese, oregano.

$9.95


White Pizza

A sauceless pie topped with ricotta, mozzarella, and parmesan cheese.

$12.00

White Pizza

Vegetable Pizza

$12.00


Chicken Parmesan Pizza

Breaded chicken & mozzarella.

$12.00


Baked Ziti Pizza

Topped with penne, mozzarella cheese, and tomato sauce.

$12.00


Lasagna Pizza

Comes with ground beef, sauce, and ricotta, and mozzarella cheese.

$12.00


Four Cheese Pizza

$12.00


BBQ Chicken Pizza

Topped with BBQ sauce, mozzarella, and chicken meat.

$12.00


Buffalo Chicken Pizza

$12.00


Godfather Pizza

$12.00


Chicken & Fresh Tomato Pizza

$12.00


Meat Lover's Pizza

Meatballs, sausage, pepperoni, ham & mozzarella cheese.

$12.00


Eggplant Parmigiana Pizza

$12.00


Eggplant Rollatini Pizza

Ham, ricotta cheese & mozzarella cheese.

$12.00


Fresh Mozzarella & Tomato with Balsamic Pizza

$12.00

Fresh Mozzarella & Tomato with Balsamic Pizza

Bread Crumb, Grated Cheese & Onion Pizza

$12.00


Spinach & Fresh Tomato Pizza

$12.00


Broccoli & Fresh Tomatoes Pizza

$12.00


Broccoli & Cheddar Cheese Pizza

$12.00


Chicken Francese Pizza

$12.00


Caesar Salad Pizza

$13.00


Greek Salad Pizza

$13.00


Pear Salad Pizza

$13.00


Angel Hair Bolognese Pizza

$13.00


Chicken, Bacon Ranch Pizza

$13.00

Chicken, Bacon Ranch Pizza

Hawaiian Pizza

Ham, bacon and pineapple.

$13.00


Artichoke Pizza

$13.00


Chicken & Roasted Pepper Pizza

$13.00


Penne Alla Vodka Pizza

$13.00


Sicilian Specialty Pizza

$13.00


Chicken Marsala Specialty Pizza

$12.00

pizza-by-the-slice
Pizza by the Slice

Regular Pizza Slice

$3.00


Sicilian Pizza Slice

$3.00


Grandma Pizza Slice

$3.00


Old Fashioned Sicilian Pizza Slice

$2.76


Margherita Pizza Slice

Tomato sauce, cheese, oregano.

$5.00


White Pizza Slice

A sauceless pie topped with ricotta, mozzarella, and parmesan cheese.

$5.00


Vegetable Pizza Slice

$5.00


Chicken Parmesan Pizza Slice

Breaded chicken & mozzarella.

$5.00


Baked Ziti Pizza Slice

Topped with penne, mozzarella cheese, and tomato sauce.

$5.00


Lasagna Pizza Slice

Comes with ground beef, sauce, and ricotta, and mozzarella cheese.

$5.00


BBQ Chicken Pizza Slice

Topped with BBQ sauce, mozzarella, and chicken meat.

$5.00


Buffalo Chicken Pizza Slice

$5.00


Godfather Pizza Slice

$5.00


Chicken & Fresh Tomato Pizza Slice

$5.00


Meat Lover's Pizza Slice

Meatballs, sausage, pepperoni, ham.

$5.00


Eggplant Parmigiana Pizza Slice

$5.00


Eggplant Rollatini Pizza Slice

Ham, ricotta cheese & mozzarella cheese.

$5.00


Fresh Mozzarella & Tomato with Balsamic Pizza Slice

$5.00


Bread Crumb, Grated Cheese & Onion Pizza Slice

$5.00


Broccoli & Cheddar Pizza Slice

$5.00


Chicken Francese Pizza Slice

$5.00


Spinach & Fresh Tomato Pizza Slice

$5.00


Greek Pizza Slice

$6.00


Pear Salad Pizza Slice

$6.00


Angel Hair Bolognese Pizza Slice

$5.00


Chicken, Bacon Ranch Pizza Slice

$5.00


Chicken & Roasted Peppers Pizza Slice

$5.00


Penne Alla Vodka Pizza Slice

$5.00


Artichoke Pizza Slice

$5.00


Broccoli & Fresh Tomatoes Pizza

$5.00


Hawaiian Pizza Slice

Ham, bacon, and pineapple.

$5.00

appetizers
Appetizers

Baked Clams

$12.00

Baked Clams

Little Necks

$12.00


Clams Casino

Six whole clams, roasted pepper, and bacon.

$12.00


Hot Antipasto

Eggplant rollatini, baked clams, stuffed mushrooms, artichokes & shrimp.

$17.95


Shrimp Cocktail

Six large shrimp with cocktail sauce.

$14.95

Shrimp Cocktail

Shrimp Scampi

$14.95


Fried Shrimp

With tomato sauce.

$14.95


Fried Calamari

Breaded and fried with marinara.

$13.95


Mussels Marinara

Bowl of steamed mussels, choice red or white sauce.

$15.95


Fried Ravioli

With tomato sauce.

$11.95


Beer Battered Onion Rings

With ketchup.

$6.95


French Fries

With ketchup.

$5.95


Mozzarella Sticks

With tomato sauce.

$10.95


Mozzarella En Carrozzo

With marinara sauce.

$10.95


Stuffed Mushrooms

$10.95


Zucchini Sticks

With tomato sauce.

$9.95


Chicken Fingers

With honey, mustard, french fries, ketchup.

$10.95


Bruschetta

$9.95


Eggplant Rollatini

Slices of eggplant, dusted in wheat flour or lightly breaded and covered with ricotta and other cheeses and seasonings.

$12.95


Spinach & Mushrooms

Sauteed in garlic & oil.

$9.95


Buffalo Wings

With bleu cheese.

$12.95


Maryland Crab Cakes

With tartar sauce.

$14.95

side-orders
Side Orders

Garlic Bread

Bread, topped with garlic, herb seasoning, baked to perfection.

$4.95


Garlic Bread with Mozzarella Cheese

French garlic bread with mozzarella cheese served with marinara sauce.

$5.95


Side of Sausage

$6.95


Side of Meatballs

$6.95


Side of Pasta

$6.95


Side of Potato & Vegetables

$6.95


Grilled Chicken

$9.95


Garlic Knots

A classic snack, our garlic knots are strips of pizza dough tied in a knot, baked, and then topped with melted butter, garlic, and parsley.

$0.50

Garlic Knots

Focaccia Bread

$0.50


Zeppoli

$0.65

Zeppoli

Sauce on the Side

$0.75


Tomato Sauce

$5.00


Marinara Sauce

$5.00


Vodka Sauce

$7.95


Meat Sauce

$7.95


Bolognese Sauce

$7.95

soups-of-the-day
Soups of the Day
Served with Italian bread & butter.

Pasta Faggioli Soup

Served with Italian Bread & Butter.

$6.95


French Onion Soup

Served with Italian Bread & Butter

$8.00


Stratchatelli Soup

Served with Italian Bread & Butter

$6.95


Chicken Soup

Served with Italian Bread & Butter

$6.95


Minestrone Soup

Served with Italian Bread & Butter

$6.95


Tortellini Soup

Served with Italian Bread & Butter

$6.95

salads
Salads
Served with Italian bread & butter.

Antipasta Salad

Cold with salami, ham, provolone, fresh mozzarella cheese, roasted peppers, pepperoni, soppressata, lettuce, tomatoes, and balsamic vinaigrette.

$12.95


Italian Salad

With mozzarella cheese, balsamic vinaigrette.

$8.00


House Salad

A mixture of fresh seasonal greens.

$7.00


Caesar Salad

With Parmesan cheese & Caesar dressing.

$7.00


Greek Salad

With feta cheese & balsamic vinaigrette dressing.

$8.00


Fresh Mozzarella & Tomatoes Salad

With roasted peppers, balsamic vinaigrette dressing.

$11.95

Fresh Mozzarella & Tomatoes Salad

Calamari Salad

Lettuce, celery, lemons, onions.

$14.95


Spinach Salad

Warm with bacon, red onions, mushrooms, balsamic vinaigrette.

$12.00


Bosc Pear Salad

With gorgonzola cheese, raspberry vinaigrette.

$12.00


Cold Seafood Salad

Mussels, calamari, shrimp, scallops, scungilli.

$24.95

heroes
Heroes

Meatball Hero

With marinara sauce and meatballs.

$8.00


Meatball & Mushrooms Hero

$9.00


Sausage & Peppers Hero

$9.00


Sausage Hero

$8.00


Veal Cutlet Hero

$10.00


Veal & Peppers Hero

$12.00


Veal & Mushrooms Hero

$12.00


Pepper & Egg Hero

With ketchup.

$8.00


Potato & Egg Hero

With ketchup.

$8.00


Chicken Cutlet Hero

Breaded cutlet topped with sauce.

$8.00


Chicken Cutlet with Lettuce & Tomatoes Hero

$9.00


Grilled Chicken with Lettuce & Tomatoes Hero

$9.50


Eggplant Hero

$9.00


Shrimp Hero

$13.00


Salami & Provolone Hero

Lettuce, tomatoes, balsamic vinaigrette dressing.

$8.00


Cheesesteak Hero

With peppers, and onions.

$9.00


Fresh Mozzarella & Prosciutto Hero

On garlic bread.

$10.00


Fresh Mozzarella Hero

With roasted peppers on garlic bread.

$9.00


Italian Combo Hero

Salami, provolone cheese, pepperoni, soppressata, ham, lettuce, tomatoes, balsamic vinaigrette.

$9.00

pastaria-delights
Pastaria Delights

Calzone

Made with ricotta cheese and mozzarella.

$8.00


Broccoli Roll

With cheddar cheese.

$7.25


Rice Ball Parmigiana

$6.95


Rice Ball

Deep-fried balls of delicious rice and cheese.

$5.95


Meatball Roll

$7.25


Sausage, Pepper & Onion Roll

$7.25


Spinach Roll

Roll stuffed with spinach and mozzarella.

$7.25


Chicken Roll

Strips of breaded chicken topped with tomato sauce and mozzarella.

$7.25


Eggplant Roll

Eggplant slices and parmesan cheese.

$7.25


Pepperoni Roll

Pepperoni pizza in a roll.

$7.25


Special Roll

$7.25


Stuffed Garlic Knot

Chicken.

$6.95

Stuffed Garlic Knot

Pepperoni Pinwheel

A delicious spiralized version of pepperoni pizza. An NYC pizza parlor classic you can enjoy at your table.

$5.50

pasta-dishes
Pasta Dishes
Served with choice pasta, Italian bread & butter.

Pasta with Tomato Sauce

Pasta tossed in our homemade tomato sauce.

$13.95


Pasta with Marinara Sauce

Pasta tossed in our homemade marinara sauce.

$14.95


Pasta with Bolognese Sauce

Pasta tossed in bolognese sauce.

$16.95

Pasta with Bolognese Sauce

Pasta with Meat Sauce

Pasta tossed in our homemade meat sauce.

$16.95


Pasta with Red Clam Sauce

$18.95


Pasta with White Clam Sauce

Pasta in a white wine & butter sauce topped with clams.

$18.95


Pasta with Butter Sauce

$11.95


Pasta with Garlic & Oil

Delicious pasta covered in silky garlic oil.

$13.95


Pasta with Carbonara

$16.95


Pasta with Puttanesca

$16.95


Pasta with Primavera

Red or white sauce. Comes with zucchini, mushrooms, squash, onions, peppers.

$16.95


Pasta with Meatballs

Two pieces of meatballs. Pasta topped in our homemade meatballs.

$15.95


Pasta with Sweet Italian Sausage

Two pieces of sausage.

$15.95


Pasta with Broccoli, Garlic & Oil

$16.95


Pasta with Vodka Sauce

Pasta in vodka sauce.

$16.95


Pasta with Calamari

Marinara sauce.

$17.95


Pasta with Frutta Di Mare

Clams, mussels, shrimp, scallops, scungilli & lobster tail.

$32.95


Seafood Lasagna

Lasagna with shrimp, scallops, and lobster meat in a creamy pink sauce.

$24.00


Lobster Ravioli

Lobster filled pasta topped with shrimp, lobster meat, and asparagus in a pink sauce.

$24.00


Penne Broccoli Rabe

Penne, broccoli rabe, sausage, and sun-dried tomatoes in a garlic and oil sauce.

$18.00


Chicken Tre Scallini

Sauteed chicken breast with spinach in a pink sauce, topped with fresh mozzarella over rigatoni.

$19.00


Stuffed Rigatoni Bolognese

Ricotta stuffed rigatoni in a bolognese sauce.

$19.00


Cheese Tortellini

with grilled chicken, mushrooms, prosciutto, and sun-dried tomatoes in a parmesan cream sauce.

$18.00

pasta-specials
Pasta Specials
Served with Italian bread & butter.

Baked Ziti with Ricotta

$15.95


Baked Ziti with Two Sausages

$18.95


Baked Ziti with Two Meatballs

$18.95


Baked Lasagna

Stacked layers of pasta packed with meat and cheese, covered in red sauce. Pro tip: Go for the crispy edge pieces.

$16.95


Baked Ravioli

$16.95


Baked Manicotti

$16.95


Baked Stuffed Shells

$16.95


Fettuccine Alfredo

Fettuccine tossed in our creamy homemade alfredo sauce.

$16.95


Fettuccine Alfredo with Broccoli

$16.95


Fettuccine Alfredo with Shrimp

Five pieces shrimp.

$23.95


Fettuccine Alfredo with Broccoli, Garlic & Oil

$15.95


Penne Alla Vodka with Shrimp

$23.95


Cavatelli

With fresh mozzarella cheese.

$17.95


Gnocchi Ala Napolitano

With fresh mozzarella cheese.

$17.95

entrees
Entrees
Served with your choice of pasta, salad or potatoes & vegetables, & with Italian bread & butter.

Veal Parmigiana

$24.00


Veal & Peppers

With onions.

$24.00


Veal Marsala

With mushrooms.

$24.00


Veal Francese

Veal cutlets with white wine, arugula, butter & olive oil.

$24.00


Shrimp Parmigiana

$25.00


Shrimp Fra Diavolo

$25.00


Shrimp Francese

$25.00


Shrimp Scampi

$25.00


Chicken Marsala With Mushrooms

$22.00


Chicken Cutlet Parmigiana

Grilled chicken, marinara sauce, and Parmesan cheese.

$22.00


Chicken Francese

$22.00


Chicken Rollatini

$22.00


Chicken Sorrentino

Chicken topped with eggplant, prosciutto, & mozzarella cheese.

$22.00


Chicken Cacciatore

$22.00


Chicken Scarpello

$22.00

Chicken Scarpello

Eggplant Rollatini

With prosciutto.

$22.00


Eggplant Parmigiana

$21.00

ice-creams
Ice Creams

Vanilla Ice Cream

$7.00

desserts
Desserts

Cannoli Petites

$6.00


Cannoli

Chocolate shelled cannoli

$5.00

Cannoli

Cheesecake

Cheesecake

$6.00


Tiramisu Cake

Traditional tiramisu with a sponge layer cake.

$6.00


Chocolate Layer Cake

Layered rich chocolate cake & frosting.

$6.00


Gluten-Free Rice Pudding

Topped with cinnamon & whipped cream.

$6.00


Chocolate Lava A La Mode

Chocolate souffle with liquid chocolate heart paired with vanilla ice cream.

$7.00


Gluten Free Tartufo

Chocolate & vanilla gelato, cherry almond center, chocolate shell.

$7.00


Gluten Free Spumoni Tortufo

Strawberry, pistachio & chocolate gelato, hazelnut pieces, cherry, chocolate shell.

$7.00

beverages
Beverages

Soda

$3.00


Fountain Soda

$1.50


Unsweetened Iced Tea

$3.00


Apple Juice

$3.00


Pellegrino

$4.00


Cappuccino

$4.00


Espresso

$3.00


Coffee

$1.50


Tea

$1.50

catering
Catering
Graduations, birthdays, anniversaries, confirmations, communions, engagements, weddings, office parties, club parties, picnics & BBQs. Servers are available for occasions upon request. Includes garlic knots, Foccacia bread & paper goods.

Stuffed Mushrooms Catering

$65.00


Super Loaded Giant Hero Catering

Lettuce, tomatoes, homemade macaroni salad, potato salad, cole slaw, mayonnaise & dressing.

$69.95


Broccoli Sauté Catering

$75.00


String Beans with Almonds Catering

$65.00


Spinach with Mushrooms & Garlic Catering

$65.00


Fried Calamari Catering

$110.00


Chicken Fingers Catering

$85.00


French Fries Catering

$55.00


Garlic Knots Catering

$30.00


Focaccia Bread Catering

$30.00


Rice Balls Catering

$5.50


Tossed Salad Platter Catering

$49.00


Greek Salad Platter Catering

$60.00


Caesar Salad Platter Catering

$45.00


Pear Salad Platter Catering

$65.00


Antipasta Salad Platter Catering

$85.00


Scungilli Salad Catering

$89.00


Buffalo Wings Catering

$95.00


Italian Hero Catering

Lettuce, tomatoes, homemade macaroni salad, potato salad, cole slaw, mustard and mayonnaise, and paper goods. One foot serves 3-4 people.

$59.95


American Hero Catering

Lettuce, tomatoes, homemade macaroni salad, potato salad, cole slaw, mustard and mayonnaise, and paper goods. One foot serves 3-4 people.

$59.95


Baked Ravioli Catering

$80.00


Baked Ziti Catering

$80.00


Spaghetti with Garlic & Oil Catering

$70.00


Rigatoni Bolognese Catering

$85.00


Baked Lasagna Catering

$85.00


Rigatoni Fillet Catering

$80.00


Penne di Pomodoro Catering

$80.00


Stuffed Shells Catering

$79.00


Manicotti Catering

$79.00


Linguine with Clam Sauce Catering

Red or white sauce.

$90.00


Tortellini Alfredo Catering

$85.00


Penne Alla Vodka Catering

$85.00

Penne Alla Vodka Catering

Tortellini Carbonara Catering

$85.00


Pasta Puttanesca

$85.00


Penne with Ham & Peas Catering

In brown cream sauce.

$69.00


Eggplant Parmigiana Catering

$100.00


Eggplant Rollatini Catering

$105.00


Chicken Cacciatore Catering

$110.00


Chicken Marsala Catering

$110.00


Veal Marsala Catering

$135.00


Veal & Peppers Hero Catering

$135.00


Chicken Parmigiana Catering

$110.00


Chicken Sorrentino Catering

$110.00


Chicken Scarpiello Catering

$110.00


Chicken Francese Catering

$110.00


Chicken Rollatini Catering

$110.00


Veal Parmigiana Catering

$135.00


Veal Francese Catering

$135.00


Veal & Peppers Catering

$135.00


Pepper Steak & Onions Catering

$100.00


Steak & Mushrooms Catering

$100.00


Italian Meatballs Catering

$100.00


Sausage & Peppers Catering

$100.00


Shrimp Francese Catering

$150.00


Shrimp Fra Diavolo Catering

$150.00


Shrimp Scampi Catering

$150.00


Shrimp Parmigiana Catering

$150.00


Stuffed Flounder Catering

$135.00


Salmon Oreganata Catering

$155.00


Pistachio Salmon Catering

$155.00


Mussels Marinara Catering

$80.00


Baked Clams Oreganata Catering

$90.00


Frutti di Mare Catering

$139.00


Stuffed Peppers Catering

$75.00


Basmati Rice Catering

$45.00


Dinner Rolls Catering

$30.00


Onion Rings Catering

$50.00


Mozzarella Sticks Catering

$85.00


Fried Ravioli Catering

$80.00


Potato & Vegetable Platter Catering

$60.00

monday-lunch-specials
Monday Lunch Specials
Includes one numbered lunch & soda.

1. Mesclun Salad Monday Lunch

With tomatoes & cucumbers. Served on Monday & until 3pm.

$7.00


2. Soup of the Day Monday Lunch

Please call the restaurant for today's selection. Served on Monday & until 3pm.

$7.00


3. Chicken Parmesan with Spaghetti Marinara Monday Lunch

Served on Monday & until 3pm.

$7.00


4. Baked Ziti with Meatballs Monday Lunch

Served on Monday & until 3pm.

$7.00


5. Grilled Chicken Caesar Salad Wrap Monday Lunch

With potato salad. Served on Monday & until 3pm.

$7.00

tuesday-lunch-specials
Tuesday Lunch Specials
Includes one numbered lunch & soda.

1. Caesar Salad Tuesday Lunch

Served on Tuesday & until 3pm.

$7.00


2. Soup of the Day Tuesday Lunch

Please call the restaurant for today's selection. Served on Tuesday & until 3pm.

$7.00


3. Chicken Francese Tuesday Lunch

Linguine pasta. Served on Tuesday & until 3pm.

$7.00


4. Spaghetti with Meatballs Tuesday Lunch

Served on Tuesday & until 3pm.

$7.00


5. Meatball Parmesan Hero Tuesday Lunch

Served on Tuesday & until 3pm.

$7.00

wednesday-lunch-specials
Wednesday Lunch Specials
Includes one numbered lunch & soda.

1. Pear Salad Wednesday Lunch

With honey walnuts & gorgonzola cheese & raspberry vinaigrette. Served on Wednesday & until 3pm.

$7.00


2. Soup of the Day Wednesday Lunch

Please call the restaurant for today's selection. Served on Wednesday & until 3pm.

$7.00


3. Chicken Marsala Wednesday Lunch

With penne. Served on Wednesday & until 3pm.

$7.00


4. Stuffed Shells Wednesday Lunch

Served on Wednesday & until 3pm.

$7.00


5. Chicken Mozzarella & Tomato Sauce Roll Wednesday Lunch

Served on Wednesday & until 3pm.

$7.00

thursday-lunch-specials
Thursday Lunch Specials
Includes one numbered lunch & soda.

1. Warm Spinach Salad Thursday Lunch

With bacon, mushrooms, onions. Served on Thursday & until 3pm.

$7.00


2. Soup of the Day Thursday Lunch

Please call the restaurant for today's selection. Served on Thursday & until 3pm.

$7.00


3. Chicken Parmesan Thursday Lunch

With spaghetti marinara. Served on Thursday & until 3pm.

$7.00


4. Penne Alla Vodka Thursday Lunch

Served on Thursday & until 3pm.

$7.00


5. Sausage & Pepper Hero Thursday Lunch

Served on Thursday & until 3pm.

$7.00

friday-lunch-specials
Friday Lunch Specials
Includes one numbered lunch & soda.

1. 12'' Personal Cheese Pizza Friday Lunch

Served on Friday & until 3pm.

$7.00


2. Soup of the Day Friday Lunch

Please call the restaurant for today's selection. Served on Friday & until 3pm.

$7.00


3. Mozzarella & Spinach Roll Friday Lunch

Served on Friday & until 3pm.

$7.00


4. Fettuccine Alfredo Friday Lunch

Served on Friday & until 3pm.

$7.00


5. Eggplant Rollatini Friday Lunch

Served on Friday & until 3pm.

$7.00