Skip to main content
Cottage Inn Pizza is currently ONLY available for PICKUP orders.
Cottage Inn Pizza

Cottage Inn Pizza

2167 N High St, Columbus, OH 43201
614-564-9292

Open until 9:00 PM

Full Hours
    Skip to first category
    build-your-own-pizza

    Build Your Own Pizza

    Build Your Own Pizza

    Classic cheese or create your own pizza.

    $11.25

    Build Your Own Pizza

    Gluten Free Pizza

    $17.50

    Nino One Topping Pizza

    $8.75

    classic-gourmet-pizza

    Classic Gourmet Pizza

    Smokehouse BBQ Pizza

    Features Sweet Baby Ray's BBQ base sauce, topped with pulled pork, our gourmet cheese blend, onions, and bacon.

    $17.50

    BLT Pizza

    No sauce base, bacon, tomato, lettuce, drizzled with homemade ranch.

    $17.50

    All Meat Pizza

    Pepperoni, ham, Italian sausage, beef, and bacon.

    $17.50

    The Cuban Pizza

    Carolina Tangy Gold BBQ sauce base, pulled pork, ham, and bread & butter pickles, drizzled with Carolina Tangy Gold BBQ sauce.

    $17.50

    Deluxe Pizza

    Pepperoni, Italian sausage, red onion, green pepper, and fresh mushrooms.

    $17.50

    Ranch Taco Pizza

    $17.50

    Price Burstethe Favorite Pizza

    Pepperoni, ham, Italian sausage, red onion, green pepper, fresh mushrooms, beef, green and black olives.

    $17.50

    Spicy Italian Pizza

    $17.50

    Phillysteak Supreme Pizza

    Steak, red onion, green pepper, and sweet red pepper.

    $17.50

    Nino Gourmet Pizza with One Topping

    $10.00

    Motor City Meatball Pizza

    Meatballs, pepperoni, Italian sausage, shredded Parmesan cheese, and Italian seasoning.

    $17.50

    chicken-gourmet-pizza

    Chicken Gourmet Pizza

    Cheese Chicken Buffalo Ranch Pizza

    $17.50

    BBQ Chicken Pizza

    Sweet Baby Ray's BBQ sauce, grilled chicken, red onion, and bacon, drizzled with Sweet Baby Ray's BBQ sauce.

    $17.50

    Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza

    Homemade ranch dressing base, topped with grilled chicken, our gourmet cheese blend, and finished with a mouth-watering dose of bacon.

    $17.50

    Chicken Artichoke Pizza

    Olive oil base, minced garlic, grilled chicken, artichoke, spinach, shredded Parmesan cheese, and Italian seasoning.

    $17.50

    Chicken Alfredo Pizza

    Alfredo sauce base, grilled chicken, tomato, and fresh mushrooms.

    $17.50

    Buffalo Chicken Blue Pizza

    $17.50

    Chicken Mediterranean Pizza

    Grilled chicken, banana pepper rings, feta cheese, olive oil, and Italian seasoning.

    $17.50

    Hot Honey Chicken Pizza

    Mango Habanero sauce, topped with our gourmet cheese blend, breaded chicken, bacon, and finished with a drizzle of Mike's Hot Honey.

    $17.50

    classic-vegetarian-pizza

    Classic Vegetarian Pizza

    Greek Pizza

    Feta cheese, black olives, banana pepper rings, tomato, red onion, olive oil, and Italian seasoning.

    $17.50

    Spinach Alfredo Pizza

    Alfredo sauce base, spinach, fresh mushrooms, and tomato.

    $17.50

    Roma Pesto Pizza

    Sun-dried tomato, spinach, tomato, and feta cheese, topped with a swirl of pesto (nut-free).

    $17.50

    Traditional Vegetarian Pizza

    Fresh mushrooms, red onion, green pepper, black olives, and tomato.

    $17.50

    Spicy Mediterranean Pizza

    Banana pepper rings, feta cheese, olive oil, and Italian seasoning.

    $17.50

    gluten-free-gourmet-pizza

    Gluten Free Gourmet Pizza

    Gluten Free Smokehouse BBQ Pizza

    $21.25

    Gluten Free Chicken Alfredo Pizza

    $21.25

    Gluten Free All Meat Pizza

    $21.25

    Gluten Free Chicken Mediterranean Pizza

    $21.25

    Gluten Free Deluxe Pizza

    $21.25

    Gluten Free BBQ Chicken Pizza

    $21.25

    Gluten Free Price Burstethe Favorite Pizza

    $21.25

    Gluten Free Chicken Artichoke Pizza

    $21.25

    Gluten Free Phillysteak Supreme Pizza

    $21.25

    Gluten Free Buffalo Chicken Blue Pizza

    $21.25

    Gluten Free Motor City Meatball Pizza

    $21.25

    Gluten Free Hot Honey Chicken Pizza

    $21.25

    Gluten Free BLT Pizza

    $21.25

    Gluten Free Greek Pizza

    $21.25

    Gluten Free The Cuban Pizza

    $21.25

    Gluten Free Roma Pesto Pizza

    $21.25

    Gluten Free Ranch Taco Pizza

    $21.25

    Gluten Free Spicy Mediterranean Pizza

    $21.25

    Gluten Free Spicy Italian Pizza

    $21.25

    Gluten Free Spinach Alfredo Pizza

    $21.25

    Gluten Free Cheese Chicken Buffalo Ranch Pizza

    $21.25

    Gluten Free Traditional Vegetarian Pizza

    $21.25

    Gluten Free Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza

    $21.25

    innstix

    Innstix

    Traditional Stix

    Topped with garlic butter and grated parmesan cheese. Served with pizza sauce

    $6.85

    Traditional Stix

    Everything Stix

    Topped with garlic butter and everything seasoning. Served with homemade garlic cream cheese.

    $9.60

    Everything Stix
    cheesebreads

    Cheesebreads

    Featured

    Classic Cheesebread

    $10.95

    Classic Cheesebread

    Bacon Cheddar Bread

    Garlic cheese bread with bacon, cheddar cheese and Italian seasoning.

    $12.35

    Bacon Cheddar Bread

    Feta Cheesebread

    Garlic cheese bread with feta cheese, Italian seasoning and olive oil.

    $12.35

    Feta Cheesebread

    Pepperoni Bread

    Garlic cheese bread with pepperoni, Italian seasoning, and grated parmesan cheese.

    $12.35

    gluten-free-cheesebreads

    Gluten Free Cheesebreads

    Featured

    Gluten Free Classic Cheesebread

    $16.25

    Gluten Free Classic Cheesebread

    Gluten Free Bacon Cheddar Bread

    Garlic cheese bread with bacon, cheddar cheese and Italian seasoning.

    $17.50

    Gluten Free Bacon Cheddar Bread

    Gluten Free Feta Cheesebread

    Garlic cheese bread with feta cheese, Italian seasoning and olive oil.

    $17.50

    Gluten Free Feta Cheesebread

    Gluten Free Pepperoni Bread

    Garlic cheese bread with pepperoni, Italian seasoning, and grated parmesan cheese.

    $17.50

    wings

    Wings

    Featured

    Oven Roasted Wings

    $12.50

    Oven Roasted Wings

    Boneless Wings

    $12.50

    Boneless Wings
    dip-cups

    Dip Cups

    Garlic Cream Cheese Dipping Sauce

    $3.50

    Garlic Dipping Sauce

    $2.15

    Ranch Dipping Sauce

    $2.15

    Wings Dipping Sauce

    $2.15

    Pizza Dipping Sauce

    $2.15

    classic-salads

    Classic Salads

    Caesar Salad

    Romaine lettuce, shredded parmesan cheese, croutons, and Caesar dressing.

    $9.99

    Caesar Salad

    Tossed Salad

    Romaine lettuce, tomatoes, cucumbers, croutons, and Italian dressing.

    $9.99

    Tossed Salad
    gourmet-salads

    Gourmet Salads

    Antipasto Salad

    Romaine lettuce, red onions, hot pepper rings, tomatoes, gourmet cheese blend and Italian dressing.

    $11.25

    Antipasto Salad

    Grilled Chicken Salad

    Romaine lettuce, grilled chicken, tomatoes, red onions, gourmet cheese blend, and Italian dressing.

    $11.25

    Grilled Chicken Salad

    Chicken Caesar Salad

    Romaine, lettuce, grilled chicken, shredded parmesan, cheese, croutons, and Caesar dressing.

    $11.25

    Chicken Caesar Salad

    Greek Salad

    Romaine lettuce, pepperoncini peppers, red onions, beets, tomatoes, kalamata olive, feta cheese, Italian seasoning and greek dressing.

    $11.25

    Greek Salad

    Cranberry Walnut Salad

    Romaine lettuce, dried cranberries, walnuts, tomatoes, red onions, bleu cheese crumbles, and raspberry vinaigrette dressing.

    $11.25

    Cranberry Walnut Salad
    calzones

    Calzones

    Calzone with Three Toppings

    $12.50

    subs

    Subs

    Featured

    Italian Sub

    Ham, salami, hot pepper rings, red onions, lettuce, tomatoes, provolone cheese and mustard sauce.

    $9.99

    Italian Sub

    BLT Sub

    Bacon, lettuce, tomatoes, and provolone cheese with a side of homemade ranch.

    $9.99

    BLT Sub

    Motor City Meatball Sub

    Meatballs, shredded parmesan cheese, gourmet cheese blend and pizza sauce.

    $9.99

    Motor City Meatball Sub

    BBQ Chicken Sub

    Chicken, bacon, red onions, gourmet cheese blend, and sweet baby ray's BBQ sauce.

    $9.99

    BBQ Chicken Sub

    Philly Steak Sub

    Steak, red onions, green peppers, hot pepper rings, fresh mushrooms, tomatoes, and gourmet cheese blend with a side of homemade ranch.

    $9.99

    Philly Steak Sub

    Chicken Club Sub

    Chicken, bacon, lettuce, tomatoes, and provolone cheese with a side of homemade ranch.

    $9.99

    Chicken Club Sub

    Pizza Sub

    $9.99

    Pizza Sub

    Chicken Parmesan Sub

    Breaded chicken, shredded parmesan cheese, gourmet cheese blend, pizza sauce.

    $9.99

    Chicken Parmesan Sub

    Pulled Pork Sub

    Pulled pork, gourmet cheese blend and your choice of sweet baby ray's BBQ sauce or Carolina tangy gold BBQ sauce.

    $9.99

    Pulled Pork Sub

    Cottage Inn Club Sub

    Turkey, ham, bacon, lettuce, tomatoes and provolone cheese with a side of mayo.

    $9.99

    Turkey & Cheese Sub

    Turkey, lettuce, tomatoes, red onions, hot pepper rings, and provolone cheese with a side of mayo.

    $9.99

    Turkey & Cheese Sub

    Cuban Sub

    Pulled pork, ham, gourmet cheese blend, bread & butter pickles, and Carolina tangy gold BBQ sauce.

    $9.99

    Cuban Sub

    Veggie Sub

    Red onions, green peppers, lettuce, green olives, fresh mushrooms, tomatoes, hot pepper rings, provolone cheese and mustard sauce.

    $9.99

    Veggie Sub

    Ham & Cheese Sub

    Ham, hot pepper rings, red onions, lettuce, tomatoes, provolone cheese and mustard sauce.

    $9.99

    Ham & Cheese Sub

    Chicken Pita Sandwich Sub

    Grilled chicken, red onions, lettuce, tomatoes, and feta cheese on a baked pita with side of Italian dressing.

    $9.99

    Chicken Pita Sandwich Sub
    gluten-free-subs

    Gluten Free Subs

    Gluten Free BLT Sub

    Bacon, lettuce, tomatoes, and provolone cheese with a side of homemade ranch.

    $16.25

    Gluten Free Italian Sub

    Ham, salami, hot pepper rings, red onions, lettuce, tomatoes, provolone cheese and mustard sauce.

    $16.25

    Gluten Free BBQ Chicken Sub

    Chicken, bacon, red onions, gourmet cheese blend, and sweet baby ray's BBQ sauce.

    $16.25

    Gluten Free Philly Steak Sub

    Steak, red onions, green peppers, hot pepper rings, fresh mushrooms, tomatoes, and gourmet cheese blend with a side of homemade ranch.

    $16.25

    Gluten Free Chicken Club Sub

    Chicken, bacon, lettuce, tomatoes, and provolone cheese with a side of homemade ranch.

    $16.25

    Gluten Free Pulled Pork Sub

    Pulled pork, gourmet cheese blend and your choice of sweet baby ray's BBQ sauce or Carolina tangy gold BBQ sauce.

    $16.25

    Gluten Free Cottage Inn Club Sub

    Turkey, ham, bacon, lettuce, tomatoes and provolone cheese with a side of mayo.

    $16.25

    Gluten Free Turkey & Cheese Sub

    Turkey, lettuce, tomatoes, red onions, hot pepper rings, and provolone cheese with a side of mayo.

    $16.25

    Gluten Free Ham & Cheese Sub

    Ham, hot pepper rings, red onions, lettuce, tomatoes, provolone cheese and mustard sauce.

    $16.25

    Gluten Free Veggie Sub

    Red onions, green peppers, lettuce, green olives, fresh mushrooms, tomatoes, hot pepper rings, provolone cheese and mustard sauce.

    $16.25

    pitas

    Pitas

    Chicken Pita

    $13.75

    italian-favorites

    Italian Favorites

    Lasagna

    Layers of pasta, beef and ricotta cheese topped with our signature sauce and gourmet cheese blend

    $14.99

    Lasagna

    Lasagna Dinner

    Lasagna with regular innstix and choice of small classic salad.

    $21.25

    Lasagna Dinner
    desserts

    Desserts

    Cinnamon Stix

    Breaded stix topped with cinnamon sugar and vanilla icing.

    $9.99

    Cinnamon Stix

    Apple Piezza

    Cheesecake filling base and cinnamon apple, topped with cinnamon sugar.

    $11.25

    Apple Piezza
    beverages

    Beverages

    Soda

    $2.75

    Cottage Inn Pizza - View Menu & Order Online - 2167 N High St, Columbus, OH 43201 - Slice

    SliceOHColumbus43201 Cottage Inn Pizza
    Price: $$