Skip to main content
John's of Arthur Ave Restaurant

John's of Arthur Ave Restaurant

19 W Main St, Middletown, NY 10940
845-467-4712

Order Ahead We open at 10:00 AM

Full Hours
  • 5% off online orders
NY Health ScoreNew Window Icon
Skip to first category

House Favorites

These are the shop recommendations for a great meal experience.

White Pizza

Fresh ricotta, grande mozzarella, pecorino romano & parmigiano reggiano.

Original price was $14.25

Discounted price is $13.54

BBQ Chicken Pizza

Topped with BBQ sauce, mozzarella, and chicken meat.

Original price was $14.25

Discounted price is $13.54

Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza

Mozzarella cheese, bacon, chicken, and yummy ranch dressing.

Original price was $14.25

Discounted price is $13.54

Buffalo Chicken Pizza

Buffalo chicken and mozzarella cheese.

Original price was $14.25

Discounted price is $13.54

House Special Eggplant Pizza

Cheese & tomato pie topped with fried eggplant, fresh ricotta, pecorino, Parmigiano & basil.

Original price was $14.25

Discounted price is $13.54

Pear Salad

With organic mesclun, cranberries, candied walnuts, gorgonzola & balsamic vinaigrette.

Original price was $10.95

Discounted price is $10.40

Balsamic Fresh Mozzarella Hero

Soft, fresh, homemade mozzarella, roasted red peppers, balsamic vinaigrette & fresh basil.

Original price was $13.15

Discounted price is $12.49

Homemade Lasagna

Stacked layers of pasta packed with meat and cheese, covered in red sauce. Pro tip: Go for the crispy edge pieces.

Original price was $14.25

Discounted price is $13.54

Eggplant Parmigiana

Tomato sauce & homemade mozzarella with spaghetti.

Original price was $18.65

Discounted price is $17.72

Chicken Parmigiana

Tomato sauce & homemade mozzarella with spaghetti.

Original price was $18.65

Discounted price is $17.72

arthur-ave-style-pizza

Arthur Ave. Style Pizza

Thin & crispy crust, zesty sauce & aged grande mozzarella. Our mozzarella is made fresh daily. The half pizza toppings are not available for the personal pizza.

Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza

Mozzarella cheese, bacon, chicken, and yummy ranch dressing.

Original price was $14.25

Discounted price is $13.54

White Pizza

Fresh ricotta, grande mozzarella, pecorino romano & parmigiano reggiano.

Original price was $14.25

Discounted price is $13.54

Buffalo Chicken Pizza

Buffalo chicken and mozzarella cheese.

Original price was $14.25

Discounted price is $13.54

BBQ Chicken Pizza

Topped with BBQ sauce, mozzarella, and chicken meat.

Original price was $14.25

Discounted price is $13.54

House Special Eggplant Pizza

Cheese & tomato pie topped with fried eggplant, fresh ricotta, pecorino, Parmigiano & basil.

Original price was $14.25

Discounted price is $13.54

Broccoli Rabe & Sausage Pizza

Crushed tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, sweet fennel sausage, garlic & broccoli rabe.

Original price was $14.25

Discounted price is $13.54

Pizza Margherita

Crushed tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, basil & olive oil.

Original price was $14.25

Discounted price is $13.54

Sausage, Pepper & Onions Dinner Pizza

Pizza sauce, mozzarella, sweet fennel sausage, grilled peppers & onions.

Original price was $14.25

Discounted price is $13.54

Chicken Alfredo Pizza

Topped in our homemade creamy alfredo sauce with chicken.

Original price was $14.25

Discounted price is $13.54

Chicken Alla Vodka Pizza

With chicken.

Original price was $14.25

Discounted price is $13.54

Sunday Pizza

Sauce & mozzarella with sausage, meatballs, pepperoni & pecorino.

Original price was $14.25

Discounted price is $13.54

Best seller

Cheese Pizza

Classic cheese or create your own pizza. Thin and crispy crust, zesty sauce & aged grande mozzarella.

Original price was $9.85

Discounted price is $9.36

sicilian-pizza-square

Sicilian Pizza (Square)

Sicilian Pizza

Deep-dish pan pizza with cooked tomato sauce & aged mozzarella.

Original price was $14.25

Discounted price is $13.54

Gramma Pizza

Thin crust pan pizza crushed tomatoes, basil, homemade mozzarella & olive oil.

Original price was $16.45

Discounted price is $15.63

appetizers

Appetizers

Antipasto.

Homemade Meatballs

With tomato sauce, pecorino & basil.

Original price was $6.05

Discounted price is $5.75

Fried Calamari

Your choice of garlic-basil aioli or marinara.

Original price was $13.15

Discounted price is $12.49

Boneless Wings

Original price was $8.75

Discounted price is $8.31

Plain Garlic Bread

Original price was $4.40

Discounted price is $4.18

Eggplant Appetizer

Homemade eggplant cutlets, tomato sauce, parmigiano reggiano & fresh basil.

Original price was $10.95

Discounted price is $10.40

Chicken Fingers

Served with a side of honey mustard or BBQ sauce.

Original price was $9.85

Discounted price is $9.36

Mozzarella Caprese

Fresh, homemade mozzarella, olive oil, sea salt, fresh basil, tomatoes & balsamic reduction.

Original price was $9.85

Discounted price is $9.36

House Special Pepperoni Garlic Bread

Topped with mozzarella, pecorino, parmigiano & pepperoni.

Original price was $7.15

Discounted price is $6.79

Mozzarella Sticks

Deep-fried cheese sticks. Crispy on the outside, gooey on the inside.

Original price was $9.85

Discounted price is $9.36

Broccoli Rabe

Sauteed garlic, olive oil, a touch of pepperoncini (hot chili flakes).

Original price was $12.05

Discounted price is $11.45

Antipasto

A neighborhood selection of dry-cured meats, pickled vegetables & our own homemade mozzarella.

Original price was $13.15

Discounted price is $12.49

Sweet Fennel Sausage

Original price was $6.55

Discounted price is $6.22

Best seller

Buffalo Wings

Original price was $8.75

Discounted price is $8.31

French Fries

Our delicious French fries are deep-fried 'till golden brown, with a crunchy exterior and a light fluffy interior. Seasoned to perfection!

Original price was $5.45

Discounted price is $5.18

Best seller

Garlic Knots

With marinara.

Original price was $3.85

Discounted price is $3.66

Grandma's Meatballs

Homemade tomato sauce, fresh ricotta, pecorino & basil.

Original price was $9.85

Discounted price is $9.36

Rice Balls

With marinara.

Original price was $9.85

Discounted price is $9.36

salads

Salads

Best seller

Pear Salad

With organic mesclun, cranberries, candied walnuts, gorgonzola & balsamic vinaigrette.

Original price was $10.95

Discounted price is $10.40

House Salad

Romaine, tomatoes, house-pickled red onions, kalamata olives & house vinaigrette.

Original price was $8.25

Discounted price is $7.84

Mango Avocado Salad

Romaine, cucumbers, tomatoes & fresh mozzarella.

Original price was $10.95

Discounted price is $10.40

Caesar Salad

Caesar dressing, garlic croutons & pecorino.

Original price was $8.75

Discounted price is $8.31

Arthur Ave. Special Salad

Mixed Italian salad, salami, pepperoni, provolone, romaine lettuce, chickpeas, pepperoncini, kalamata olives, pickled red onions, tomatoes & red wine vinaigrette.

Original price was $12.05

Discounted price is $11.45

Tomato Avocado Salad

Romaine, cucumbers & fresh mozzarella.

Original price was $10.95

Discounted price is $10.40

Chef Salad

Romaine, turkey, ham, provolone, tomatoes, house-pickled red onions, kalamata olives & house vinaigrette.

Original price was $12.05

Discounted price is $11.45

calzones

Calzones

Served with tomato sauce.

Chicken Calzone

Original price was $12.05

Discounted price is $11.45

Pepperoni Calzone

Original price was $12.05

Discounted price is $11.45

Prosciutto Calzone

Original price was $14.25

Discounted price is $13.54

Ricotta & Homemade Mozzarella Calzone

Original price was $10.95

Discounted price is $10.40

Ham Calzone

Original price was $12.05

Discounted price is $11.45

Broccoli Rabe Calzone

Original price was $14.25

Discounted price is $13.54

strombolis

Strombolis

Served with tomato sauce.

Bronx Bomber Stromboli

Ham, salami, pepperoni, aged mozzarella, peppers & onions.

Original price was $10.95

Discounted price is $10.40

Buffalo Chicken Stromboli

Original price was $10.95

Discounted price is $10.40

Veggie Deluxe Stromboli

Peppers, onions, mushrooms & eggplant.

Original price was $10.95

Discounted price is $10.40

Pepperoni Stromboli

Original price was $10.95

Discounted price is $10.40

Meat Lover Stromboli

Sausage, pepperoni & bacon.

Original price was $10.95

Discounted price is $10.40

Bronx Eggplant Stromboli

Sliced tomatoes, eggplant, ricotta & mozzarella.

Original price was $12.05

Discounted price is $11.45

BBQ Stromboli

Original price was $10.95

Discounted price is $10.40

The Godfather Stromboli

Green peppers, onions, mushrooms, sausage & pepperoni.

Original price was $12.05

Discounted price is $11.45

Old Mexico Stromboli

Ground beef, jalapenos & cheddar.

Original price was $12.05

Discounted price is $11.45

hero-sandwiches

Hero Sandwiches

Featuring our own homemade mozzarella & Italian sourdough bread. The recipe made especially for us by DeFillippis.

Balsamic Fresh Mozzarella Hero

Soft, fresh, homemade mozzarella, roasted red peppers, balsamic vinaigrette & fresh basil.

Original price was $13.15

Discounted price is $12.49

Sausage Parmigiana Hero

Topped with sausage and parmesan cheese.

Original price was $10.95

Discounted price is $10.40

Chicken Parmigiana Hero

Boneless breast of chicken with marinara sauce, parmesan & melted mozzarella.

Original price was $10.95

Discounted price is $10.40

Sausage, Peppers & Onions Hero

With tomato sauce.

Original price was $10.95

Discounted price is $10.40

Cheeseburger & Fries Hero

Original price was $10.95

Discounted price is $10.40

Balsamic Eggplant Special Hero

Fried eggplant, roasted peppers, fresh mozzarella & balsamic vinaigrette with fresh basil.

Original price was $13.15

Discounted price is $12.49

Philly Cheese Steak Hero

Steak and cheese.

Original price was $10.45

Discounted price is $9.93

Philly Cheese Steak Works Hero

Original price was $12.65

Discounted price is $12.02

Meatball Parmigiana Hero

With marinara sauce, meatballs and parmesan cheese.

Original price was $10.95

Discounted price is $10.40

Shrimp Parmigiana Hero

With shrimp and parmesan cheese.

Original price was $13.15

Discounted price is $12.49

Italian Combo Hero

Ham, salami, provolone, lettuce, tomatoes, onions & house dressing.

Original price was $10.95

Discounted price is $10.40

Veal Parmigiana Hero

Veal cutlets, tomato sauce, and parmesan cheese.

Original price was $13.15

Discounted price is $12.49

Broccoli Rabe & Sausage Hero

With tomato sauce & pecorino.

Original price was $13.15

Discounted price is $12.49

Eggplant Parmigiana Hero

Topped with eggplant slices, parmesan cheese, and marinara sauce.

Original price was $10.95

Discounted price is $10.40

Pollo Prosciutto Hero

Grilled chicken, prosciutto, fresh mozzarella & marinated red peppers with fresh basil.

Original price was $14.25

Discounted price is $13.54

Tuscan Fried Chicken Cutlet Hero

With lettuce, tomatoes & garlic-basil aioli.

Original price was $10.95

Discounted price is $10.40

wraps

Wraps

Served with french fries or side salad.

Turkey Wrap

Bacon, cheddar, red onions, apple, lettuce, tomatoes & Russian dressing.

Original price was $10.95

Discounted price is $10.40

Fajita Wrap

Chicken, onions, peppers & swiss.

Original price was $10.95

Discounted price is $10.40

Grilled Chicken Caesar Wrap

Romaine, caesar dressing & pecorino.

Original price was $10.95

Discounted price is $10.40

Steak Wrap

Peppers, onions & cheese.

Original price was $10.95

Discounted price is $10.40

Buffalo Chicken Wrap

Lettuce, tomatoes & ranch dressing.

Original price was $10.95

Discounted price is $10.40

arthur-ave-pasta-shop

Arthur Ave. Pasta Shop

Individual dinners come with choice of soup or salad & bread.

Homemade Lasagna

Stacked layers of pasta packed with meat and cheese, covered in red sauce. Pro tip: Go for the crispy edge pieces.

Original price was $14.25

Discounted price is $13.54

Penne with Broccoli Rabe & Sausage

Original price was $18.65

Discounted price is $17.72

Spaghetti with Garlic & Oil

Garlic, olive oil & pecorino.

Original price was $14.25

Discounted price is $13.54

Cheese Ravioli

From Terranova bakery in the Bronx! Tomato sauce & pecorino.

Original price was $14.25

Discounted price is $13.54

Spaghetti with Tomato Basil Sauce

Homemade tomato sauce & pecorino.

Original price was $10.95

Discounted price is $10.40

Baked Ziti

Baked with tomato sauce, ricotta & homemade mozzarella.

Original price was $13.15

Discounted price is $12.49

Penne Alfredo

Parmesan cream sauce.

Original price was $14.85

Discounted price is $14.11

Penne Portobello

Sauteed portobello mushrooms, marsala-parmesan cream sauce & imported white truffle oil.

Original price was $18.65

Discounted price is $17.72

Baked Manicotti

Homemade ricotta-filled crepes baked with tomato sauce, pecorino & mozzarella.

Original price was $14.25

Discounted price is $13.54

Penne Alla Vodka

Shallots, prosciutto, tomatoes, basil & cream.

Original price was $14.85

Discounted price is $14.11

arthur-ave-pasta-shop-a-la-carte

Arthur Ave. Pasta Shop A La Carte

Cheese Ravioli A La Carte

From Terranova bakery in the Bronx! Tomato sauce & pecorino.

Original price was $36.25

Discounted price is $34.44

Penne with Broccoli Rabe & Sausage A La Carte

With broccoli rabe & sausage.

Original price was $40.65

Discounted price is $38.62

Homemade Lasagna A La Carte

Stacked layers of pasta packed with meat and cheese, covered in red sauce. Pro tip: Go for the crispy edge pieces.

Original price was $38.45

Discounted price is $36.53

Penne Alla Vodka A La Carte

Shallots, prosciutto, tomatoes, basil & cream.

Original price was $36.25

Discounted price is $34.44

Spaghetti with Tomato Basil Sauce A La Carte

Homemade tomato sauce & pecorino.

Original price was $21.95

Discounted price is $20.85

Penne Portobello A La Carte

Sauteed portobello mushrooms, marsala-parmesan cream sauce & imported white truffle oil.

Original price was $40.65

Discounted price is $38.62

Baked Manicotti A La Carte

Homemade ricotta-filled crepes baked with tomato sauce, pecorino & mozzarella.

Original price was $36.25

Discounted price is $34.44

Baked Ziti A La Carte

Baked with tomato sauce, ricotta & homemade mozzarella.

Original price was $36.25

Discounted price is $34.44

Penne Alfredo A La Carte

Parmesan cream sauce.

Original price was $36.25

Discounted price is $34.44

Spaghetti with Garlic & Oil A La Carte

Garlic, olive oil & pecorino.

Original price was $25.25

Discounted price is $23.99

little-italy-entrees

Little Italy Entrees

Individual dinners come with a choice of soup or salad & bread.

Eggplant Parmigiana

Tomato sauce & homemade mozzarella with spaghetti.

Original price was $18.65

Discounted price is $17.72

Chicken Parmigiana

Tomato sauce & homemade mozzarella with spaghetti.

Original price was $18.65

Discounted price is $17.72

Veal Parmigiana

Tomato sauce & homemade mozzarella with spaghetti.

Original price was $20.85

Discounted price is $19.81

Eggplant Rollatini

Filled with ricotta & homemade mozzarella. Served with spaghetti tomato basil sauce.

Original price was $19.75

Discounted price is $18.76

Chicken Marsala

With mushrooms & marsala wine sauce over spaghetti.

Original price was $18.65

Discounted price is $17.72

Chicken Scarpariello

Sauteed chicken, sausage, hot vinegar peppers, Italian herbs & pan sauce over spaghetti.

Original price was $19.75

Discounted price is $18.76

Shrimp Scampi

With lemon garlic sauce.

Original price was $20.85

Discounted price is $19.81

Chicken Francese

Herb butter & lemon sauce over spaghetti.

Original price was $18.65

Discounted price is $17.72

little-italy-entrees-a-la-carte

Little Italy Entrees A La Carte

Chicken Francese A La Carte

Herb butter & lemon sauce.

Original price was $41.75

Discounted price is $39.66

Veal Parmigiana A La Carte

Tomato sauce & homemade mozzarella.

Original price was $47.25

Discounted price is $44.89

Eggplant Parmigiana A La Carte

Tomato sauce & homemade mozzarella.

Original price was $41.75

Discounted price is $39.66

Chicken Marsala A La Carte

With mushrooms & marsala wine sauce.

Original price was $41.75

Discounted price is $39.66

Chicken Scarpariello A La Carte

Sauteed chicken, sausage, hot vinegar peppers, Italian herbs & pan sauce.

Original price was $43.95

Discounted price is $41.75

Eggplant Rollatini A La Carte

Filled with ricotta & homemade mozzarella. Served tomato basil sauce.

Original price was $43.95

Discounted price is $41.75

Chicken Parmigiana A La Carte

Tomato sauce & homemade mozzarella.

Original price was $41.75

Discounted price is $39.66

Shrimp Scampi A La Carte

With lemon garlic sauce.

Original price was $47.25

Discounted price is $44.89

kids-menu

Kids Menu

Kid's Penne with Butter & Cheese

Original price was $8.75

Discounted price is $8.31

Kid's Chicken Fingers & Fries

Original price was $8.75

Discounted price is $8.31

Kid's Spaghetti with One Meatball

Original price was $8.75

Discounted price is $8.31

Kid's Ravioli with Sauce

Original price was $8.75

Discounted price is $8.31

desserts

Desserts

Zeppole with Cannoli Cream

Original price was $8.75

Discounted price is $8.31

Zeppole with Nutella

Original price was $8.75

Discounted price is $8.31

Ricotta Cheesecake

Original price was $4.95

Discounted price is $4.70

Chocolate Mousse Cake

Original price was $4.95

Discounted price is $4.70

Cannoli

Original price was $4.35

Discounted price is $4.13

Zeppole with Powdered Sugar

Original price was $6.55

Discounted price is $6.22

beverages

Beverages

Pure Leaf

Original price was $2.50

Discounted price is $2.38

Juice

Original price was $2.50

Discounted price is $2.38

Brisk Iced Tea

Original price was $3.60

Discounted price is $3.42

Seltzer Water

Original price was $2.50

Discounted price is $2.38

Best seller

Soda

Original price was $2.50

Discounted price is $2.38

lunch-specials

Lunch Specials

Only available 11:30 AM - 3:30 PM

Baked Manicotti Lunch

Homemade ricotta-filled crepes baked with tomato sauce, pecorino & mozzarella. Served from 11:30 am till 3:30 pm.

Original price was $10.95

Discounted price is $10.40

Wrap & French Fries Lunch

Served from 11:30 am till 3:30 pm.

Original price was $10.95

Discounted price is $10.40

Penne with Broccoli Rabe & Sausage Lunch

Served from 11:30 am till 3:30 pm.

Original price was $10.95

Discounted price is $10.40

Penne Alla Vodka Lunch

Shallots, prosciutto, tomatoes, basil & cream. Served from 11:30 am till 3:30 pm.

Original price was $10.95

Discounted price is $10.40

Spaghetti with Tomato Basil Sauce Lunch

Homemade tomato sauce & pecorino. Served from 11:30 am till 3:30 pm.

Original price was $10.95

Discounted price is $10.40

Penne Portobello Lunch

Sauteed portobello mushrooms, marsala-parmesan cream sauce & imported white truffle oil. Served from 11:30 am till 3:30 pm.

Original price was $10.95

Discounted price is $10.40

Baked Ziti Lunch

Baked with tomato sauce, ricotta & homemade mozzarella. Served from 11:30 am till 3:30 pm.

Original price was $10.95

Discounted price is $10.40

Spaghetti with Garlic & Oil Lunch

Garlic, olive oil & pecorino. Served from 11:30 am till 3:30 pm.

Original price was $10.95

Discounted price is $10.40

Cheese Ravioli Lunch

From Terranova bakery in the Bronx! Tomato sauce & pecorino. Served from 11:30 am till 3:30 pm.

Original price was $10.95

Discounted price is $10.40

Penne Alfredo Lunch

Parmesan cream sauce. Served from 11:30 am till 3:30 pm.

Original price was $10.95

Discounted price is $10.40

John's of Arthur Ave Restaurant - View Menu & Order Online - 19 W Main St, Middletown, NY 10940 - Slice

Price: $$