Skip to main content
Geno Nottolini's Pizza

Geno Nottolini's Pizza

1235 Indiana Ave, Sheboygan, WI 53081
920-547-2805

Open until Sun at 12:45 AM

Full Hours
    specialty-pizza
    Specialty Pizza
    Made on Thin crust - Traditional thin crust old faithful. You can't go wrong with this light, flaky, golden-brown crust, or New York Style - A thin crust pizza with large bready, chewy outer crust.

    Basic Cheese Pizza

    Classic cheese or create your own pizza.

    $9.75


    Italian Delight Pizza

    No red sauce, olive oil, fresh garlic, fresh basil, grilled chicken, lightly seasoned with mozzarella cheese.

    $11.95


    Pizza Bianca

    Our famous Alfredo sauce, made with spinach & grilled chicken.

    $12.95


    Gyro Pizza

    Gyro meat, onion, tomato & cucumber sauce.

    $12.95


    Hawaiian Pizza

    Includes pineapple, Canadian bacon, shrimp with BBQ sauce.

    $12.95


    Mexican Pizza

    Includes hamburger, tomatoes, lettuce, cheddar cheese & sour cream.

    $12.95


    Spinach Classic Pizza

    Fresh spinach, tomatoes & garlic.

    $11.95


    Heavyweight Pizza

    Extra sausage, extra mushrooms, extra cheese.

    $13.95


    B.L.T. Pizza

    Bacon, lettuce, tomatoes with mayo.

    $11.95


    Meat Wagon Pizza

    Includes cheese, sausage, pepperoni, Canadian bacon with a special mixed sauce.

    $12.95


    Margarita Pizza

    Pizza sauce, tomatoes, fresh garlic, fresh basil, mozzarella cheese & shot of olive oil.

    $11.95


    Vegetarian Pizza

    Includes cheese, spinach, green peppers, mushrooms, zucchini, onions & black olives.

    $11.95


    Nottolini's Ultimate Pizza

    Includes cheese, sausage, green peppers, mushrooms, pepperoni, onions & black olives.

    $13.95


    Henry Hog Pizza

    Includes cheese, sausage, pepperoni, Canadian bacon, ground beef, bacon, green peppers, onions, mushrooms, black olives & tomatoes.

    $13.50

    deep-dish-pan-pizza
    Deep Dish Pan Pizza
    The critics' choice. Known worldwide as Chicago style. Our dough is made fresh every day! Our ingredients are sliced & prepared fresh daily & never frozen!

    Deep Dish Pan Cheese Pizza

    Stuffed, round-shaped pizza, with classic cheese.

    $9.95


    Deep Dish Pan Meat Wagon Pizza

    Includes cheese, sausage, pepperoni, Canadian bacon, with a special mixed sauce.

    $10.95


    Deep Dish Pan Nottolini's Ultimate Pizza

    Includes cheese, sausage, green peppers, mushrooms, pepperoni, onions, & black olives.

    $11.95


    Deep Dish Pan Veggie Pizza

    Includes cheese, spinach, green peppers, mushrooms, zucchini, onions, & black olives.

    $11.95


    Deep Dish Pan Margarita Pizza

    Pizza sauce, tomatoes, fresh garlic, fresh basil, mozzarella cheese, & a shot of olive oil.

    $10.95


    Deep Dish Pan Henry Hog Pizza

    Includes cheese, sausage, pepperoni, Canadian bacon, ground beef, bacon, green peppers, onions, mushrooms, black olives, & tomatoes.

    $12.95

    thick-crust-pizza
    Thick Crust Pizza
    A truly original creation. A unique pizza with a slightly thick crust & rolled edge.

    Thick Crust Basic Cheese Pizza

    Classic square, thick crust pizza with mozzarella, & tomato sauce.

    $9.75


    Thick Crust Meat Wagon Pizza

    Includes cheese, sausage, pepperoni, Canadian bacon, with a special mixed sauce.

    $10.45


    Thick Crust Nottolini's Ultimate Pizza

    Includes cheese, sausage, green peppers, mushrooms, pepperoni, onions, & black olives.

    $10.95


    Thick Crust Veggie Pizza

    Includes cheese, spinach, green peppers, mushrooms, zucchini, onions, & black olives.

    $10.95


    Thick Crust Margarita Pizza

    Pizza sauce, tomatoes, fresh garlic, fresh basil, mozzarella cheese, & a shot of olive oil.

    $10.45


    Thick Crust Henry Hog Pizza

    Includes cheese, sausage, pepperoni, Canadian bacon, ground beef, bacon, green peppers, onions, mushrooms, black olives & tomatoes.

    $13.00

    stuffed-crust-pizza
    Stuffed Crust Pizza

    Stuffed Crust Basic Cheese Pizza

    Stuffed pizza with mozzarella cheese.

    $19.70


    Stuffed Crust Meat Wagon Pizza

    Includes cheese, sausage, pepperoni, Canadian bacon with a special mixed sauce.

    $22.80


    Stuffed Crust Nottolini's Ultimate Pizza

    Includes cheese, sausage, green peppers, mushrooms, pepperoni, onions & black olives.

    $24.40


    Stuffed Crust Veggie Pizza

    Includes cheese, spinach, green peppers, mushrooms, zucchini, onions & black olives.

    $24.40


    Stuffed Crust Margarita Pizza

    Pizza sauce, tomatoes, fresh garlic, fresh basil, mozzarella cheese & shot of olive oil.

    $22.80


    Stuffed Crust Henry Hog Pizza

    Includes cheese, sausage, pepperoni, Canadian bacon, ground beef, bacon, green peppers, onions, mushrooms, black olives & tomatoes.

    $26.50

    chicago-style-pizza
    Chicago Style Pizza
    This is the pie that made Chicago famous. With buttery crust, lots of cheese & topped with a sauce full of chunky tomatoes it's a totally gourmet pizza "made in a pan"

    Chicago Style Basic Cheese Pizza

    Cooked in an olive oil-coated pan & topped with classic cheese.

    $16.70


    Chicago Style Meat Wagon Pizza

    Includes cheese, sausage, pepperoni, Canadian bacon with a special mixed sauce.

    $19.80


    Chicago Style Nottolini's Ultimate Pizza

    Includes cheese, sausage, green peppers, mushrooms, pepperoni, onions & black olives.

    $21.40


    Chicago Style Veggie Pizza

    Includes cheese, spinach, green peppers, mushrooms, zucchini, onions & black olives.

    $21.40


    Chicago Style Margarita Pizza

    Pizza sauce, tomatoes, fresh garlic, fresh basil, mozzarella cheese & shot of olive oil.

    $19.80


    Chicago Style Henry Hog Pizza

    Includes cheese, sausage, pepperoni, Canadian bacon, ground beef, bacon, green peppers, onions, mushrooms, black olives & tomatoes.

    $23.50

    appetizers
    Appetizers

    Guacamole con Chips

    $5.95


    Pico de Gallo con Chips

    $3.95


    Mexican Nachos

    Prepared with grilled steak, beans, fresh cheese, sour cream & a side of green salsa.

    $8.25


    Regular nachos

    Prepared with nacho cheese, tomato & jalapenos.

    $5.25


    Nachos Rancheros

    Prepared with beans, jalapenos, fresh cheese & chorizo.

    $7.95

    breads
    Breads

    Pizza Puffs

    $3.75


    Breadsticks

    With marinara sauce.

    $5.95


    Garlic Bread

    With real butter.

    $2.75


    Mozzarella Garlic Bread

    French garlic bread with mozzarella cheese served with marinara sauce.

    $3.75

    soups
    Soups

    7 Sea Soup

    Caldo de 7 mares.

    $14.95


    Shrimp Soup

    Caldo de camaron.

    $13.95

    salads
    Salads

    Garden Salad

    Lettuce, tomato, onion, mushrooms, pepperoncini & black olives.

    $5.95


    Garden Salad with Chicken Breast

    Lettuce, tomato, onion, mushrooms, pepperoncini & black olives.

    $8.95


    Side Salad

    Lettuce, tomato & onion.

    $3.95


    Caesar Salad

    Crisp romaine tossed with croutons, Caesar dressing & grated cheese.

    $6.95


    Greek Salad

    Romaine lettuce, kalamata olives, feta cheese, cucumber, tomato, red onion & shredded parmesan.

    $7.95

    side-orders
    Side Orders

    Sweet Potato Fries

    Sweet potato fries with house seasoning & paprika. A real crowd-pleaser.

    $3.50


    Chicken Fries

    $4.95


    Chili Cheese Fries

    Topped with cheddar cheese & chili.

    $7.95


    Bacon Fries

    Topped with bacon, jalapenos, melted cheese & a side of sour cream.

    $7.95


    Carne Asada Fries

    Topped with nacho cheese, Carne asada, lettuce, tomatoes, sour cream & salsa verde on the side.

    $10.75

    Carne Asada Fries

    French Fries

    Our delicious French fries are deep-fried till golden brown, with a crunchy exterior & a light fluffy interior. Seasoned to perfection!

    $2.50


    Waffle Fries

    $3.95


    Combo Basket

    2 poppers, 3 mozzarella sticks, mushrooms & onion rings.

    $6.75


    Chicken Fingers

    With BBQ or ranch sauce.

    $6.25


    Potato Skins

    Cheddar cheese & real bacon with a side of sour cream.

    $6.95


    Breaded Mushrooms

    Fresh hand-breaded mushrooms, deep-fried to a golden brown color.

    $4.75


    Spicy Curly Fries

    Spiralized potatoes, deep-fried & seasoned.

    $2.95


    Nacho Supreme

    With cheese, jalapenos, tomatoes & ground beef, or grilled chicken

    $7.75


    Mini Shrimp Basket

    Deliciously battered & fried mini shrimp.

    $8.98


    Mini Tacos

    With salsa or sour cream.

    $6.95


    Calamari

    $7.95


    Onion Rings

    Crispy onion slices deep-fried until golden-brown.

    $4.95


    Breaded Mozzarella Sticks

    Breaded cheese sticks. Crispy on the outside, gooey on the inside. Virtually guaranteed to be a table favorite! Served with a side of marinara sauce.

    $5.75


    Fried Jalapenos

    Cream cheese or cheddar.

    $6.75


    Buffalo Chicken Strips

    Breaded chicken tossed with spicy buffalo sauce. Served with ranch.

    $6.95


    Gyro Fries

    Topped with gyro meat, nacho cheese, tomato & a side of tzatziki sauce.

    $8.95


    Side of Rice

    Piles of rice for delicious side dishes that you can't get enough of.

    $2.50


    Side of Beans

    $2.50


    Fried Chiles

    $1.50


    Fried Green Onions

    $2.00


    Red Salsa

    $1.00


    Green Salsa

    $1.00


    Sour Cream

    $1.00


    Nacho Cheese

    $1.50


    Sope

    Prepared with beans, lettuce, tomato, sour cream & fresh cheese.

    $4.25


    Gordita

    Prepared with beans, lettuce, tomato, sour cream & fresh cheese.

    $4.25


    Pambaso

    Prepared with beans, lettuce, tomato, sour cream & fresh cheese.

    $7.95


    Quesadilla

    Prepared only with melted cheese, meat & a side of sour cream. Choice of meat: grilled steak, dried meat, chorizo, marinated pork, chicken or pig skin in green salsa.

    $6.95

    wings
    Wings
    Served with choice of ranch or blue cheese. We offer boneless wings in all flavors.

    Wings

    Deep-fried chicken wings with your choice of sauce.

    $11.95

    Wings
    calzones
    Calzones
    Thin crust pizza turnover - baked to perfection!

    Cheese Calzone

    Made with ricotta cheese & mozzarella.

    $11.95

    sandwiches
    Sandwiches

    Geno's Special Steak Sandwich

    On a hard roll, with grilled onions, sauteed mushrooms & mozzarella cheese.

    $7.95


    Chicken Parmesan Sandwich

    On toasted French bread.

    $7.25


    Rick's Special Beef Sandwich

    Italian beef sandwich on garlic bread with onions, sweet peppers, fresh tomatoes, red sauce, then topped with mozzarella cheese & baked.

    $8.95


    Texas Beef Sandwich

    Beef with BBQ sauce, onions, topped with cheddar & mozzarella then baked.

    $7.95


    Gyro Sandwich

    Tzatziki sauce, onions & tomatoes with a side of fries.

    $10.95


    B.L.T. Sandwich

    Classic bacon, lettuce & tomato sandwich.

    $5.95

    B.L.T. Sandwich

    Italian Beef Sandwich

    Italian beef served in hoagie roll for the perfect sandwich.

    $6.95


    Italian Meatball Sandwich

    Meatball marinara sandwich.

    $6.95


    Italian Sausage Sandwich

    $6.95


    Italian Combo Sandwich

    Pick any two: beef, sausage, or meatball.

    $8.95


    Triple Combo Sandwich

    Beef, sausage & meatball.

    $9.95


    Hamburger

    $5.95


    Cheeseburger

    $6.75


    Double Hamburger

    $6.95


    Double Cheeseburger

    $7.95

    Double Cheeseburger

    Texas Burger

    Topped with our own homemade BBQ sauce, cheddar cheese, bacon & red onion.

    $8.50


    Hot Dog

    $3.95


    Chili Cheese Dog

    $4.95


    Grilled Chicken Sandwich

    Delicious grilled chicken sandwich topped with cheese.

    $7.95


    Breaded Chicken Sandwich

    Delicious breaded chicken sandwich topped with cheese.

    $6.95


    Italian Chicken Sandwich

    On garlic bread with mozzarella cheese, lettuce, mayo, onion & tomatoes.

    $8.95


    Gyro Cheeseburger

    Prepared with gyro meat, tzatziki sauce, lettuce, tomato & onion.

    $8.95

    tacos
    Tacos
    Prepared with onions & cilantro.

    Grilled Steak Taco

    $2.25


    Dried Meat Taco

    $2.25


    Chorizo Taco

    $2.25


    Marinated Pork Taco

    $2.25


    Chicken Taco

    $2.25


    Tongue Taco

    $3.50


    Tripe Taco

    $3.00


    Barbacoa Taco

    $3.00


    Fish Taco

    $2.50


    Shrimp Taco

    $2.50


    Lamb Taco

    $3.00

    tortas
    Tortas

    Lengua Torta

    $8.95


    Tripa Torta

    $8.95


    Barbacoa Torta

    $8.95

    burritos
    Burritos
    Prepared with rice, beans, lettuce, tomatoes, sour cream & fresh cheese.

    Grilled Steak Burrito

    Grilled steak, sliced onions, bell peppers, chopped tomatoes & black beans.

    $6.95


    Dried Meat Burrito

    $6.95


    Marinated Pork Burrito

    $6.95


    Chicken Burrito

    $6.95


    Chorizo Burrito

    $6.95


    Lamb Burrito

    $7.95


    Tongue Burrito

    $9.95


    Tripe Burrito

    $7.95


    Barbacoa Burrito

    $7.95

    pasta
    Pasta
    With homemade sauces: meat sauce, marinara, garlic butter, or Alfredo.

    Chicken Parmesan Pasta

    Chicken breast topped with choice of sauce, mozzarella & parmesan cheese over pasta.

    $9.95


    Chicken Carbonara Pasta

    Grilled chicken, smoked bacon, mushroom & onions with creamy Alfredo sauce.

    $11.95


    Tortellini

    With meat or cheese.

    $8.95


    Spaghetti

    $7.95


    Ravioli

    With meat or cheese.

    $8.95


    Giant Cheese Stuffed Shells

    Filled with ricotta cheese topped with mozzarella (choice of meat or tomato sauce).

    $8.95


    Fettuccini

    With garlic butter, mushrooms, parmesan & mozzarella cheese.

    $8.95


    Fettuccini with Shrimp

    With garlic butter, mushrooms, parmesan & mozzarella cheese.

    $13.75


    Fettuccini with Alfredo Sauce

    Fettuccine tossed in our creamy homemade Alfredo sauce.

    $8.95


    Nottolini's Special

    Jumbo shrimp, sauteed with garlic butter & white wine sauce then tossed with angel hair pasta.

    $13.95

    entrees
    Entrees
    Platillos. Served with rice, beans, and tortillas.

    Bistec ala Mexicana

    Prepared with onion, tomato, and jalapeno.

    $14.95


    Carne Asada

    Prepared with lettuce, tomato, onion, and jalapeno.

    $13.95


    Especialidad Mi Ranchito

    Includes steak, shrimp, chicken, cactus, jalapeno, and onion.

    $15.95


    Enchiladas

    Topped with lettuce, tomato, fresh cheese, and sour cream.

    $11.95


    Flautas

    Topped with lettuce, tomato, fresh cheese, and sour cream.

    $11.95

    seafood
    Seafood
    Mariscos.

    Shrimp

    Camarones Served with rice and beans, devil hot, garlic butter, or Mexican style.

    $12.95


    Tilapia

    Mojarras. Fried or devil hot.

    $11.95

    dinners
    Dinners
    All dinners served with coleslaw, bread, butter & fries.

    Ribs Dinner

    Mouth watering ribs in our own homemade BBQ sauce.

    $13.95


    Shrimp Dinner

    $13.95


    Lake Perch Fillet Dinner

    $12.95


    Battered Cod Dinner

    $10.95


    Seafood Platter

    Shrimp (6), perch (2) & cod (2).

    $17.95

    desserts
    Desserts

    Cheesecake

    Classic cheesecake with a rich, dense, smooth & creamy consistency.

    $3.75


    Tiramisu

    A delicious coffee-flavored Italian dessert. Ladyfingers dipped in coffee, layered with a whipped mixture of eggs, sugar & mascarpone cheese, flavored with cocoa.

    $4.95


    Cannoli

    Delicious tube of fried dough, filled with a sweet, creamy ricotta filling.

    $3.50


    Tres Leche

    $5.00


    Milk Cake

    $4.00


    Flan

    $3.50

    drinks
    Drinks
    We proudly serve Coke & Pepsi products.

    Soda

    Nothing like a cold soda to go with your pizza.

    $1.25


    Refresco Mexicano

    Mexican drink.

    $2.50


    Horchata

    Rice milk.

    $3.00

    SliceWISheboygan53081 Geno Nottolini's Pizza
    Price: $$