Skip to main content
Pies on 37

Pies on 37

1311 NJ-37, Toms River, NJ 08755
732-538-8869
(448)

Open until 9:45 PM

Full Hours
  • 5% off online orders
Skip to first category
deals-and-coupons

Deals and Coupons

Coupon

$3 OFF An Order of $25 or More

$3

Deal

Large Grandma Pie

$3 off grandma pie.

$20.45

pizza

Pizza

Best seller

Plain Pizza

Classic cheese or create your own pizza.

$15.45

$14.68

Best seller

Sicilian Pizza

$21.00

$19.95

Best seller

White Pizza

$15.50

$14.72

Sicilian Pizza Bread

Our Sicilian pizza topped with our special sauce, light garlic and parmesan cheese, perfect for a party appetizer.

$23.00

$21.85

Bar Pie

$16.45

$15.63

Gluten Free Pizza

$14.95

$14.20

Grandma Pizza

Thin, square crust with fresh mozzarella, basil & red sauce.

$23.45

$22.28

Gluten Free Cauliflower Crust Pan Cheese Pizza

$13.95

$13.25

gourmet-pizza

Gourmet Pizza

Chicken Vodka Sauce Pizza

$23.50

$22.32

Five Cheese Pizza

$22.50

$21.38

Chicken Parmigiana Pizza

$23.50

$22.32

Margherita Pizza

$23.50

$22.32

Chicken Francese Pizza

$23.50

$22.32

Meatlovers Pizza

$23.50

$22.32

Chicken Marsala Pizza

$23.50

$22.32

Mac & Cheese Pizza

$25.00

$23.75

Shrimp Scampi Pizza

$25.95

$24.65

Bacon Mac & Cheese Pizza

$26.00

$24.70

Special Pizza

Pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, onions and peppers.

$23.95

$22.75

Balsamic Chicken Pizza

$25.00

$23.75

Cheesesteak Pizza

Peppers, onions, and mushrooms.

$23.95

$22.75

Penne Vodka Pizza

$23.50

$22.32

Hot Honey Margherita Pizza

Fresh mozzarella, basil, pepperoni cups and hot honey.

$25.95

$24.65

Baked Ziti Pizza

$23.50

$22.32

Veggie Pizza

Onions, peppers, mushrooms, broccoli.

$23.50

$22.32

Chipotle Chicken Cheesesteak Pizza

$24.50

$23.27

Chicken, Bacon & Ranch Pizza

$23.50

$22.32

Pickle Pizza

$22.00

$20.90

Chicken Wing Pizza

Choose buffalo, honey BBQ, sweet chili, boom boom or garlic parmesan.

$23.50

$22.32

Hawaiian Pizza

$23.00

$21.85

Sicilian Special Pizza

Pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, onions and peppers.

$25.95

$24.65

Burrata Margherita Pizza

The queen of cheese over our delicious sauce topped with arugula and balsamic drizzle.

$30.00

$28.50

Chicken Murphy Pizza

Peppers, onions, hot peppers and potatoes.

$24.50

$23.27

Big Mac Pizza

Ground beef topped with cheese, lettuce, pickles, onions and our special sauce.

$30.00

$28.50

appetizers

Appetizers

Cheese Balls

$9.95

$9.45

Scampi Mussels

$15.95

$15.15

Jalapeno Poppers

$8.95

$8.50

Fried Calamari

$15.95

$15.15

Best seller

Onion Rings

$7.95

$7.55

Best seller

Fries

$6.95

$6.60

Fried Mushrooms

Served with red sauce, ranch, or horseradish.

$9.95

$9.45

Cheese Fries

$8.45

$8.03

Zucchini Sticks

Served with ranch.

$9.95

$9.45

Garlic Knots

$4.95

$4.70

Sweet Potato Fries

$7.50

$7.13

Eggplant Rollatini

$9.95

$9.45

Meatballs

$9.95

$9.45

Best seller

Chicken Fingers

With fries.

$12.99

$12.34

Sausage

$9.95

$9.45

Garlic Bread

$4.95

$4.70

Hot Mussels

$15.95

$15.15

Garlic Bread with Cheese

$5.95

$5.65

Sweet Mussels

$15.95

$15.15

Mozzarella Caprese

Fresh mozzarella, Jersey tomatoes, roasted peppers, balsamic glaze, and fresh basil.

$14.95

$14.20

Mild Mussels

$15.95

$15.15

Mozzarella Sticks

$8.50

$8.07

salads

Salads

Antipasto Salad

Iceberg lettuce, roasted peppers, cucumber, black and green olives, red onion, tomato, ham, salami, provolone, fresh mozzarella.

$14.95

$14.20

Paisano Salad

Romaine, grilled chicken, roasted peppers, cucumber, olives, red onion, artichoke heart, bacon, fresh mozzarella, house vinaigrette.

$14.95

$14.20

Chef Salad

Roast beef, turkey, provolone, iceberg lettuce, red onion, cucumber, tomato, black and green olives.

$14.95

$14.20

Autumn Salad

Romaine, grilled chicken, walnuts, craisins, red onion, feta cheese.

$14.95

$14.20

Garden Salad

Iceberg lettuce, cucumber, black and green olives, tomato, red onion.

$11.00

$10.45

California Chicken Salad

Iceberg lettuce, breaded chicken, tomato, red onion, cucumber, olives.

$14.95

$14.20

Calista Salad

Romaine, eggplant, prosciutto, roasted red peppers, fresh mozzarella, provolone, sun-dried tomatoes, artichoke hearts, cucumber, olives & red onion.

$16.00

$15.20

Caesar Salad

$12.95

$12.30

Buffalo Bleu Salad

Iceberg and Romaine mix; buffalo grilled chicken, grape tomato, cucumber and chunky bleu cheese dressing.

$14.95

$14.20

Boom Boom Shrimp Salad

Jumbo shrimp tossed in boom boom sauce & served over romaine with cherry tomatoes, bacon, fresh mozzarella, cucumber & red onion.

$16.50

$15.67

Greek Salad

Romaine, gaeta olives, feta cheese, grape tomato, red onion.

$11.00

$10.45

wings

Wings

Regular Wings

Served with sauce on the side or dipped in sauce.

$9.95

$9.45

Boneless Wings

Served with blue cheese or ranch.

$7.95

$7.55

calzones

Calzones

Cheesesteak Calzone

Peppers, onions, mushrooms.

$14.00

$13.30

Ham Calzone

$13.50

$12.82

Veggie Calzone

Peppers, onions, mushrooms, broccoli.

$13.50

$12.82

Cheese Calzone

Mozzarella and ricotta.

$12.50

$11.88

strombolis

Strombolis

Pepperoni & Cheese Stromboli

$12.50

$11.88

Peppers, Onions, Mushrooms, Pepperoni & Mozzarella Stromboli

$13.50

$12.82

Cheesesteak Stromboli

Peppers, onions, mushrooms.

$13.50

$12.82

Vegetarian Stromboli

Peppers, onions, mushrooms, broccoli.

$13.50

$12.82

Chicken Parmigiana Stromboli

$13.50

$12.82

Chicken Bacon Ranch Stromboli

$13.50

$12.82

cold-subs

Cold Subs

All Cold Subs are served with lettuce, tomato, onions, oil & vinegar. Chipotle Sauce or Horseradish available on request. Cold Subs are sliced fresh and made to order.

Ham, Provolone & Salami Sub

$10.50

$9.97

Roast Beef Sub

$12.95

$12.30

Ham, Provolone & Capicola Sub

$10.50

$9.97

Turkey Sub

$11.95

$11.35

Ham, Provolone, Salami & Capicola Sub

$10.95

$10.40

Roast Beef & Turkey Sub

$11.95

$11.35

BLT Sub

$10.50

$9.97

Tuna Sub

$10.50

$9.97

hot-subs

Hot Subs

Chicken Parmigiana Sub

$10.50

$9.97

Chicken Vodka Parmigiana Sub

$10.50

$9.97

Veal Parmigiana Sub

$10.50

$9.97

Italian Hot Dog

$10.50

$9.97

Shrimp Parmigiana Sub

$10.50

$9.97

Pepper & Egg Sub

$10.50

$9.97

Sausage Parmigiana Sub

$10.50

$9.97

California Chicken Sandwich

Breaded chicken, lettuce, tomato, onion,and mayo.

$10.50

$9.97

Eggplant Parmigiana Sub

$10.50

$9.97

Sausage & Peppers Sub

With onion and marinara.

$10.50

$9.97

Meatball Parmigiana Sub

$10.50

$9.97

Italiano Sub

Grilled chicken, fresh mozzarella, roasted peppers and balsamic glaze.

$10.50

$9.97

paninis

Paninis

All served with fries & a pickle.

Buffalo Chicken Panini

Grilled or breaded buffalo chicken, provolone, bleu cheese.

$13.50

$12.82

New Yorker Panini

Roast beef, Swiss, sautéed onion, deli mustard.

$14.95

$14.20

Caprese Panini

Fresh mozzarella, Jersey tomatoes, pesto spread, balsamic glaze.

$14.95

$14.20

Godfather Panini

Prosciutto, roasted red peppers and fresh mozzarella topped with balsamic glaze.

$14.95

$14.20

Chicken Parmesan Panini

Tomato sauce or vodka sauce.

$13.95

$13.25

Ella Panini

Eggplant, fresh mozzarella, pesto spread, balsamic glaze.

$14.95

$14.20

Siciliano Panini

Eggplant, roasted peppers, fresh mozzarella, balsamic glaze.

$14.95

$14.20

Spinach & Artichoke Panini

Sautéed spinach, artichoke, fresh mozzarella and garlic parmesan sauce.

$14.95

$14.20

Chipotle Chicken Panini

Grilled chicken, American cheese, lettuce, tomato with chipotle sauce.

$13.95

$13.25

wraps

Wraps

Whole wheat, white wrap, or gluten-free wrap. Served with fries or a side salad.

Chicken Bacon Ranch Wrap

Fried chicken, bacon, ranch, lettuce, tomato.

$14.95

$14.20

Italiano Wrap

Grilled chicken, roasted peppers, fresh mozzarella, balsamic glaze.

$13.95

$13.25

Buffalo Chicken Wrap

Grilled or breaded chicken breast, lettuce, tomato, provolone, bleu cheese.

$14.95

$14.20

Greek Wrap

Romaine lettuce, grape tomato, gaeta olives, feta cheese, balsamic glaze, mushrooms.

$12.95

$12.30

Chicken Caesar Wrap

Grilled chicken, crisp romaine, parmesan cheese, creamy caesar dressing.

$13.95

$13.25

Veggie Wrap

Eggplant, roasted peppers, fresh mozzarella, mushrooms.

$12.95

$12.30

Ranchero Wrap

Fried chicken, bacon, american, provolone, ranch dressing.

$14.95

$14.20

Turkey BLT Wrap

Thinly sliced turkey, lettuce, tomato, bacon, mayo, american cheese.

$14.95

$14.20

cheesesteaks

Cheesesteaks

All cheesesteaks come with American cheese.

Plain Cheesesteak

Cheese sauce is available upon request.

$10.50

$9.97

Pizza Steak

With sauce and mozzarella.

$12.50

$11.88

Special Cheesesteak

Peppers, onions, and mushrooms.

$11.50

$10.92

Chicken Cheesesteak

$11.50

$10.92

Buffalo Chicken Cheesesteak

With American cheese and buffalo sauce.

$11.50

$10.92

Chipotle Chicken Cheesesteak

$11.50

$10.92

California Cheesesteak

Lettuce, tomato, onions and mayo.

$11.50

$10.92

pasta

Pasta

Choose your pasta: ziti • spaghetti • linguine • capellini & match it with your choice of sauce. Gluten-free pasta is available.

Pasta with Tomato Sauce

$14.00

$13.30

Pasta with Butter & Garlic

$14.50

$13.77

Pasta with Marinara Sauce

$14.00

$13.30

Pasta with Meat Sauce

$16.50

$15.67

Pasta with Meatballs

$15.00

$14.25

Pasta with Vodka Sauce

$16.50

$15.67

Pasta with Sausage

$15.00

$14.25

Pasta with Red Clam Sauce

$17.50

$16.63

Pasta with Garlic & Oil

$14.50

$13.77

Pasta with White Clam Sauce

$17.50

$16.63

specialty-pasta

Specialty Pasta

All specialty pastas are served with a salad & bread. Gluten-Free Pasta Available.

Stuffed Rigatoni Vodka

$19.00

$18.05

Fettuccine Alfredo With Grilled Chicken

$20.95

$19.90

Cavatelli & Broccoli

$17.00

$16.15

Fettuccine Alfredo With Grilled Shrimp

$22.95

$21.80

Stuffed Shells

$16.50

$15.67

Eggplant Parmigiana Pasta

$18.95

$18.00

Penne Puttanesca

Marinara, capers, and black olives.

$17.95

$17.05

Eggplant Rollatini Pasta

$19.95

$18.95

Pasta Primavera

Broccoli, tomato, spinach, mushroom and roasted red peppers sautéed in oil and garlic.

$17.95

$17.05

Cheese Ravioli

$16.50

$15.67

Pasta Primavera with Grilled Chicken

Broccoli, tomato, spinach, mushroom and roasted red peppers sautéed in oil and garlic.

$20.95

$19.90

Cheese Tortellini

Alfredo or vodka sauce.

$18.00

$17.10

Pasta Primavera with Grilled Shrimp

Broccoli, tomato, spinach, mushroom and roasted red peppers sautéed in oil and garlic.

$22.95

$21.80

Tortellini Carbonara

Alfredo sauce, prosciutto and peas.

$19.95

$18.95

Baked Ziti

$16.50

$15.67

Stuffed Rigatoni Sebastian

Topped with vodka sauce, melted mozzarella, and breaded chicken.

$21.95

$20.85

Baked Ziti Sicilian-Style

With chopped eggplant.

$17.50

$16.63

Lasagna

Homemade meat lasagna topped with melted mozzarella & tomato sauce.

$16.95

$16.10

Fettuccine Alfredo

$17.95

$17.05

entrees

Entrees

All entrees include pasta, salad & bread. Our chicken is all natural & certified organic. Never been given antibiotics, vegetarian diet fed & has no added growth hormones.Gluten-Free Pasta Available.

Chicken Alla Prosciutto

Chicken sautéed with butter & wine topped with prosciutto & mozzarella on a bed of spinach.

$20.99

$19.94

Chicken Cacciatore

Tender pieces of chicken, mixed peppers, onions & mushrooms in marinara sauce.

$20.99

$19.94

Chicken Parmesan

Chicken breast seasoned & baked under a layer of blended Italian cheese.

$20.99

$19.94

Chicken Marsala

Chicken breast sautéed in a light Marsala wine, accompanied by fresh mushrooms.

$20.99

$19.94

Veal Parmesan

Veal seasoned & baked under a layer of blended Italian cheese.

$21.99

$20.89

Chicken Garden

Chicken with broccoli, mushrooms & tomatoes in a garlic wine sauce.

$20.99

$19.94

Chicken Piccata

Chicken breast sautéed in a white wine lemon sauce with mushrooms and capers.

$20.99

$19.94

Chicken Scarpariella

Chicken & sausage combined with mushrooms, onions & wine in a pink sauce.

$20.99

$19.94

Chicken Caprese

Breaded cutlet topped with ricotta cheese, eggplant, mozzarella & tomato sauce.

$20.99

$19.94

Chicken Pisano

Chicken breast, eggplant, mushrooms & roasted red peppers in a cream wine sauce.

$20.99

$19.94

Chicken Francese

Tender chicken breast battered in eggs & sautéed in our white wine & lemon sauce.

$20.99

$19.94

Grilled Chicken Dinner

Served with sautéed broccoli.

$20.99

$19.94

Chicken Murphy

Chicken breast, potatoes, onions & hot peppers in a white wine sauce.

$20.99

$19.94

seafood

Seafood

All entrees include pasta, salad & bread. Gluten-Free Pasta Available.

Mussels Marinara

Chicken sautéed with butter & wine topped with prosciutto & mozzarella on a bed of spinach.

$21.99

$20.89

Fried Shrimp

$21.99

$20.89

Shrimp Vodka Sauce

Over pasta.

$21.99

$20.89

Shrimp Scampi

Jumbo shrimp sautéed in a wine, butter & garlic sauce with fresh lemon.

$21.99

$20.89

Shrimp Parmigiana

Jumbo shrimp sautéed in a sauce, covered in mozzarella & baked.

$21.99

$20.89

Shrimp Marinara

Sautéed with garlic & wine in our marinara.

$21.99

$20.89

Grilled Shrimp Dinner

Served with sautéed broccoli.

$21.99

$20.89

Shrimp Fra Diavolo

Jumbo shrimp sautéed in a garlic wine & spicy marinara sauce.

$21.99

$20.89

Calamari Alla Marinara

Sautéed in wine, garlic & our own marinara.

$21.99

$20.89

Shrimp Garden

Shrimp with broccoli, mushrooms & tomatoes in a garlic wine sauce.

$21.99

$20.89

Pies on 37 - View Menu & Order Online - 1311 NJ-37, Toms River, NJ 08755 - Slice

SliceNJToms River08755 Pies on 37
Price: $$