Skip to main content
The Pizza Heist

The Pizza Heist

231 Aurora St, Lancaster, NY 14086
716-671-3463

Closed until Tue at 11:00 AM

Full Hours

Opens Tue at 11:00 AM

pizza
Pizza

Build Your Own Pizza

Classic cheese or create your own pizza.

$8.99


Cheese & Pepperoni Pizza

Classic cheese and pepperoni.

$10.99

Cheese & Pepperoni Pizza
specialty-pizzas
Specialty Pizzas

White Pizza

Brushed with house oil, covered with fresh tomato, onions, blended cheese, and sprinkled with seasonings.

$15.99


Veggie Pizza

Broccoli, mushrooms, onions, choice of peppers, choice of olives, cheese.

$15.99

Veggie Pizza

Taco Pizza

Choice of taco, steak, or chicken, topped with fresh lettuce, black olives, tomato, and blended cheeses.

$15.99


Garlic Bread Pizza

Topped with cheese, garlic bits and seasoning.

$11.99


Chicken Finger Pizza

Your choice of hot/med/mild or bbq sauces, covered with mozzarella cheese and chopped chicken fingers. Served with bleu cheese on the side.

$15.99

Chicken Finger Pizza

Steak Pizza

Brushed with oil, mozzarella cheese, choice of peppers, onions, and chopped steak.

$15.99

Steak Pizza

In The Grass Pizza

Choice of chicken or steak, brushed with oil, mixed with fresh garlic, spinach, covered with mozzarella cheese.

$15.99


Carnivore Pizza

A mix of steak, sausage & chicken with sauteed onions, peppers, covered with blended cheeses & sprinkled with seasonings.

$16.99


Rodeo Pizza

A bbq red sauce with ground beef, covered with blended cheeses, topped with onion rings, lettuce & tomato.

$16.99


Stinger Pizza

A generous portion of steak & chicken finger covered in mozzarella cheese with a layer of lettuce & tomato.

$16.99

pizza-by-the-slice
Pizza by the Slice

Cheese & Pepperoni Pizza Slice

Classic cheese and pepperoni.

$2.24

Cheese & Pepperoni Pizza Slice
monday-specials
Monday Specials

Large Cheese Pizza with One Topping Monday Special

Monday only.

$9.99

tuesday-special
Tuesday Special

Buy 2 Tacos & Receive One Free Special

$3.99

wednesday-special
Wednesday Special

Wednesday Special

The whole 12" sub receives $1.00 off. Wednesday only.

$7.99

thursday-specials
Thursday Specials

Wings Thursday Special

Thursday only.

$5.00

everyday-specials
Everyday Specials

Pizza Special

2 Slices (Cheese + 1 Item) 20 oz. Soda.

$5.99


Mini Sub Special

$5.99


Chicken Finger Special

3 fingers & fries with bleu cheese, celery & 20 oz. Soda.

$8.99


Small Cheese Pizza with One Topping & 10 Boneless Wings Special

$14.99


Small Cheese Pizza with One Topping & 10 Regular Wings Special

$19.99


Small Cheese Pizza with One Topping & 5 Fingers Special

$19.99


Two Large Cheese Pizza with One Topping Special

$24.99


Large Cheese Pizza with One Topping & 20 Boneless Wings Special

$24.99


Large Cheese Pizza with One Topping & 20 Regular Wings Special

$33.99


Large Cheese Pizza with One Topping & 10 Fingers Special

$33.99


Large Cheese Pizza with One Toppings & 30 Boneless Wings Special

$32.99


Large Cheese Pizza with One Toppings & 30 Regular Wings Special

$40.99


Sheet Cheese Pizza with One Topping & 30 Boneless Wings Special

$40.99


Sheet Cheese Pizza with One Topping & 30 Regular Wings Special

$48.99


Two Large Cheese Pizza with One Topping & 30 Boneless Wings Special

$40.99


Two Large Cheese Pizza with One Topping & 30 Regular Wings Special

$48.99


Sheet Cheese Pizza with One Topping & 50 Boneless Wings Special

$51.99


Sheet Cheese Pizza with One Topping & 50 Regular Wings Special

$62.99


Sheet Cheese Pizza with One Topping & 25 Fingers Special

$62.99


Two Large Pizza with One Topping & 50 Boneless Wings Special

$51.99


Two Large Pizza with One Topping & 50 Regular Wings Special

$62.99


Two Large Pizza with One Topping & 25 Fingers Special

$62.99

appetizers
Appetizers
Our appetizers are great with lunch, dinner or just a snack.

Mozzarella Sticks

Deep fried cheese sticks. Crispy on the outside, gooey on the inside.

$5.99


Onion Rings

Crispy onion slices deep-fried until golden-brown.

$2.99


Mac & Cheese Bites

$5.99


French Fries

Our delicious french fries are deep-fried 'till golden brown with a crunchy exterior and a light fluffy interior, seasoned to perfection.

$2.99

French Fries

Bread Sticks

$3.99


Garlic Bread

Bread, topped with garlic, herb seasoning, baked to perfection.

$2.99

Garlic Bread

Sampler Platter

2 chicken fingers, 2 mozzarella sticks, 4 poppers, 2 pizza logs, & 1 order of onion rings.

$13.99

Sampler Platter

Hot Poppers

$5.99


Fried Dough

$3.99


Pizza Logs

$5.99


Tator Tots

$2.99


Funnel Cake Fries

$2.99


Apple Pie Logs

$5.99

salads
Salads
We use the finest ingredients in every salad including cold fresh crisp lettuce & red ripe tomatoes.

Chef Salad

Lettuce, tomatoes, croutons, black olives, and cheddar.

$3.99


Antipasto Salad

Lettuce, tomatoes, croutons, ham, salami, capicola, pepperoni, mozzarella, black olives, and green olives.

$4.99


Grilled Chicken Salad

Lettuce, tomatoes, croutons, chicken, mozzarella.

$4.99


Chicken Finger Salad

Lettuce, tomatoes, croutons, chicken, mozzarella, and cheddar.

$4.99

Chicken Finger Salad

Tuna Salad

Lettuce, tomatoes, croutons, tuna, and mozzarella.

$4.99


Taco Salad

Chili over crisp greens in a fried taco shell, topped with cheddar cheese, cheese sauce, diced tomatoes, olives, salsa, and sour cream.

$4.99


Julienne Salad

Lettuce, tomatoes, croutons, turkey, ham, mozzarella, and cheddar.

$4.99

chicken-wings
Chicken Wings
Every order served with bleu cheese & celery.

Chicken Wings

Whole chicken wings deep-fried.

$13.99

Chicken Wings
boneless-wings
Boneless Wings
Every order served with bleu cheese & celery.

Boneless Wings

$9.99

chicken-fingers
Chicken Fingers
Served with fries, bleu cheese & celery.

Chicken Fingers

Breaded & fried chicken strips.

$13.99

hot-cold-subs
Hot & Cold Subs
Our subs feature toasted Costanzo's rolls, fresh lettuce, tomatoes, cheese, and your choice of mayo, oil, or Onions.

Ham Cold Sub

Topped with deli-sliced ham. Cold sub.

$5.99


Turkey Cold Sub

Turkey and veggies make for a scrumptious sub. Cold sub.

$5.99


Ham & Turkey Cold Sub

Cold sub.

$5.99


Salami Cold Sub

Cold sub.

$5.99


Cheese Cold Sub

Cold sub.

$5.99


Tuna Cold Sub

Delicious tuna fish salad & veggies in a satisfying sub. Cold sub.

$5.99


Capicola Cold Sub

Cold sub.

$6.99


Assorted Cold Sub

Cold sub.

$6.99


Turkey Club Cold Sub

Turkey and veggies make for a scrumptious sub. Cold sub.

$7.99


Pizza Hot Sub

Made with generous portions of pepperoni, pizza sauce & cheese. Hot sub.

$5.99


White Pizza Hot Sub

Hot sub.

$6.99


Sausage Hot Sub

Sausage, mushrooms and cheese over delicious red sauce.

$6.99


Steak Hot Sub

A killer sub packed with succulent steak. Hot sub.

$6.99


Chicken Fingers Hot Sub

Chicken fingers and classic cheese. Hot sub.

$6.99


Chicken Fingers Pizza Hot Sub

Hot sub.

$6.99

Chicken Fingers Pizza Hot Sub

Grilled Chicken Hot Sub

Grilled chicken and classic cheese. Hot sub.

$7.99


BLT Hot Sub

Classic bacon, lettuce, and tomato. Hot sub.

$7.99


Royal Hot Sub

Hot sub.

$7.99


Cheeseburger Hot Sub

The flavors of your favorite cheeseburger, in sub form! Hot sub.

$7.99

Cheeseburger Hot Sub

Bacon Cheeseburger Hot Sub

Hot sub.

$10.99


Stinger Hot Sub

Hot sub.

$10.99

Stinger Hot Sub

Fish Hot Sub

Hot sub.

$10.99


In The Grass Steak Sub

$7.99


In The Grass Chicken Sub

$7.99

In The Grass Chicken Sub

Eggplant Parmesan Sub

Topped with eggplant slices and parmesan cheese.

$6.99


Meatball Parmesan Sub

Topped with homemade meatballs and parmesan cheese.

$6.99


Sausage Parmesan Sub

$6.99


Chicken Parmesan Sub

Fried chicken breast, marinara sauce, and mozzarella cheese.

$7.99


Philly Steak Hoagie Sub

$7.99

Philly Steak Hoagie Sub

Sausage Hoagie Sub

$7.99


Chicken Hoagie Sub

$7.99

wraps
Wraps
Wraps available in flour tortillas.

Ham Wrap

$5.99


Turkey Wrap

Turkey, lettuce, tomatoes, and onions.

$5.99


Ham & Turkey Wrap

$5.99


Salami Wrap

$5.99


Cheese Wrap

$5.99


Tuna Wrap

Lettuce, tomatoes, onions, and melted cheese.

$5.99


Capicola Wrap

$6.99


Assorted Wrap

$6.99


Turkey Club Wrap

$7.99

tacos
Tacos
Served on a soft tortilla shell with shredded lettuce, tomato, and cheese. Hot, medium, mild.

Beef & Cheese Taco

$4.99


Chicken Finger Taco

$6.99


Veggie Taco

$3.99


Steak Taco

Sliced steak, cheese, lettuce, and tomato. Served with salsa and topped with sour cream.

$6.99

Steak Taco
dinners
Dinners
Includes macaroni salad & coleslaw on friday.

Fish Fry with Fries Dinner

Haddock.

$13.99

beverages
Beverages

Soda

Nothing like a cold soda to go with your pizza.

$1.99