hero

Thirsty Pony

1935 Cleveland Rd W, Sandusky, OH 44870

Open NowFull HoursAre you the owner?

We're all about supporting local pizzerias - even those who are not Slice partners.
Give Thirsty Pony a call to order. We hear their food's delish.

Menu
gourmet-pizza
We kneed the dough! A delicious thick crust - crispy on the outside, puffy on the inside, topped with mounds and mounds of cheese.
Cheese Pizza$14.00 +
Classic cheese or create your own pizza.
Pizza Margherita$16.00 +
Mozzarella & provolone cheese, garlic, basil, olive oil & slices of tomatoes.
Alfredo Chicken Pizza$16.00 +
Mozzarella, provolone, alfredo sauce & grilled chciken.
Fricking Chicken Pizza$16.00 +
Mama frickin' mia topped with fricker's chicken, your choice of wing sauce, with monterey and marble cheese banana peppers upon request.
Fricking Mac & Cheese Pizza$16.00 +
Topped with Fricker's chicken, your choice of wing sauce and creamy mac & cheese.
The Bacon Ranch Chicken Pizza$16.00 +
Ranch dressing topped with fried chicken, bacon, cheddar, Monterey jack, mozzarella and provolone cheese.
Chicken & Broccoli Pizza$16.00 +
Grilled chicken, broccoli, diced tomatoes, cheddar, monterey jack, parmesan, mozzarella & provolone cheeses on a garlic butter crust.
super-starters
Lobster Bisque$11.00
Served in a sourdough bread bowl.
French Onion Soup$7.00
Served in a crock & topped with cheese.
Old Fashioned Chili$8.00
Topped with Mexican cheese & served with a trio of jalapenos, onions & sour cream on the side.
Spinach Artichoke Dip$11.00
Served in bread with tri-colored nacho chips.
Sauerkraut Balls$9.00
Made from scratch, stuffed with sausage & kraut, and served with bistro sauce.
Fricking Chicken Dip$11.00
Shredded frickin' chicken in a creamy wing sauce served with tri-colored nacho chips.
Fried Green Beans$7.00
Battered & fried & served with teriyaki dipping sauce.
Fried Pickles$9.00
Dill pickle spears & spicy pickle chips, breaded and served with ranch dressing.
Southwestern Egg Rolls$9.00
A crispy flour tortilla filled with chicken, black beans, corn, jalapeno jack cheese, red peppers & spinach, served with ranch dressing.
Giant Hanging Pretzels$9.00
A crispy flour tortilla filled with chicken, black beans, corn, jalapeno jack cheese, red peppers & spinach, served with ranch dressing.
Strip Tease Chicken$10.00
Chicken strips & fries with bbq, ranch or honey mustard sauce.
Soup of the Day$3.00 +
Call the restaurant for today's selection.
Cheese Stick Stack$8.00
Fried batter dipped cheese stacked high with a side of dippin' red sauce.
Beer Battered Onion Rings$8.00
Beer battered onion rings served with a bistro dipping sauce.
BBQ Rib Basket$12.00
Fire braised st. Louis-style ribs basted in our flickers bbq sauce over fries with slaw.
fishy-starters
Petite Perch$15.00
Lake Erie perch served with tartar sauce.
Walleye Fingers$15.00
Lake erie walleye served with tartar sauce.
NLE Coconut Shrimp$12.00
Coconut shrimp served with a creamy coconut dipping sauce.
flatbread-pizzatizers
Philly Cheese Steak Flatbread$12.00
Philly cheesesteak sauteed with peppers, mushrooms & onions & topped with mozzarella & provolone cheese on garlic buttered flatbread.
Cheeseburger Flatbread$12.00
Hamburger & melted cheddar cheese topped with lettuce, tomato, pickles, onions, ketchup & mustard on a buttered flatbread.
Spinach Artichoke Flatbread$12.00
Garlic buttered flatbread with creamy spinach & artichoke topped with tomatoes & parmesan cheese on garlic buttered flatbread.
Cheesy Portobello Flatbread$12.00
Marinated slices of portobello mushrooms topped with mozzarella, provolone & parmesan cheese on garlic buttered flatbread.
Greek Flatbread$12.00
Slow grilled gyro meat on a flatbread topped with red onions, mozzarella & feta cheeses, lettuce, tomato & tzatziki sauce.
every-day-is-fryday
Loaded Potato Skins$10.00
Cheese, onions, black olives & bacon with a side of sour cream.
Beer Battered French Fries$6.00
Tater Puffs$6.00
Sweet Potato Waffle Fries$8.00
Dusted in cinnamon sugar & served with a creamy brown sugar dippin' sauce.
Goopy Cheesy Fries$8.00
Chili Cheese Fries$10.00
Potato Trio Sampler$10.00
Sweet potato fries, beer battered French fries & tater puffs served with creamy brown sugar sauce, Bourbon Molasses & cheese sauce.
Philly Fries$10.00
Sliced philly cheese steak, mushrooms, green & red peppers & provolone cheese.
Pizza Fries$10.00
Pepperoni, pizza sauce & melted mozzarella & provolone cheese with banana peppers.
ToTchos$10.00
Tater tots loaded with taco beef, green onions, cilantro, diced tomatoes, black olives & cheese topped with sour cream, jalapenos & salsa.
Porky Tots$10.00
Slow roasted pork, flickers bbq sauce, jalapenos & cheddar cheese sauce.
Pork Belly Bacon & Egg Fries$10.00
Pork belly bacon, sunnyside up egg with our creamy cheddar cheese sauce.
Cheeseburger Fries$10.00
Hamburger, bacon, lettuce, tomato, onion & cheese sauce.
Bleu Chicken Cajun Fries$10.00
Breaded strips of chicken topped with creamy & crumbled bleu cheese.
Greek Fries$10.00
Gyro meat, feta cheese, diced cucumbers & tomatoes with tzatziki sauce.
salads
Salad dressings house Italian, avocado ranch, cilantro lime, Russian, creamy parmesan, bleu cheese, ranch, thousand islands, creamy Italian, light Italian, sweet & sour, oil & vinegar.
House Salad$8.00
A mix fresh greens topped with tomatoes, onions, marbled cheese, cucumbers, croutons & your choice of salad dressing.
Chef Salad$12.00
A mix of fresh greens topped with tomatoes, onions, marbled cheese, cucumbers, ham, turkey, croutons & your choice of salad dressing.
Chicken Pepper Pasta Salad$14.00
Grilled chicken, onions, red & green peppers over a bed of pasta & mixed greens.
Chicken Caesar Salad$12.00
Romaine lettuce, croutons & parmesan cheese topped with grilled chicken & our own creamy caesar dressing.
Gyro Salad$14.00
Slow grilled gyro meat with feta cheese, lettuce, tomato, cucumbers & tzatziki dressing.
Wedge Salad$12.00
A wedge iceberg lettuce topped with crispy bacon, crumbled Blue cheese, tomatoes & Green Goddess dressing.
Taco Salad$12.00
Romaine lettuce topped with taco beef, cheeses, black olives, tomatoes, green onions, salsa & sour cream served in a tortilla shell.
Frickin' Chicken Salad By Fricker's$13.00
A jumbo house salad topped with our famous frickin' chicken breast served in your choice of wing sauce and salad dressing.
Grilled Black & Blue Steak House$14.00
A mix of fresh greens topped with tomatoes, onions, cucumbers, croutons, crumbled bleu cheese, grilled & your choice of salad dressing.
Chicken Spinach Salad$13.00
Baby spinach, tomatoes, cucumbers, red onions, almonds & chopped grilled chicken with French Celery Seed Betty dressing.
Southwestern Salad$12.00
A mix of fresh greens topped with crispy southwestern chicken rolls, corn, black beans, pepper jack cheese & tortilla strips with our avocado ranch salad dressing.
sliders
Mini Cheeseburger$10.00
Slider topped with a pickle.
BBQ Little Porker$10.00
Pulled pork slider.
Mini Bourbon Molasses$10.00
Pork belly & slaw slider.
chicken-wings-chunks
Mix & match any 2 sauces together for your own flavor.
World Famous Fricking Chicken Wings$12.00 +
Wing Sampler$32.00
30 frickin' chicken wings in your choice of three frickin' sauces, wings served naked upon request no breading.
Fricking Chicken Chunks$12.00
No bones about it. 10 ounces of tender chunks of chicken tossed in your favorite wing sauce.
pot-belly-sandwiches
Sandwiches so big you might have to use a fork! Sandwiches served with a bag of potato chips, pasta salad, and a fried dill pickle.
Pulled Pork BBQ Sandwich$11.00
Traditional southern pulled pork smothered in Fricker's bbq sauce & served on ciabatta bread.
Toasted Philly Cheese Steak Sandwich$12.00
Sliced Philly steak with grilled onions, peppers, mushrooms & hot cheddar then topped with mozzarella cheese all on a toasted hoagie bun.
New Yorker Sandwich$11.00
Kosher style corned beef topped with swiss cheese & homemade cole slaw on grilled marbled rye bread.
Perch Sandwich$12.00
Lake Erie Yellow Perch with tartar sauce on a dusted kaiser bun.
Walleye Sandwich$13.00
Lake Erie Yellow Perch with tartar sauce on a dusted kaiser bun.
Prime Rib French Dip Sandwich$12.00
Sliced prime rib, horseradish sauce, provolone cheese on a hoagie and french onion au jus for dunking.
Sausage & Peppers Sandwich$11.00
Sliced prime rib, horseradish sauce, provolone cheese on a hoagie and french onion au jus for dunking.
Sloppy Pig Sandwich$12.00
Pulled pork with cheddar macaroni & cheese on a toasted hoagie bun.
Reuben Sandwich$11.00
Kosher style corned beef, swiss cheese topped with sauerkraut & thousand island dressing served on grilled marbled rye bread.
Reuben Gobbler Sandwich$11.00
Sliced turkey topped with swiss cheese, sauerkraut & thousand island dressing served on grilled marbled rye bread.
Deli Stack Cuban Sandwich$12.00
Turkey, corned beef & ham topped with swiss & mozzarella, pickles & spicy mustard on ciabatta bread.
Toasted Italian Hoagie$12.00
Genoa salami, ham, pepperoni, & mozzarella with tomato, shredded lettuce, onion & creamy Italian dressing on a toasted hoagie.
PBLT Sandwich$11.00
Pork belly, lettuce & tomato with rosemary mayo on ciabatta bread.
sandwich-wraps
Chicken Caesar Wrap$11.00
Grilled chicken breast, parmesan cheese & caesar dressing wrapped in a spinach tortilla.
Fajita Chicken Wrap$11.00
Grilled chicken breast with fajita seasoning then topped with grilled peppers & pepper jack cheese wrapped in a spinach tortilla.
Frickin Chicken Wrap$11.00
Breaded chicken breast, pepper jack cheese, lettuce, tomato and any Fricker's famous wing sauce wrapped in a flour tortilla.
Turkey Bacon Wrap$11.00
Thinly sliced turkey topped with applewood bacon, avocado, American & swiss cheese wrapped in a spinach tortilla.
Club Wrap$11.00
Turkey, ham, applewood bacon, lettuce & tomato wrapped in a spinach tortilla.
Gyro Wrap$11.00
Slow grilled gyro meat with feta cheese, lettuce, tomato, cucumbers & tzatziki dressing wrapped in a flour tortilla.
belly-buster-burger
Belly buster burgers are 1/2 lb, of fresh hand-picked quality beef, cooked on the grill for maximum flavor & topped with lettuce, tomato & onion, all burgers are served on a kaiser bun with a bag of potato chips, coleslaw, and a fried dill pickled.
Bald Burger$10.00
Plain, no topping on a scored brioche bun.
Belly & Bleu Burger$11.00
Topped with pork belly and creamy & crumbled bleu cheese on a branded bun.
Patty Melt Burger$11.00
Topped with American & swiss cheese and sauteed onions served on grilled marbled rye bread.
Cluck Cluck Burger$12.00
Not just for breakfast anymore, topped with a fried egg, bacon & American cheese on a pretzel bun.
Baby Chubby Burger$12.00
A smaller version of the chubby hubby - 1/2 lb. Double-decker topped with American & swiss cheese & bacon on a scored brioche bun.
Philly Burger$11.00
Philly-style with mozzarella cheese, sauteed green, red peppers & onions on a scored brioche bun.
Bubba Burger$11.00
Topped with cheddar cheese, bbq sauce and onion straws between 2 slices of texas toast.
Guacamole Bacon Burger$12.00
Topped with zesty guacamole, bacon pepper jack cheese on a pretzel bun.
Humungus Fungus Burger$10.00
Vegetarian, marinated portobello mushroom topped with provolone on a braided bun.
Goopy Cheese Burger$11.00
A four-towel burger smothered in hot goopy cheese on a scored brioche bun.
Whiskey Burger$11.00
Topped with sauteed onions, our tangy jack daniel's bbq sauce & American cheese on a scored brioche bun.
The Thirsty Bam Burger$12.00
Our signature burger ground with a touch of horseradish and fresh garlic, seasoned with salt, pepper & steak sauce, topped with swiss & mozzarella cheeses on ciabatta bread.
Chubby Hubby Burger$15.00
A double-decker topped with American & swiss cheeses & bacon on a scored brioche bun.
M & M Burger$11.00
Topped with mozzarella & mushrooms on a scored brioche bun.
Bacon Burger$11.00
Piled high with applewood bacon, lettuce & tomato on a pretzel bun.
Pepper Jack Cajun Burger$11.00
Topped with pepper jack cheese, cajun seasoning & grilled peppers on a scored brioche bun.
Mac & Cheese Burger$12.00
Topped with mac & cheese and crumbled bacon on a brioche bun.
Roma Burger$12.00
Topped with salami, mozzarella, provolone cheeses & Italian dressing on a ciabatta bun.
Sweet Potato Quinoa Burger$10.00
Vegetarian ,our vegan burger served on a branded bun.
cluck-on-a-bun
Chicken sandwiches served with a bag of potato chips, pasta salad, and a fried dill pickle.
Fricking Chicken Sandwich$11.00
Breaded chicken breast sandwich topped with any frickers famous wing sauce on a dusted kaiser bun.
Smothered Grilled Chicken Sandwich$12.00
Topped with mozzarella cheese, sauteed onions & mushrooms on a kaiser bun.
Chicken Philly Sandwich$12.00
Grilled chicken sliced Philly-style with grilled onions, peppers, mushrooms & hot cheddar then topped with mozzarella cheese all on a toasted hoagie bun.
The Naked Chicken Sandwich By Frickers$11.00
Grilled chicken breast topped with any flickers famous wing sauce served on a dusted kaiser bun.
Chicken Guacamole Bacon Sandwich$12.00
Grilled chicken breast topped with guacamole, bacon & pepper jack cheese.
nacho-ordinary
Super Nachos$10.00 +
Nachos loaded with cheese, olives, taco meat or chicken, onions, tomatoes, jalapenos, refried beans, & anything else we can find - plenty to share, served with salsa & sour cream, guacamole upon request.
Steak & Chicken Quesadillas$10.00
Cheese, chicken or steak, tomatoes, black beans & green onions grilled between tortillas served with sour cream and salsa.
Guacamole, Chips & Salsa Nacho$8.00
dinners
All dinner selections served with one salad selection and one side selection.
Lake Erie Perch Dinner$20.00
Lightly breaded deep fried Lake Erie Yellow Perch served with tartar sauce.
Coconut Shrimp Dinner$20.00
Coconut shrimp served with a cream coconut dipping sauce.
Bird & Beef Dinner$18.00
A 6oz sirloin with five frickin' chicken wings in your choice of frickin' sauce.
BBQ Rib Dinner$18.00
Fire braised st. Louis style ribs basted in fricker's bbq sauce.
Lake Erie Walleye Dinner$20.00
A fillet of Lake Erie Walleye lightly breaded & deep fried then served with tartar sauce.
Beef & Shrimp Dinner$20.00
A 6 oz. Sirloin with five crispy cracklin' shrimp and cocktail sauce.
T-Bone Dinner$18.00
A 16oz. T-Bone steak charbroiled on an open flame.
Rib & Wings Dinner$20.00
Petite ribs with five frickin' chicken wings in your choice of frickin' sauce.
little-pony
Reserved for our littlest guests. Includes tater tots, applesauce, a special treat & prize
Kid's Chicken Tenders$8.00
Kid's Mini Cheeseburgers$8.00
Kid's Spaghettio's$8.00
Kid's Cheese Quesadilla$8.00
Kid's Mac & Cheese$8.00
desserts
Oreo Churros$6.00
Oreo meets churro, crispy chocolaty oreo outside with creamy filling inside.
Fat Matt's Fat Chocolate Cake$8.00
Layers of chocolate cake & sweet cream filling topped with whipped cream, caramel & chocolate sauces--big enough to share.
Dippin' Dots$4.00
Banana split, cookies & cream w/ oreo's mint chocolate chip & cookie dough.

FAQ

Price: $$