Skip to main content
The Kaatskeller is currently ONLY available for PICKUP orders.
The Kaatskeller

The Kaatskeller

39 Main St, Livingston Manor, NY 12758
845-439-4339

Open until 4:00 PM

Full Hours
    wood-fried-pizza
    Wood Fried Pizza
    12" pizza wood-fired with Sullivan Country kiln dried ash. Traditional Italian "OO" flour blended with New York organic wheat.

    NY Style Cheese Pizza

    Our version of NY style 12" pizza - shredded whole milk mozzarella, DOP San Marzano tomato sauce, oregano, EVOO. Buy 3 for $23. Save $22. Toppings Extra. Discount is taken at cart. Great to freeze for later.

    $15.00

    NY Style Cheese Pizza

    Margherita The High Life Pizza

    Our best seller for good reason - local mozzarella, authentic DOP San Marzano tomato, Agrarian Feast micro basil, EVOO.

    $19.00

    Margherita The High Life Pizza

    Wild One Pizza

    Wild Boar pepperoni, smoked mozzarella, shaved white onion, spicy Harissa spiked San Marzano tomato. Alderwood smoked sea salt. EVOO. Catskill Provisions pepper infused raw honey accompaniment.

    $24.00

    Wild One Pizza

    Saltwater Pizza

    New Haven-style white pizza with littleneck clams. Arugula, lemon. Ah, summer...

    $27.00


    The Manor Pizza

    Wild arugula, roasted red pepper, aged prosciutto, fresh local mozzarella, San Marzano tomato, 10-year Modena balsamic vinegar.

    $23.00


    My Italian Friend Pizza

    Freshly minced garlic, white onion, aged prosciutto, shaved Parmigiano-Reggiano, San Marzano tomato, live basil, olive oil.

    $19.50

    My Italian Friend Pizza

    Hawaii Five-Oh Pizza

    Sweet and Savory - pineapple, prosciutto, and mix of sweet and hot peppers. San Marzano tomato, shredded mozzarella cheese, oregano, EVOO.

    $21.00


    Mediterranean Retreat Pizza

    Kalamata olives, onion, spinach, sun-dried tomato, feta, authentic San Marzano tomato, EVOO.

    $23.00


    Dreaming of Buffalo Pizza

    Buffalo Kombucha hot sauce, organic ground chicken breast, Tonjes Farm blue cheese crumble, micro chives. Butter crust. Blue cheese dip.

    $21.50


    The White Album Pizza

    Seven local farms and the wild Catskill forest meet here. House-made wild ramp kale pesto, bacon jam, chevre, aged Parmigiano-Reggiano, egg, broccoli shoots, EVOO.

    $25.00

    The White Album Pizza

    Marinara Pizza

    DOP San Marzano tomatoes, oregano, garlic, EVOO. A very tasty red pizza but also a terrific base to customize as you wish. We recommend simply adding anchovies but you're welcome to get creative.

    $12.00


    The Kaatskeller Pizza Dough

    Special blend of traditional "00" and New York organic milled wheat. Great for making pizzas at home. Freeze until ready to use.

    $5.00

    soups
    Soups

    Soup of The Day

    $8.00

    salads
    Salads

    Wild Apple Arugula

    Wild arugula, aged Italian-style hard cheese, apple, raw walnut. House cider and raw honey dressing. (Gluten-free, vegetarian).

    $15.00

    Wild Apple Arugula

    Wood Fired Caesar Salad

    Wood-fired curly kale or little gem lettuce, curried chickpeas, house vegan Caesar dressing, parmesan cheese (GF, V, contains nuts).

    $15.00

    Wood Fired Caesar Salad
    small-plate
    Small Plate

    Flat Bread & Butter

    Wood-fired house-made flat bread. Local farm butter. Sea Salt. EVOO.

    $7.00

    Flat Bread & Butter

    Skillet Meatballs

    Hand rolled, local grass-fed beef, Stewed DOP San Marzano tomatoes, Tonjes Dairy Farm ricotta, Agrarian Feast micro basil.

    $17.00

    Skillet Meatballs

    Meatball Sammie

    Hand-rolled local beef. Stewed DOP San Marzano tomatoes. Italian cheese blend. Chopped Kale Finished in our wood-fired oven.

    $17.00


    Brook Trout Rillettes

    House recipe, smoked trout dip. Wood-fired flatbread & chipotle pepper accompaniment. GF upon request. (contains fish and dairy).

    $17.00

    Brook Trout Rillettes

    Burrata Caponatina

    Roasted tomato, eggplant, olive, onion, and green pepper. Burrata and bread accompaniment. A perfect summer appetizer.

    $17.00


    Wood Fired Trout

    Native whole trout. House ramp pesto. Roasted in our wood fired oven with lemon, seasonal vegetable and a starch. Share or entrée dish (GF). A guest favorite.

    $25.00

    kids-menu
    Kids Menu

    Kid's Cheese Pizza

    Made the same as our NY-style cheese pizza but 1/2 the size.

    $9.00

    beverages
    Beverages

    Assorted Soda

    $3.50


    Sprindrift

    No sugar, sparkling black tea & lemon.

    $3.00


    Apple Cider

    $4.50


    Sparkling Water

    $3.50

    SliceNYLivingston Manor12758 The Kaatskeller
    Price: $$