Top Pizza Restaurants in Toronto, OH Near You

Keep Local Thriving. Every order on Slice supports small, local shops, their families, and the community.

The best pizza in Toronto: a local guide

Also known as the Gem City and taking its name from the famous Canadian city, Toronto is the second largest town in Jefferson County, Ohio. Although it used to be a large heavy industry center with many factories in the 20th century, nowadays, Toronto is popular for family-friendly entertainment, amusement parks, and nature parks. Therefore, visiting it with children is a great idea, as all family members can relax and have fun in this city.

People who live in Toronto often attend local festivals such as the famous Toronto’s Festival of the Arts or travel to nearby cities to participate in the many different festivals and fairs organized in the area. One of the most visited is the Upper Ohio Valley Italian Heritage Festival, usually held during the summer. Here, you get a taste of Italy by trying authentic pizza, calzones, or desserts made by Italians and learning more about their culture.

Toronto is Known for Detroit-style Pizza

The square-cut Detroit-style pizza is very popular in Toronto, Ohio, and many locals choose it when dining out or getting takeout. Made for the first time in the late 1940s at a pizza place called Buddy’s Rendezvous, this pizza has quickly gained fame thanks to its buttery, fluffy crust with crunchy edges. Savvy chefs also apply a lot of delicious fresh tomato sauce, melted mozzarella, and Wisconsin brick cheese. These ingredients, coupled with the perfect baking pan, give this pizza the distinctive flavor we all adore.

The reason Detroit-style pizza dough is always so airy and soft is its relation to Sicilian pizza, a spongy focaccia-like pie topped with tomato sauce, cheese, and olive oil. It’s considered Detroit pizza’s Italian cousin. Many restaurants and pizzerias in Toronto have mastered the art of baking Detroit-style pizza, where it is cooked at 230 degrees and has a light and porous crust, unlike New York-style or Chicago deep-dish pizza.

Best Delivery Pizza in Toronto

Starting in 1986, Iggy’s Pizza and Pasta has served some of the best homemade pizza in all of Toronto. Their menu is based on authentic Italian cuisine and offers specialty round pizza predominantly, but they also keep the traditional Ohio Valley-style square slices. The inside of the restaurant is nice and cozy, meant to amplify the relaxing atmosphere of the entire place where customers can unwind after a long day at work and savor a tasty pizza.

The family-owned pizzeria makes all of its dishes from scratch, only using the best ingredients on the market. As a result, clients from all over Toronto adore their incredible Taco Pizza that resembles a traditional taco with its seasoned beef, salsa, shredded cheddar, tomatoes, lettuce, and salsa. Their Stuffed Pizza is another top choice among customers, as it is always delicious and loaded with mozzarella, provolone, pepperoni, Iggy’s original pizza sauce, and another four toppings of your choice.

Best Takeout Pizza in Toronto

Considered a fantastic pizza restaurant in Toronto, according to locals, DiCarlo’s Original Pizza is a family-run restaurant with very friendly and polite staff, as well as incredible customer service. The most popular items on their menu are all of their delicious pizzas, their calzones, pepperoni rolls, subs, or their healthy and fresh salads.

Since their menu is so diverse, there is no way for you to leave their pizzeria hungry. If you happen to be anywhere in the area, place a takeout order that starts with DiCarlo’s Original Pizza. It has pepperoni, mushrooms, and Italian sausage. All the ingredients are fresh, and the crust is thick and buttery, making the pizza simply taste amazing. The BLT Pizza is another top choice, and it uses crispy bacon, shredded lettuce, and tomatoes to recreate the famous BLT sandwich.

Best Pizza Near Toronto

Aliquippa

Famous for being the location where the Jones and Laughlin Steel Company built a steel mill in 1905 and taking its name from Queen Aliquippa, Aliquippa is a small city in western Pennsylvania.

If you plan on visiting the town anytime soon and would love to eat a delicious pizza, then Breezy’s Pizza is the place to go. Locals call it an Aliquippa institution. Their square-cut Pepperoni Pizza seems to be the most ordered item on their menu because it is incredibly cheesy and loaded with crispy pepperoni.

Steubenville

Incorporated in 1797, Steubenville gained its popularity thanks to its many industries, such as glass factories, coal mining, steel mills, paper mills, and potteries.

Giannamore’s Pizza is one of Steubenville’s most celebrated pizza restaurants, and locals love their fresh pizza made with high-quality ingredients. The Pepperoni Pizza or Extra Cheese Pizza are crowd-pleasers and never impress even the biggest pizza enthusiast.

Weirton

Historically a sizeable steel-producing village, Weirton was Initially known as Holliday’s Cove. It’s now one of the ten largest cities in West Virginia.

Should you visit this area hungry, head to Mario DiCarlo’s Pizza will always be here to serve you their beloved pizza. Their most ordered dish is the rectangular Pepperoni Pizza, filled to the top with a lot of freshly-shredded mozzarella cheese, then topped off with premium pepperoni. Pizza is also available counter-style by the slice.

show more iconSee More

FAQ

PIZZA TYPES IN TORONTO

Slicechevron right iconOhiochevron right icon Pizza Places in Toronto, OH