Skip to main content
John's of Arthur Ave Restaurant

John's of Arthur Ave Restaurant

19 W Main St, Middletown, NY 10940
845-467-4712

Order Ahead We open at 10:00 AM

Full Hours
  • 5% off online orders
Skip to first category
arthur-ave-style-pizza

Arthur Ave. Style Pizza

Thin & crispy crust, zesty sauce & aged grande mozzarella. Our mozzarella is made fresh daily.

Featured

White Pizza

Fresh ricotta, grande mozzarella, pecorino romano & parmigiano reggiano.

$14.25

White Pizza

Featured

House Special Eggplant Pizza

Cheese & tomato pie topped with fried eggplant, fresh ricotta, pecorino, Parmigiano & basil.

$14.25

House Special Eggplant Pizza

Featured

BBQ Chicken Pizza

Topped with BBQ sauce, mozzarella, and chicken meat.

$14.25

BBQ Chicken Pizza

Featured

Buffalo Chicken Pizza

Buffalo chicken and mozzarella cheese.

$14.25

Buffalo Chicken Pizza

Featured

Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza

Mozzarella cheese, bacon, chicken, and yummy ranch dressing.

$14.25

Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza

Cheese Pizza

Classic cheese or create your own pizza. Thin and crispy crust, zesty sauce & aged grande mozzarella.

$9.85

Cheese Pizza

Chicken Alfredo Pizza

Topped in our homemade creamy alfredo sauce with chicken.

$14.25

Sausage, Pepper & Onions Dinner Pizza

Pizza sauce, mozzarella, sweet fennel sausage, grilled peppers & onions.

$14.25

Sunday Pizza

Sauce & mozzarella with sausage, meatballs, pepperoni & pecorino.

$14.25

Broccoli Rabe & Sausage Pizza

Crushed tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, sweet fennel sausage, garlic & broccoli rabe.

$14.25

Pizza Margherita

Crushed tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, basil & olive oil.

$14.25

Pizza Margherita

Chicken Alla Vodka Pizza

With chicken.

$14.25

Chicken Alla Vodka Pizza
sicilian-pizza-square

Sicilian Pizza (Square)

Sicilian Pizza

Deep-dish pan pizza with cooked tomato sauce & aged mozzarella.

$14.25

Gramma Pizza

Thin crust pan pizza crushed tomatoes, basil, homemade mozzarella & olive oil.

$16.45

appetizers

Appetizers

Antipasto.

Antipasto

A neighborhood selection of dry-cured meats, pickled vegetables & our own homemade mozzarella.

$13.15

Antipasto

Rice Balls

With marinara.

$9.85

Mozzarella Sticks

Deep-fried cheese sticks. Crispy on the outside, gooey on the inside.

$9.85

Mozzarella Sticks

House Special Pepperoni Garlic Bread

Topped with mozzarella, pecorino, parmigiano & pepperoni.

$7.15

Mozzarella Caprese

Fresh, homemade mozzarella, olive oil, sea salt, fresh basil, tomatoes & balsamic reduction.

$9.85

Fried Calamari

Your choice of garlic-basil aioli or marinara.

$13.15

French Fries

Our delicious French fries are deep-fried 'till golden brown, with a crunchy exterior and a light fluffy interior. Seasoned to perfection!

$5.45

French Fries

Eggplant Appetizer

Homemade eggplant cutlets, tomato sauce, parmigiano reggiano & fresh basil.

$10.95

Buffalo Wings

$8.75

Broccoli Rabe

Sauteed garlic, olive oil, a touch of pepperoncini (hot chili flakes).

$12.05

Boneless Wings

$8.75

Sweet Fennel Sausage

$6.55

Chicken Fingers

Served with a side of honey mustard or BBQ sauce.

$9.85

Homemade Meatballs

With tomato sauce, pecorino & basil.

$6.05

Garlic Knots

With marinara.

$3.85

Garlic Knots

Grandma's Meatballs

Homemade tomato sauce, fresh ricotta, pecorino & basil.

$9.85

Grandma's Meatballs

Plain Garlic Bread

$4.40

salads

Salads

Featured

Pear Salad

With organic mesclun, cranberries, candied walnuts, gorgonzola & balsamic vinaigrette.

$10.95

Pear Salad

Arthur Ave. Special Salad

Mixed Italian salad, salami, pepperoni, provolone, romaine lettuce, chickpeas, pepperoncini, kalamata olives, pickled red onions, tomatoes & red wine vinaigrette.

$12.05

Caesar Salad

Caesar dressing, garlic croutons & pecorino.

$8.75

Caesar Salad

Tomato Avocado Salad

Romaine, cucumbers & fresh mozzarella.

$10.95

Tomato Avocado Salad

Mango Avocado Salad

Romaine, cucumbers, tomatoes & fresh mozzarella.

$10.95

Mango Avocado Salad

Chef Salad

Romaine, turkey, ham, provolone, tomatoes, house-pickled red onions, kalamata olives & house vinaigrette.

$12.05

Chef Salad

House Salad

Romaine, tomatoes, house-pickled red onions, kalamata olives & house vinaigrette.

$8.25

calzones

Calzones

Served with tomato sauce.

Ricotta & Homemade Mozzarella Calzone

$10.95

Chicken Calzone

$12.05

Ham Calzone

$12.05

Ham Calzone

Broccoli Rabe Calzone

$14.25

Pepperoni Calzone

$12.05

Prosciutto Calzone

$14.25

strombolis

Strombolis

Served with tomato sauce.

BBQ Stromboli

$10.95

Veggie Deluxe Stromboli

Peppers, onions, mushrooms & eggplant.

$10.95

Buffalo Chicken Stromboli

$10.95

Old Mexico Stromboli

Ground beef, jalapenos & cheddar.

$12.05

Pepperoni Stromboli

$10.95

Bronx Eggplant Stromboli

Sliced tomatoes, eggplant, ricotta & mozzarella.

$12.05

Meat Lover Stromboli

Sausage, pepperoni & bacon.

$10.95

Bronx Bomber Stromboli

Ham, salami, pepperoni, aged mozzarella, peppers & onions.

$10.95

Bronx Bomber Stromboli

The Godfather Stromboli

Green peppers, onions, mushrooms, sausage & pepperoni.

$12.05

hero-sandwiches

Hero Sandwiches

Featuring our own homemade mozzarella & Italian sourdough bread. The recipe made especially for us by DeFillippis.

Featured

Balsamic Fresh Mozzarella Hero

Soft, fresh, homemade mozzarella, roasted red peppers, balsamic vinaigrette & fresh basil.

$13.15

Balsamic Fresh Mozzarella Hero

Italian Combo Hero

Ham, salami, provolone, lettuce, tomatoes, onions & house dressing.

$10.95

Meatball Parmigiana Hero

With marinara sauce, meatballs and parmesan cheese.

$10.95

Pollo Prosciutto Hero

Grilled chicken, prosciutto, fresh mozzarella & marinated red peppers with fresh basil.

$14.25

Sausage Parmigiana Hero

Topped with sausage and parmesan cheese.

$10.95

Cheeseburger & Fries Hero

$10.95

Eggplant Parmigiana Hero

Topped with eggplant slices, parmesan cheese, and marinara sauce.

$10.95

Balsamic Eggplant Special Hero

Fried eggplant, roasted peppers, fresh mozzarella & balsamic vinaigrette with fresh basil.

$13.15

Tuscan Fried Chicken Cutlet Hero

With lettuce, tomatoes & garlic-basil aioli.

$10.95

Philly Cheese Steak Hero

Steak and cheese.

$10.45

Sausage, Peppers & Onions Hero

With tomato sauce.

$10.95

Philly Cheese Steak Works Hero

$12.65

Broccoli Rabe & Sausage Hero

With tomato sauce & pecorino.

$13.15

Shrimp Parmigiana Hero

With shrimp and parmesan cheese.

$13.15

Chicken Parmigiana Hero

Boneless breast of chicken with marinara sauce, parmesan & melted mozzarella.

$10.95

Veal Parmigiana Hero

Veal cutlets, tomato sauce, and parmesan cheese.

$13.15

wraps

Wraps

Served with french fries or side salad.

Buffalo Chicken Wrap

Lettuce, tomatoes & ranch dressing.

$10.95

Turkey Wrap

Bacon, cheddar, red onions, apple, lettuce, tomatoes & Russian dressing.

$10.95

Fajita Wrap

Chicken, onions, peppers & swiss.

$10.95

Grilled Chicken Caesar Wrap

Romaine, caesar dressing & pecorino.

$10.95

Steak Wrap

Peppers, onions & cheese.

$10.95

arthur-ave-pasta-shop

Arthur Ave. Pasta Shop

Individual dinners come with choice of soup or salad & bread.

Featured

Homemade Lasagna

Stacked layers of pasta packed with meat and cheese, covered in red sauce. Pro tip: Go for the crispy edge pieces.

$14.25

Homemade Lasagna

Baked Manicotti

Homemade ricotta-filled crepes baked with tomato sauce, pecorino & mozzarella.

$14.25

Penne Alla Vodka

Shallots, prosciutto, tomatoes, basil & cream.

$14.85

Spaghetti with Garlic & Oil

Garlic, olive oil & pecorino.

$14.25

Cheese Ravioli

From Terranova bakery in the Bronx! Tomato sauce & pecorino.

$14.25

Spaghetti with Tomato Basil Sauce

Homemade tomato sauce & pecorino.

$10.95

Baked Ziti

Baked with tomato sauce, ricotta & homemade mozzarella.

$13.15

Penne with Broccoli Rabe & Sausage

$18.65

Penne Alfredo

Parmesan cream sauce.

$14.85

Penne Portobello

Sauteed portobello mushrooms, marsala-parmesan cream sauce & imported white truffle oil.

$18.65

arthur-ave-pasta-shop-a-la-carte

Arthur Ave. Pasta Shop A La Carte

Baked Manicotti A La Carte

Homemade ricotta-filled crepes baked with tomato sauce, pecorino & mozzarella.

$36.25

Homemade Lasagna A La Carte

Stacked layers of pasta packed with meat and cheese, covered in red sauce. Pro tip: Go for the crispy edge pieces.

$38.45

Penne Alla Vodka A La Carte

Shallots, prosciutto, tomatoes, basil & cream.

$36.25

Spaghetti with Garlic & Oil A La Carte

Garlic, olive oil & pecorino.

$25.25

Cheese Ravioli A La Carte

From Terranova bakery in the Bronx! Tomato sauce & pecorino.

$36.25

Spaghetti with Tomato Basil Sauce A La Carte

Homemade tomato sauce & pecorino.

$21.95

Baked Ziti A La Carte

Baked with tomato sauce, ricotta & homemade mozzarella.

$36.25

Penne with Broccoli Rabe & Sausage A La Carte

With broccoli rabe & sausage.

$40.65

Penne Alfredo A La Carte

Parmesan cream sauce.

$36.25

Penne Portobello A La Carte

Sauteed portobello mushrooms, marsala-parmesan cream sauce & imported white truffle oil.

$40.65

little-italy-entrees

Little Italy Entrees

Individual dinners come with a choice of soup or salad & bread.

Featured

Chicken Parmigiana

Tomato sauce & homemade mozzarella with spaghetti.

$18.65

Chicken Parmigiana

Featured

Eggplant Parmigiana

Tomato sauce & homemade mozzarella with spaghetti.

$18.65

Eggplant Parmigiana

Chicken Scarpariello

Sauteed chicken, sausage, hot vinegar peppers, Italian herbs & pan sauce over spaghetti.

$19.75

Chicken Francese

Herb butter & lemon sauce over spaghetti.

$18.65

Chicken Marsala

With mushrooms & marsala wine sauce over spaghetti.

$18.65

Eggplant Rollatini

Filled with ricotta & homemade mozzarella. Served with spaghetti tomato basil sauce.

$19.75

Veal Parmigiana

Tomato sauce & homemade mozzarella with spaghetti.

$20.85

Shrimp Scampi

With lemon garlic sauce.

$20.85

little-italy-entrees-a-la-carte

Little Italy Entrees A La Carte

Chicken Scarpariello A La Carte

Sauteed chicken, sausage, hot vinegar peppers, Italian herbs & pan sauce.

$43.95

Chicken Francese A La Carte

Herb butter & lemon sauce.

$41.75

Chicken Parmigiana A La Carte

Tomato sauce & homemade mozzarella.

$41.75

Chicken Marsala A La Carte

With mushrooms & marsala wine sauce.

$41.75

Eggplant Parmigiana A La Carte

Tomato sauce & homemade mozzarella.

$41.75

Eggplant Rollatini A La Carte

Filled with ricotta & homemade mozzarella. Served tomato basil sauce.

$43.95

Veal Parmigiana A La Carte

Tomato sauce & homemade mozzarella.

$47.25

Shrimp Scampi A La Carte

With lemon garlic sauce.

$47.25

kids-menu

Kids Menu

Kid's Penne with Butter & Cheese

$8.75

Kid's Chicken Fingers & Fries

$8.75

Kid's Spaghetti with One Meatball

$8.75

Kid's Ravioli with Sauce

$8.75

desserts

Desserts

Cannoli

$4.35

Cannoli

Zeppole with Powdered Sugar

$6.55

Ricotta Cheesecake

$4.95

Zeppole with Cannoli Cream

$8.75

Chocolate Mousse Cake

$4.95

Zeppole with Nutella

$8.75

beverages

Beverages

Soda

$2.50

Seltzer Water

$2.50

Pure Leaf

$2.50

Brisk Iced Tea

$3.60

Juice

$2.50

lunch-specials

Lunch Specials

Only available 11:30 AM - 3:30 PM

Baked Manicotti Lunch

Homemade ricotta-filled crepes baked with tomato sauce, pecorino & mozzarella. Served from 11:30 am till 3:30 pm.

$10.95

Spaghetti with Garlic & Oil Lunch

Garlic, olive oil & pecorino. Served from 11:30 am till 3:30 pm.

$10.95

Penne Alla Vodka Lunch

Shallots, prosciutto, tomatoes, basil & cream. Served from 11:30 am till 3:30 pm.

$10.95

Spaghetti with Tomato Basil Sauce Lunch

Homemade tomato sauce & pecorino. Served from 11:30 am till 3:30 pm.

$10.95

Cheese Ravioli Lunch

From Terranova bakery in the Bronx! Tomato sauce & pecorino. Served from 11:30 am till 3:30 pm.

$10.95

Penne with Broccoli Rabe & Sausage Lunch

Served from 11:30 am till 3:30 pm.

$10.95

Baked Ziti Lunch

Baked with tomato sauce, ricotta & homemade mozzarella. Served from 11:30 am till 3:30 pm.

$10.95

Penne Portobello Lunch

Sauteed portobello mushrooms, marsala-parmesan cream sauce & imported white truffle oil. Served from 11:30 am till 3:30 pm.

$10.95

Penne Alfredo Lunch

Parmesan cream sauce. Served from 11:30 am till 3:30 pm.

$10.95

Wrap & French Fries Lunch

Served from 11:30 am till 3:30 pm.

$10.95

John's of Arthur Ave Restaurant - View Menu & Order Online - 19 W Main St, Middletown, NY 10940 - Slice

SliceNYMiddletown10940 John's of Arthur Ave Restaurant
Price: $$